You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Marcus Rashford
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Marcus Rashford


Page 3 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Oct 20 3.21pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

The debate is who should feed the children in the school holidays. Something that's unprecedented.

We've not had 10 years of Tory rule. We've had less than a year of a Tory government. The previous one was 10 years are made up of about 3 years worth of Tory rule and 7 of coalitions.

The Labour leadership has been completely inept over most of the last decade. 10 years ago the Tories couldn't even win an election even though Labour had made a complete balls up of the economy.

Perhaps be angry at the people who voted for Ed instead of David, then wouldn't chuck Corbyn out of the party despite being told time and time again that the electorate hated him....

but it's easier to blame the Tory Government than to take accountability.

Oh, I must've been dreaming it then.

In this dream I'm sure there was an Old Etonian in number 10, followed by a woman who looked a bit like Thatcher, then another Etonian. They sold off the health service, cut public spending and gave billionaires a tax cut, telling us it was for the sake of the economy. Funny thing was, by the end of the dream the economy was even worse than when they got in!

Thank god it was a dream though. Else God knows how bad things would be.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

The Dolphin Flag 22 Oct 20 3.25pm

Part of the ten years was a stupid coalition so not all Tory rule.
Billionaire tax breaks - hmm - Blair and Brown spring to mind on that - inviting Russian and Far East money into the Country.
Selling off the health service - I don't remember that the same as you probably don't remember how Blair championed the NHS whilst closing down more beds than anyone before him - and the cuts in the last ten years have been fewer than his were!
One mustn't have a selective memory for these things - it can cloud one's judgement!

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Oct 20 3.53pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Part of the ten years was a stupid coalition so not all Tory rule.
Billionaire tax breaks - hmm - Blair and Brown spring to mind on that - inviting Russian and Far East money into the Country.
Selling off the health service - I don't remember that the same as you probably don't remember how Blair championed the NHS whilst closing down more beds than anyone before him - and the cuts in the last ten years have been fewer than his were!
One mustn't have a selective memory for these things - it can cloud one's judgement!

Ok, so let's pretend that the Lib Dems and DUP were really such a burden that they prevented the Tories from being the effective governors they could've been


So how have those years of Tory majority rule gone? Well the first one imploded within 2 years over Brexit, divided the nation and left the pig lover out on his ear.

And the last year has been an unmitigated success, with Boris showing himself to be the expert at leading us through a crisis, the economy roaring, unemployment down and business booming. Or something like that!

BTW I make no excuses for Blair. He was a Tory in a red rosette.

Edited by serial thriller (22 Oct 2020 3.53pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Oct 20 4.24pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

[Link]

I wonder how much tax he pays on the additional £10m a year he earns.

But admittedly, most people the super rich are their because of inherited wealth. Like poor old Elon Musk who's parents owned a diamond mine.

People who make money from sports the arts make it through sheer talent.

Pretty much all wealthy business men aren't really that much more talented than the people they employ. It's just they had huge trust funds so failure wouldn't be catastrophic.

Labour didn't bring social justice. They brought easy credit making it simple for people to get buy-to-let homes sending house prices skyrocketing and compounding poverty on the poorest. Followed by a huge crash.

Labour has been trying to claim that they were the victim of a world wide credit crunch they could do nothing about, yet the Tories are having to deal with a pandemic.

Best thing Labour can do is stop bitching about how the Tories are the nasty party and how all their voters are evil. They need to start regaining trust by kicking out momentum and proving they can be trusted with the economy.

Edited by jeeagles (22 Oct 2020 3.19pm)

Thatcher de-regulated the financial markets and that's where the credit boom started.

Labour did bring prosperity and social justice particularly on sensible policies cutting crime and sure-start, properly funded public services.

It is quite an eye-opener to see, after all the tory years of private wealth and profit, that nationalisation of railway services is being re-introduced.

When the going gets tough, the tories get lost........

 

jeeagles Flag 22 Oct 20 4.31pm

Problem with those in the left of the Labour Party is that they dont understand that people can have their own opinions, but they can't have their own facts.


Edited by jeeagles (22 Oct 2020 4.33pm)

 

buzby1 Flag Devon 22 Oct 20 4.44pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

Oh, I must've been dreaming it then.

In this dream I'm sure there was an Old Etonian in number 10, followed by a woman who looked a bit like Thatcher, then another Etonian. They sold off the health service, cut public spending and gave billionaires a tax cut, telling us it was for the sake of the economy. Funny thing was, by the end of the dream the economy was even worse than when they got in!

Thank god it was a dream though. Else God knows how bad things would be.


Spot on!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 22 Oct 20 5.02pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You seem to be conflating sportspeople and entertainers with the actual super rich in society.

Footballers tend to be some of the most charitable wealthy people in the country - most of them are working class boys who have experienced hardship and they’ve got far more awareness as to the realities of life at the bottom.

Secondly, they are PAYE employees and so already some of the biggest tax contributors in the country.

It’s not their job to solve this.

There are also 250 of them under investigation for tax evasion so they’re not all saints.

 

OldFella Flag London 22 Oct 20 5.19pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

So we can get the footballers to pay for hungry kids, maybe pop stars can pay for victims of domestic abuse, cricketers can pay for housing the homeless and the government can spend the savings on giving billionaires another tax break?

Good boy, you're learning quickly! Keep at it and we won't have to listen to your trite left wing dogma for too much longer. Which will be wonderful.

No-one needs to go hungry, due to the welfare system. It is a parent's prime responsibility to keep their kids safe and fed. All the rest comes after that.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

BlueJay Flag UK 22 Oct 20 6.39pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Problem with those in the left of the Labour Party is that they dont understand that people can have their own opinions, but they can't have their own facts.


Edited by jeeagles (22 Oct 2020 4.33pm)

But can they have their own quotes?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Oct 20 6.44pm

Originally posted by OldFella

Good boy, you're learning quickly! Keep at it and we won't have to listen to your trite left wing dogma for too much longer. Which will be wonderful.

No-one needs to go hungry, due to the welfare system. It is a parent's prime responsibility to keep their kids safe and fed. All the rest comes after that.

Dont you ever put the responsibility on to the parents. They need fags , beer, nails and good hair. Sacrificing any of those will be wrong I'm sure. It's all borises fault dont you know!

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Oct 20 7.02pm

Originally posted by OldFella

Good boy, you're learning quickly! Keep at it and we won't have to listen to your trite left wing dogma for too much longer. Which will be wonderful.

No-one needs to go hungry, due to the welfare system. It is a parent's prime responsibility to keep their kids safe and fed. All the rest comes after that.

Ok, let's take an example then.

Mother, single parent, one 12 year old. No family support, she works as much as she can to support her kid and sacrifices all personal luxuries.

She get 450 a month from universal credit, no extra for housing benefit or child support. She works minimum wage, but hours have been cut sown during pandemic so she makes about 700 a month.

But she pays 600 a month rent, plus bills is 750. She's paying back a loan which she took out a couple months ago when UC was delayed and that's another 100 out. 100 for travel for the month, and she gives her kid a tenner a week. If she buys no clothes, presents, drinks, meals out or any extras, that leaves £60 a month to feed both of them, just under £15 for the weekly shop.

When it gets to the holiday, she wants to stay and look after her kid, but has to go to work to pay bills, so she can't guarantee that her kid is having lunch.

2 questions for you. 1 what would you do in her position. 2 Do you think the state should support this situation by offering meals to kids through the holidays?


Edited by serial thriller (22 Oct 2020 7.05pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Oct 20 7.16pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

Ok, let's take an example then.

Mother, single parent, one 12 year old. No family support, she works as much as she can to support her kid and sacrifices all personal luxuries.

She get 450 a month from universal credit, no extra for housing benefit or child support. She works minimum wage, but hours have been cut sown during pandemic so she makes about 700 a month.

But she pays 600 a month rent, plus bills is 750. She's paying back a loan which she took out a couple months ago when UC was delayed and that's another 100 out. 100 for travel for the month, and she gives her kid a tenner a week. If she buys no clothes, presents, drinks, meals out or any extras, that leaves £60 a month to feed both of them, just under £15 for the weekly shop.

When it gets to the holiday, she wants to stay and look after her kid, but has to go to work to pay bills, so she can't guarantee that her kid is having lunch.

2 questions for you. 1 what would you do in her position. 2 Do you think the state should support this situation by offering meals through the holidays?

Edited by serial thriller (22 Oct 2020 7.04pm)

I think meals are a worthy cause, particularly for kids. It's not money that can be wasted, or a system easy to abuse. It's meals for kids. If their parents are like you point out, or if they're scagheads or dossiers, still the kids deserve meals. Kids shouldn't suffer from hunger due to poverty in a rich country. I speak having come from a poor family myself and I know what it's like. School meals were my dinners.

 


Red and Blue Army!

BlueJay Flag UK 22 Oct 20 7.26pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I think meals are a worthy cause, particularly for kids. It's not money that can be wasted, or a system easy to abuse. It's meals for kids. If their parents are like you point out, or if they're scagheads or dossiers, still the kids deserve meals. Kids shouldn't suffer from hunger due to poverty in a rich country. I speak having come from a poor family myself and I know what it's like. School meals were my dinners.

Well put! The cynicism is all a bit theoretical isn't it, this idea that the kids shouldn't need these meals. Well, they either do or they don't regardless of pontificating on the matter. With job losses piling up there are no doubt plenty of good parents struggling to put a square meal on the table.

We shouldn't be more up in arms about feeding kids than the doling out of 50% off for 100 million pub meals.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Oct 20 7.34pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

Ok, let's take an example then.

Mother, single parent, one 12 year old. No family support, she works as much as she can to support her kid and sacrifices all personal luxuries.

She get 450 a month from universal credit, no extra for housing benefit or child support. She works minimum wage, but hours have been cut sown during pandemic so she makes about 700 a month.

But she pays 600 a month rent, plus bills is 750. She's paying back a loan which she took out a couple months ago when UC was delayed and that's another 100 out. 100 for travel for the month, and she gives her kid a tenner a week. If she buys no clothes, presents, drinks, meals out or any extras, that leaves £60 a month to feed both of them, just under £15 for the weekly shop.

When it gets to the holiday, she wants to stay and look after her kid, but has to go to work to pay bills, so she can't guarantee that her kid is having lunch.

2 questions for you. 1 what would you do in her position. 2 Do you think the state should support this situation by offering meals to kids through the holidays?


Edited by serial thriller (22 Oct 2020 7.05pm)

Why would a loan for 2 months be a 100 a month?

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 22 Oct 20 8.40pm

Such a refreshing change. A compassionate celebrity who has actually looked into the details of a REAL issue, with which he has some personal connection.
Rather than these BLM 'advocates' who are addressing some amorphous, debatable (at best) problem through lazy posturing (taking a knee) and basically jumping on the bandwagon to chastise all those who aren't as 'woke' as them.
Well done, Marcus, for thinking for yourself and acting with compassion rather than just passion.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

jeeagles Flag 22 Oct 20 8.41pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

Ok, let's take an example then.

Mother, single parent, one 12 year old. No family support, she works as much as she can to support her kid and sacrifices all personal luxuries.

She get 450 a month from universal credit, no extra for housing benefit or child support. She works minimum wage, but hours have been cut sown during pandemic so she makes about 700 a month.

But she pays 600 a month rent, plus bills is 750. She's paying back a loan which she took out a couple months ago when UC was delayed and that's another 100 out. 100 for travel for the month, and she gives her kid a tenner a week. If she buys no clothes, presents, drinks, meals out or any extras, that leaves £60 a month to feed both of them, just under £15 for the weekly shop.

When it gets to the holiday, she wants to stay and look after her kid, but has to go to work to pay bills, so she can't guarantee that her kid is having lunch.

2 questions for you. 1 what would you do in her position. 2 Do you think the state should support this situation by offering meals to kids through the holidays?


Edited by serial thriller (22 Oct 2020 7.05pm)

How contrived is that situation? Tell the dad to pay.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 22 Oct 20 8.46pm

Sir Marcus Rashford? Come on boris, you know it makes sense!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Oct 20 8.55pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

How contrived is that situation? Tell the dad to pay.

I agree that there would be plenty of undeserving parents, or even one or no parents or whatever.
However, again, it's not the kid's fault is it?
Personally my father left when I was young. His maintenance was 1 pound a week. He didn't pay that even. Should we then think f€ck the kids, the parents are sh1t? Still doesn't help anyone. Perhaps one of these poor kids could end up like Rashford, or he could end up in jail, he or she could play for Palace, could be a doctor, could work in the Pound Shop, could win a World Cup for England - who knows? Surely we can have the grace to ensure they at least have food, regardless of other sh1t that may go on in their life? I applaud Rashford for this - he seems a decent person. And I despise the undeserving scroungers as much as anyone - but hungry kids, they deserve our support.

 


Red and Blue Army!

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 22 Oct 20 9.06pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I agree that there would be plenty of undeserving parents, or even one or no parents or whatever.
However, again, it's not the kid's fault is it?
Personally my father left when I was young. His maintenance was 1 pound a week. He didn't pay that even. Should we then think f€ck the kids, the parents are sh1t? Still doesn't help anyone. Perhaps one of these poor kids could end up like Rashford, or he could end up in jail, he or she could play for Palace, could be a doctor, could work in the Pound Shop, could win a World Cup for England - who knows? Surely we can have the grace to ensure they at least have food, regardless of other sh1t that may go on in their life? I applaud Rashford for this - he seems a decent person. And I despise the undeserving scroungers as much as anyone - but hungry kids, they deserve our support.

Well put asc, well put indeed!

 

BlueJay Flag UK 22 Oct 20 9.22pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I agree that there would be plenty of undeserving parents, or even one or no parents or whatever.
However, again, it's not the kid's fault is it?
Personally my father left when I was young. His maintenance was 1 pound a week. He didn't pay that even. Should we then think f€ck the kids, the parents are sh1t? Still doesn't help anyone. Perhaps one of these poor kids could end up like Rashford, or he could end up in jail, he or she could play for Palace, could be a doctor, could work in the Pound Shop, could win a World Cup for England - who knows? Surely we can have the grace to ensure they at least have food, regardless of other sh1t that may go on in their life? I applaud Rashford for this - he seems a decent person. And I despise the undeserving scroungers as much as anyone - but hungry kids, they deserve our support.

Well said. It's not helpful to be cynical about Rashford's campaign and the benefits of extending a hand to kids in need. What kind of message does this send out to them? My family doesn't care and my country doesn't either? And anyway, there are many good parents struggling right now too, most of them rarely the first to ask for help.

The government spunk enough public £££ up the wall on contracts for their mates and botched IT systems, not to mention the 12bn flop track and trace system. £15 vouchers for hungry kids though... God forbid. Well done Marcus Rashford.


Edited by BlueJay (22 Oct 2020 9.31pm)

 

Page 3 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Marcus Rashford