You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We are Staying up !!!!
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We are Staying up !!!!


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Mar 21 4.01pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

Pretty much every seasons the majority of clubs other than Burnley, and sometimes the promoted teams start with either more money then us or rich owners who can chuck cash at the clubs, we don’t since Allardyce left we have broken even on transfers while Brighton have done £250m net. You can argue Parish should do more to look for a sugar daddy to sell us to fair enough but I can’t expect him to lavish money on us or begrudge him not doing it nor do I want to see him hawking our future so he can have some nice photos next to a £50m signing.
I don’t mind when people say that they would rather see us playing nice football in the championship then in the premier although to be fair can’t remember great football with Calvin Andrews upfront but there you go . There would also be outrage if the club was managed in that way.
This is premier league life, Southampton have spent the best part of the last 40 years in the top league, have a modern stadium, a larger turnover then us and have had a well-respected category one academy for 20 years and still as likely to be fighting relegation then worrying the top 10 .
Until the £20m investment in the academy pays off and/or the Old stand gets rebuilt it is likely to be the way we are, workman like organized and doing enough when needed, Hodgson is great for that.


Edited by Ketteridge (14 Mar 2021 3.52pm)


Thanks for this - the reality of life in the Money-ruined PL for clubs like Southampton and Palace. 'Lucky' Hodgson has almost certainly assured, for the fourth season in a row, our continued presence in the PL. His remit was almost certainly to keep us in this megadosh league by whatever means were necessary.

It has not been pretty. WE can hope that next season, whoever is in charge, we will play more entertaining football.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 14 Mar 21 4.04pm

Originally posted by doombear


Thanks for this - the reality of life in the Money-ruined PL for clubs like Southampton and Palace. 'Lucky' Hodgson has almost certainly assured, for the fourth season in a row, our continued presence in the PL. His remit was almost certainly to keep us in this megadosh league by whatever means were necessary.

It has not been pretty. WE can hope that next season, whoever is in charge, we will play more entertaining football.

It is a depressing thought though another 30 years of this and we could be Southampton

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Mar 21 4.10pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

It is a depressing thought though another 30 years of this and we could be Southampton


I don't expect to be around then (70 in a few weeks time). Hope to live long enough, though, to see the new stand and a some of our youngsters make the grade (even, if like Southampton, we have to sell some to keep afloat).

 

CPFC Dartford Flag Dartford 14 Mar 21 5.35pm

Originally posted by glaziermart


It is unbelievable that safety is all that matters on here. As someone else said, we should have been beaten by Brighton and Fulham. Nothing to do with tactics or good old Croydon Roy!!! Honestly the excuses he gets because he is one of our own is pathetic

You are right the performances have been very sub standard in the main and we are being slated by many outsiders and our own fans for this. However we needed to stay up to at least be able to address this in the summer, if we got relegated and the best players left I really think we would struggle to bounce back. It could be 10 years again in the doldrums.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 14 Mar 21 5.51pm

I'm glad some others think like me. It really doesn't matter how bad it is (for now) as long as there is a legacy for a better future for the club.

I think there would be less moaning if we had a coherent plan where the club, rather than the shareholders and the players benefitted from the Premier millions. I just hope and pray there is one and I can feel better after a year of real pain.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Mar 21 6.10pm

Originally posted by esox lucius

Okay, job done, we’re staying up. Some think that this is the ultimate objective of each season, however it has been bloody hard work to stomach most of the football that has been served up this season.

Will Roy do another season ? We have an ever ageing squad, there appears to be limited funds available for any transfers. I do really fear for us next season. I’ll be there, it’s in the blood, I can’t change now after 60 odd years, I don’t know why I even do it, most of the time I don’t enjoy it. Yes I like a win but just don’t enjoy the football we play. Be careful what you wish for is often said, I am just looking forward to a new era.

Was this copy and paste ftom the end of last season, nothing changes and we still achieved safety easily.

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 14 Mar 21 6.35pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

It’s not. It’s about enjoyment, pride and being part of the club. We’ve become a nothing team with no identity and are just making up the numbers.

My bet is that if Roy remains next season there will be a lot of empty seats at Selhurst Park. The life has been sucked out of us and we have nothing to offer without Zaha. We just hang in for dear life every game in the hope we might nick a goal, which amazingly we’ve been doing recently.

My bet is that us safely sitting mid table on course for a record number of points is more important than looking pretty. My bet is that we will fill out the stadium every week. My bet is that our fans would not swap places with Brighton right now. My bet is that despite daily conversations trying to force the conversation about Roy, our fans are happy barring a noisy minority...

Agree to disagree of course, but utterly sick of people trying to force us to discuss this daily just because they cant get the consensus they want. Personaly I want Roy to get an extra season so we can get a squad that Roy wants but im not going to bring it up daily to try and force the issue...

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Mar 21 6.48pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

My bet is that us safely sitting mid table on course for a record number of points is more important than looking pretty. My bet is that we will fill out the stadium every week. My bet is that our fans would not swap places with Brighton right now. My bet is that despite daily conversations trying to force the conversation about Roy, our fans are happy barring a noisy minority...

Agree to disagree of course, but utterly sick of people trying to force us to discuss this daily just because they cant get the consensus they want. Personaly I want Roy to get an extra season so we can get a squad that Roy wants but im not going to bring it up daily to try and force the issue...

What squad would Roy want? He has repeatedly excused himself from all aspects of transfers and contracts.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 14 Mar 21 6.55pm

Agree - I think there is a bigger picture behind the scenes with;

- Stabilise the club financially and reduce the wage structure of the club
- Build up the academy
- Upgrade the Main Stand

All this is only possible if we are in the Premier League. This is the clubs ambition and our playing style has sacrificed as a result. Even more so during a pandemic.

Also.....we seem to be missing the progress under Roy despite the biggest negative spend in the prem in his four year spell.

- minus 11m net spend in Roy’s reign
- most premier league points after 29 games in our history
- most points total in a top flight season since 1992
......is this not progress????

Anyone would think the clubs going backward!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Mar 21 7.44pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Agree - I think there is a bigger picture behind the scenes with;

- Stabilise the club financially and reduce the wage structure of the club
- Build up the academy
- Upgrade the Main Stand

All this is only possible if we are in the Premier League. This is the clubs ambition and our playing style has sacrificed as a result. Even more so during a pandemic.

Also.....we seem to be missing the progress under Roy despite the biggest negative spend in the prem in his four year spell.

- minus 11m net spend in Roy’s reign
- most premier league points after 29 games in our history
- most points total in a top flight season since 1992
......is this not progress????

Anyone would think the clubs going backward!


That was achieved last year (39 pts) NOT this.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 14 Mar 21 8.08pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Agree - I think there is a bigger picture behind the scenes with;

- Stabilise the club financially and reduce the wage structure of the club
- Build up the academy
- Upgrade the Main Stand

All this is only possible if we are in the Premier League. This is the clubs ambition and our playing style has sacrificed as a result. Even more so during a pandemic.

Also.....we seem to be missing the progress under Roy despite the biggest negative spend in the prem in his four year spell.

- minus 11m net spend in Roy’s reign
- most premier league points after 29 games in our history
- most points total in a top flight season since 1992
......is this not progress????

Anyone would think the clubs going backward!

Good post , I know this is a negative way of looking it but everyone bar the big 6 and Everton will at some point be relegated , the point being clubs like West Ham and Newcastle are more likely to come back quickly then the likes of Palace, Brighton, Wolves , Watford, Bournemouth etc. So how do we get to that point , if we had gone down a few years back we would have pretty much had a slightly enlarged fan based and some good memoires . If we go down now we have the academy, given the amount of quality players that come from South London that is pretty important, I’ve being getting text from a gooner mate this afternoon about Smith-Rowe being the Croydon-De Bruyne so if the next generation Smith-Rowe or Loftus-cheeks are playing for Palace not a bad thing.
If we go down a few years from now after the New old stand has been built and we have had a few years of 35k fans and improved income even less of a problem especially if we have half a dozen good youngsters coming through.
Ok, spending money on infrastructure is boring ,and over last few years there has probably been more focus on the long term rather then the short term which has lead to an aging squad. I’m sure that many on here will see this as missing an opportunity to push on but that is to ignore the fact that in the last 20 years West Ham have been in the Championship more times than they have been in the top half, again it is depressing but in the premier league money largely counts and sensible progress is improving the worst scenario while hoping for the best rather then taking a punt of the best case scenario.
If we are dull and boring and finish 13th next season and starting work on the development that is progress and fine by me.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 15 Mar 21 9.49am

Yes it looks as if safety is only a point or two away, and may already have been achieved. Similar to last season when I seem to remember the win against Brighton gave us a points total that would eventually not be superceded by any of the bottom three.Then there were still 10 or so games to play just as there are now.

I have to say I am glad there is a three week gap until the next game.I am finding it very hard watching us at the moment. Perhaps our players will come back refreshed and, with safety close to being assured, play with a little more freedom and adventure. And, hopefully, there will be no repeat of the tail end of last season.

Edited by Pete53 (15 Mar 2021 9.51am)

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 Mar 21 5.41pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

I concur 7 points is not to be sniffed at.

But watching us play this year has Ben bloody hard going.

we are Palace. Bloody hard going for as long as i can remember.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

jeeagles Flag 16 Mar 21 12.51pm

Originally posted by doombear
That was achieved last year (39 pts) NOT this.

Exactly. It's a terrible argument.

From 29 games onwards last year we picked up 4 points.

Similar noises were being made about our points tally with so many games left, but no one kept an eye on who we had to play.

In the reverse fixtures against the sides we have got left to play I think we picked up 8 points.

To get 40 points. I still use the rule you have to draw against the 10 bottom half teams away and beat them all at home. Those are your critical games, everything else is a bonus.

On that objective criteria, we are looking at getting 5 more points (Sheffield Utd 1, Southampton 1, Arsenal 3 as things stand).

Brace yourself for a frustrating run in.

My forecast is cynical, but has a sound basis to it. However, its looking like we'll get between 41 and 45 points.

In a season with no cup run or real signs that we are building anything for the future it is another disappointing season where we have regressed again.

 

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 16 Mar 21 1.13pm

Originally posted by jeeagles


In a season with no cup run or real signs that we are building anything for the future it is another disappointing season where we have regressed again.

And here is the nub of the disagreement. Many of us, including me, would be more than happy to achieve between 41 and 45 points in the top division every season. We may not be going forward, but we are not regressing either. There are worse places to be than in the middle of the top division for what will soon be nine successive seasons, with a cup final thrown in too. Any sustainable improvement from here would require hundreds of millions of investment to compete. It is not going to happen.

 

jeeagles Flag 16 Mar 21 1.58pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

And here is the nub of the disagreement. Many of us, including me, would be more than happy to achieve between 41 and 45 points in the top division every season. We may not be going forward, but we are not regressing either. There are worse places to be than in the middle of the top division for what will soon be nine successive seasons, with a cup final thrown in too. Any sustainable improvement from here would require hundreds of millions of investment to compete. It is not going to happen.

The issue is, the cup final was now 5 years ago. That's when we peaked. Many sides have a rocky season after they get to a cup final like we did, getting to the cup final and staying up can be regarded as a decent achievement. Finishing 11th in Roy's first season was a good finish too.

Those years were when we hit the top of the curve. Many think we are still there and that complacency has allowed the regression to kick in unnoticed.

I'm not really asking for much more than 45 points, and with the squad we have 11th to 14th place finish of around 50 points should be reasonable to achievable. That's not even a mid table finish.

If we consistently finish around there we should get some memorable games, a cup run, and perhaps break the top ten once every few years if we are lucky, which would be fantastic.

Probably nit picking, but I cant see what's sustainable about spending hundreds of millions.

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 16 Mar 21 3.44pm

I feel that unless the club has the extremely good fortune to be taken over by some wealthy billionaire (very unlikely) then we have reached our peak with with a top half finish tantalisingly just out of reach. 45ish points is our max.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Mar 21 3.57pm

In terms of revenue the Premier has higher income than any other league - and we're mid-table and safe. On most metrics that's pretty good surely?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Mar 21 3.59pm

Originally posted by esox lucius

I feel that unless the club has the extremely good fortune to be taken over by some wealthy billionaire (very unlikely) then we have reached our peak with with a top half finish tantalisingly just out of reach. 45ish points is our max.

As some have explained in detail it is irrelevant having wealthy owners. It is to do with your ability to earn income as to whether you can spend money on players.

Wealthy owners can buy you a new ground but you are looking at 5-10 years before that is done and the size of the club reaches the critical mass where you can start competing for top players in the transfer window.

We are, along with at least another 10-12 teams in the PL just treading water and nothing really will change. The big teams bias created by FFP has sown up the league in terms of a realistic chance of competing at the top level by making it impossible to do another Chelsea or Man City.

Leicester is the only exception to the rule and they have semi broken into the big time and credit to them for doing so.

If the big teams truly get their way they will not even have to qualify for the CL and their guaranteed £100m for getting there will of course cement their ability to buy the top players.

In short, unless the FFP rules are changed we are never going to become a top team.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 16 Mar 21 4.13pm

Originally posted by esox lucius

I feel that unless the club has the extremely good fortune to be taken over by some wealthy billionaire (very unlikely) then we have reached our peak with with a top half finish tantalisingly just out of reach. 45ish points is our max.

Not just any old wealthy billionaire though. Should at least show some interest in the game generally, if not Palace in particular. Too many just want to make a quick buck and move on with little or no regard to the problems left behind.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We are Staying up !!!!