You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mismanagement
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mismanagement


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jun 21 11.13am

Originally posted by Swindy

Having followed the club for the best part of 50 years, every time that relegation from the top flight has happened in all that time (probably barring 1992-93), it has carried a certain inevitability.
There is a lot to be pleased about from the Parish years. Salvation, the longest top-flight stay, significant strides last season taken by the academy, though a successful academy is more of an asset outside the Premiership.
However, the finger of blame for the current squad situation and the seemingly unending and embarassing manager searches etc stands firmly at Mr P's door. Whether it came as a surprise that Roy was leaving at the end of the season or not (and great job that he did on keeping the club up with limited resources, he was not the future), clearly no succession planning was done.
Then there is the ludicrous situation that there are so many players out of contract at the end of this month - I mean, who knew ???
Further, apparently the players concerned were told that they'd have to wait till a new manager is appointed before anything gets resolved. Now clearly, Palace won't want to keep them all but it surely unnecessarily encourages other clubs and certainly diminishes any remaining likelihood of Wilf being persuaded to stay.
In these years in the Premiership this club has made more money than EVER before, yet do any of the fans really feel that at the start of the season we are any more established ?? (and I do accept that we have no divine right to stay up) or does it feel that we are still little more than a newly-promoted club with a number of games written off ??
Apparently 1 reason why Nuno & Favre said no was the likely size of the 'war chest' for the new season - perhaps there would be more if Mr Parish had not spent shedloads on professional crocks Sakho, Wickham and Fergusson etc. The Wan-Bissaka money went towards to balancing the books.
It is not his fault, but why do we seem to get so many more injuries than other top-flight clubs each season ?
I do not yearn for movement to the mythical 'next level', but it would be good if it felt that the club was progressing in a calm, businesslike way and even had a cup run again next season, instead of playing out as being a media soap opera.
The quality in the Premiership reduces every year so there is a chance, even starting from this point of unattractiveness to a prospective new manager, that things might not be as bad as many fear next season, but Mr Parish needs to sort it out very quickly or it will be pre-season training with Messrs Derry, Mccarthy and Kiely and extremely frantic attempts in the transfer market.

I don't understand your point about the Academy being more of an asset outside the Premiership. If it produces another AWB, that's £50m in potential income plus a home grown talent occupying a first team place.

The Manager search has proven to be more difficult than thought. Of the supposed candidates, opinion on HOL has been extremely divided as to who should get the job. With little or no ' official ' updates coming out of the club, we are left to speculate. As you have done re the '' war chest ''. If Parish had someone in mind to replace Roy, then for whatever reason, it didn't happen. On the face of it, it looks like mismanagement but I think there is more to it than that. As an example, SP could not have legislated for the U-turn by Favre.

With regards to the players contract situation, it's an unusual one for sure. Most of those players are past their best and some have been expensive non-playing liabilities. I for one would have signed Sakho on the back of his initial performances for us, but both his form and fitness have been a huge disappointment that I would not have predicted any more than SP could of.

As for the club being '' established '' in the Premier, well other clubs have thought the same and look at say, Stoke now. You can't take it for granted. For the majority of clubs the definition of success is just staying in the league.

So...have mistakes been made ? - Yes. Palace are not unique in that respect. Is Steve Parish beyond critisism ? - No. Nobody's perfect. What I do believe is that some people underestimate the size of the job he has done in keeping Palace in the Premier League.

Edited by NEILLO (27 Jun 2021 11.14am)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Jun 21 11.21am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I don't understand your point about the Academy being more of an asset outside the Premiership. If it produces another AWB, that's £50m in potential income plus a home grown talent occupying a first team place.

The Manager search has proven to be more difficult than thought. Of the supposed candidates, opinion on HOL has been extremely divided as to who should get the job. With little or no ' official ' updates coming out of the club, we are left to speculate. As you have done re the '' war chest ''. If Parish had someone in mind to replace Roy, then for whatever reason, it didn't happen. On the face of it, it looks like mismanagement but I think there is more to it than that. As an example, SP could not have legislated for the U-turn by Favre.

With regards to the players contract situation, it's an unusual one for sure. Most of those players are past their best and some have been expensive non-playing liabilities. I for one would have signed Sakho on the back of his initial performances for us, but both his form and fitness have been a huge disappointment that I would not have predicted any more than SP could of.

As for the club being '' established '' in the Premier, well other clubs have thought the same and look at say, Stoke now. You can't take it for granted. For the majority of clubs the definition of success is just staying in the league.

So...have mistakes been made ? - Yes. Palace are not unique in that respect. Is Steve Parish beyond critisism ? - No. Nobody's perfect. What I do believe is that some people underestimate the size of the job he has done in keeping Palace in the Premier League.

Edited by NEILLO (27 Jun 2021 11.14am)

I for one is not one of these people.

In actual fact, only last night I made such comments to a chap in a local establishment, the response being that I was being supportive for obvious reasons !!!!
Fawning Willo !!!!

Edited by Willo (27 Jun 2021 11.26am)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Jun 21 11.27am

Originally posted by OldFella

Made me laugh. Keyboard warrior from thousands of miles away. What a wally

Nice one old fella. Can’t say I’ve been called a Wally for a while. I’ll take it.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Jun 21 11.29am

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

'Fickle Fans'.
If one were to post that Parish was a brilliant Chairman and then subsequently write that he was abysmal, only to add that he was top notch and shortly afterwards that he was really very poor then one could reasonably be accused of being a 'fickle fan'. Or even a psychopath. But if one repeatedly suggests that Mr Parish's abilities as an Advertising guru are not quite matched by his performance as a Premiership Chairman, that's not 'fickle'. It's consistent.
As for those who claim to understand how the 'real world' works, do please share the secret with the rest of us. Premiership football is about anything BUT the 'real world'. It's about escapism and its economics are the stuff of fantasy.
The OP points out that there are real issues that at the moment are not being addressed. That is clearly correct. If the reply to that is that critics have to be 'realistic', then let's stop farting around with ideas that top managers would want to come to Palace. Why would they, when the purse strings are so tightly drawn? The best we can hope for is a manager on the way up, or perhaps in gentle decline, having sampled the heights elsewhere. I wouldn't mind at all if a Pochettino used us as a stepping stone. Indeed, we might well use Southampton as yardstick. There's no particular reason why we shouldn't be on par with them.
This is a forum for the exchange of ideas, or the venting of spleen when we've just lost 0-7, or the wish that we could sign such and such a player. Can we please avoid protestations about whether one is 'woke' or 'tough' or not and just stick to a polite spirit of agreement or disagreement.

Yep, sounds like a plan. Let’s do that
(Your post was considered and well argued, by the way. Guess we’re just approaching things from slightly different angles.)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 27 Jun 21 11.35am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Batshuayi was a loanee not a contracted player so he's doesn't really count.

Yes, he does we were paying him 90k a week, not Chelsea, and he has gone

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Jun 21 11.47am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Yes, he does we were paying him 90k a week, not Chelsea, and he has gone

Batshuayi started 7 games, and was substitute in 11 games.
Scored 2 goals, both after coming off the bench, and both late strikes.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 27 Jun 21 11.58am

'NEILLO'
How many players have gone straight into the first team from the academy in this premiership stay ?? That will be Wan-Bissaka then, who then had to be sold to balance the books !! Previous comments apply on that one.
If you read my first post properly, you will see that I did in fact say that I realise we have no divine right to be where we are but it should feel as if were a club with a better standing than those newly-promoted !

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Jun 21 1.32pm

Originally posted by sprites

First up, I don’t need to toughen up one bit. Careful there.

Secondly, I’m as far away from woke as it gets. All I’m saying is no one knows the bloody story and yet we’ve all hung Parish out to dry. It’s fine margins. If Favre signs, Parish is a hero who’s pulled off the coup of the season signing a manager of that ilk. Instead, an 11th hour change of heart (for personal reasons it sounds) and suddenly he’s incompetent and guilty or mismanagement etc.

It’s fickle fans having no idea how the real world works. I for one am glad Steve’s in charge and I trust him to make the right decision for the club - like he’s always done.


Sprites Palace don’t have hardly any fickle fans. Nearly everyone posting here including you care about our club. But fans are fans and we all like to have our say on topics good or bad. So it doesn’t wash saying your not going to look on at the abuse. I’m sure you are as tough as the rest if you say so,so just make your points and let everyone else make theirs. One thing for sure we can’t all agree on everything and that’s what makes the forum. Just chill stay tough! And carry on posting.
Glad you’re not a woke too.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 27 Jun 21 1.44pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I cannot understand why anyone thinks its a bad thing that the contract situation is bad, its 11 players,
Sakho, Batshuayi ,Clyne, Dann, Wickham, PVA, McCarthy, Ward, Hennessey, Townsend And Cahill,
Only the last too might be worth keeping
The other players are finished anyway, The saving on wages is 700k a week, 37million a year,
There is some very good young players knocking on the door, Partially in my view Rich-Baghuelou, Rak-Sakyi and Hannam,
3 loan stops are available, CD, RB, AM,
All is not Awful, if it is Cooper (who wouldn't be my Choice) he must be backed 100% by Players, Staff, and fans until he has been given a fair chance

Hopefully you are correct in what you say, but it will be a challenge to replace all those departing ( although admittedly we don't know yet how many will go) with Premier League standard players.

There is a question mark regards the promising Academy players and whether they are good enough to step up, so I am not sure we can rely upon them. A for loans, yes that is an option, but our record on bringing in effective loanees hasn't been that great.

As such we are still going to have to spend in the transfer market and whether adequate funds will be available to buy in several quality players looks doubtful. It wouldn't be so bad if we had the backbone of a good side to build on but we don't ( particularly if Wilf goes and Eze is unfit for the time being) and there lies the problem.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jun 21 1.51pm

Originally posted by Swindy

'NEILLO'
How many players have gone straight into the first team from the academy in this premiership stay ?? That will be Wan-Bissaka then, who then had to be sold to balance the books !! Previous comments apply on that one.
If you read my first post properly, you will see that I did in fact say that I realise we have no divine right to be where we are but it should feel as if were a club with a better standing than those newly-promoted !

I think you’re missing the point about the Academy.

It’s only recently been invested in and upgraded to Cat1 status. This in turn will attract the better players to the club that we have previously missed out on. If that means we produce players that can go into our first team and then generate substantial transfer fees then those are big steps towards a sustainable future. If you don’t see that as a positive then we will just have to disagree.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Swindy Flag Bromley 27 Jun 21 3.03pm

Again if you look at my initial post I didn't say it wasn't a positive.
A club like ours is not going to blood academy players at this level frequently - we have seen they prefer to go with the finished article.
Historically our young players have been used more frequently after 2 successive relegations and overspending or at the time of the first administration when there was little else available.
2 players now from the academy (irrespective of the level it has been granted) being brought through to the first team since Wilf's debut in August 2010 (and one of those sold with the funds not being used to revamp the team) is not a lot to shout about.
However, had we spent (or if we subsequently spend) more time in the Championship, then the academy would be more of an asset and would most likely be significantly drawn on particularly as any extended stay tends to see available funds and better players dwindling, which you can starkly see with the Championship and to a lesser extent league 1 being stuffed with failed premiership teams.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jun 21 3.08pm

Originally posted by Swindy

Again if you look at my initial post I didn't say it wasn't a positive.
A club like ours is not going to blood academy players at this level frequently - we have seen they prefer to go with the finished article.
Historically our young players have been used more frequently after 2 successive relegations and overspending or at the time of the first administration when there was little else available.
2 players now from the academy (irrespective of the level it has been granted) being brought through to the first team since Wilf's debut in August 2010 (and one of those sold with the funds not being used to revamp the team) is not a lot to shout about.
However, had we spent (or if we subsequently spend) more time in the Championship, then the academy would be more of an asset and would most likely be significantly drawn on particularly as any extended stay tends to see available funds and better players dwindling, which you can starkly see with the Championship and to a lesser extent league 1 being stuffed with failed premiership teams.

I looked at your original post.

You are looking at things from a historical perspective.

I am looking at the future.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Swindy Flag Bromley 27 Jun 21 3.14pm

Then I am possibly speaking from a position of strength - there would have to be relegation or a complete change of playing ethos for our young players to be playing in numbers or regularly in a Palace side in the Premiership.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jun 21 3.34pm

Originally posted by Swindy

Then I am possibly speaking from a position of strength - there would have to be relegation or a complete change of playing ethos for our young players to be playing in numbers or regularly in a Palace side in the Premiership.

You aren't speaking from a position of strength.

You are speaking from past experience. Which I am not contesting.

But there is absolutely no point in making the kind of investment that Palace have in their Academy unless the future plan is to produce better quality players that are capable of competing for first team places and that could bring in a revenue stream.

Have you missed the conversations on here around the topic on the likes of Lampard or Cooper's ability to work with and develop young players ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 27 Jun 21 4.49pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think you’re missing the point about the Academy.

It’s only recently been invested in and upgraded to Cat1 status. This in turn will attract the better players to the club that we have previously missed out on. If that means we produce players that can go into our first team and then generate substantial transfer fees then those are big steps towards a sustainable future. If you don’t see that as a positive then we will just have to disagree.


We already have attracted a better quality of youngster, hence the success of our youngsters in their first season in a higher, tougher league.

Several youngsters moved to us from other academies last summer when Cat 1 status was confirmed, including Reece Hannam who some of us (who have regularly watched the U23s) think is ready to be given a chance in the first team. There are others in both the development squad and the Academy who may well be able to step up in the next 12 months or so.

Consequently, I'm on your side in this debate with Swindy. I don't think one can compare our past few decades of bringing through youngsters with the structure we are developing.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 27 Jun 21 5.10pm

I agree we cannot ignore the fact that those out of contract are all players towards the end - or arguably at the end of their top flight careers, but they do form a considerable part of our match day squads in recent seasons. The academy may be the answer but I see that as being a while away. It needs to itself develop and grow into its new catagory one status.

We have I think seen in our recent lack of cup runs where we have played some fringe players just how thin our squad is and losing this many players this much experience is I feel an issue.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 27 Jun 21 5.11pm

That remains to be seen.
Cooper & Lampard may indeed have had some success with young players but in different circumstances, Cooper at a lower level and Lampard at a club with slightly more clout than Palace to compensate should things not work. Neither could be said to be a raging success at their respective clubs.
Neither are nailed on to come to Palace and it is unknown that in the event they should, whether circumstances would allow.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jun 21 5.25pm

Originally posted by Swindy

That remains to be seen.
Cooper & Lampard may indeed have had some success with young players but in different circumstances, Cooper at a lower level and Lampard at a club with slightly more clout than Palace to compensate should things not work. Neither could be said to be a raging success at their respective clubs.
Neither are nailed on to come to Palace and it is unknown that in the event they should, whether circumstances would allow.

Yes, well everything remains to be seen !

I just wouldn't let the past be a blocker to seeing the club's future strategy, which as Doombear has already pointed out, is already bearing fruit.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Swindy Flag Bromley 27 Jun 21 5.42pm

Nothing gets past you !!
But I wouldn't hold your breath too much - the way prospects are looking for this season currently and given recent history.
Yes it is a developing Academy which in time could be significant and yes I saw the U23 semi and final and yes players like Hannam look, in time as if they will develop into potential regular first team players but they are just not going to be thrown in en masse into a likely relegation scrap.

 

OldFella Flag London 30 Jun 21 9.18am

Originally posted by sprites

Nice one old fella. Can’t say I’ve been called a Wally for a while. I’ll take it.

Respect, sprites. COYP.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mismanagement