This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The record intake last year from France was only 8,000. In fact we could welcome more, as many more people are leaving the UK than coming here. It would be simpler, and safer, just to go and pick them up. France takes in many more people than we do. Doing some research, it was actually 8400 but these are only this crossing the Channel and have been found. Does not include daily arrivals at other ports and the 9000 we take through the legitimate resettlement programme
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Another factor to consider is the UK death rate since 2016. The elderly brexit generation is departing, the referendum result would not be the same now, and wasn't when we actually left either. They are also mainly takers, not givers to the state. 8,000 asylum seekers is a paltry amount. We have shortages now in service jobs UK people sniff at, an asylum seeker would jump at them. I have a few here very occasionally, they only need a decent break. It is not 8000 though is it! Are you saying the elderly Brexit generation are takers not givers? What about those that worked their entire lives, they have given to the State.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The double check analogy was about holding a confirmatory referendum, given all the new information available since the first, to make sure Brexit was really what people wanted. Not just whether they were tired of the process. And I have stated many times that as the EU needs to reform, it ultimately will reform. It was therefore very much in our interests to stay inside and be the driver of that reform rather than merely observing. Again, how can you see the future. Its impossible without a delorian and doc brown.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Another factor to consider is the UK death rate since 2016. The elderly brexit generation is departing, the referendum result would not be the same now, and wasn't when we actually left either. They are also mainly takers, not givers to the state. 8,000 asylum seekers is a paltry amount. We have shortages now in service jobs UK people sniff at, an asylum seeker would jump at them. I have a few here very occasionally, they only need a decent break. It’s not 8000 though is it?
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Another factor to consider is the UK death rate since 2016. The elderly brexit generation is departing, the referendum result would not be the same now, and wasn't when we actually left either. They are also mainly takers, not givers to the state. 8,000 asylum seekers is a paltry amount. We have shortages now in service jobs UK people sniff at, an asylum seeker would jump at them. I have a few here very occasionally, they only need a decent break. Or the number of people who would now vote leave has gone up as Remainers and the undecided see how badly the EU is behaving.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Another factor to consider is the UK death rate since 2016. The elderly brexit generation is departing, the referendum result would not be the same now, and wasn't when we actually left either. They are also mainly takers, not givers to the state. 8,000 asylum seekers is a paltry amount. We have shortages now in service jobs UK people sniff at, an asylum seeker would jump at them. I have a few here very occasionally, they only need a decent break. I understand the givers and takers bit and you may be correct. Might it be that we are being somewhat forced into an uber healthy lifestyle so creating generation 90 plus which 30 years ago would have been 80% less. Edited by cryrst (06 Jul 2021 1.29pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The double check analogy was about holding a confirmatory referendum, given all the new information available since the first, to make sure Brexit was really what people wanted. Not just whether they were tired of the process. And I have stated many times that as the EU needs to reform, it ultimately will reform. It was therefore very much in our interests to stay inside and be the driver of that reform rather than merely observing. You really are a sad man.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
So if Remain had won we should have had a second referendum just to confirm that's what the voters intended? Edited by Badger11 (06 Jul 2021 9.09am) If the context so demanded, of course it should. If lies, evidence of foreign interference and political shenanigans indicated that a close result was unreliable, then the argument for confirmation would have been pushed very hard by Farage and his motley crew.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Sorry to disagree. The EU is a dinosaur. Soon to go extinct. And good riddance. The eu is hated by Greeks, Catalans, Italians, the Dutch, French, polish, Hungarians, Danish...even countries outside the eu like Switzerland.... etc The eu is Rome circa 470 ad , Napoleon in 1815 , ibm computers in 1985, Charlton athletic , ..... your heyday is over.
Extinct? No. Evolve to better suit it's environment? Yes. There is a need for an EU and when a need exists it will be met. We have just removed our DNA from the gene pool to go off and form our our branch line. You don't need to be Dr Beeching to know what happens to branch lines.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Extinct? No. Evolve to better suit it's environment? Yes. There is a need for an EU and when a need exists it will be met. We have just removed our DNA from the gene pool to go off and form our our branch line. You don't need to be Dr Beeching to know what happens to branch lines. Pray tell why there is a need for an EU?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Again, how can you see the future. Its impossible without a delorian and doc brown. The EU will reform. It's not a question of if, but of how and when. Outside, we will have no say in that reformation and will have very little leverage. If the union has disintegrated by then the whole episode will be seen as the historical disaster I believe it to be. Just pride overcoming common sense. If you don't think things are too bad, then you haven't noticed the rising prices and shortages. The pandemic has confused everything, but as we get back on our feet, the impact will become clearer. As interest rates rise we face some seriously difficult times.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The EU will reform. It's not a question of if, but of how and when. Outside, we will have no say in that reformation and will have very little leverage. If the union has disintegrated by then the whole episode will be seen as the historical disaster I believe it to be. Just pride overcoming common sense. If you don't think things are too bad, then you haven't noticed the rising prices and shortages. The pandemic has confused everything, but as we get back on our feet, the impact will become clearer. As interest rates rise we face some seriously difficult times. you hope???
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The EU will reform. It's not a question of if, but of how and when. Outside, we will have no say in that reformation and will have very little leverage. If the union has disintegrated by then the whole episode will be seen as the historical disaster I believe it to be. Just pride overcoming common sense. If you don't think things are too bad, then you haven't noticed the rising prices and shortages. The pandemic has confused everything, but as we get back on our feet, the impact will become clearer. As interest rates rise we face some seriously difficult times.
The eu will be gone after the next financial crisis.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
You do realise that if you just copy + paste the same post in response to even the slightest questioning of the effect of Brexit, that people will simply scan through your posts - pausing only to note the irony of a Brexiteer asserting low intelligence among Remainers - without reading them? A fair point although I would pull you up on your last point. Anybody who thought that a second referendum that included a Remain option before we had actually left the EU was a vote winner (and a second referendum could only come about after another General Election given the requirement for another specific referendum act) has to be retarded given all the evidence out there pointing to the exact opposite. And why Johnson now has a majority of 80. I am sure Boris thanks all of those who made that possibe. Pushing for a position of just ignoring the Brexit vote and continuing the UK's membership of the EU was actually the far smarter stance to take, albeit again an electorally disastrous one. But given the legal status of the referendum as being only advisory, as opposed to a plebiscite, then HMG was quite within its constitutional rights to have just ignored the result. Of course, there would have been consequences but that position was far more logical than any nonsense about a second vote before the first one was acted upon. Ignore or act upon the June 2016 result were the only two courses of action that made any rational sense. A second vote along the lines of Labour was proposing would have plunged this country into effective civil war and lives would have been lost. An utter catastrophe on so many levels. But it, thankfully, never came to that. So yes, I question with absolute confidence the intelligence of anybody who thought it an idea that would solve anything in a meaningful way. Edited by Matov (06 Jul 2021 3.10pm)
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The EU will reform. It's not a question of if, but of how and when. Why would it reform? One thing I have to pull up many on my side of the debate about, and its a position I have had to move towards, is this notion that somehow the EU is going to disintegrate in the next 10 years. Logic dictates it should due to the disastrous Euro project but the reality that for many European nations, their populace has so little faith in their own political systems/politicians that the EU is actually seen as the less of two evils. Sometimes I think we forget how precarious the lives of many Europeans are, especially those in the southern, central and eastern part. The fate of people in places like Greece and so on, over the last 10 years, has been heart-breaking but on this rotten project trundles because the wider European political class is actually far more venal than even our own. So Brussels actually appears a far safer bet than their own Capital cities with the nations that have adopted the Euro effectively having their entire economies under German control. Hitler tried to do with Panzers, Merkal did it with banknotes.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
A fair point although I would pull you up on your last point. Anybody who thought that a second referendum that included a Remain option before we had actually left the EU was a vote winner (and a second referendum could only come about after another General Election given the requirement for another specific referendum act) has to be retarded given all the evidence out there pointing to the exact opposite. And why Johnson now has a majority of 80. I am sure Boris thanks all of those who made that possibe. Pushing for a position of just ignoring the Brexit vote and continuing the UK's membership of the EU was actually the far smarter stance to take, albeit again an electorally disastrous one. But given the legal status of the referendum as being only advisory, as opposed to a plebiscite, then HMG was quite within its constitutional rights to have just ignored the result. Of course, there would have been consequences but that position was far more logical than any nonsense about a second vote before the first one was acted upon. Ignore or act upon the June 2016 result were the only two courses of action that made any rational sense. A second vote along the lines of Labour was proposing would have plunged this country into effective civil war and lives would have been lost. An utter catastrophe on so many levels. But it, thankfully, never came to that. So yes, I question with absolute confidence the intelligence of anybody who thought it an idea that would solve anything in a meaningful way. Edited by Matov (06 Jul 2021 3.10pm) Remoaners like me do not advocate a second referendum. I suspect most of us have long given that up and are as bored as you at re-hashing the same arguments. If we were really determined, there would not have been the last GE landslide. That does not mean that we cannot identify any failings that arise or say I told you so if any predicted calamity comes to pass. So far I am not sure there is any clear evidence either way. Not enough time, and the impact of Covid and still felt financial crisis is hammering and skewering the data.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Its good riddance to the UK, in fact it looks very likely the EU left us, not the other way round.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
EU leaders were prevented from putting their case in the 2016 referendum. The EU bashers cannot take the reality of the brexit disaster and ignore the coming break-up of the UK caused by leaves deceit and lies that the public could not examine in 2016. Their whole campaign was a disgraceful pack of lies. Why they persist with this b****x about the EU reforming or breaking-up God only knows, probably because things are so bad here they don't want to face it. Its good riddance to the UK, in fact it looks very likely the EU left us, not the other way round. ^^^ all valid points. Massive irony if England win The Euros
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.