You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke £8m (Papertalk)
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke £8m (Papertalk)


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
hcjbrooks Flag 11 Aug 20 2.54pm

£ 8 million for Benteke £ 30 million net for Zaha £ 40 million for Sarr I don’t think Parish will all his shortcomings would settle for those mathematics

 

Den1923 Flag 11 Aug 20 3.53pm

Originally posted by hcjbrooks

£ 8 million for Benteke £ 30 million net for Zaha £ 40 million for Sarr I don’t think Parish will all his shortcomings would settle for those mathematics

Sadly, this is the problem, his overly controlling way of running this club is the problem, whilst he has to take overall responsibility he has never learned to empower his people and I suspect DF as DoF, still has to get his approval if he wants to travel scouting players for now and for the future!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Aug 20 7.53pm

Nice to know an EX player (not, THAT good) stibks his oar in.

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Aug 20 9.09pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Nice to know an EX player (not, THAT good) stibks his oar in.

[Link]

He's just taking a break from slapping his missus.

 


Red and Blue Army!

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Aug 20 6.59am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

He's just taking a break from slapping his missus.

Or dogging

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Aug 20 7.28am

Originally posted by Den1923

How correct you are, for some reason we do not seem to tap in to the affordable talent that is around in the lower divisions or indeed the european markets we good player are often available at affordable prices, both Ian Wright and Jamie Vardy are proof that is so. Our problem is we have DOF who is not on the ball, he should have a a bank of player he has researched for various positions so that when there is a need we can move quickly to fill the gap or in our case gap's that are present in our squad. Our strategy seems to be firefighting at the last minute for aged bargains, sick notes or loan deals all of which are often only temporary solutions.

Players like Wright and Vardy don't come along very often to be fair.

Much as I have been critical of Dougie, I would also point out that when he was manager, he wanted to sign Vardy but Parish wouldn't risk the £1m fee....Leicester did...

 


Old, Ungifted and White

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 13 Aug 20 10.15am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Nice to know an EX player (not, THAT good) stibks his oar in.

[Link]

“Christian Benteke hasn’t had a decent game for five years". Not one decent game in 5 years?????

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Aug 20 10.23am

Benteke appears to have been Pardew and Parish's idea of a marquee signing to announce to the world Palace are in the big time. A few years down the line and it is apparent that that is a financial tactic best left to others. I had to remind myself what Cabaye cost: a mere £10m. Good players are out there, it's up to the scouting network to identify them.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 13 Aug 20 10.29am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Benteke appears to have been Pardew and Parish's idea of a marquee signing to announce to the world Palace are in the big time. A few years down the line and it is apparent that that is a financial tactic best left to others. I had to remind myself what Cabaye cost: a mere £10m. Good players are out there, it's up to the scouting network to identify them.

Cabaye was a Pardew signing too, one which really worked out. Benteke in theory was a good signing, with Benteke getting on the end of crosses from Zaha and Townsend. But .....say no more!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Aug 20 11.27am

Originally posted by Petereagle

Cabaye was a Pardew signing too, one which really worked out. Benteke in theory was a good signing, with Benteke getting on the end of crosses from Zaha and Townsend. But .....say no more!

Indeed. Apart from Benteke costing almost 3 times the Cabaye fee, part of the deal brought Benteke's brother to the club also...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 13 Aug 20 12.24pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Indeed. Apart from Benteke costing almost 3 times the Cabaye fee, part of the deal brought Benteke's brother to the club also...


Benteke is in prime still Cabaye was on his way out also a completely different player so a silly compare.

Roy does not use Benteke correctly this is the problem we saw this when he got a recall for Belgium and went on to score twice even when he had not been playing for Palace

Whoever gets this guy if its for only 8m is getting a bargain if they use him correctly.

Anybody that claims he has not had good games are not clearly watching the games yes hes not scoring but he is doing a lot of work and winning headers but he has no support plus the service stinks Wilf just slows everything up no interest in crosses and a lot of the time Roy does not even play Townsend so we have no proper winger on both sides plus we don't play direct balls or crossing game anymore slow boring build up at the back football which goes know where

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

palace99 Flag New Mills 13 Aug 20 1.53pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Benteke is in prime still Cabaye was on his way out also a completely different player so a silly compare.

Roy does not use Benteke correctly this is the problem we saw this when he got a recall for Belgium and went on to score twice even when he had not been playing for Palace

Whoever gets this guy if its for only 8m is getting a bargain if they use him correctly.

Anybody that claims he has not had good games are not clearly watching the games yes hes not scoring but he is doing a lot of work and winning headers but he has no support plus the service stinks Wilf just slows everything up no interest in crosses and a lot of the time Roy does not even play Townsend so we have no proper winger on both sides plus we don't play direct balls or crossing game anymore slow boring build up at the back football which goes know where

when we do break though he appears to hide in the box behind both central defenders (so ball would have to miss both of them before reaching him) rather than gamble and just make a run to say the near post in the hope that the cross will go in that area.
Also after 4 years he is still constantly off side , particularly in the 2nd phase of an attack as he's slow coming out which is just stupid and lazy IMHO


 

slubglurge Flag welling 13 Aug 20 1.57pm

It became very trendy to play a left footer on the right and vice versa but it doesnt work with Benteke because the wingers have to check before crossing allowing defenders to set themselves. He scored a great header at Bournemouth 3 yrs ago when Townsend crossed from the left early and CB powered it in

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 20 2.36pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Benteke is in prime still Cabaye was on his way out also a completely different player so a silly compare.

Roy does not use Benteke correctly this is the problem we saw this when he got a recall for Belgium and went on to score twice even when he had not been playing for Palace

Whoever gets this guy if its for only 8m is getting a bargain if they use him correctly.

Anybody that claims he has not had good games are not clearly watching the games yes hes not scoring but he is doing a lot of work and winning headers but he has no support plus the service stinks Wilf just slows everything up no interest in crosses and a lot of the time Roy does not even play Townsend so we have no proper winger on both sides plus we don't play direct balls or crossing game anymore slow boring build up at the back football which goes know where

Brilliant.

 


COYP

Den1923 Flag 13 Aug 20 2.57pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Benteke is in prime still Cabaye was on his way out also a completely different player so a silly compare.

Roy does not use Benteke correctly this is the problem we saw this when he got a recall for Belgium and went on to score twice even when he had not been playing for Palace

Whoever gets this guy if its for only 8m is getting a bargain if they use him correctly.

Anybody that claims he has not had good games are not clearly watching the games yes hes not scoring but he is doing a lot of work and winning headers but he has no support plus the service stinks Wilf just slows everything up no interest in crosses and a lot of the time Roy does not even play Townsend so we have no proper winger on both sides plus we don't play direct balls or crossing game anymore slow boring build up at the back football which goes know where

CB, played international against Cyprus, Kazakstan & San Marino hardly top class opposition, the rest of the time in 2019 he was a bench player for his country. He had one good season for us (his first) when he did scored 15 goals, he has not had many decent games since and his scoring record is abysmal. IMO he is lazy cannot work defenders off the ball in the same as Jamie Vardy does and has no ground skills and is really just a one trick striker who can head a ball providing he does not have to do too much work to get to the header. Why we ever extended his contract I will never know, whatever salary he is getting he does not deserve and is bleeding this club dry. As for his 8mil valuation, I will be surprised if any one decent will even want shell out that amount of money for him when you take into consideration his wage demands and his inability to score. Sorry in his prime he is not butin rapid decline he is and its there for all to see, no wonder Klopp got shot of him!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 13 Aug 20 3.21pm

So many clueless people in here it just shows you have never completed in any sports in your life you just dont have a clue at all.

To state that international teams are minor so it does not count yeah ok so remove all those teams from tournaments etc the results are meaningless clueless.

Now trying to compare to Vardy they are nothing alike complete different player wow you dont have a clue about football.

Yes Benetke goes and hides good one o my think use your brain look at the bigger picture its because of the super slow build up play and why would a guy even bother to charge into the box when he wont get the service.

I suggest you go back and watch the games under roy and when benteke was scoring for palace you will spot massive differences it may well open your eyes why theirs a problem.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 13 Aug 20 3.35pm

My biggest fear here is that in our desire to get a high earner off the books - assume to bring in another who can not just hold up play but who scores - we get a low fee and offer to pay a chunk of wages moving forward.

I don't doubt Tekkers will come good with the right service and again we end up looking right mugs

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 13 Aug 20 3.36pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Benteke is in prime still Cabaye was on his way out also a completely different player so a silly compare.

Roy does not use Benteke correctly this is the problem we saw this when he got a recall for Belgium and went on to score twice even when he had not been playing for Palace

Whoever gets this guy if its for only 8m is getting a bargain if they use him correctly.

Anybody that claims he has not had good games are not clearly watching the games yes hes not scoring but he is doing a lot of work and winning headers but he has no support plus the service stinks Wilf just slows everything up no interest in crosses and a lot of the time Roy does not even play Townsend so we have no proper winger on both sides plus we don't play direct balls or crossing game anymore slow boring build up at the back football which goes know where


This is all too true. I believe Pardew was still around in Benteke 's first season, when he scored 15 goals I think? Roy cam in and changed to a much more defensive pattern of play. If we do land Eze, he should be able to create a lot more chances for him?

 

Den1923 Flag 13 Aug 20 4.35pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

So many clueless people in here it just shows you have never completed in any sports in your life you just dont have a clue at all.

To state that international teams are minor so it does not count yeah ok so remove all those teams from tournaments etc the results are meaningless clueless.

Now trying to compare to Vardy they are nothing alike complete different player wow you dont have a clue about football.

Yes Benetke goes and hides good one o my think use your brain look at the bigger picture its because of the super slow build up play and why would a guy even bother to charge into the box when he wont get the service.

I suggest you go back and watch the games under roy and when benteke was scoring for palace you will spot massive differences it may well open your eyes why theirs a problem.

[Link]

The views of someone else who does not understand football!

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 13 Aug 20 4.53pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

Yes Benetke goes and hides good one o my think use your brain look at the bigger picture its because of the super slow build up play and why would a guy even bother to charge into the box when he wont get the service.

Even with a slow build up he should be putting in more effort and scoring a few more.

I agree that Roy's tactics have not brought out the best of Benteke but strikers have to score goals, that's all they get judged on ultimately.

He doesn't have a shot on him, he has no left foot, he can't go past a player and get a shot away, he can't head the ball unless it's pinged in with pace 'away' from the keeper, he gets out muscled by smaller guys all the time, he makes odd runs behind defenders as if he doesn't want to be played in, he can hold the ball up if it's played into his chest but loses possession quite often because of his first touch...apart from that he's great and worth every penny!

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke £8m (Papertalk)