This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Are you seriously suggesting that someone can use their religious belief as a justification to break the law and not be prosecuted as a consequence? How many of certain faiths have been prosecuted for bigamy, even when when the local authority has been obliged to provide a second home for the second wife and children? Last time I looked, bigamy (the offence of marrying someone while already married to another person) under English Law was simply passed off as 'polyandry' under someone else's culture - and ignored.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I had to laugh, Sikhs refused to wear helmet on motorbikes and the law was changed to accommodate them. Also, the Christian bakery who refused to bake a cake and ice it with 'support gay marriage' on it eventually won the day in court.....however if they hadn't had the religious aspect they wouldn't have. Once again made silly by his own words. People break laws all the time for principles, religious or not.....when homosexuality was illegal for example....I can imagine the social conservative version of WE making this argument of adherence to the law despite any personal convictions......This way very little would ever really change. As for the rest of the waffle, it's characterised by that manipulation of wordplay....stating one thing before seemingly contradicting it. I can't be bothered. You need to actually read what I write and not make assumptions born out of your prejudices. Rather than making me look "silly" you really ought to reflect on how ridiculous this makes you look, to anyone with the eyes to see it. No-where have I said that people aren't free to break the law. As you point out, they can, and they do, and changes to the law can sometimes result. That's a matter of conscience. What I have said is that no-one is above the law and insulated from prosecution. Those cake makers were prosecuted, and in the event they were found (very wrongly in my own view) not guilty. They were though subject to the law. As were the Sikhs who refused to wear helmets. That their disobedience campaign resulted in the law being changed is another issue. The law of the time applied to them just as much as it did to everyone else. What you have tried to do is a regular tactic of yours. Deflection from the actual issue. Andrew Torba can break the law if he chooses to, but he is as subject to it as everyone else. It doesn't seem to me as though he accepts this is the position and believes that "God's law" is superior. Which is a defence which has failed in the past. My original question wasn't whether people could break the law if they chose to, or not. It was:- "Do you think that the appeals to God as the ultimate authority, and justification, is wise, given that there are echoes of the reasoning used by extremists of other faiths to be heard?" So is it wise, give the context of today's world?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
How many of certain faiths have been prosecuted for bigamy, even when when the local authority has been obliged to provide a second home for the second wife and children? Last time I looked, bigamy (the offence of marrying someone while already married to another person) under English Law was simply passed off as 'polyandry' under someone else's culture - and ignored. With all due respect, this is another issue. Doubtless very important and deserving of debate, but unconnected to this one. Maybe a new topic?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You need to actually read what I write and not make assumptions born out of your prejudices. Rather than making me look "silly" you really ought to reflect on how ridiculous this makes you look, to anyone with the eyes to see it. No-where have I said that people aren't free to break the law. As you point out, they can, and they do, and changes to the law can sometimes result. That's a matter of conscience. What I have said is that no-one is above the law and insulated from prosecution. Those cake makers were prosecuted, and in the event they were found (very wrongly in my own view) not guilty. They were though subject to the law. As were the Sikhs who refused to wear helmets. That their disobedience campaign resulted in the law being changed is another issue. The law of the time applied to them just as much as it did to everyone else. What you have tried to do is a regular tactic of yours. Deflection from the actual issue. Andrew Torba can break the law if he chooses to, but he is as subject to it as everyone else. It doesn't seem to me as though he accepts this is the position and believes that "God's law" is superior. Which is a defence which has failed in the past. My original question wasn't whether people could break the law if they chose to, or not. It was:- "Do you think that the appeals to God as the ultimate authority, and justification, is wise, given that there are echoes of the reasoning used by extremists of other faiths to be heard?" So is it wise, give the context of today's world? Wow. They were targetted by gay activists they were quite happy to produce a cake for anyone just not the pro gay marriage message. This case was about whose rights were being infringed. The court correctly decided that the gay person did not have the right to insist that the bakers put a message they could not agree with. If the court had upheld the decision it could mean for instance that a Muslim or black baker could be forced to produce a cake with something they felt offensive on. FYI Peter Tatchell the gay rights activist agreed with the court decision as he could see the wider implications. This was never about "get out your gay I'm not serving you".
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
With all due respect, this is another issue. Doubtless very important and deserving of debate, but unconnected to this one. Maybe a new topic? Maybe, but it does refute your point as to whether "someone can use their religious belief as a justification to break the law and not be prosecuted as a consequence?" Polygamy is against the Law in this country, but is not only ignored when practiced by certain people, but actively supported, in many cases, by the provision of social housing.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Maybe, but it does refute your point as to whether "someone can use their religious belief as a justification to break the law and not be prosecuted as a consequence?" Polygamy is against the Law in this country, but is not only ignored when practiced by certain people, but actively supported, in many cases, by the provision of social housing. And benefits.
One more point |
|
|
The guy is pathologically dishonest.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Wow. They were targetted by gay activists they were quite happy to produce a cake for anyone just not the pro gay marriage message. This case was about whose rights were being infringed. The court correctly decided that the gay person did not have the right to insist that the bakers put a message they could not agree with. If the court had upheld the decision it could mean for instance that a Muslim or black baker could be forced to produce a cake with something they felt offensive on. FYI Peter Tatchell the gay rights activist agreed with the court decision as he could see the wider implications. This was never about "get out your gay I'm not serving you". I really don't to get deflected onto the "cake bakers" debate again. It's been done to death! I could see both sides of the argument, and understood that the bakers were deliberately targetted to get a reaction. Nevertheless, I do believe that the underlying principle at stake, namely that if you offer a service for reward, then you leave any personal beliefs on the doorstep, was incorrectly assessed by the Court, who took the view that they could be used as a justification for refusal. I disagreed. If there was no monitory transaction involved, then the judgement was correct but as soon as it became commercial, personal opinions get put aside.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Maybe, but it does refute your point as to whether "someone can use their religious belief as a justification to break the law and not be prosecuted as a consequence?" Polygamy is against the Law in this country, but is not only ignored when practiced by certain people, but actively supported, in many cases, by the provision of social housing. Not really. They can, and should, be prosecuted. If the authorities are deciding not to prosecute, then that's a criticism of the authorities and not the law. Without wanting to get diverted, I wonder how many actual cases of polygamy there are? Someone taking a second partner isn't polygamy unless an actual marriage is involved. It might be considered immoral, but isn't illegal. Any resultant family would be entitled to the same treatment as any other family. The issue is about whether people are ever above the law because of a religious belief. Not whether the law is sometimes not being applied in full.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The guy is pathologically dishonest. Countering argument with insult is the last refuge of the intellectually defeated.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Not really. They can, and should, be prosecuted. If the authorities are deciding not to prosecute, then that's a criticism of the authorities and not the law. Without wanting to get diverted, I wonder how many actual cases of polygamy there are? Someone taking a second partner isn't polygamy unless an actual marriage is involved. It might be considered immoral, but isn't illegal. Any resultant family would be entitled to the same treatment as any other family. The issue is about whether people are ever above the law because of a religious belief. Not whether the law is sometimes not being applied in full. In cases like the cake and turban issue, the people involved aren't necessarily breaking the law. It's more that their are conflicting laws, or laws which are drafted in a way that could be misinterpreted, then they are tested in court. Polygamy in this country is possibly impossible from a legal perspective as second marriage cannot be legally binding.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As stated homosexuality was illegal for centuries, so under WE persecution is what he wants for anyone breaking the law. So the WE of those times would be fully on board with persecuting homosexuals. It's a fallacious argument to suggest people think it's ok to just break the law, no one said that. However, it's also ridiculous to regard the law as something that rises above any consideration and must be obeyed independent of circumstance. There is context, there are bad laws and bad regimes and there is the human right to decide which of those apply. There are many laws on the books that aren't applied in practice for many reasons. Torba is rightly protected under the first amendment. WE can squirm all he likes but my advice is to stop visiting his site. He also represents millions of people who regard silicon valley as anti free speech. I fine WE's views on quite a few subjects abhorrent. However, I wouldn't agree that he should be persecuted for them or pushed underground. WE doesn't seem to realise that his views and indeed social liberalism within society are only in the ascendency now because they were allowed to rise in the past....during far more conservative environments. Essentially an environment where political ideas you don't like aren't allowed to compete with your own is wholly anti western. Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Sep 2021 11.19am) Not the issue. Plenty of campaigns have been run by people deciding to break the law to draw attention to an unfairness, and have won. Indeed, many welcomed prosecutions as they provided the oxygen of publicity they needed they get acceptance within society, and the law changed. Torba doesn't appear to think like that. He wants to create a totally separate economy, and presumably the legal system needed to support it. He doesn't want to work within the system. For those interested, try reading this opinion piece. There is a lot more going on here than a simple claim of seeking "free speech":-
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
In cases like the cake and turban issue, the people involved aren't necessarily breaking the law. It's more that their are conflicting laws, or laws which are drafted in a way that could be misinterpreted, then they are tested in court. Polygamy in this country is possibly impossible from a legal perspective as second marriage cannot be legally binding. Fair points. The law though applied, even if it needed to be clarified.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's not an insult, it's what I believe is the truth, just as is the recognition that you are intelligent. Also let's remember that you once called me a sub species, and have used 'insults' many times....you even called this a far right site. So on this summary intellectual defeat must be something you regularly feel. I believe your condition is how you deal with it. Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Sep 2021 11.27am) Spending weeks trawling back to be able to find comments which resemble those I am accused of making, and then setting them in context, is not something I have either the time, or inclination to do. There would though have been a context, and without it, they are meaningless. This site is disproportionately much further to the right than the views held by the average British person. Whether you regard that as "far" right will always depend on how far along the spectrum you are yourself.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Spending weeks trawling back to be able to find comments which resemble those I am accused of making, and then setting them in context, is not something I have either the time, or inclination to do. There would though have been a context, and without it, they are meaningless. This site is disproportionately much further to the right than the views held by the average British person. Whether you regard that as "far" right will always depend on how far along the spectrum you are yourself. The number of users on the site also appear to be dwindling, as a handful of far right posters keep turning everything into an issue about ethnicities, imigration and how hard done by they are. Now it's predictably time for the PA supporter trying to claim he's not far right...
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
The number of users on the site also appear to be dwindling, as a handful of far right posters keep turning everything into an issue about ethnicities, imigration and how hard done by they are. Now it's predictably time for the PA supporter trying to claim he's not far right... I don't really care what a centralist desperate to be liked by leftists thinks I am. I'm a social conservative and compared to today's right I'm more Norman Tebbit than Cameron.....or in your fantasy world I'm sitting here with a Hitler poster on the wall practicing my goose stepping. Believe what you want to believe....while you still have the privilege. Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Sep 2021 1.11pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.