You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ayew and Benteke
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ayew and Benteke


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Sep 21 7.56pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

You're like a broken record.

I think most agree that Ayew is playing out of position. The Manager is selecting him because he thinks he's currently the best man for the job. Olise only recently returned from injury and is unproven at this level. PV is breaking him in gently - I realise from reading your posts that this is a concept that you find difficult to grasp.

As for Benteke, look at it this way. We spent big on Edouard. We potentially have spent big on Mateta, although I doubt we will see him signed permanently. We don't have unlimited funds. So re-signing Benteke made absolute sense.

Edouard started last night and looks set to get a run in the team. Mateta is assessed, as are all the players, on a daily basis. If he's not getting game time there is a reason for it. As for Rob Street, I think he's a big, bustling grafter but I don't think he's even remotely close to a first team spot. And I'll go on record now and say that I don't think he'll make it at Palace although I hope I'm proven wrong.


Sadly, I don't think you will be. Having been a fairly regular watcher of the U23s over the last 18 months or so, I haven't seen Street do anything to convince me that he'll be a PL or even Championship player.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 28 Sep 21 10.47pm

Originally posted by sprites

Second the broken record comment. It’s beyond boring now. They have their limitations, but they’re palace abs they’re what we’ve got. Benteke should’ve had an assist which is more than EO achieved.

Lanzo and others hate Benteke and want him gone. Others think he’s worth having in the squad.

Shall we all move on?

But he didn't have an assist did he so in fact he didn't achieve more than EO did at all... Pretty pointless point you're making.

Nobody is blaming Benteke for the loss as that would be ridiculous.. But it was clear to see he was slow and lazy when he came on.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

HeathMan Flag Purley 28 Sep 21 11.41pm

Would have enjoyed the Spurs presentation (20 then 22) rather than the Brighton presentation (22 then 20).

When Mr B starts a match (since Roy focused his mind) he does trouble and tire defenders. Replace him with Mr E and our opponents become more fearful. Go the other way without a Mr E goal, and things just coast along. I suspect that with a Mr E start and a goal Mr B will come on as a "starter" and work his socks off - inflicting fear on the opponents. I trust in P.V. and the good surprises I expect him to provide.

COYP

 

sprites Flag Auckland 29 Sep 21 2.02am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

But he didn't have an assist did he so in fact he didn't achieve more than EO did at all... Pretty pointless point you're making.

Nobody is blaming Benteke for the loss as that would be ridiculous.. But it was clear to see he was slow and lazy when he came on.

1) I think you'll find plenty of people are blaming him, in part, for the loss.

2) Ayew's ability to find the net is hardly Benteke's fault. He should've had an assist.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 29 Sep 21 8.01am

Whatever your view on Bentenke surely it must have been frustrating for everyone having seen our forwards force mistakes all game by closing down their defenders to see him trot on and make a half-hearted effort at closing the defenders down. I mean, he was at the game, so he could see that tactic was ruffling their feathers. Is it a fitness issue? A lack of willingness? Whatever it is I personally found it disappointing that he didn't put himself about.

 

eric youngs headband Flag amersham 29 Sep 21 8.32am

Im not aware that we lost? thought it was a draw....

 


4 playoff finals, Claridge, Hopkin, Shipperley, Phillips....

Life's never dull!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Sep 21 9.07am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Whatever your view on Bentenke surely it must have been frustrating for everyone having seen our forwards force mistakes all game by closing down their defenders to see him trot on and make a half-hearted effort at closing the defenders down. I mean, he was at the game, so he could see that tactic was ruffling their feathers. Is it a fitness issue? A lack of willingness? Whatever it is I personally found it disappointing that he didn't put himself about.

This is the issue for me. We were pressing high and it was working. At any level of the game, if you swap in an attacking player when ahead with 10 mins left the instruction is always to empty the tank. To provide some fresh legs against tired defenders.

Unfortunately the Brighton back line must have been pretty happy as they moved past him with ease, and were never under real pressure.

I've said it many time, but effort costs nothing. And if he cant do it for 10 mins after losing his place when can he do it.

 

beak Flag croydon 29 Sep 21 9.58am

Originally posted by eric youngs headband

Im not aware that we lost? thought it was a draw....

I hope you are aware that it felt like a loss. :'(

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 29 Sep 21 10.00am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Do many managers often change their starting 11's when doing well. Over the last couple of games PV has transitioned Luka and Eduard in, and I'm sure Olise will also come in when ready. Out of interest what changes to the starting 11 did you want?

For what its worth I think the subs were right (on paper). The game was starting to swing, and we couldn't really get the ball to stick up top. Plus they are a big side. So bring on some height and some fresh legs. Unfortunately Benteke didn't put a shift in, so we were basically down to 10 men.

Viera isn't stupid and would have seen what we saw. Will he trust that he can bring Benteke on for the last 15 to continue the good pressing work and help lead from the front? I doubt it.

(In the same way that after Jairo's shocker I doubt he'll get a look in for a while.)

FFS this is a discussion board, why do some people get so defensive. I'm happy if you disagree, just state your opinion and go.

For the record we have won 1 game all season and are struggling to score so 'doing well' is clearly subjective.

As you've asked what changes i would make, here are my observations.

1. Kouyate and Macca can't play in the same midfield - both work hard but neither is a great passer. So pick 1. He kept them in the same team until Monday's game. Luka has been slowly coming back to fitness but we also have Hughes who has not kicked a ball yet. Luka after a fine cameo against Spurs didn't feature at all against Liverpool - Jairo was brought on and we all know what happened thereafter, so your transitioning comment is a tad strange.

2. I would have put Olise on with 10 to go on Monday and changed to 442. We were getting overrun at 433 so simply changing personnel would have little impact - and it didn't

3. If we continue playing 433 start switching the Zaha and who ever is on the right. We are too predictable ATM

4. During games also consider switching to 352 and 442 in games rather than rigidly sticking to same system.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 Sep 21 10.14am

Originally posted by eric youngs headband

Im not aware that we lost? thought it was a draw....

We lost two points

 

eric youngs headband Flag amersham 29 Sep 21 10.40am

Originally posted by beak

I hope you are aware that it felt like a loss. :'(


Maybe to some, we got what we deserved in the end. Only one goal to show for all the pretty football, a point in a derby, learnings for Vieira and move on..

 


4 playoff finals, Claridge, Hopkin, Shipperley, Phillips....

Life's never dull!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Sep 21 11.43am

Originally posted by palace99

FFS this is a discussion board, why do some people get so defensive. I'm happy if you disagree, just state your opinion and go.

For the record we have won 1 game all season and are struggling to score so 'doing well' is clearly subjective.

As you've asked what changes i would make, here are my observations.

1. Kouyate and Macca can't play in the same midfield - both work hard but neither is a great passer. So pick 1. He kept them in the same team until Monday's game. Luka has been slowly coming back to fitness but we also have Hughes who has not kicked a ball yet. Luka after a fine cameo against Spurs didn't feature at all against Liverpool - Jairo was brought on and we all know what happened thereafter, so your transitioning comment is a tad strange.

2. I would have put Olise on with 10 to go on Monday and changed to 442. We were getting overrun at 433 so simply changing personnel would have little impact - and it didn't

3. If we continue playing 433 start switching the Zaha and who ever is on the right. We are too predictable ATM

4. During games also consider switching to 352 and 442 in games rather than rigidly sticking to same system.

Wasn’t defensive, it was the start of a discussion. PV made 2 changes to the starting 11 and so I was genuinely interested in what other changes you wanted?

I’d agree on CK and Macca, as with Luka and JR for pace reasons. I’m surprised we haven’t seen Hughes yet, but Macca is playing well, and we suspected he was a Macca stand in vs a starting CM when we bought him.

Personally, I’d disagree on Olise. I am desperate to see him and desperate for him to do well, but in a game of that magnitude, where he might have to do a lot of defending for the final 10 I think it would have been a bit of a risk. But hey, he literally couldn’t have done any worse than Benteke.

I’d be in favour of Wilf being more fluid, like when him and Bolasie used to do it, but he’s not done that in years, so can’t imagine him starting again now.

Yeah, the subs were predictable, in my book that was a good thing. Bring 2 big men on to counter their height for the last 15, and Jeff is an experienced premiership player. The fact that you would have put Macca on the wing and Olise upfront absolutely baffles me. But hey everyone’s opinion is valid.

And formations are fluid. The first half looked very different positionally to the last 10 mins. CK was practically playing as a CB and both wingers were pegged back, so we were effectively playing a 541 at the end. Well 450 because of how little effort Benteke put in.

 

PatrickA Flag London 29 Sep 21 12.05pm

At the time I was happy with the substitutions and understood the logic, particularly with Brighton playing more directly and using their physical presence.
In hindsight the substitutions didn't help, but that's easy to say with the benefit of hindsight.
An argument could me made that Ayew rather than Benteke would be a better option as a sub in a similar scenario i.e when we're holding a lead in the last 15 minutes.
At least he will chase down defenders and run about a bit, which Benteke either won't or can't do.
I'm unconvinced that Benteke will suit Vieira's style in any event.
Has he even looked like scoring in any game where he's featured under Vieira so far?

 

slubglurge Flag welling 29 Sep 21 2.44pm

I actually think we should spend the entire next seasons budget on him. He's that good

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 29 Sep 21 3.48pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Whatever your view on Bentenke surely it must have been frustrating for everyone having seen our forwards force mistakes all game by closing down their defenders to see him trot on and make a half-hearted effort at closing the defenders down. I mean, he was at the game, so he could see that tactic was ruffling their feathers. Is it a fitness issue? A lack of willingness? Whatever it is I personally found it disappointing that he didn't put himself about.


And his laziness was apparent within 30 seconds of him coming on. PV was doing his nut trying to get Benteke to get stuck in.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Sep 21 4.27pm

Lets hope that PV learns fast, that what you do on the training pitch and in the real game is completely different.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

ChicagoPalace Flag 29 Sep 21 4.44pm

There really is not much excuse for Ayew's off target attempt. That's a shot he has to convert. That said, when it comes to holding a lead, and assuming both Benteke and Ayew are on the bench, I'd much rather Ayew come in for Edouard than Benteke. Ayew's work rate is much higher, and he is much better at holding/maintaining possession and drawing fouls than Benteke. It's a role he fit most capably two seasons ago.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 29 Sep 21 5.22pm

Regarding Benteke, he's a mediocre footballer, and to top it off, he's a lazy cnut as well. I have no doubt that PV has realised that Benteke won't fit into the high press scheme of things, and as currently we don't seem to be playing for crosses that much I wonder where that leaves Benteke...

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 29 Sep 21 8.03pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

I actually think we should spend the entire next seasons budget on him. He's that good

yup.
agree with that.
be too late soon.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Sep 21 9.03pm

Originally posted by doombear


And his laziness was apparent within 30 seconds of him coming on. PV was doing his nut trying to get Benteke to get stuck in.

That's good to know. PV will either get him to work, or just wont trust him

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ayew and Benteke