This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
NHS hot potato
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
cryrst The garden of England 12 Jan 22 2.46pm |
|
|
So mention privatising the NHS and loads go in to melt down about care at point of need etc etc. The NHS is too big to fail but to big to succeed. It is an inefficient dinosaur wasting money and not fulfilling its potential. (CP this isn't about the recent dosh ) Most staff are wonderful people with caring being the prime reason for working in said NHS. Wages are paid for the job they do rightly or wrongly but that is a matter of opinion. Now that's out of the way I think there are parts of it which would benefit from being privatised. There are too many chiefs and not enough Indians for a start. (figure of speech before; you know.....). Anyhow I'm not a business man but some learned people on here and within our society could prove these points no doubt with facts and figures. Alongside less wastage, less crap staff, possible better wages, savings to hmg whichever colour could and would be made. Any ideas because whenever it's mentioned the BMA rock up to Russel square for a march and any suggestion is put to bed.
|
kingdowieonthewall Sussex, ex-Cronx. 12 Jan 22 3.22pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So mention privatising the NHS and loads go in to melt down about care at point of need etc etc. The NHS is too big to fail but to big to succeed. It is an inefficient dinosaur wasting money and not fulfilling its potential. (CP this isn't about the recent dosh ) Most staff are wonderful people with caring being the prime reason for working in said NHS. Wages are paid for the job they do rightly or wrongly but that is a matter of opinion. Now that's out of the way I think there are parts of it which would benefit from being privatised. There are too many chiefs and not enough Indians for a start. (figure of speech before; you know.....). Anyhow I'm not a business man but some learned people on here and within our society could prove these points no doubt with facts and figures. Alongside less wastage, less crap staff, possible better wages, savings to hmg whichever colour could and would be made. Any ideas because whenever it's mentioned the BMA rock up to Russel square for a march and any suggestion is put to bed.
absolutely. I worked as a contractor in many NHS properties. the amount of £££ spunked on trivial schemes & tinpot ideas is atrocious. Ive seen large waste containers the size of a bungalow, full of reasonably new office furniture, chairs etc as they 'no longer complied' painted whole corridors 100s yds long, to re-do it all again a year later as the 'focus colour' had changed. i could go on..
Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents? Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.
|
the.universal 12 Jan 22 3.34pm |
|
|
Public sector inefficiency or private sector profit. You pay for either system.
Generally I am pro-business but I don’t believe certain utilities can ever really be privatised. Take the railways - heads the private companies win, tails they don’t lose - just hand it back if isn’t making money.
Risk of going bust is a key motivator for private sector firms. Feck it up and you are toast. Without that incentive they are not truly private companies.
Regarding privatising the NHS, I can’t see it providing much benefit. For sure it is inefficient but if you look at the US, which is mainly done on an insurance basis is also full of inefficiency. Care is massively over-specced, drugs over-prescribed, just to make money, not for any health benefits. Also their system is much less fair than ours.
Vive le Roy!
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Jan 22 5.31pm |
|
Originally posted by the.universal
Public sector inefficiency or private sector profit. You pay for either system.
Generally I am pro-business but I don’t believe certain utilities can ever really be privatised. Take the railways - heads the private companies win, tails they don’t lose - just hand it back if isn’t making money.
Risk of going bust is a key motivator for private sector firms. Feck it up and you are toast. Without that incentive they are not truly private companies.
Regarding privatising the NHS, I can’t see it providing much benefit. For sure it is inefficient but if you look at the US, which is mainly done on an insurance basis is also full of inefficiency. Care is massively over-specced, drugs over-prescribed, just to make money, not for any health benefits. Also their system is much less fair than ours.
I mean certain parts, like patient transport or ambulances. Maybe procurement of medication and bedding and equipment etc. Care is paramount but savings here can go towards the care and wages maybe.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Jan 22 5.48pm |
|
|
They used to have hot potatoes. Usually cold and not even much real potato these days.
Red and Blue Army!
|
croydon proud Any european country i fancy! 12 Jan 22 6.16pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So mention privatising the NHS and loads go in to melt down about care at point of need etc etc. The NHS is too big to fail but to big to succeed. It is an inefficient dinosaur wasting money and not fulfilling its potential. (CP this isn't about the recent dosh ) Most staff are wonderful people with caring being the prime reason for working in said NHS. Wages are paid for the job they do rightly or wrongly but that is a matter of opinion. Now that's out of the way I think there are parts of it which would benefit from being privatised. There are too many chiefs and not enough Indians for a start. (figure of speech before; you know.....). Anyhow I'm not a business man but some learned people on here and within our society could prove these points no doubt with facts and figures. Alongside less wastage, less crap staff, possible better wages, savings to hmg whichever colour could and would be made. Any ideas because whenever it's mentioned the BMA rock up to Russel square for a march and any suggestion is put to bed.
To top heavy for sure, but they only want to privatise the bits that can make them money-let the taxpayer pick up the dross, thats business!
|
BlueJay UK 12 Jan 22 6.24pm |
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
To top heavy for sure, but they only want to privatise the bits that can make them money-let the taxpayer pick up the dross, thats business!
There's something to that unfortunately. The NHS, though imperfect is a valuable and vital safety net. I'm not sure that we have anything more valuable to lose in this country. We must be on the look out to ward off any creeping changing that will warp its nature. Governments will likely attempt to do the opposite. They will invite such changes in.
|
croydon proud Any european country i fancy! 12 Jan 22 6.28pm |
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
There's something to that unfortunately. The NHS, though imperfect is a valuable and vital safety net. I'm not sure that we have anything more valuable to lose in this country. We must be on the look out to ward off any creeping changing that will warp its nature. Governments will likely attempt to do the opposite. They will invite such changes in.
Richi was in California the other week getting the ball rolling, we soon won"t be able to get the drugs required for treatment as the pharmos are already in charge- it will be just the stuff you could do yourself at home that you will get an appointment for.
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Jan 22 7.19pm |
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
To top heavy for sure, but they only want to privatise the bits that can make them money-let the taxpayer pick up the dross, thats business!
Isn't making money the same as saving money in this particular scenario. Lets say hmg were to offer to privatise certain bits and then guaranteed a healthy pay rise for the staff. You would then say what?
Edited by cryrst (12 Jan 2022 7.21pm)
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Jan 22 7.23pm |
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Richi was in California the other week getting the ball rolling, we soon won"t be able to get the drugs required for treatment as the pharmos are already in charge- it will be just the stuff you could do yourself at home that you will get an appointment for.
You do talk some belony. Why would they limit drugs that people need. Take the red glasses off and try to see any benefit of cost savings.
|
croydon proud Any european country i fancy! 12 Jan 22 7.35pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Isn't making money the same as saving money in this particular scenario. Lets say hmg were to offer to privatise certain bits and then guaranteed a healthy pay rise for the staff. You would then say what?
Edited by cryrst (12 Jan 2022 7.21pm)
It doesn"t work like that- they might privatise but only give the bare minimum to staff- always works that way.
|
croydon proud Any european country i fancy! 12 Jan 22 7.37pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
You do talk some belony. Why would they limit drugs that people need. Take the red glasses off and try to see any benefit of cost savings.
You just don"t get it, they wont spend on the privatised drugs as they are to expensive and would rather bandage 10 peoples arms- thats 10 happy customers- rather than the one life saving op- looks better in the accounts.Take off those blue tinted specs !
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Jan 22 7.52pm |
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
You just don"t get it, they wont spend on the privatised drugs as they are to expensive and would rather bandage 10 peoples arms- thats 10 happy customers- rather than the one life saving op- looks better in the accounts.Take off those blue tinted specs !
Apart from by not bandaging the arm they might have two deaths. The NHS was never designed to keep people alive. It was designed to make people better. Sooner people realise that death happens the expectations might be more realistic!
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 12 Jan 22 9.42pm |
|
|
We have universal health care medicine mostly free at the point of delivery via the NHS.
This model would make it hard for the service to be run as anything but a nationalised service.
Ok we can take two very real examples of where public and private try to co exist in universal healthcare.
GP's are mostly self employed and some are so overworked they are no longer able to provide a service. I know a few and for them it is not a money issue. It is simply they do not have enough hours in the day. They are so reliant on other non existent services they have taken up as much slack as they can. Dentists meanwhile will often not provide an NHS service as it is far more profitable to run a private one. (Despite NHS dental fees being too expensive for those who probably really need them.)
Back in the day National Insurance was a levy to pay for things like the NHS, increasingly now that pot as more akin to general taxation. Maybe we should go back to ring fenced funding of the NHS. I wonder if folks would miss as many appointments if they understood the costs.
|
Badadmcmad Leeds 12 Jan 22 9.55pm |
|
|
I wonder if it occurs to people, generally, that the Tories are big fans of privatisation and indeed have been privatising a lot of the NHS over the years.
They are also responsible for the record waiting list times - despite the money being thrown at the NHS (well, more and more syphoned quickly to the private sector).
Also, worth noting that the private sector which receives billions from NHS contracts also are involved in billion pound litigations against the NHS over contract issues (Virgin Health).
The point is, that the NHS is struggling because it's not being directed properly and that is more than likely deliberate.
If you think privatisation is a good thing, where is the extreme example of such a system? The US...?
The NHS is very efficient. This is why the vaccine rollout went well once the NHS took over from Tory corporate buddies.
Originally posted by cryrst
So mention privatising the NHS and loads go in to melt down about care at point of need etc etc. The NHS is too big to fail but to big to succeed. It is an inefficient dinosaur wasting money and not fulfilling its potential. (CP this isn't about the recent dosh ) Most staff are wonderful people with caring being the prime reason for working in said NHS. Wages are paid for the job they do rightly or wrongly but that is a matter of opinion. Now that's out of the way I think there are parts of it which would benefit from being privatised. There are too many chiefs and not enough Indians for a start. (figure of speech before; you know.....). Anyhow I'm not a business man but some learned people on here and within our society could prove these points no doubt with facts and figures. Alongside less wastage, less crap staff, possible better wages, savings to hmg whichever colour could and would be made. Any ideas because whenever it's mentioned the BMA rock up to Russel square for a march and any suggestion is put to bed.
D'oh!
|
Wisbech Eagle Truro Cornwall 12 Jan 22 10.30pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So mention privatising the NHS and loads go in to melt down about care at point of need etc etc. The NHS is too big to fail but to big to succeed. It is an inefficient dinosaur wasting money and not fulfilling its potential. (CP this isn't about the recent dosh ) Most staff are wonderful people with caring being the prime reason for working in said NHS. Wages are paid for the job they do rightly or wrongly but that is a matter of opinion. Now that's out of the way I think there are parts of it which would benefit from being privatised. There are too many chiefs and not enough Indians for a start. (figure of speech before; you know.....). Anyhow I'm not a business man but some learned people on here and within our society could prove these points no doubt with facts and figures. Alongside less wastage, less crap staff, possible better wages, savings to hmg whichever colour could and would be made. Any ideas because whenever it's mentioned the BMA rock up to Russel square for a march and any suggestion is put to bed.
This seems to suggest that the private sector is not already heavily involved in the NHS. Estimates vary that between 25% and 40% of its budget is spent via the private sector. Which is already substantial by any measurement. Some ambulance services, for instance, are privatised.
It's a question of common sense. If using the profit motive produces hard work and efficiency, go for it. If it results in cutting corners, stressing staff, reducing care quality and lengthening waits then don't. That generally means that support services can be privatised whilst clinical provisions ought not to be.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.
|
The Dolphin 13 Jan 22 7.20am |
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
absolutely. I worked as a contractor in many NHS properties. the amount of £££ spunked on trivial schemes & tinpot ideas is atrocious. Ive seen large waste containers the size of a bungalow, full of reasonably new office furniture, chairs etc as they 'no longer complied' painted whole corridors 100s yds long, to re-do it all again a year later as the 'focus colour' had changed. i could go on..
Me too! There are too many stories to tell!
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Jan 22 12.55pm |
|
|
My first adult job was as admin in the NHS. Hilarious title of deceased patient's property, I also did the wages and petty cash,and gave out 'pocket money' from the welfare of longer term patients. There were three in total in my office. We had five managers. I presume it hasn't changed much in that regard. Of course, the hospital used to do a lot then, but very little now. Just minor procedures. Not even A & E which is 30 miles away on packed roads.
Edited by ASCPFC (14 Jan 2022 12.56pm)
Red and Blue Army!
|
Badger11 Beckenham 16 Mar 22 7.46am |
|
|
My neighbour has prostrate cancer and had it removed. He was then having regular scans to check if they had got it all.
I saw him yesterday the cancer has now spread to his pelvis and requires more aggressive treatment e.g. Chemo. What is really upsetting him is that the NHS knew this from his last scan over 2 months ago.
So having taking over 2 months to tell him the operation hadn't worked when they knew back then he now has to join a waiting list for chemo, yet more delays.
Understandably he is now fearful that it is too late and the cancer has spread too far.
I hope this is not a common occurrence but you do wonder with the NHS.
Edited by Badger11 (16 Mar 2022 7.47am)
One more point
|
Hrolf The Ganger 16 Mar 22 9.04am |
|
|
In the real world, my experience of my local hospitals tells me that they are disgracefully run by often underqualified people with little or no communication or organisation and with too few staff.
The net result is a service that is not fit for purpose.
I despair at the amount of people who must die unnecessarily due to misdiagnosis, poor treatment or incorrect or unnecessary medication.
Something has to change.
|