You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Curious Case of Wilfred Zaha
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Curious Case of Wilfred Zaha


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Feb 21 12.43pm

Originally posted by NorthYorkshireEagle

I don't wish the boy an injury.... But I will be happy not see his winging, sulky, miserable face on the pitch for a while.
Zaha is just turning into a petulant child, constantly complaining.
Ayew in particular, Eze, Jairo and Benteke all got hammered in that game and all of them got up, trotted off and back in their position.
Watch Zaha, sit on the floor and throw his hands in the air, not winning a freekick.
He has flashes of brilliance, but they are few and far between now. Build the team with the decent players we have - Eze is the man, Benteke up front, and interchange with the new lad and Bats. that is a good forward line.

Sadly, that level of brilliance is usually accompanied by that level of petulance. Go up the quality scale further - Messi Maradona Cruyff Ronaldo - all have/had those characteristics in spades.

Players who just get on with it are generally down the scale. Journeymen.

No doubt some bright sparks will list "greats" who were not like that. If they do, can they be flair players; and ideally post 1980.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Feb 21 12.47pm

Zaha is too inconsistent to be up there amongst the very best.

However, for Palace he definitely is up there with the best who have ever played for us. Without Zaha, we would still be a Championship side.....that's how important he was.

When he leaves none of us will be sure if Palace can stay in the Premiership, it'll be a massive test.

As for his personality, he has a sense of victimhood and entitlement that pulls down his game. However the talent level is beyond teaching and has been vital to the success this club has had.

People forget where we were and how bigger clubs than us stayed in the Championship while we rose....through a combination of luck at the right time, brilliant signings and once in a generation academy players like Zaha.

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Feb 2021 12.49pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

peterg Flag Anerley 03 Feb 21 12.58pm

The puzzle is that he doesn't seem involved with the rest of the team. He doesn't join goal celebrations and is very muted even when he scores himself. You get the feeling that he doesn't really want to be out there and is still annoyed that he didn't get a transfer. There seems to be a simmering anger that boils over, like with his stupid yellow v Wolves. I say all that as someone who admires his skills enormously and feels that we have been lucky to have such a gifted player all this time. He was and is crucial to our staying in the division, as the stats show - i.e. how few games we win when he is not playing. I just wish he would sort out his feelings, or someone would help him to do so.

 


The right place at the right time

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 Feb 21 1.16pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Great header by Wilf in the SF Play offs at Brighton.. before he headed (pun) off to utd??

i think he has scored 2 headers in his career (and he is now 28 and has played almost 400 games) both against the scum.

That's like saying Salah is a good at heading because he scored one. Salah BTW is about 5 ft 7 whereas Wilf is almost 6 foot.

He doesn't even make a challenge for the ball when the keeper kicks.

My point is he's not a natural header of the ball and has never tried to improve that part of his game.

 

Aquilachrysaetos Flag Hailsham 03 Feb 21 1.54pm

I'm not surprised he's more petulant at the moment. Another transfer window has passed without any large, successful club pitching in an offer and he looks more and more unlikely to ever win a decent trophy.

He also became a father again only 10 weeks ago. Sleepless nights, family pressures etc are enough to make anyone tired and emotional. I can forgive him his petulance - he's still the most talented and exciting player I've seen at Palace, and that includes Don Rogers, Peter Taylor, Ian Wright et al.

 

Mojo87 Flag 03 Feb 21 3.04pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

We are a better team with him in it and yes he has been more effective this season than last but it was going to be difficult for him to be any less effective than last season. He has lost his blistering pace and doesn’t take players on like he used to. Yes he is fouled a lot but then so are other players like Mane & Messi and they just get on with it without all the histrionics. His tantrums are embarrassing and his moaning and petulance do him no favours at all. As someone else mentioned in the Newcastle match thread last night, there is also his open displays of frustration and annoyance of playing alongside certain players of our own such as Batshuayi.

He is past his best but he is still a good player and worth keeping for now, as no one in their right mind are going to pay anything decent for him. He is also one of the very few players we have who can be, at times, exciting to watch. He would just do himself a massive favour if he could sort his moaning and his attitude out.

Yup agree with this for the most part.
But I've stated it before if not at least thought it, we need to sell Zaha sooner rather than later. If we can sort out having a new manager in place for the pending rebuild, then provided that we get a strong fee quoted to us for Zaha, then that money can help reposition and balance the squad for many years to come.

There is no logic in being a one-man for team which is effectively what we are with Zaha as the stats will show; eventually he will go, deteriorate or even retire so we need to be smart. Look at Chelsea for example, sold their best player at the right time in Hazard and rebuilt from there.

Whenever or if ever Zaha gets his wish and moves to a "big club", I wouldn't be too surprised if he will be found out a bit.

Mourinho doesn't take any nonsense (ask dele Alli, rose), Klopp doesn't either (ask sakho how he ended up at Palace), Guardiola came into Barca and tried to get rid of Eto'o and then Zlatan... He also put Stones out to pasture for a long time until recent events, Arsenal had Ozil out the entire squad selection this season and so on and so on.

Yet we all know deep down we put up with Zaha's petulance and antics because we have no one better or other stars - essentially pampering him

 

eaglesdare Flag 03 Feb 21 3.20pm

Originally posted by peterg

The puzzle is that he doesn't seem involved with the rest of the team. He doesn't join goal celebrations and is very muted even when he scores himself. You get the feeling that he doesn't really want to be out there and is still annoyed that he didn't get a transfer. There seems to be a simmering anger that boils over, like with his stupid yellow v Wolves. I say all that as someone who admires his skills enormously and feels that we have been lucky to have such a gifted player all this time. He was and is crucial to our staying in the division, as the stats show - i.e. how few games we win when he is not playing. I just wish he would sort out his feelings, or someone would help him to do so.


Tbh i felt he got the yellow against wolves at a time when we needed a break! i got the feeling that was more time wasting!

Not to say his other times have been either!

 

Glazier#1 Flag 03 Feb 21 3.23pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

He is a great player and a joy to watch.
Does he have a dark and petulant side - yes he does and so what?
With talent there are flaws but he is fouled the whole time so I get his frustration.
Without him we would have been playing Championship football for the last few years so as far as I am concerned people need to get off his back.

I tell you 'So what'.

When he goes into one of his outstretched arms, palms up, furrow browed, moaning, petulant child episodes, he succeeds in nothing except completely losing focus and the fading from the game.

My God, does anyone think that professional opponents don't notice this?

They know full-well how to wind him up and, consequently, that he will blot himself out of the game as a result.

The only person who hasn't realised this is the man himself. Until he addresses this self-destructive tendency, he will never mature or progress to the top level.

Watch Lewandoski get kicked up i the air all the time yet keep his composure and destroy the opposition. The cool professionalism is part of what sets him apart on the world stage.

Imo, Wilf is the most exciting and yet frustrating players in the division.

He's ours, I love him and he is a Palace great but could be a Palace greater

Edited by Glazier#1 (03 Feb 2021 3.26pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (03 Feb 2021 3.32pm)

 

NorthYorkshireEagle Flag Bedale 03 Feb 21 3.27pm

If a "big club" wanted him, they would have taken him by now. He has to face facts, he's had his chance and stropping every 5 minutes won't help him. Big clubs don't want him. He'll end up playing for a Villa or Leicester!

Originally posted by Mojo87

Yup agree with this for the most part.
But I've stated it before if not at least thought it, we need to sell Zaha sooner rather than later. If we can sort out having a new manager in place for the pending rebuild, then provided that we get a strong fee quoted to us for Zaha, then that money can help reposition and balance the squad for many years to come.

There is no logic in being a one-man for team which is effectively what we are with Zaha as the stats will show; eventually he will go, deteriorate or even retire so we need to be smart. Look at Chelsea for example, sold their best player at the right time in Hazard and rebuilt from there.

Whenever or if ever Zaha gets his wish and moves to a "big club", I wouldn't be too surprised if he will be found out a bit.

Mourinho doesn't take any nonsense (ask dele Alli, rose), Klopp doesn't either (ask sakho how he ended up at Palace), Guardiola came into Barca and tried to get rid of Eto'o and then Zlatan... He also put Stones out to pasture for a long time until recent events, Arsenal had Ozil out the entire squad selection this season and so on and so on.

Yet we all know deep down we put up with Zaha's petulance and antics because we have no one better or other stars - essentially pampering him

 

NorthYorkshireEagle Flag Bedale 03 Feb 21 3.29pm

Spot on!!

Originally posted by Glazier#1

I tell you 'Why not'.

When he goes into one of his outstretched arms, palms up, furrow browed, moaning, petulant child episodes, he succeeds in nothing except completely losing focus and the fading from the game.

My God, does anyone think that professional opponents don't notice this?

They know full-well how to wind him up and, consequently, that he will blot himself out of the game as a result.

The only person who hasn't realised this is the man himself. Until he addresses this self-destructive tendency, he will never mature or progress to the top level.

Watch Lewandoski get kicked up i the air all the time yet keep his composure and destroy the opposition. The cool professionalism is part of what sets him apart on the world stage.

Imo, Wilf is the most exciting and yet frustrating players in the division.

He's ours, I love him and he is a Palace great but could be a Palace greater

Edited by Glazier#1 (03 Feb 2021 3.26pm)

 

OldFella Flag London 03 Feb 21 3.32pm

Originally posted by sprites

We rate him better than he actually is. Been saying that for what feels like years now.

You've been saying a lot of things for what feels like years now. Most of it also nonsense.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 03 Feb 21 3.39pm

Wilf's antics are bemusing at best sometimes but to be honest I have never really given it much more thought and just accepted it.

As much as I'd love him to change in the manner many have articulated he is who he is and in my own humble opinion we have not had a squad in the last 6 or 7 years where he would not be one of the obvious first names on the team sheet for me.

Would I like him to 'grow up' and concentrate more on the game - yes, will he change - probably not, would I rather we play without him as a result of his antics - no, has been and still is critical for us.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 03 Feb 21 5.43pm

One thing for people to think about. If Zaha wasn't the focal point for nearly every game Palace has played for however many years and if he was not one of the only outlets Palace has for counter attacking. Why is it opponents just rotate their players around to foul him if he is too much to handle for their defence.

He may fall over easily sometimes and have a strop but he will be the one in the team being routinely fouled far more times than any other player because Palace hasn't had any other players quite so dangerous going forward for some time. Hopefully Eze will bring a change to that and a few more.

If he was in a team with a higher calibre squad, I'd dare say he wouldn't be seeming so stressed all the time.

 

Jefroc Flag Crete 04 Feb 21 4.00pm

Enough of this waffle. Any news on his injury?

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 04 Feb 21 6.02pm

I've written an article arguing why we should sell Wilf this summer, controversial though that may be. Article linked below if you're interested.

Be warned it's on a betting site blog so don't go on it unless you're 18+ or are against gambling.

[Link]

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 04 Feb 21 6.28pm

Unfortunately, Wilf's worst enemy is himself. With his talent he should be one of the mega stars in the PL or whatever league he wants to play in but the general perception (if you listen at all to commentators and pundits) is that he is moody, petulant and always seeking attention. We have all observed how it affects his game so I don't know why successive managers and team captains don't appear to have picked him up on it. Was it his attitude that cost him his England place? Such a shame as he is idolised by his followers.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

sprites Flag Auckland 04 Feb 21 7.02pm

Originally posted by OldFella

You've been saying a lot of things for what feels like years now. Most of it also nonsense.


Hahaha. And here I was thinking that's exactly what online forums were for. Nice one old fella.

 

Mojo87 Flag 05 Feb 21 1.52am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I've written an article arguing why we should sell Wilf this summer, controversial though that may be. Article linked below if you're interested.

Be warned it's on a betting site blog so don't go on it unless you're 18+ or are against gambling.

[Link]


Good article. You're certainly right about newly promoted clubs overtaking us (e.g. Leicester, Wolves, Aston Villa) and all it takes is 1-2 seasons to do so based on principally good transfer strategy.

For the price that we pay players wages relative to performance and style output is shocking, so we've got to invest in a more prudent approach here in this regard.

A Zaha sale would be a short-term blow but I truly believe in the long-term interests of the club, the right approach to aid the right kind of rebuild for the club.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 05 Feb 21 3.20am

It is a difficult situation and one that needs to handled carefully. Proven EPL players on free transfers i.e. Cahill give you a proven player though you can expect to pay decent wages. Bringing in unproven but potentially good EPL players is a risk i.e. Eze. He has shown some great things but also some naivety in the defensive side of his game. Get the balance wrong and it could end in relegation. Will be interesting to see how things pan out over the next few months. I really want to see PVA and Schlupp sign new contracts as they are 2 with real pace along with Zaha. It looks like Fulhan, WBA and Sheffield Utd are doomed and there are some good players spread across these clubs that we might be able to sign.

 

gazNgiz Flag 05 Feb 21 9.55am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I've written an article arguing why we should sell Wilf this summer, controversial though that may be. Article linked below if you're interested.

Be warned it's on a betting site blog so don't go on it unless you're 18+ or are against gambling.

[Link]

Great article! Hopefully Palace change how they do business? I'm not sure if they will though as so far it has kept us in the league. What's bonkers is how we've managed to end up with so many contracts running out at the same time.

 


I'm a little bit backwards

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Curious Case of Wilfred Zaha