This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
|
|
|
Thanks Willo!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yet more staggering evidence as to just how useless referees are, we aren't all just subjectively imagining it. I still maintain VAR should be utilised like hawkeye or whatever it's called in Tennis. The Captain/manager should have 3 chances a game to challenge a decision that should be objectively decided upon. You get it right you keep your challenge, you get it wrong you lose it. The only concern would be disruption to the game however with the amount of time often spent on VAR now I would imagine it wouldn't make much difference and be quicker if anything, the only other time it should be used is for goals/red cards. I strongly suspect everybody in football would be against this as not to further expose the staggering incompetence of referees. In the final analysis referees are human beings operating in high pressure environments, having to make split-second decisions in real time in fast-moving games and of course err from time to time but I do not share the view that they display "Staggering incompetence". In the past whenever I have defended referees on HOL, the discussion has evolved into dastardly "Willo threads", accordingly I have no further comment on this matter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In the final analysis referees are human beings operating in high pressure environments, having to make split-second decisions in real time in fast-moving games and of course err from time to time but I do not share the view that they display "Staggering incompetence". In the past whenever I have defended referees on HOL, the discussion has evolved into dastardly "Willo threads", accordingly I have no further comment on this matter. I would strongly assert that their incompetence is 'staggering' Willo. To provide a balanced argument for my view on this, I had long hailed Michael Oliver as some sort of refereeing deity for no reason whatsoever aligned to my love and support of Palace. I just thought he was very good at his job and still do whilst acknowledging he is as fallible to human fault as anyone else, something I have articulated a number of times on this platform. Therefore it is not any stereotyped, subjective, heavily biased hysterics from a football fan for me, it is a very sincere view that many of them should not be in the role and a complete loss as to how we are not able to churn out such officials as the afore described. Edited by Nicholas91 (19 Aug 2022 9.14am)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Mike Dean has admitted that he got Sundays decision on the hair pulling incident wrong and that the Spurs player should probably have got a red card and would have done if he had directed Taylor to look at the pitch side monitor. Not quite. He said he should have given the referee the final decision. He didn't say it probably was a red card or that Taylor probably would have given one. If I were the referee, I definitely would have booked him for it had I seen it. That isn't something VAR can decide on. I may be in the minority, but like Mike Dean at the time I didn't think it was a clear red card. It's a different level to a headbutt, a 2 footed lunge, a knee high challenge... the severity of the outcome is so much lower and it's not like Romero has dropped his bodyweight to add huge force to it. Is it that different to a push to the chest or squaring up which is always a yellow card? I'm all for the referee on the pitch making the decision provided referees feel that they can look at a decision pitchside and decide not to penalise which rarely seems to happen.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Not quite. He said he should have given the referee the final decision. He didn't say it probably was a red card or that Taylor probably would have given one. If I were the referee, I definitely would have booked him for it had I seen it. That isn't something VAR can decide on. I may be in the minority, but like Mike Dean at the time I didn't think it was a clear red card. It's a different level to a headbutt, a 2 footed lunge, a knee high challenge... the severity of the outcome is so much lower and it's not like Romero has dropped his bodyweight to add huge force to it. Is it that different to a push to the chest or squaring up which is always a yellow card? I'm all for the referee on the pitch making the decision provided referees feel that they can look at a decision pitchside and decide not to penalise which rarely seems to happen. Video Assistant Referee Mike Dean says he should have recommended referee Anthony Taylor to review Cristian Romero's hair pull on Marc Cucurella for a possible red card in Tottenham's 2-2 draw at Chelsea. He would/should have sent Taylor to look for a possible red
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Video Assistant Referee Mike Dean says he should have recommended referee Anthony Taylor to review Cristian Romero's hair pull on Marc Cucurella for a possible red card in Tottenham's 2-2 draw at Chelsea. He would/should have sent Taylor to look for a possible red Yes. Which does not mean that "the Spurs player ... would have (got a red card) if he had directed Taylor to look at the pitch side monitor." I personally don't think it was a red card. Mike Dean hasn't made any statement that he thinks it was a red card either. He simply says that the outcome is up for debate and the referee should have had the final say rather than Mike Dean. Edited by ambrose7 (19 Aug 2022 12.34pm)
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
He could only ask him to look if he thought it was a red card incident. He can ask him to look if thinks it could be a red card incident, he doesn't have to think that it is a red card incident. Or, to use Mike Dean's exact words, "to consider a possible red card". This statement from Mike Dean merely says that in cases where it could go either way it's better for the referee to make the call than the VAR. The definition of violent conduct is: Violent conduct is when a player uses or attempts to use excessive force or brutality against an opponent when not challenging for the ball, or against a team-mate, team official, match official, spectator or any other person, regardless of whether contact is made. In addition, a player who, when not challenging for the ball, deliberately strikes an opponent or any other person on the head or face with the hand or arm, is guilty of violent conduct unless the force used was negligible. Hair pulling doesn't fall into the first part any more so than a push does, so it isn't a clear red card there. Hair pulling doesn't fall into the second part because it isn't a 'strike', in the same way that squaring up and going head to head isn't a strike and is a yellow card offence, so it isn't a clear red card there. Neither Mike Dean nor Anthony Taylor nor anyone else from the refereeing body have said that it should have been a red card. They've merely said that it's better for the referee to make the call themselves when it could go either way. And it could have gone either way - the laws aren't clear here. If you look at the attached image, it's not as if Romero has walked up to Cucurella from behind and done it as an all out assault. Cucurella has blocked him, no intention to play the ball, and Romero grabs him at the height his arms were already at. You see this all the time with shirts in the box - unfortunately it's head height because Cucurella is that much shorter and his hair that much bigger. "upon reflection, I should have asked Taylor to visit his pitch-side monitor to take a look for himself. The referee on field always has the final say." Going to leave it there, nothing else to add.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Certainly valid points - especially the VAR representative - Just throwing this out there - we have talked often about how few academy players actually make the grade, most either drop down the football pyramid until they find their level or leave the game altogether - I wonder if there is any mechanism in place to try to capture some of these youngsters that are not going to make it & put them into referee school ( ok probably not the correct terminology but you know what I am getting at) Originally posted by Badger11
Webb is looking for ex players to become referees. I doubt this will happen as it takes too long and multi millionaire players are not going to slum it in non league whilst they learn their trade. However I could see the value of having a players representative on the VAR panel. The VAR team know the law but a player can probably point out where someone has dived or committed a foul.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Certainly valid points - especially the VAR representative - Just throwing this out there - we have talked often about how few academy players actually make the grade, most either drop down the football pyramid until they find their level or leave the game altogether - I wonder if there is any mechanism in place to try to capture some of these youngsters that are not going to make it & put them into referee school ( ok probably not the correct terminology but you know what I am getting at) I think your idea has merit but the simple truth is that if someone wants to become a referee they will.
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.