You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pva
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pva


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
palace chick Flag South Croydon 01 Jan 21 1.34pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Sorry to keep banging on about this but Eze is playing out of position. He is not a left midfield he should be playing as a 10 next to Benteke. Get Schlupp in his best position which is left midfield and get Zaha where he should be on the right wing getting crosses in for our centre forward. It is more than beyond their whit for the Schlupp, Eze and Zaha roles to be interchangeable during the game. This gives us left/right balance and allows for two ball winners in central midfield.

I agree, however I don’t think RH does I’m afraid.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Jan 21 2.44pm

Given PVA's form and the relative inexperience of Mitchell I'd play Schlupp at left back for the time being.

Michell IMO is one for the future but he ain't quite there yet and looked a little suspect against Leicester.

Meantime we need to be getting results.

COYP

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Jan 21 2.56pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Given PVA's form and the relative inexperience of Mitchell I'd play Schlupp at left back for the time being.

Michell IMO is one for the future but he ain't quite there yet and looked a little suspect against Leicester.

Meantime we need to be getting results.

COYP

Sorry, i disagree, i think Mitchell is ready, he's already proving that. I refer ylu back a cpl of seasons to AWB.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Jan 21 3.13pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Sorry, i disagree, i think Mitchell is ready, he's already proving that. I refer ylu back a cpl of seasons to AWB.

Mate

I don't disagree with the parallels to AWB and think you're right Mitchell has potential there's no doubt about it.

But I'm just not sure he is there just yet - hence I'd play Schlupp for the time being.

But opinions is opinions..!!

COYP

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 01 Jan 21 3.22pm

Schlupp is a far better left back than both PVA (who I think is s***e) and Mitchell ( who I think is a decent player but has a lot to learn).
Schlupp isn’t scared to get stuck in and is a very versatile and valuable player IMO.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Jan 21 3.35pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Mate

I don't disagree with the parallels to AWB and think you're right Mitchell has potential there's no doubt about it.

But I'm just not sure he is there just yet - hence I'd play Schlupp for the time being.

But opinions is opinions..!!

COYP

No problems there, but if we use Schlupp as LB, who do we use as left wing, Eze?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 21 3.48pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

No problems there, but if we use Schlupp as LB, who do we use as left wing, Eze?

Both Schlupp and Eze are not wingers and to play them as such is not playing to their strengths.

Schlupp is more effective tucked in more centrally on the left.

Eze at QPR played far more centrally, more as a No 10 where he could get on the ball in more central positions,ghost past players and create opportunities either directly or indirectly with his movement.

In our 4-4-2 system we lack the extra dimension of attacking full-backs who could provide the width to enable Eze and Schlupp to operate in more central areas.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Jan 21 4.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

Both Schlupp and Eze are not wingers and to play them as such is not playing to their strengths.

Schlupp is more effective tucked in more centrally on the left.

Eze at QPR played far more centrally, more as a No 10 where he could get on the ball in more central positions,ghost past players and create opportunities either directly or indirectly with his movement.

In our 4-4-2 system we lack the extra dimension of attacking full-backs who could provide the width to enable Eze and Schlupp to operate in more central areas.

Thanks Willo, but you didnt answer the Q?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 21 4.22pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Thanks Willo, but you didnt answer the Q?

I cannot see Schlupp being deployed at left-back tomorrow.

If in a 4-4-2, Schlupp is played at left-back and Eze ahead of him, I don't believe this plays to Eze's strengths.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 01 Jan 21 4.22pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

It's remarkable that team selection can be based around finding adequate cover for a defender who can't defend. Square pegs round holes.

I was thinking exactly the same.
So if we play our defender that can’t defend (pva), we need schlupp playing on the wing to help him defend. But we are doing it so pva can get forward?
But if we play our defender that can defend (Mitchell), then we can play a winger Eze that can actually play as a winger.But Mitchell will just be defending ?
Brilliant.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 01 Jan 21 4.30pm

Originally posted by kevlee

Schlupp is a far better left back than both PVA (who I think is s***e) and Mitchell ( who I think is a decent player but has a lot to learn).
Schlupp isn’t scared to get stuck in and is a very versatile and valuable player IMO.

I think it’s more about having a left sided midfielder (eg Eze) who gives the ball away a lot and doesn’t support his left back. If it’s PVA, then he attacks too much and the left side is left open. You need that balance for which I believe we have with Schlupp as the left midfielder and PVA at left back. Schlupp is not only good in the air but scores occasionally and will support PVA. I’m not against playing Eze against a side like Sheffield Utd but it will need a player who defends better than PVA and that in my mind is Mitchell. Schlupp can play left back but has never looked that good in that position. Opinions I know, but that’s mine :-)

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Jan 21 4.31pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

No problems there, but if we use Schlupp as LB, who do we use as left wing, Eze?

Mate

If it were me and everyone fit I'd go;

Gauita
Clyne, Tomkins, Cahill (C), Schlupp
Kouyate, Jario
Townsend, Eze, Zaha
Bats

No square pegs in round holes..!!

So putting Wilf back out left and playing Eze in the 10 role.

Won't happen of course because Roy will want to stick 4-4-2.

On Bats, I think he deserves a run - playing Benteke up front to hold it up ain't working.

COYP

 

Osvaldo Flag Epsom 01 Jan 21 4.44pm

yes, a forward not a defender.
While we are talking about forwards, what about King from Bournemouth, 13m. He would score at least 12 goals a season. Brooks would also be a sensation in m/f with Eze. Then we can release some older midfielders.
Eddie Howe new manager when Roy hangs his boots up.
Allow Benteke to depart gracefully for 15m. Good deal.
It would be the start of an entertaining, watchable team if we could keep Wilfred.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Jan 21 4.55pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Mate

If it were me and everyone fit I'd go;

Gauita
Clyne, Tomkins, Cahill (C), Schlupp
Kouyate, Jario
Townsend, Eze, Zaha
Bats

No square pegs in round holes..!!

So putting Wilf back out left and playing Eze in the 10 role.

Won't happen of course because Roy will want to stick 4-4-2.

On Bats, I think he deserves a run - playing Benteke up front to hold it up ain't working.

COYP

4-2-3-1 is a formation I'd favour too, if not the personnel in your team selection. I'd have Mitchell lb, Schlupp left mid, Zaha right mid. l Has a good balance between attack and defence. I agree that Eze should play centrally, he's not a winger despite what Hodgson thinks.

 

doi209 Flag Fighting for the weak and innocent... 01 Jan 21 5.04pm

Originally posted by Osvaldo

yes, a forward not a defender.
While we are talking about forwards, what about King from Bournemouth, 13m. He would score at least 12 goals a season. Brooks would also be a sensation in m/f with Eze. Then we can release some older midfielders.
Eddie Howe new manager when Roy hangs his boots up.
Allow Benteke to depart gracefully for 15m. Good deal.
It would be the start of an entertaining, watchable team if we could keep Wilfred.

15m for Benteke wouldn't be a good deal - it would absolutely fanatastic !

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 01 Jan 21 7.54pm

Originally posted by doi209

15m for Benteke wouldn't be a good deal - it would absolutely fanatastic !

Be a Christmas miracle, out of contract in June so can pre sign this window .. I sincerely hope that’s the end of the sorry Tekkers saga, but with Roy continuing to play him week in week out, got a terrible feeling he will get another 2 years of impersonating a number 9.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Jan 21 9.23pm

For me the problem is not that PvA gets caught out defensively when he goes forward, it's that he gets caught out defensively when he's defending.

He's so clueless positionaly that his recent farces (wandering off so that West Brom can play the pass inside him for their goal against us, brilliantly showing Salah inside onto his left foot to have the greatest possible chance of scoring against us for Liverpool) pass without comment because they're just the norm.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 21 11.23pm

PVA's defensive frailties have been well documented but he does have a commendable scoring record for a defender.
I believe it was last season that I heard he had scored 18 goals in the PL, for us and Sunderland, which was the most for a PL defender at that time.

 

deleted9 Flag 02 Jan 21 6.29am

PLAY PVA AT WING BACK!

I’ve been crying out for this since we signed him. Such a great threat going forward. Either 3 at the back or a defensive midfielder drops deeper for cover when we’re attacking.

Likewise, Clyne is also quite attack minded in my opinion and could do the same. This would spread the pitch out, creating more space to manipulate the ball and move the opposition around.

Roy’s rigidity is infuriating, especially when you look at Villa, Leeds and Southampton‘s progress. We have a good Premier League squad, including PVA, it the players play with shackles on.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 02 Jan 21 12.09pm

Originally posted by alexdyoung87

PLAY PVA AT WING BACK!

I’ve been crying out for this since we signed him. Such a great threat going forward. Either 3 at the back or a defensive midfielder drops deeper for cover when we’re attacking.

Likewise, Clyne is also quite attack minded in my opinion and could do the same. This would spread the pitch out, creating more space to manipulate the ball and move the opposition around.

Roy’s rigidity is infuriating, especially when you look at Villa, Leeds and Southampton‘s progress. We have a good Premier League squad, including PVA, it the players play with shackles on.


Agree 100%! Then he can concentrate on his offensive play because he knows zero about defending.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pva