You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Ivan Toney
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ivan Toney


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 01 Dec 20 10.03pm

Watching Brentford tonight who are always a good watch as all there players are athletic and comfortable on the ball and think we would struggle to beat them.I find it amazing how their scouting system can find and sign Toney for £5 mill from Posh without us identifying that if Brentford were interested and with their great track record of finding gems in lower leagues we should have stepped in and signed him.

 

eagleheath Flag Burgess Hill 01 Dec 20 11.09pm

Wouldn’t mind Brentford’s manager to replace Roy next season

 

aashman12 Flag 01 Dec 20 11.17pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Watching Brentford tonight who are always a good watch as all there players are athletic and comfortable on the ball and think we would struggle to beat them.I find it amazing how their scouting system can find and sign Toney for £5 mill from Posh without us identifying that if Brentford were interested and with their great track record of finding gems in lower leagues we should have stepped in and signed him.

Wasn't 5m, hardly needed scouting as he was banging them in for Peterborough

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 01 Dec 20 11.34pm

Originally posted by aashman12


We
Wasn't 5m, hardly needed scouting as he was banging them in for Peterborough

My point was,if Brentford were interested we should have been.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 11.34pm

Originally posted by eagleheath

Wouldn’t mind Brentford’s manager to replace Roy next season

When Thomas Frank took over from Dean Smith after 12 league games,Brentford were 7th. Brentford lost 8 of Frank's first 10 games in charge and it did look as though he would be removed of his duties but the club of course never 'Pulled the trigger' and they got to the play-off final the next season where they lost out to Fulham.

Edited by Willo (01 Dec 2020 11.35pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 11.40pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

My point was,if Brentford were interested we should have been.

I was led to believe he was given consideration and I might have posted this on HOL.

He has not been a stranger to cards over the seasons.I believe in the last 2 seasons he has collected 12 'Yellows' each season and a 'Red'.He had also collected quite a few cards before that.

Edited by Willo (01 Dec 2020 11.46pm)

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 02 Dec 20 12.58am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

My point was,if Brentford were interested we should have been.

Apparently there were Prem clubs interested but he chose Brentford as thought it was a better choice to further his career. Maybe we were one of those clubs that wanted him.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 02 Dec 20 9.56am

If we ever manage to find a creative midfield (unlikely under the present manager) he would be one to keep tabs on.

Bought from Peterborough for £5m his value is already likely to have quadrupled.

Why is it that Brentford manage to find and buy likely lads from lower divisions or abroad?

Instance Ollie Watkins from Exeter, Benarama and now Toney ....

Perhaps we should sign their scout?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Dec 20 10.34am

Originally posted by Uphill

If we ever manage to find a creative midfield (unlikely under the present manager) he would be one to keep tabs on.

Bought from Peterborough for £5m his value is already likely to have quadrupled.

Why is it that Brentford manage to find and buy likely lads from lower divisions or abroad?

Instance Ollie Watkins from Exeter, Benarama and now Toney ....

Perhaps we should sign their scout?

Brentford have two Co-Directors of Football and a Head of Recruitment and have used 'Moneyball' to good effect.

Toney was recruited for £5 Mill rising to £10 Mill.
Benrahma was a £2.7 Mill signing from Nice.
Ollie Watkins was signed for £1.8 Mill + a 15% Sell-On clause.A. Villa paid £28 Mill rising to £33 Mill.
Mbeumo part of the 'BMW' last season cost under £6 Mill.
Maupay whom they sold o Brighton for £18 Mill cost Brentford £1.75 Mill.
Konsa was signed for £1.6 Mill and sold to A.Villa for £12 Mill.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Dec 20 10.36am

Originally posted by Uphill

If we ever manage to find a creative midfield (unlikely under the present manager) he would be one to keep tabs on.

Bought from Peterborough for £5m his value is already likely to have quadrupled.

Why is it that Brentford manage to find and buy likely lads from lower divisions or abroad?

Instance Ollie Watkins from Exeter, Benarama and now Toney ....

Perhaps we should sign their scout?

Make your mind up - is it the Manager that finds players or the Scouts ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Dec 20 10.43am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Make your mind up - is it the Manager that finds players or the Scouts ?

Gone are the days when a manager used to drive the length and breadth of the country,often in inclement weather, to assess a player.

In this modern era there are Recruitment teams using modern technology to 'run the rule' over a panoply of players around the globe.There is a great deal of information to be found using technology.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 02 Dec 20 11.04am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Make your mind up - is it the Manager that finds players or the Scouts ?

I am often under the impression that in this current era of Roy, the scouting and ultimate recruitment of players is a process which almost completely eludes or excludes the manager.

Whether that is true or not I have no idea, just the impression I get.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 02 Dec 20 11.12am

I hink it is more that they are very capable of finding players that fit their system. The are very analytically driven and like most teams that are analytically driven play possession football , that is great keep the ball stay patient and create lots of chances for the centre forwards. The problem is against the best teams or at the higher level chances are harder to create. Brighton are finding that out now lots of nice possession but not turning that into points.
DOesn't mean Toney is not upto it or worth looking at just means you need to put him in context of the system he is playing in , even Benteke looked better on Friday when we got crosses in for him.
Neal Maupay has been ok since leaving Brentford but you wouldn't be battering to get him , Scott Horgan looked prolific a few years back and now is kicking around lower championship on loan. Interesting to see how Ollie Watkin and Benrahma get on this year

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Dec 20 11.33am

Originally posted by Willo

Gone are the days when a manager used to drive the length and breadth of the country,often in inclement weather, to assess a player.

In this modern era there are Recruitment teams using modern technology to 'run the rule' over a panoply of players around the globe.There is a great deal of information to be found using technology.

Absolutely. The Poster was just having another cheap shot at Hodgson.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Dec 20 11.42am

Originally posted by Ketteridge

I hink it is more that they are very capable of finding players that fit their system. The are very analytically driven and like most teams that are analytically driven play possession football , that is great keep the ball stay patient and create lots of chances for the centre forwards. The problem is against the best teams or at the higher level chances are harder to create. Brighton are finding that out now lots of nice possession but not turning that into points.
DOesn't mean Toney is not upto it or worth looking at just means you need to put him in context of the system he is playing in , even Benteke looked better on Friday when we got crosses in for him.
Neal Maupay has been ok since leaving Brentford but you wouldn't be battering to get him , Scott Horgan looked prolific a few years back and now is kicking around lower championship on loan. Interesting to see how Ollie Watkin and Benrahma get on this year

Hogan has had lengthy spells out of the game with knee injuries.Steve Bruce signed him for A.Villa from Brentford.
Many years ago, Hogan turned up at Birmingham for a trial from Hyde as a right-back but the club could not afford the £30K fee.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Dec 20 12.48pm

Can this be moved to football talk. Not sure what Ivan Toney has got to do with Palace, other than a brief discussion over his merits during the transfer window.

 

jeeagles Flag 02 Dec 20 12.54pm

Originally posted by Willo

Gone are the days when a manager used to drive the length and breadth of the country,often in inclement weather, to assess a player.

In this modern era there are Recruitment teams using modern technology to 'run the rule' over a panoply of players around the globe. There is a great deal of information to be found using technology.

Since CPFC2010 took over we've had a mix bag in terms of managers finding players.

Freedman was the top performer for me bringing in some fantastic signings. I'm not sure he had the infrastructure to scout players extensively at the time. Allardyce, managed to identify 4 excellent signings in a matter of weeks. Therefore, it's a bit of an excuse to blame the managers failing a scouting network.

I'm not really sure who fans expect the club to find. You won't just magically dig up another Ian Wright or Kante no matter how much money you throw at scouting networks. It appears it could be an inefficient endeavour.

It's also a lot easier for Championship clubs with money to identify a target that will perform well at that level. Struggling premiership clubs with limited resources are going to find things

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 02 Dec 20 5.15pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Since CPFC2010 took over we've had a mix bag in terms of managers finding players.

Freedman was the top performer for me bringing in some fantastic signings. I'm not sure he had the infrastructure to scout players extensively at the time. Allardyce, managed to identify 4 excellent signings in a matter of weeks. Therefore, it's a bit of an excuse to blame the managers failing a scouting network.

I'm not really sure who fans expect the club to find. You won't just magically dig up another Ian Wright or Kante no matter how much money you throw at scouting networks. It appears it could be an inefficient endeavour.

It's also a lot easier for Championship clubs with money to identify a target that will perform well at that level. Struggling premiership clubs with limited resources are going to find things

Freedman made some fantastic signings when we were struggling in the championship with little funds. Now we have funds and hes our director of football he is not cutting it. Perhaps its harder when your in the prem as everybody knows your minted.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Dec 20 6.56pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Freedman made some fantastic signings when we were struggling in the championship with little funds. Now we have funds and hes our director of football he is not cutting it. Perhaps its harder when your in the prem as everybody knows your minted.

Precisely. The food chain leads up to the Prem and beyond. It's how Parish managed to put a £80m price tag on Zaha.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 02 Dec 20 7.04pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Absolutely. The Poster was just having another cheap shot at Hodgson.

Not true, more like a dig at Freedman !!

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Ivan Toney