This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
Campbell's problems appear closely linked to his "difficult" personality. I've heard from more than one source that over the years, a number of clubs (admittedly outside the Premiership) have interviewed him with a serious interest in hiring him but completely changed their minds after speaking to him in person. Wasn't that the reason he lost the jobs he did get, too; the results weren't awful (given the resources he had at his disposal) but within six months he had fallen out with everyone from the chairman to the players? From what I've heard in the media and from direct interviews with him, he appears to take the view that it's "my way or the highway" and he has a rather higher view of his (totally unproven) managerial abilities than his prospective bosses do. Furthermore, he's been quick to play the racism card as the reason he's had few opportunities. To be clear, it's pretty obvious that ingrained racism is almost certainly a reason we haven't had more black managers, but I'm not sure it's the reason Sol Campbell hasn't found a job. Edited by sydtheeagle (08 Aug 2021 2.37pm) some good points. Is there racism at the top end of football? A difficult one, but it is interesting that senior England internationals such as Ince and Campbell had to go to lowly Macclesfield to get a job whereas others got much better opportunities - Lampard, Gerrard etc. Sol does like to use the racism card though. At Arsenal he was one of the highest earning players in the game (similar to Sterling now) so there are clearly opportunities regardless of colour. I do remember Campbell implying he would have been England captain more often if he was white. He played 73 times for England and 500 club games and to my knowledge was rarely captain of his clubs, so thought that a slightly strange conclusion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Is there racism at the top end of football? A difficult one, but it is interesting that senior England internationals such as Ince and Campbell had to go to lowly Macclesfield to get a job whereas others got much better opportunities - Lampard, Gerrard etc. I very much doubt whether there is racism in the Premier League boardrooms as every club will look to appoint the very best manager for the job just as they look to bring in the best players for their teams irrespective of the colour of their skin. I'm not sure that you can use Lampard and Gerrard as examples as they are very rare examples with our own Patrick Vieira moving into coaching in a more traditional manner
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
So no facts to back up your original statement then? Fact are unimportant to some. To deviate from the argument a little, 'trans activist' Munroe Berghof debated with Andrew Neil about the lack of opportunities for black people due to 'systemic racism' and when he challenged her with statistics on how many more black kids got to university than white ones percentage wise, she just said 'those are just facts'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Cor blimey you are one of them guys who’d argue that a circle wasn’t round unless I had the exact measurement of the circumference and multiplied it by pi in front of you...give it a rest son you just look desperate for a row. I just gave an opinion. Grow up. Just wanted to point out 2 tiny errors here; firstly, performing this calculation will not help you determine the roundness of a circle. Secondly, if the circle proves not to be round, it is not, ipso facto, a circle. Hope that helps.
|
|
|
A circle is the locus of a point that moves in two dimensions so that it is a fixed distance from a fixed point. That is a proper mathematical definition. It has nothing to do with whether or not there is systemic racism in football, something which most of us are unable to comment on with any authority. What cannot be denied is that some football fans (who knows how many) are racist (listen to supposed England fans booing John Barnes in the 1980s). For how this can affect players I can recommend reading "My Story" by our very own Mark Bright [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by midlandspalace
A circle is the locus of a point that moves in two dimensions so that it is a fixed distance from a fixed point. That is a proper mathematical definition. It has nothing to do with whether or not there is systemic racism in football, something which most of us are unable to comment on with any authority. What cannot be denied is that some football fans (who knows how many) are racist (listen to supposed England fans booing John Barnes in the 1980s). For how this can affect players I can recommend reading "My Story" by our very own Mark Bright [Link] Thanks for the tip, I didn't know he had an autobiography out but have ordered a copy.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses. |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
For someone who only joined this forum in July ( apparently) you seem to be very angry and aggressive towards people who do not share your opinion. Your post on Henry/Rooney thread seems to substantiate this. Lol did you not read how bitter and dismissive the original post about Henry was? The general consensus seemed to agree with me and the OP literally called Henry “just an arrogant bully” who was not world class..I mean does that not sound like a twisted bitter opinion of someone who’s just out to hate..all I did was suggest he’s chasing the dragon as in a smack head...was not overly aggressive but did list attributes as to back up my reasoning that Henry was as good as everyone said he was... But I’m just a troublemaker aren’t I haha doesn’t matter if the original post was inflammatory and aggressive or not I was there to start trouble ok mate Someone please tell me what was so inflammatory or outrageous about my first comment on this post to have someone draw his sword at me and tell me my opinion was invalid and disgraceful just because I dared to suggest black players might have a difference experience..is the the English football lads alliance page am I on the wrong forum or what? I know there are a few Yaxley-Lennon minions on here but cor blimey I didn’t realise they were so sensitive and fragile The pack mentality I’m seeing on this forum is really infantile yet unsurprising as there is safety in numbers and the internet is a safe space for people with strong outdated convictions that lack substance- daily mail readers etc And just to let you know I’ve been reading this forum for around ten years probably a bit more so not new here at all and been watching palace since my first game at selhurst millwall 1994 I was there at Leicester Claridge I was there when hopkin curled one I was there for Lombardo and at Sasha curcic’s protests I was at Liverpool in the league cup featuring Julian grey etc...I was standing on the advertising boards at Stockport when dougie scored and he ran to me to celebrate and hence been there at too many poignant moments over the last twenty years than I could mention..I even walked for an hour and a half to see Trevor Francis punch kolinko in his nose on a cold Tuesday night against Bradford..I’ve got stripes and pedigree and hundreds and hundreds of games on the holmesdale and Arthur wait so I’ve got every right to be here as much as anyone before you question my position again sorry for turning up and having an opinion maybe I’ll just keep it to myself and let the old timers talk trash about whatever they like unchallenged...proper sad little community
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Lol did you not read how bitter and dismissive the original post about Henry was? The general consensus seemed to agree with me and the OP literally called Henry “just an arrogant bully” who was not world class..I mean does that not sound like a twisted bitter opinion of someone who’s just out to hate..all I did was suggest he’s chasing the dragon as in a smack head...was not overly aggressive but did list attributes as to back up my reasoning that Henry was as good as everyone said he was... But I’m just a troublemaker aren’t I haha doesn’t matter if the original post was inflammatory and aggressive or not I was there to start trouble ok mate Someone please tell me what was so inflammatory or outrageous about my first comment on this post to have someone draw his sword at me and tell me my opinion was invalid and disgraceful just because I dared to suggest black players might have a difference experience..is the the English football lads alliance page am I on the wrong forum or what? I know there are a few Yaxley-Lennon minions on here but cor blimey I didn’t realise they were so sensitive and fragile The pack mentality I’m seeing on this forum is really infantile yet unsurprising as there is safety in numbers and the internet is a safe space for people with strong outdated convictions that lack substance- daily mail readers etc And just to let you know I’ve been reading this forum for around ten years probably a bit more so not new here at all and been watching palace since my first game at selhurst millwall 1994 I was there at Leicester Claridge I was there when hopkin curled one I was there for Lombardo and at Sasha curcic’s protests I was at Liverpool in the league cup featuring Julian grey etc...I was standing on the advertising boards at Stockport when dougie scored and he ran to me to celebrate and hence been there at too many poignant moments over the last twenty years than I could mention..I even walked for an hour and a half to see Trevor Francis punch kolinko in his nose on a cold Tuesday night against Bradford..I’ve got stripes and pedigree and hundreds and hundreds of games on the holmesdale and Arthur wait so I’ve got every right to be here as much as anyone before you question my position again sorry for turning up and having an opinion maybe I’ll just keep it to myself and let the old timers talk trash about whatever they like unchallenged...proper sad little community You may have just proved my point
|
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
Thanks for the tip, I didn't know he had an autobiography out but have ordered a copy. It really is a very good read, highly recommended.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
You may have just proved my point Yeah I could have written anything and you’d assume your point to be proven it’s called small mindedness.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Yeah I could have written anything and you’d assume your point to be proven it’s called small mindedness. You could have agreed you were stronging it a bit to call someone a heroin user for having a different view of the merits of one player over another.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
You could have agreed you were stronging it a bit to call someone a heroin user for having a different view of the merits of one player over another. There’s having an opinion then there is straight up calling one of the best footballers of his generation and possibly all time nothing but an arrogant bully and overhyped I mean come on crack head smack head whatever but the guy literally gunned for himself by starting a thread that was so obnoxious me saying you have to be a crazy smack head is not actually that harsh if you take into account a certain level of jest...let’s be honest he was an angry little man bashing his keyboard but me calling him out makes me a troublemaker? I mean seriously these are the same people who call lefties PC snowflakes but they get emotionally fragile when somebody is colourful with a response to an inflammatory opinion there’s a lot of cry babies here I’ve only been here for a week haven’t seen this many grown men cry about non issues in a while..
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
There’s having an opinion then there is straight up calling one of the best footballers of his generation and possibly all time nothing but an arrogant bully and overhyped I mean come on crack head smack head whatever but the guy literally gunned for himself by starting a thread that was so obnoxious me saying you have to be a crazy smack head is not actually that harsh if you take into account a certain level of jest...let’s be honest he was an angry little man bashing his keyboard but me calling him out makes me a troublemaker? I mean seriously these are the same people who call lefties PC snowflakes but they get emotionally fragile when somebody is colourful with a response to an inflammatory opinion there’s a lot of cry babies here I’ve only been here for a week haven’t seen this many grown men cry about non issues in a while.. OK. Personally I’d rather watch Denis Bergkamp than either of them but I’m not going to cry about it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
OK. Personally I’d rather watch Denis Bergkamp than either of them but I’m not going to cry about it. Fair enough that’s a very debatable and valid opinion
|
|
|
Originally posted by dg1937
When we were doing the research for 'Football's Black Pioneers' my co-author and I interviewed many black players who broke into first team football in the '70s and '80s, they pretty much all spoke, in often graphic terms, of the racism they experienced in the game. They also suggested almost unanimously that it was far harder for black former players to get offered chances in management than white former players. People like Rooney, Lampard and Gerrard (I could go on) weren't required to cut their management teeth in the lower divisions. Of course, just because that's what they think doesn't make it true but the statistics do clearly suggest that something is holding black players back from getting management jobs. My money would be on institutional racism being a factor but you don't have to agree with me. I do tend to agree with something Syd said earlier that, in addition to facing the extra barriers that all the aspiring black managers face, Sol Campbell faces an additional barrier called 'being Sol Campbell'. I understand the point that the three often mentioned white players seemed to 'walk' into top management, but to be fair they were all modern day legends (if they exist any more) and reputation talks, whether fair or not. Sol Campbell and Paul Ince, yes both major footballers of their generation, were not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Yeah I could have written anything and you’d assume your point to be proven it’s called small mindedness. Not true but hey Ho. For what it is worth, having up until now not commented on the actual post, I would have Henry in my team over Rooney all day long. Football is all about opinions, if we all thought the same how boring would it be? I do stick to my opinion that you seemed unnecessarily angry though
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Both well articulated and valid points I’m sure some people will be a bit upset about it though because racism definitely doesn’t exist at all apparently Is it any wonder Dion Dublin is managing homes under the hammer rather than Coventry city Probably earning more money on tv, given Coventry’s finances
|
|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Both well articulated and valid points I’m sure some people will be a bit upset about it though because racism definitely doesn’t exist at all apparently Is it any wonder Dion Dublin is managing homes under the hammer rather than Coventry city
Back in the day a senior player could not retire on their football wages so either they went into coaching or they ran a pub. Today these players do not need to work, there is plenty of media work for the photogenic and articulate so this comes back to why go into coaching? Many players make a deal with their partner that once they finish playing they will focus on the family which often comes second e.g. moving clubs / countries. A PL manager is even more time consuming and high profile than being a player as you have 25 time bombs waiting to go of. Is it any wonder that many players think no thanks.
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.