You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Post Match Analysis Semi - Thoughts? What next?
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Post Match Analysis Semi - Thoughts? What next?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 18 Apr 22 9.08pm

It's quite clear to me that without CG we are a different team, I would look at now as a pre season run for next year.

CG should now predominantly be on the bench in favour for our starters for next year. We need to see what we have, to then decide what we need to do in terms of signings for the summer.

To keep using CG til the end is only kidding ourselves - we are secure for this season and should utilize that.

Chelsea have done us no favours what so ever, so why should we to them and keep CG in the shop window or gaining game time - this is nothing personal, he's a fantastic player, but he isn't ours or our future.

A mistake opened us up and that's understandable given Cheslea's squad and experience.

we have had a fantastic season and it's not even over.

 


This was once a quality forum....

daven Flag Hailsham 18 Apr 22 11.05pm

We have a manager in his first season in the Premier league, so let's cut him some slack. We did have a not too testing route to the semi final and when you come up against a club with resources like Chelsea then it was going to be difficult. We needed everything to go perfectly in the build up but with Gallagher missing and problems with Mitchell and Olise and Clyne we were always going to be up against it.
Having said all that I felt that the Mateta withdrawal was a bit strange, because we had no focal point for the attack. Zaha was asked to play in the middle which might work against lesser opposition. Then to bring Benteke on seemed to be an admission that he got it wrong. Bringing Olise on late, made me think back to Ian Wright being brought on late in the cup final. Many wise managers have said that you have to start your best players so that you see how long they can manage rather than guess how long you think they will last.
Chelsea are reigning European, World champions , they didn't get there by being naive, they used cynical tactics to beat us so we should hold our heads high and just enjoy the ride wherever it takes us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Apr 22 11.49pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

It's quite clear to me that without CG we are a different team, I would look at now as a pre season run for next year.

CG should now predominantly be on the bench in favour for our starters for next year. We need to see what we have, to then decide what we need to do in terms of signings for the summer.

To keep using CG til the end is only kidding ourselves - we are secure for this season and should utilize that.

Chelsea have done us no favours what so ever, so why should we to them and keep CG in the shop window or gaining game time - this is nothing personal, he's a fantastic player, but he isn't ours or our future.

A mistake opened us up and that's understandable given Cheslea's squad and experience.

we have had a fantastic season and it's not even over.

My view is that thus far we have enjoyed a season where the football has been far more enjoyable than in recent campaigns,we are a 'Work in progress' and in transition and the portents are encouraging and promising, however I would not go so far as to label it in the 'Fantastic' category.

New manager, new players, new style of football, accordingly I have always kept a lid on my expectations whilst being cautiously optimistic about our prospects.

Edited by Willo (18 Apr 2022 11.53pm)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 19 Apr 22 12.24am

Originally posted by Vaibow

It's quite clear to me that without CG we are a different team, I would look at now as a pre season run for next year.

CG should now predominantly be on the bench in favour for our starters for next year. We need to see what we have, to then decide what we need to do in terms of signings for the summer.

To keep using CG til the end is only kidding ourselves - we are secure for this season and should utilize that.

Chelsea have done us no favours what so ever, so why should we to them and keep CG in the shop window or gaining game time - this is nothing personal, he's a fantastic player, but he isn't ours or our future.

A mistake opened us up and that's understandable given Cheslea's squad and experience.

we have had a fantastic season and it's not even over.

I absolutely understand what you say. It makes sense to ditch him now and learn to play without him. But, we have him until the end of the season, paid up already. If we ditch him and lose a few places, that has no value to us, apart from realising we need him. However, if we play him and we gain places we will have more money in the 'war chest' to replace him (A hypothetical four place swing is worth more than he will have cost us, so would effectively pay for his loan period). And if we lose places whilst playing him, we have a bigger problem than we realise.

I think I know which the management will choose.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 19 Apr 22 3.15am

1. I am ecstatically pleased with having PV as our manager.
2. I think PV has achieved miracles and needs to be acclaimed.
3. I hope PV stays for a long time as CPFC manager.
4. As PV keeps saying, his players needs to keep improving, and
I believe that sentiment applies to him as a manager too.
5. PV is not perfect and I am not going to pretend that he is.
6. I do not want him gone. I hope for the opposite in fact.

That said, regarding the semi final:

1. He screwed up. With what he's achieved so far I would be very mean not to forgive that. But he screwed up. I know it. YOU know it. Never a chance in hell with the line-up he picked and the tactics he adopted.

Now some will angrily retort: "Oh shut up! You're not the manager! He is! We were just beaten by a far better team! Olise, Hughes, Clyne etc must have been injured!

Sorry... If you are fit enough to be on the bench you are fit enough to play as Olise showed. Sometimes, getting too much praise about your performance (as a manager) can go to your head. I think it went to his head. I saw Ward high on the right wings several times in the first half trying to reach Andersen's long crosses... SEVERAL TIMES! Even if Wardy (Bless HIM!!!) did reach those crosses...WTF could he possibly do with it to create a chance??? We are not good enough as a team to have the luxury of weak pieces of the jigsaw. And Chelsea are too good. Ward on, together with 'hang back' tactics, spelt disaster. Then when we were 2-0 down the silly subs...

You know, I know, we all know, for Palace to have had a chance, Eze in place of Conor (I do not believe that Palace are so weak that we are useless without Gallagher) and strict tactics to go at their heels for the get-go, try and force a mistake, stop them playing (which we achieved with Man City and Arse and Everton and others), steal an early goal and get them rattled and freaking out and under pressure. Now, THAT still may not have worked against a very good Chelsea team, but we all know that was our biggest hope - not sitting back, allowing them to play, soaking pressure, which we have proven is not our strong point.

So, please do not reply with insulting accusations at me for wanting to crucify PV and being a lousy supporter. I just want to call things true. PV stuffed up - okay - let's move on...

 

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Apr 22 4.36am

Originally posted by Oddball2021

1. I am ecstatically pleased with having PV as our manager.
2. I think PV has achieved miracles and needs to be acclaimed.
3. I hope PV stays for a long time as CPFC manager.
4. As PV keeps saying, his players needs to keep improving, and
I believe that sentiment applies to him as a manager too.
5. PV is not perfect and I am not going to pretend that he is.
6. I do not want him gone. I hope for the opposite in fact.

That said, regarding the semi final:

1. He screwed up. With what he's achieved so far I would be very mean not to forgive that. But he screwed up. I know it. YOU know it. Never a chance in hell with the line-up he picked and the tactics he adopted.

Now some will angrily retort: "Oh shut up! You're not the manager! He is! We were just beaten by a far better team! Olise, Hughes, Clyne etc must have been injured!

Sorry... If you are fit enough to be on the bench you are fit enough to play as Olise showed. Sometimes, getting too much praise about your performance (as a manager) can go to your head. I think it went to his head. I saw Ward high on the right wings several times in the first half trying to reach Andersen's long crosses... SEVERAL TIMES! Even if Wardy (Bless HIM!!!) did reach those crosses...WTF could he possibly do with it to create a chance??? We are not good enough as a team to have the luxury of weak pieces of the jigsaw. And Chelsea are too good. Ward on, together with 'hang back' tactics, spelt disaster. Then when we were 2-0 down the silly subs...

You know, I know, we all know, for Palace to have had a chance, Eze in place of Conor (I do not believe that Palace are so weak that we are useless without Gallagher) and strict tactics to go at their heels for the get-go, try and force a mistake, stop them playing (which we achieved with Man City and Arse and Everton and others), steal an early goal and get them rattled and freaking out and under pressure. Now, THAT still may not have worked against a very good Chelsea team, but we all know that was our biggest hope - not sitting back, allowing them to play, soaking pressure, which we have proven is not our strong point.

So, please do not reply with insulting accusations at me for wanting to crucify PV and being a lousy supporter. I just want to call things true. PV stuffed up - okay - let's move on...

The thing is, we'll never know. So it's pointless speculating really. We may have gone at them just as you say, left ourselves too open and ended up losing 5-0. (Which to be fair, is no worse off than 2-0 in a knockout game.) Either way, I think to say Vieria screwed up is a tad harsh. We were well in it for the first 45.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 19 Apr 22 6.15am

Joel Ward is many things, one of which is not a wing back.

Nick Pope off Burnley, a decent young right back, and something close to Connor and we will be in good shape for next year. Offload Trekkers, Jairo, Luka, Tomkins, Kelly, and bring some of the 23s through.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 19 Apr 22 6.22am

Pope will be very much in demand

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

YT Flag Oxford 19 Apr 22 7.07am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Pope will be very much in demand

Is he a Catholic?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 19 Apr 22 7.33am

Had we taken our chances early on, if Loftus-Cheek hadn't got the deflected pass and if he's shot hadn't taken a deflection.......

It could have been different. As it was they came out in the 2nd half and were much better.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

YT Flag Oxford 19 Apr 22 7.46am

Originally posted by Willo

Personally I will be surprised if we attain 50 pts.

I too will be surprised. We were pretty poor against Leicester (with Gallagher) and duly lost, and I expect a similar result away to Newcastle. I hope I'm wrong, but if I'm right, that would mean 13 points from 6 games to hit 50 points. Unlikely.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

The Dolphin Flag 19 Apr 22 8.45am

My general summary of Sunday is that PV changed our normal set-up and it just didn't work.
Ward instead of Clyne as well which was odd.
A poor set up which was badly executed.
This business of Chelsea and money is a smokescreen.
Yes - of course they should beat us but we have just drawn against City and thrashed Arsenal.
We should have gone at Chelsea from the off and in my opinion they were there for the taking.
I feel that it was a poor game and we were the worst of two poor sides - based purely on Sunday's game.
Life without Connor Gallacher doesn't look good though - when he doesn't play you really realise how good he is!
As for our season - we are safe and have reached a cup semi-final which is amazing and we have youth starting to play under a Manager who is getting a lot more right than wrong overall so the future is bright.
Come on you Palace!

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 19 Apr 22 3.26pm

agree with OP - it's fine to set up defensive, but when we did get the ball in an advanced area at times there was a real lack of conviction or support going forward - like we actually wanted to give them the ball back. We missed Gallagher so much - I think we were found out to a degree. The plan was to be more direct, but we could not put together any good link play, it was like Coppell was the manager the way we attacked.

 

eaglesdare Flag 19 Apr 22 3.33pm

If we win, Vieira gives a tactical master class but we lost so he got it wrong!

Thought it was going well in the first half! Second half Chelsea stepped up a few gears and a goal was comming!

The top teams know how to win those games! They are in them every season!

In hindsight I would have loved us to play like we normally did this season but hey! Whatcha gonna do? Had a great day out! Minus bumping into Chelsea fans! They really are the worst!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Apr 22 3.50pm

Been off for a week, so catching up - but looking through this thread has surprised me somewhat.

Saw the game on tv, and surprised that most of you think that PV made errors, or was at fault for anything...

Chelsea's form has picked up recently, and we were without CG, and Olise - who has just come back From injury, has played 0 minutes since, so was never going to start. I was expecting Chelsea simply to have too much for us, and so it proved - but thought we gave a good account of ourselves. for me it Was a lesson in taking chances. We gave them little, they scored with one well hit shot - which would have been saved but for a deflection, and one good goal - where Mounts excellent first touch out him through. (similar to that CG goal recently)

I thought Ward starting was odd, but understandable given that he's only been out through Injury, and is PVs choice when a solid defence is required. And I was encouraged by the inclusion of Eze (although I thought he was pretty ineffectual all night, rarely passing the ball forwards and slowing down the play).

Both teams remained solid in the first half, with midfields generally cancelling each other out, but Were unlucky not to go in at half time ahead after we hit the post.

The Ayew sub I found the Most bizzare, taking off Mateta so early. It did mean Eze was moved a little more centrally, which I think suited him more.. not that he did much. - Chelsea marked him out of the Game A little too easily. He looks like a player who needs some confidence to turn and attack and not quite on the same wavelengh as his teammates.

When Chelsea scored, PV reacted quickly with 2 attacking subs, and we immediately looked more threatening. would RH had done that? fair play to PV, he rolled the dice.. we needed a goal. Shame Mateta had gone off earlier.

All in all, It went as I expected. We had our 2 MVP's out, and Eze still finding his feet after injury. In spite of this we were competitive and made a few chances (would have liked to have created more.. think this can be Attributed to Eze's woes mentioned earlier) as soon as Olise came on we looked more dangerous.

I think PV saw this, and put out a team accordingly, and but for those two goals, and a couple of misses from our Players it could have been a different result, against a very good team.

Edited by CrazyBadger (19 Apr 2022 3.56pm)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 19 Apr 22 8.13pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

My overriding thought when I got home last night was that football is dead. As lifted and proud as I always am by following the Palace in victory or defeat, I was utterly depressed at the pointlessness of it all. Following Palace feels like being a missionary for something that no longer exists.

Sport is competition, and there is none left in ours. So what's the point? The game is just a handful of foreign millionaires who, if you're lucky, leave a few scraps for the other 90 clubs to fight over. Personally, I genuinely wish the European Super League would go ahead. Then Liverpool, Man City, Chelsea, and a couple of others can f*** off and let the rest of us revive and enjoy what sport used to be and should be all about.

Yesterday was embarrassing and the authorities who've allowed the game to be reduced to a giant, prawn sandwich should hang their heads in shame. What happened at Wembley? A big wallet followed by absolutely no one who gave a f*** (I'm not sure who the people were at the other end of the stadium, but I wouldn't call them "football supporters" have reached yet another soul-less Cup Final. Palace, meanwhile, were the last actual football club standing in the competition.

Note the words "football club". We are a CLUB. The other sides in the semi-finals were "teams" (possibly excepting Liverpool). There's no sense of "club" about them. I'm surprised, on the back of their shirts, Chelsea and Man City don't add sort codes to their squad numbers.

Edited by sydtheeagle (18 Apr 2022 10.56am)

I’ve only just started to get over the weekend and am slowly going through the comments made- Syd I totally echo your sentiments! Could not have put it better myself.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 19 Apr 22 8.24pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

My general summary of Sunday is that PV changed our normal set-up and it just didn't work.
Ward instead of Clyne as well which was odd.
A poor set up which was badly executed.
This business of Chelsea and money is a smokescreen.
Yes - of course they should beat us but we have just drawn against City and thrashed Arsenal.
We should have gone at Chelsea from the off and in my opinion they were there for the taking.
I feel that it was a poor game and we were the worst of two poor sides - based purely on Sunday's game.
Life without Connor Gallacher doesn't look good though - when he doesn't play you really realise how good he is!
As for our season - we are safe and have reached a cup semi-final which is amazing and we have youth starting to play under a Manager who is getting a lot more right than wrong overall so the future is bright.
Come on you Palace!

Totally agree we have been so much better with Clyne and to play Ward as a wing back was the most peculiar selection of the lot in my book.
But as you say it ain’t all doom and gloom - as the fog of despair and disappointment clears we can see that we are heading in the right direction. I feel that with those remaining older pros due to be upgraded in the summer I have a growing belief that we are only 4 really decent signings away from being a very good team - and if we can keep the group together for a couple of seasons we’ll be back under the Wembley arch before you know it!

We go again. COYP!

 

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Apr 22 10.01pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Joel Ward is many things, one of which is not a wing back.

Nick Pope off Burnley, a decent young right back, and something close to Connor and we will be in good shape for next year. Offload Trekkers, Jairo, Luka, Tomkins, Kelly, and bring some of the 23s through.

And leave us with what CB cover exactly...? Madness. Tomkins is still a quality CB at this level.

The primary need looks by far to be a striker at this point. None of the three we have seem to be favoured by PV really...and not sure we can rely on a young Plange.

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 19 Apr 22 10.34pm

I think I'm the only one who thought PV did a great job on Sunday. Chelsea had practically no chances the entire first half. Kouyate had a half chance, that if it had gone in, totally changes the game.

At half-time, we had played as well as or better than Chelsea. The second half was more of the same, until Mitchell's error, then two very fortunate deflections giving Chelsea that goal.

After that, there were only about 20 minutes left, and we hadn't been generating much offense, so PV threw caution to the wind, putting on more attacking players. It didn't work, and we lose 2-0. I can live with that.

I thought we looked like we belonged on the pitch with one of the top sides in the world for most of the match. Our effort was excellent, our defending was excellent. There wasn't one stretch in the first 60 minutes where they dominated play, or created great chances.

Our ability to press them was pretty much out the window with Gallagher not playing. And Olise wasn't able to go the full 90. Given that, I think PV's plan was good, and gave us a shot to win.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

uncleneal Flag Croydon 20 Apr 22 8.18am

Every game has a few ifs and buts……if Kouyate scores then PV is a tactical genius. He doesn’t and people believe he is negative.

We were always going to play cagey football….we were playing the European and World Champions. We were missing CG who nearly always starts the press and MO who has also been great this season.

Mateta was marshalled by two very good centre halves.

I did think the inclusion of Ward was strange but the rest of the team was expected.

Of course they are beatable but you really need to take your chances when they arrive….Kouyate and Andersen headers were terrible misses.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Post Match Analysis Semi - Thoughts? What next?