You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Just a bit of perspective.... Please?


Page 3 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 28 Nov 20 5.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

Since the restart last season we have played 19 league games, half a season, and attained 17 pts.

It is only the dross below us in the league at the moment that is keeping Roy in a job. Pard's demise was across seasons, where we had woeful form since Jan and this continued into the new season, finally getting him the chop.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 28 Nov 20 6.45pm

I really do get that this is the best time ever for the club. Yes, we have been in the Premier League for 8 seasons. But it feels like we are only there to make up the numbers and avoid relegation. What happened to "pushing on"?

And before people say I am being ungrateful or unrealistic, I have followed long enough to have gone home and away in the old Division 3.

My perspective is that I am bored watching Palace. I go to pretty much all home games and the occasional away. I am fed up with Palace setting up negatively at home against teams way below us. We have lost, without scoring, against two very poor teams in the last week. Maybe, we were unlucky but we were still poor and uninspiring. I think if we lose Wilf in January (or to injury) we will go down.

Taking the situation he inherited into account, Roy has done a great job for us. But we have not "pushed on" and at best are stagnating. Maybe that is Parish's fault (or Dougie's) for not supporting him enough particularly in the transfer market. But, I sense that this is all we will get from Roy from now on.

Hopefully, Parish is thinking that we will see this season out with Roy, stay in the prem and bring in a new manager. Hopefully, he will have learnt from the FDB episode and there is already a very shortlist if not someone primed for the role.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Nov 20 7.46pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I have stayed from the post-match threads as I felt sure they would be full of the type of negativity that usually follows two poor results. Having just read a few I can see I was right.

Get real people! We have now spent a long time in the biggest league in the world and will likely stay there this year. From when I started supporting Palace, in the 3rd Division South, that's a big success.

We are in transition. We are building the academy as our future and 10 years from now things should look very different. We just need to get there. The post-Zaha era will be on us soon enough, and the post-Hodgson one sooner. Until then we have a wise head guiding us. The time will come for other styles but not yet. We may well have to spend a year or two back in the Championship at some point to allow a new, younger, team to gel but Roy is holding things together pretty well at the moment.

We didn't get outplayed either yesterday or at Burnley. We could have won either game, and probably deserved a draw in both. That's football. We missed Wilf, some of the players looked jaded, we were outpressed by teams who saw the opportunity to do so. It happens.

On to next week. And Eze looks great.

As Simon Jordan said, be carefull what you wish for!

A lot of "if we had's", "we coulds", "we cans", "in the future" in this..!!

Problem is that football is played in the here and now ..!!

And right now we have very talented squad who are under delivering/performing and that is due to tactics and the Manager - it's that simple.

Look Roy oversaw one of England's most embarrassing moments in the loss to Iceland and you can see direct parallels here - talented squad constrained by Roy's tactics, so under performing.

There is no doubt he was a good coach/Manager but his time is done, it's time to move on.

Someone asked me why we should have beaten both Burnley and Newcastle, so here you go;

Gauita - one of the best keepers in the Prem
Clyne - played for England
Cahill - played for England
Kouyate - Captain of Senegal
PVA - Plays for Netherlands
Milo - Plays for/Captains Serbia
Reidewald - came through the Ajax academy played/plays for Netherlands u21's
Eze - England u21 - widely regarded as one of England's brightest prospects.
Zaha - nuff said..!!
Townsend - played for England
Batshuayi/Benteke both play for Belgium.

There are others, but point is, if as a Manager you cant get anything out of that, you surely have to start looking at yourself..!!

And that is the point - Roy is just not getting the best out of what is available to him and that IMO is due to him as a Manager and his tactics..!!

Time to shake hands, move on and get someone in who can make something out of what is undoubtedly a very talented squad..!!

COYP

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Nov 20 7.53pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It is well documented now that the England players on the day fucked it up, they should've been good enough to organise themselves into a position of not losing that game, English players in all honesty are not actually all that useful against other well oiled and organised squads from other parts of the world, show me Mr Smarty Pants proof of any tournament where we have lit the event up? You can't because no matter who the manager is when we come up against a decent country we run into a brick wall.

This is easily the stupidest reply I have ever had on this forum

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 28 Nov 20 8.01pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

A lot of "if we had's", "we coulds", "we cans", "in the future" in this..!!

Problem is that football is played in the here and now ..!!

And right now we have very talented squad who are under delivering/performing and that is due to tactics and the Manager - it's that simple.

Look Roy oversaw one of England's most embarrassing moments in the loss to Iceland and you can see direct parallels here - talented squad constrained by Roy's tactics, so under performing.

There is no doubt he was a good coach/Manager but his time is done, it's time to move on.

Someone asked me why we should have beaten both Burnley and Newcastle, so here you go;

Gauita - one of the best keepers in the Prem
Clyne - played for England
Cahill - played for England
Kouyate - Captain of Senegal
PVA - Plays for Netherlands
Milo - Plays for/Captains Serbia
Reidewald - came through the Ajax academy played/plays for Netherlands u21's
Eze - England u21 - widely regarded as one of England's brightest prospects.
Zaha - nuff said..!!
Townsend - played for England
Batshuayi/Benteke both play for Belgium.

There are others, but point is, if as a Manager you cant get anything out of that, you surely have to start looking at yourself..!!

And that is the point - Roy is just not getting the best out of what is available to him and that IMO is due to him as a Manager and his tactics..!!

Time to shake hands, move on and get someone in who can make something out of what is undoubtedly a very talented squad..!!

COYP

Did you not notice that Zaha didnt play in either game.

 

jeeagles Flag 28 Nov 20 8.01pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

A lot of "if we had's", "we coulds", "we cans", "in the future" in this..!!

Problem is that football is played in the here and now ..!!

And right now we have very talented squad who are under delivering/performing and that is due to tactics and the Manager - it's that simple.

Look Roy oversaw one of England's most embarrassing moments in the loss to Iceland and you can see direct parallels here - talented squad constrained by Roy's tactics, so under performing.

There is no doubt he was a good coach/Manager but his time is done, it's time to move on.

Someone asked me why we should have beaten both Burnley and Newcastle, so here you go;

Gauita - one of the best keepers in the Prem
Clyne - played for England
Cahill - played for England
Kouyate - Captain of Senegal
PVA - Plays for Netherlands
Milo - Plays for/Captains Serbia
Reidewald - came through the Ajax academy played/plays for Netherlands u21's
Eze - England u21 - widely regarded as one of England's brightest prospects.
Zaha - nuff said..!!
Townsend - played for England
Batshuayi/Benteke both play for Belgium.

There are others, but point is, if as a Manager you cant get anything out of that, you surely have to start looking at yourself..!!

And that is the point - Roy is just not getting the best out of what is available to him and that IMO is due to him as a Manager and his tactics..!!

Time to shake hands, move on and get someone in who can make something out of what is undoubtedly a very talented squad..!!

COYP

Kelly has an England cap too. Courtesy of the great man.

Meyer has been capped for Germany - I'm call that an upgrade on Jordan Mutch.

Is Sakho the youngest player to captain France.

 

gaz1959 Flag Bamford Lancashire 28 Nov 20 8.04pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

But we didn't... You're making it sound like we were desperately unlucky in both games which clearly we weren't... We were awful and created hardly anything..

100% agree we didn't deserve to win and weren't unlucky we just weren't up for it or good enough.

 

eaglesdare Flag 28 Nov 20 8.12pm

Tbh I seen the two losses comming a mile off! It happens! We could win out next 3 games and Roy is a genius again! It happens during a season! Loose when you arnt expected too and then win when you are not expected to either!

If I wanted fancy football I'd be following city or liverpool! I never went to palace games in all my years for the exciting football!

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Nov 20 8.16pm

Hodgson himself has said it's the best squad he’s had at Palace and in fairness is not seeking to use squad weakness as an excuse for defeats.
Indeed he’s said it’s a nice problem to have to decide who to leave out and that some good players can’t even make the bench.
Without wishing to be complacent I think we have enough to stay clear of relegation.
We will need to keep more clean sheets though as the team does not have many goals in it.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Nov 20 8.20pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

This is easily the stupidest reply I have ever had on this forum

There is a hell of a lot of competition.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Nov 20 8.33pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Did you not notice that Zaha didnt play in either game.

What - we’re a one man team now are we?

Milo didn’t play either..!!

Jordan Ayew plays for Ghana, McArthur played for Scotland - retired, McCarthy plays for ROI..!!

What’s your point?

It just further proves my point of what a talented squad we have and Roy is not making the most of it.

Look at Sørloth - shipped out as a “no hoper” now playing for Leipzig and Norway - when we’ve been crying out for a goal scorer...!!

Just reaffirms my point Roy is not capable of getting the best from what is a very talented squad so time to move on..!!

COYP

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Nov 20 8.40pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

This is easily the stupidest reply I have ever had on this forum


So, that's how you respond when you lose an argument.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Nov 20 8.43pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

What - we’re a one man team now are we?

Milo didn’t play either..!!

Jordan Ayew plays for Ghana, McArthur played for Scotland - retired, McCarthy plays for ROI..!!

What’s your point?

It just further proves my point of what a talented squad we have and Roy is not making the most of it.

Look at Sørloth - shipped out as a “no hoper” now playing for Leipzig and Norway - when we’ve been crying out for a goal scorer...!!

Just reaffirms my point Roy is not capable of getting the best from what is a very talented squad so time to move on..!!

COYP

He has talent in it yes, but sadly that's as far as it goes.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Nov 20 8.52pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He has talent in it yes, but sadly that's as far as it goes.

I assume you mean “it has talent in it”..?

As far “as that’s as far as it goes” - surely maximising talent and potential is the Managers job - which is where Roy is failing miserably.

You’re really beginning to lose this debate...!!

COYP

 

gaz1959 Flag Bamford Lancashire 28 Nov 20 9.08pm

The problem is we have been in the premier league a good few years, we should have moved on from just survival, the disappointment is that we don't seem to have moved on much from the 2nd season, 3-3 v Liverpool at home great passion and result, would this team, manager be able to provide that type of result ?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Nov 20 9.09pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink


So, that's how you respond when you lose an argument.

I wasn’t arguing with anybody, so that’s probably the second stupidest reply I’ve ever had.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 28 Nov 20 9.23pm

Originally posted by gaz1959

The problem is we have been in the premier league a good few years, we should have moved on from just survival, the disappointment is that we don't seem to have moved on much from the 2nd season, 3-3 v Liverpool at home great passion and result, would this team, manager be able to provide that type of result ?

Good post, nope no chance. did Parish himself say that standing still in the PL is going backwards?

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 28 Nov 20 9.30pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I have stayed from the post-match threads as I felt sure they would be full of the type of negativity that usually follows two poor results. Having just read a few I can see I was right.

Get real people! We have now spent a long time in the biggest league in the world and will likely stay there this year. From when I started supporting Palace, in the 3rd Division South, that's a big success.

We are in transition. We are building the academy as our future and 10 years from now things should look very different. We just need to get there. The post-Zaha era will be on us soon enough, and the post-Hodgson one sooner. Until then we have a wise head guiding us. The time will come for other styles but not yet. We may well have to spend a year or two back in the Championship at some point to allow a new, younger, team to gel but Roy is holding things together pretty well at the moment.

We didn't get outplayed either yesterday or at Burnley. We could have won either game, and probably deserved a draw in both. That's football. We missed Wilf, some of the players looked jaded, we were outpressed by teams who saw the opportunity to do so. It happens.

On to next week. And Eze looks great.

As Simon Jordan said, be carefull what you wish for!

This is just funny... So the master plan all along has been to spend 8 or 9 seasons in the Prem, build an aged squad, play the most dullest form of 'football' ever, get relegated, spend a year or two in the Championship then come back up and become a Premiership force??

If we were to get relegated the fact you think it's as simple as 'spending a year or two' in the Championship shows how deluded your post is... The Championship is one of the hardest leagues in the world to get out of... In fact how many times do we see sides relegated from the Premiership suffer instant relegation the following season into League one.

The last time we were relegated from the Premier League it took us 12 seasons to get back up.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Nov 20 9.55pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

A lot of "if we had's", "we coulds", "we cans", "in the future" in this..!!

Problem is that football is played in the here and now ..!!

But clubs survive and grow over many years. You watch football but you support a club.

And right now we have very talented squad who are under delivering/performing and that is due to tactics and the Manager - it's that simple.

I think it's you that's simple. There are 19 other talented squads involved, all fighting and many with much bigger budgets. They are no more under-performing than anyone else. The tactics are delivering what is needed. It's obvious that you ought to go and support a glory club and not just a very successful one over the last 50 years.

Look Roy oversaw one of England's most embarrassing moments in the loss to Iceland and you can see direct parallels here - talented squad constrained by Roy's tactics, so under performing.

One game when his players froze and let him and themselves down. Have you never had a bad day?

There is no doubt he was a good coach/Manager but his time is done, it's time to move on.

He knows how to gain points and achieve decent league positions. He remains calm and treats both wins and losses as opportunities to improve for the next game. He will move on when he and Steve feel it's time and it's safe to do so.

Someone asked me why we should have beaten both Burnley and Newcastle, so here you go;

Gauita - one of the best keepers in the Prem
Clyne - played for England
Cahill - played for England
Kouyate - Captain of Senegal
PVA - Plays for Netherlands
Milo - Plays for/Captains Serbia
Reidewald - came through the Ajax academy played/plays for Netherlands u21's
Eze - England u21 - widely regarded as one of England's brightest prospects.
Zaha - nuff said..!!
Townsend - played for England
Batshuayi/Benteke both play for Belgium.

So what? Every team in the Premiership has good players, some have great players.

There are others, but point is, if as a Manager you cant get anything out of that, you surely have to start looking at yourself..!!

He is. We are still in the Premier league and keep finishing higher than forecasted.

And that is the point - Roy is just not getting the best out of what is available to him and that IMO is due to him as a Manager and his tactics..!!

Time to shake hands, move on and get someone in who can make something out of what is undoubtedly a very talented squad..!!

Go support Man U. You would be happier there.

COYP

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (28 Nov 2020 9.57pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Nov 20 10.07pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

This is just funny... So the master plan all along has been to spend 8 or 9 seasons in the Prem, build an aged squad, play the most dullest form of 'football' ever, get relegated, spend a year or two in the Championship then come back up and become a Premiership force??

If we were to get relegated the fact you think it's as simple as 'spending a year or two' in the Championship shows how deluded your post is... The Championship is one of the hardest leagues in the world to get out of... In fact how many times do we see sides relegated from the Premiership suffer instant relegation the following season into League one.

The last time we were relegated from the Premier League it took us 12 seasons to get back up.

It's obviously not the plan to return to the Championship, but it may happen, and we will be in much better shape than in the past.

Holding the ship steady whilst we move to a new phase of our development might be boring for some but I can just imagine the moans if we had been relegated 3 or more years ago and still be struggling in the Championship, with the parachute payments drying up and administration on the horizon again.

If you know of a magic money tree that Steve can harvest perhaps you would let him know.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 3 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?