This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Has Wilf become a bet CF than a winger he is definately the best finisher and times his runs well, maybe if we buy Antoine Semenyo he is LW material, the bits i have seen on youtube he reminds me of Wilf Not uncommon to see players of a certain quality, hit certain ages and switch positions to better suit their new 'mobility' status. Wilf doesn't quite look as blistering as before which was very helpful on the wing but I think has all the requirements for a very good CF: - Not blistering, but still quick I would be keen and I'd also add I'd far more fancy our chances in signing a decent LW than signing an effective CF. Jut my opinion of course
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
It all depends on... 1. Whether we have a better option than Zaha at centre forward 2. Whether playing Zaha upfront allows a better balance in midfield. On the first point, neither Mateta or Edouard have shown evidence they can trouble top premier league defences, lead the line and score 15-20 goals. We don't miss either of them when Zaha goes up top. On the second point, there is no point in having a long-term policy of buying and developing exciting young players if the formation and team selection locks them out. Olise and Eze must play most games if fit, and a space must be left open for the likes of Plange, Ebiowei, the returning Rak-Sakyi et al to get a regular run out. Moving Zaha up top allows us to use two holding midfielders (Docoure and Hughes would be my preference, though the former will need time to adapt) plus Eze, Olise, and then either a young wide-attacker in some games, or an extra central midfielder in others. One thing is for sure, whether he plays on the wing or upfront we get the same sides of the same coin from Wilf as ever - he will give the ball away foolishly when simple passes were available, display petulance when he should be focusing, and waste some eye-catching opportunities. In between all this, he will continue to provide a moment or two every week of the kind of match-winning quality that nobody else in the squad, and very few in the history of the club, are capable of. I garland these comments with concurrence and praise.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
It all depends on... 1. Whether we have a better option than Zaha at centre forward 2. Whether playing Zaha upfront allows a better balance in midfield. On the first point, neither Mateta or Edouard have shown evidence they can trouble top premier league defences, lead the line and score 15-20 goals. We don't miss either of them when Zaha goes up top. On the second point, there is no point in having a long-term policy of buying and developing exciting young players if the formation and team selection locks them out. Olise and Eze must play most games if fit, and a space must be left open for the likes of Plange, Ebiowei, the returning Rak-Sakyi et al to get a regular run out. Moving Zaha up top allows us to use two holding midfielders (Docoure and Hughes would be my preference, though the former will need time to adapt) plus Eze, Olise, and then either a young wide-attacker in some games, or an extra central midfielder in others. Moving Wilf to the wing blocks a path for Plange, Ebiowei etc. One thing is for sure, whether he plays on the wing or upfront we get the same sides of the same coin from Wilf as ever - he will give the ball away foolishly when simple passes were available, display petulance when he should be focusing, and waste some eye-catching opportunities. In between all this, he will continue to provide a moment or two every week of the kind of match-winning quality that nobody else in the squad, and very few in the history of the club, are capable of. Edited by TheBigToePunt (16 Aug 2022 11.45am) The problem with the three you mentioned, along with Olise they are all Left-Footed, Where Semenyo is Right-Footed
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
It all depends on... 1. Whether we have a better option than Zaha at centre forward 2. Whether playing Zaha upfront allows a better balance in midfield. On the first point, neither Mateta or Edouard have shown evidence they can trouble top premier league defences, lead the line and score 15-20 goals. We don't miss either of them when Zaha goes up top. Edited by TheBigToePunt (16 Aug 2022 11.45am)
As for the two strikers you are dismissing because they don't trouble top defences etc.: Edited by doombear (16 Aug 2022 1.24pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
The problem with the three you mentioned, along with Olise they are all Left-Footed, Where Semenyo is Right-Footed If Semenyo is signed, and proves to be of the same standard as Olise and Eze then I'm sure he could offer balance, though personally, I think we have become so used to seeing wingers drive infield onto their stronger foot that we forget the benefits of a left footed player on the left. Schlupp, for instance, offers something different when he plays wide left on occasion. I certainly wouldn't discount a promising left footed player from playing on the left.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
As for the two strikers you are dismissing because they don't trouble top defences etc.: Edited by doombear (16 Aug 2022 1.24pm) I would expect Zaha to get goals if he played up top, and also place pressure on Eze and Olise to get more this season, as that seems the next phase of development for them both. If Zaha plays up top we will also have space for an extra attacking wide player or midfielder, who should also be expected to contribute. I take your point regarding who Edouard scored against, and Mateta being an awkward opponent for lesser sides, but as per my previous post I don't feel like we miss either of them when they don't play. I know it's early days, and I hope he will develop and do well, but there is a reason we are still linked with strikers even after spending money on Edouard. I thought he really struggled last year. His disappointing goal return is explained in part by the time he spent on the bench or on the wing, but he spent so much time on the bench and the wing because his all-round game as a centre-forward was so flaky. He seems to lack killer pace and/or the timing of runs in behind, but isn't very good with his back to goal either. He has little obvious penalty box movement (he doesn't nip across the defender at the front post, or peel off to attack the back post etc), and looks instead to get the ball to feet so he can try and use close control and skill to make shooting chances. He seems very much an individualist, and hasn't shown signs of doing the work a centre forward must for the team. If we are going to accept poor team play in exchange for individual skill, might as well just use Wilf up top - he is far more likely to win us a game. In my opinion, Mateta must wake up and think it's Christmas every day. I just can't believe he ever gets a game, awkward customer to play against or not. Even if you feel I'm being harsh, try this exercise - give all the Palace forwards a nominal score out of ten, or a transfer market value (presuming they all had the same contract length). Then pick the three attacking players who have the highest score/value. I'd be amazed if Mateta was in anyone's most valuable front line. I appreciate that teams need balance and blend, but when it comes to Mateta we are accepting too distinct a lack of quality in exchange for effort. Edited by TheBigToePunt (16 Aug 2022 2.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
For me, the dilemma is getting Wilf, EZe and Olise in the same team, keep the balance and get enough goals. Eze is really good at number 10, like yesterday but doesn't score enough, Wilf on his owm, up-top is too light-weight for games against all but the top teams. Optimally for Wilf, Eze and Olise, we need to play more 4-4-2, with Wilf and ANO up top but the two remaining midfielders need to be top-notch so we really need a better partner for Decoure. Vieira is still singling Ayew out for praise at his press conferences so it seems we are unlikely to get our wish and see less of him in the team. Give him 6/7 more games, he has only played 2 since being fully fit
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I would expect Zaha to get goals if he played up top, and also place pressure on Eze and Olise to get more this season, as that seems the next phase of development for them both. If Zaha plays up top we will also have space for an extra attacking wide player or midfielder, who should also be expected to contribute.
Edited by TheBigToePunt (16 Aug 2022 2.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
For me, the dilemma is getting Wilf, EZe and Olise in the same team, keep the balance and get enough goals. Eze is really good at number 10, like yesterday but doesn't score enough, Wilf on his owm, up-top is too light-weight for games against all but the top teams. Optimally for Wilf, Eze and Olise, we need to play more 4-4-2, with Wilf and ANO up top but the two remaining midfielders need to be top-notch so we really need a better partner for Decoure. Vieira is still singling Ayew out for praise at his press conferences so it seems we are unlikely to get our wish and see less of him in the team.
Olise wants to come inside all the time and being one footed is not good they need to work on that and teach him to play the other side also defend which it looks like the defensive side he has picked up some. (He's young has lots of room to develop) Eze is playing almost as deep play maker how can you expect hi to score and the other thing other players have issues scoring because of service this guy is one who is to supply it now. No to 4-4-2 We play better with 3 up top and they switch around and tuck in when defending. This is what Ed does a lot of and people moan about him yet he is going a lot work rate wise when really we need him in the box with others providing service. Wilf is very lazy now you can see he is set in his ways and is not a CF or striker last night showed this he had 4-5 very good chances taking only 1, he cant battle for the ball or hold it no effort to close people down.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
For me, the dilemma is getting Wilf, EZe and Olise in the same team, keep the balance and get enough goals. Eze is really good at number 10, like yesterday but doesn't score enough, Wilf on his owm, up-top is too light-weight for games against all but the top teams. Optimally for Wilf, Eze and Olise, we need to play more 4-4-2, with Wilf and ANO up top but the two remaining midfielders need to be top-notch so we really need a better partner for Decoure. Vieira is still singling Ayew out for praise at his press conferences so it seems we are unlikely to get our wish and see less of him in the team. Simple from my perspective, I'd like to see us play the 4-3-3 with Olise on the right (RW) , I'd play Wilf up top on his own with a LW, or Wilf on the left with a CF, and play Eze ahead of Doucoure plus another. Ideally, we'd get a partner for Doucoure in the middle and a good signing up top (Goncalo Ramos for me). There's the 4-3-3 with a good few back ups up top (Mal, Ayew, Semenyo, JPM, Edouard) and a few back ups in midfield: Hughes, Schlupp (sub only), JMac, Luka etc. Just my two cents.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Good point well made, but as I understand it your sums presume (or hope!?) that Eduoard or Mateta will get 15-odd goals between them if one or other plays up front all year (or 7 or 8 each if they are rotated), and that Zaha will get roughly the same number of goals from the wing as he did last year, and finally, that he'd get no more than that if played up front. If all those things pan out then we are, as you say, missing some 15 goals in the front line, and a new winger would have to find them. As I say, I'd expect Olise to find another six to eight goals this season, at least. He is developing all the time, and needs to have appropriate expectations placed on his shoulders as part of that. I'd also expect Wilf, if played up front, to get at least another two or three goals than if he played on the wing (accepting that his goals return is high for a winger). That leaves the new winger with four or five to find, which doesn't seem too much to hope for. I'd hope Eze matches Gallagher's goals tally. Moreover, though the numbers can tell a story, they don't tell the whole story, and certainly can't tell us the future. Wilf, for his faults, is a potential menace to any defence in the world. Even top sides will keep an extra player back to offset his threat, or drop off a few yards to deny him the kind of space he took advantage of last night. That makes space for the likes of Eze and Olise, and discourages opponents from pressing us fully. The threat of Zaha alone, in comparison to Edouard or Mateta, could make a beneficial tactical difference to the shape of our games, reducing the time we spend fully under the cosh, and increasing our possession foothold in the match. It's hard to equate that to a number of goals or points lost or gained. Another thing to consider is the effect of better quality individuals on their team mates. Once Eze slipped past Alexander-Arnold and Fabinho last night, Zaha saw the opportunity to run in behind far sooner, and timed the run far better, than I would expect Mateta or Edouard to. That made Eze's excellent pass possible. From there on in, Zaha did what nobody else we have could do. It was an example of a goal that just doesn't get scored with lesser quality players. When at Reading, Olise regularly played defence-splitting passes just like Eze's, and though this is of course a higher league I think both these young creative talents have, in addition to their dribbling skills, the potential to deliver incisive forward passes if the forward is bright enough and on the move. Awareness and movement are signs of quality, and that really is my argument - get the best quality players in the side somehow, even if it means a different shape or style, and then we'll have a better chance.
|
|
|
We have spent good money on Mateta and Edouard,they are considered Centr Forwards,so leave Wilf on the wing and let the other two reveal whether they are good enough.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Has Wilf become a bet CF than a winger he is definately the best finisher and times his runs well, maybe if we buy Antoine Semenyo he is LW material, the bits i have seen on youtube he reminds me of Wilf I think Zaha gets better scoring chances as a CF than as a winger That Eze's centre through ball to Zaha to chase and score was pretty rare.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rainforest
I think Zaha gets better scoring chances as a CF than as a winger That Eze's centre through ball to Zaha to chase and score was pretty rare. I think it worth asking the question however of whether you wanted it to be Wilf, JPM, Edouard or Ayew on the receiving end?? Easy for me to say now but I'm glad it was who it was.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.