You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > State workers
November 21 2026 9.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

State workers


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Nov 22 7.32pm

So nurses want a 17% rise
Civil servants want a 10% rise with no change to Ts and Cs and no redundancy changes.
Both have basically been told to foxtrot Oscar.
This seems so political it’s beyond a joke.
Yes I’m sure they all do a great job but really taking the piss now.
So inflation is high but will they take a drop in pay when inflation goes down; and it will. Do they think they are the only ones getting an offered pay rise below inflation.
The private sector is 10-1 of employees in the uk. They won’t get close to the perks of pension, silly sick pay and HR off the scale.
Get a grip and realise it ain’t happening and so it shouldn’t.
Yes a nurse will help me and so will the council but ffs we’ve done 400 billion on covid and giving billions in fuel aid to everyone and extra benefits to plus 7 millionin in the uk alone and god knows how much to the worlds ponces for this climate bollox.
Give labour and the unions a go asap as they seem to be shouting the loudest and when they get in they will see the account is empty and they’re fecked.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 22 8.13pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So nurses want a 17% rise
Civil servants want a 10% rise with no change to Ts and Cs and no redundancy changes.
Both have basically been told to foxtrot Oscar.
This seems so political it’s beyond a joke.
Yes I’m sure they all do a great job but really taking the piss now.
So inflation is high but will they take a drop in pay when inflation goes down; and it will. Do they think they are the only ones getting an offered pay rise below inflation.
The private sector is 10-1 of employees in the uk. They won’t get close to the perks of pension, silly sick pay and HR off the scale.
Get a grip and realise it ain’t happening and so it shouldn’t.
Yes a nurse will help me and so will the council but ffs we’ve done 400 billion on covid and giving billions in fuel aid to everyone and extra benefits to plus 7 millionin in the uk alone and god knows how much to the worlds ponces for this climate bollox.
Give labour and the unions a go asap as they seem to be shouting the loudest and when they get in they will see the account is empty and they’re fecked.

Problem here is nurses have been undervalued, under supported and underpaid for years. We shouldn’t be in a situation where they’re demanding a 17% pay increase, but we are, because they’ve been treated like unskilled or low skilled workers who actually need a degree and more to qualify yet they’ll have to pay it back as a type of tax after it was loaned to them. Maybe not all of it, but they will be paying it back. It shouldn’t be charged, but if you leave the profession or country within a time period you’re paying it back as normal.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Nov 22 8.36pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Problem here is nurses have been undervalued, under supported and underpaid for years. We shouldn’t be in a situation where they’re demanding a 17% pay increase, but we are, because they’ve been treated like unskilled or low skilled workers who actually need a degree and more to qualify yet they’ll have to pay it back as a type of tax after it was loaned to them. Maybe not all of it, but they will be paying it back. It shouldn’t be charged, but if you leave the profession or country within a time period you’re paying it back as normal.

Undervalued in what way though. They do have a choice tbh. Either take the 40 pieces with massive end of employment benefits or go and work somewhere else. I’m a boiler engineer and when I repair said broken boiler and make an old or Poorly person warm and comfortable etc etc should I pat myself on the back and demand pay rises or crack on and realise I chose that particular profession. Saving lives as a nurse, sorting out someone’s benefits, or a n other role. I don’t think one is more important than the other tbh. Everything be needs help at some stage in life. The type of help is relavant to the importance of the person at the time they need it.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 10 Nov 22 9.25pm

My wife is a nurse and in her Trust they have voted to strike. We haven't discussed whether, or how, she voted. She is though sympathetic to the demands.

I am not. I don't think anyone should contemplate going on strike at the moment. If anyone achieves an above average settlement that will become the norm and our inflation and debt problems will just get worse.

Of course I am proud of her and the work she does and realise that her pay in real terms has fallen, but this is not the time to try to correct that.

I am particularly angry with the train drivers trying to get a larger share of the cake.

With a cost cutting budget due next week I have no idea what the government will do in response, but this makes me feel really uncomfortable. We are in a recession. In recessions real wages go down. There may well have to be another cap on increases in the public sector.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Matov Flag 10 Nov 22 9.38pm

This BS about 'nurses' annoys the f*** out of me. Probably one of the most highly over-rated professions who seem to believe they are above reproach.

In my experience, if you get one in 5 who actually gives much beyond the barest of basic duty of care, then you are lucky.

The ones at the top of their profession, working in say critical care and so on, different gravy but the average nurse on a hospital ward? In my experience, an utter disgrace. I know of family friends who work in the nursing profession who have nothing but utter horror stories of their colleagues, many of whom look for the merest excuse to go off sick or shirk or try and come up with malicious complaints when they are pulled up about their lack of attention.

And yet we are all meant to somehow see them as 'Angels'. Nah. Ain't having it.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Nov 22 9.41pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

My wife is a nurse and in her Trust they have voted to strike. We haven't discussed whether, or how, she voted. She is though sympathetic to the demands.

I am not. I don't think anyone should contemplate going on strike at the moment. If anyone achieves an above average settlement that will become the norm and our inflation and debt problems will just get worse.

Of course I am proud of her and the work she does and realise that her pay in real terms has fallen, but this is not the time to try to correct that.

I am particularly angry with the train drivers trying to get a larger share of the cake.

With a cost cutting budget due next week I have no idea what the government will do in response, but this makes me feel really uncomfortable. We are in a recession. In recessions real wages go down. There may well have to be another cap on increases in the public sector.

Well I take my hat off to you WE. Although I thought you may tell your mrs to do one about the pay rise and in not so many words ; indirectly you have . I’m sure she along with 1000s more do a fabulous job but we all have to cut our cloth including hmg.
The train drivers are private sector so tbh it’s up to their employer to iron them out.
I do wonder what a different political party would do atm.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 10 Nov 22 10.31pm

costs are up, bills are up.....workers are walking away from poor pay. Its not only the Nurses.

Many employers are struggling to get the staff. The coming recession will fix that problem.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 10 Nov 22 10.42pm

We have had this debate many times on this forum.

Anyone can join a union and if enough do then legally that union is able to represent its members in the workplace.

Unions have been a catalyst for change all over the world reforming T & C's for everyone but I agree thses days they are strongest in but not confined to the public services.

No one takes strike action lightly it comes with consequences and in order to call a strike any union has to ballot and thresholds have to be met. In the PCS ballot today some areas failed to meet thresholds and in them no action can be taken.

If you go on strike you lose pay and pension for the days you are out.

Its up to you if you join a union - the days of the closed shop are long gone. If you do it's up to you if you vote and who you vote for. (Oddly a strike vote has to be postal unlike say a political party voting in anew Prime minister which can be done on line.)

So people feel strong enough to vote for action. Fair play to them and maybe it might just mean as we have seen in the rail strikes a better offer than one which makes those affected poorer year on year.

Not saying BTW that others are not suffering and have not been offered or got low or no pay rises. As a nation we are all suffering right now.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 10 Nov 22 11.54pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

costs are up, bills are up.....workers are walking away from poor pay. Its not only the Nurses.

Many employers are struggling to get the staff. The coming recession will fix that problem.

You're right, they are ... the place where I work has been advertising for months to fill several staff vacancies. No one has applied because of the low level of wages.

They're okay for someone like me because I'm topping up my pension but I'd be queueing at the food banks and probably sitting in the dark if I had to depend on my earnings.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 11 Nov 22 6.27am

My opinions are formed from limited personal experience. Teachers haven't had an actual pay rise for years. This is true for other sectors of State Workers (though not all of them).
Unions are scrambling to play 'catch-up' on wages where there has been a significant shortfall for many years.
Morale is low in these low-pay sectors. People are leaving to take better paid jobs. There is a lack of people being trained for these places, because they are poorly paid. Therefore, qualification standards of entry are being 'diluted', so inevitably more 5hlt staff are getting through to take these jobs. We've seen it with teachers, nurses and police.
To cover the immediate shortfall in staff, Agencies are being used, whereby expenditure in these areas is rocketing.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Nov 22 6.37am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Problem here is nurses have been undervalued, under supported and underpaid for years. We shouldn’t be in a situation where they’re demanding a 17% pay increase, but we are, because they’ve been treated like unskilled or low skilled workers who actually need a degree and more to qualify.

True. My wife is a nurse and she entered the profession 20 years ago knowing that the pay wasn't great and nothing has really changed since.

Many of her colleagues who leave the profession don't do so for money reasons but for being treated as assets instead of people. She worked at one hospital for ten years and was entitled to seven weeks paid holiday per year but was told to take the holidays in one week blocks and preferably in school term time despite having an autistic child at school. I persuaded her to leave and find another hospital that would treat her as a person which she did

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 11 Nov 22 7.00am

Like many on here I was born in 1960, grew up in the South & my formative years were the 70 / 80s - I was aware of the various strikes around that time - Print workers / Coal Power / Car Assembly Workers etc - the power of the unions at that time & the phrase of "holding the country to ransom" was one that was being used on the news every day - "the winter of our discontent" was another phrase often used - as a southerner the coal strikes only really effected me with the power strikes, I didn't live close to any mines & knew no miners, the print was largely up in Wapping & car assembly was in the midlands - even today none of my family are school teachers or nurses so I really dont have a dog in this fight & whilst I fully believe that Unions were needed back in the early days of industrialised Britain when I saw what they did in the 80s in terms of driving those professions towards alternative methods ( i.e less reliant on people (automation) & driven towards countries with lower labour costs) I have to wonder where this current round of talks / strikes etc will end, OK its difficult to replaces nurses, Teachers with the number of lessons held over teams / zoom etc over lockdown & I am not in any way suggesting that should become the norm but you can see where I am going with this - the same with train drivers / signallers, technology already exists to replace them - anyway, as I say I dont have a dog in this fight, just my tuppence worth -

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Nov 22 8.24am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

My wife is a nurse and in her Trust they have voted to strike. We haven't discussed whether, or how, she voted. She is though sympathetic to the demands.

I am not. I don't think anyone should contemplate going on strike at the moment. If anyone achieves an above average settlement that will become the norm and our inflation and debt problems will just get worse.

Of course I am proud of her and the work she does and realise that her pay in real terms has fallen, but this is not the time to try to correct that.

I am particularly angry with the train drivers trying to get a larger share of the cake.

With a cost cutting budget due next week I have no idea what the government will do in response, but this makes me feel really uncomfortable. We are in a recession. In recessions real wages go down. There may well have to be another cap on increases in the public sector.

For once I am in agreement. I see a friend who doesn't live in London occasionally we had a nice day out booked for Sat 26 Nov until they announced it's strike day.

I may not see her now until the new year in the meantime I have booked tickets for exhibitions and stuff and I have to hope they will refund me as I don't have another date scheduled yet.

Okay I know it's petty in the scheme of things but how many other people will have their weekend ruined. I also just realised that Mayor Sad Dick has done nothing to help people on strike days, he could suspend the congestion charges but hell no he probably earns more money on those days.

I've said it before strikes should be banned in key sectors and replaced with compulsory arbitration with fines and imprisonment for those that do not confirm whether they are unions or management.

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 11 Nov 22 9.56am

Inflation tends to push the unions to push for more. It is as sure as night follows day.

However, the OP makes his point based on an assumption that state sector employees are coming from a history of sequential pay rises at least in line with (very low) inflation, but this time they are demanding a higher rise to keep up.

Actually, what you have is a diminishing state sector that will have had, perhaps, one or two below inflation pay rises since 2011. Otherwise, their pay has been largely frozen for 11 years, while their workload has significantly increased due to their colleagues being laid off.

There are always dregs in the state sector. However, people really need to stop seeing this as a lazy 9-5 gravy train to a huge pension as those days are long gone.

 

The Dolphin Flag 11 Nov 22 10.29am

It is all very political and planned industrial action across many Unions to undermine the Government and actually Society as well.
Trouble is that they are just beginning to hack everyone off.
Nurses are undervalued but they always have been.
They earn more than they say they do albeit it isn't a job I would ever want to do.
When you take job/vocation up you know the score and so to strike while asking for a ridiculous pay rise is morally wrong.
Civil Servants - don't get me started!
Most of them are working from home and saving fortunes in travel and in many cases childcare but still they want more!
If they work in London lets have the weighting back first and then talk after.
If not, then make them go back their offices before anything will even be discussed - that applies to every one of them throughout the Country.
I am not sure our government has the bottle for the fight but they should issue a statement now that sets out our rules before anything else will be so much as thought about let alone negotiated.
I am just sick of public servants now.
They generally don't do what it says on the tin and yet they want even more for less - reward for failure yet again!

 

The Dolphin Flag 11 Nov 22 10.31am

I meant to add that at a time when many people are suffering financially, mentally and more then we should all pull together - instead these people decide to cause everyone problems.
They will regret it in due course - everything comes around!
Incidentally - the railways calling of strikes last minute but with their Spanish practises still leaving us in disarray - another law needs to be passed on that a bit quick!
Hit them where it hurts!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Nov 22 11.52am

Originally posted by silvertop

Inflation tends to push the unions to push for more. It is as sure as night follows day.

However, the OP makes his point based on an assumption that state sector employees are coming from a history of sequential pay rises at least in line with (very low) inflation, but this time they are demanding a higher rise to keep up.

Actually, what you have is a diminishing state sector that will have had, perhaps, one or two below inflation pay rises since 2011. Otherwise, their pay has been largely frozen for 11 years, while their workload has significantly increased due to their colleagues being laid off.

There are always dregs in the state sector. However, people really need to stop seeing this as a lazy 9-5 gravy train to a huge pension as those days are long gone.

If we cannot produce and keep our own staff in our own healthcare service and have to import people then there is something very wrong going on and it contradicts the opinion to deal with numbers of immigration.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Nov 22 11.56am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

It is all very political and planned industrial action across many Unions to undermine the Government and actually Society as well.
Trouble is that they are just beginning to hack everyone off.
Nurses are undervalued but they always have been.
They earn more than they say they do albeit it isn't a job I would ever want to do.
When you take job/vocation up you know the score and so to strike while asking for a ridiculous pay rise is morally wrong.
Civil Servants - don't get me started!
Most of them are working from home and saving fortunes in travel and in many cases childcare but still they want more!
If they work in London lets have the weighting back first and then talk after.
If not, then make them go back their offices before anything will even be discussed - that applies to every one of them throughout the Country.
I am not sure our government has the bottle for the fight but they should issue a statement now that sets out our rules before anything else will be so much as thought about let alone negotiated.
I am just sick of public servants now.
They generally don't do what it says on the tin and yet they want even more for less - reward for failure yet again!

Any examples of what they say they earn vs what they do earn?

 


COYP

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 11 Nov 22 12.55pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

It is all very political and planned industrial action across many Unions to undermine the Government and actually Society as well.
Trouble is that they are just beginning to hack everyone off.
Nurses are undervalued but they always have been.
They earn more than they say they do albeit it isn't a job I would ever want to do.
When you take job/vocation up you know the score and so to strike while asking for a ridiculous pay rise is morally wrong.
Civil Servants - don't get me started!
Most of them are working from home and saving fortunes in travel and in many cases childcare but still they want more!
If they work in London lets have the weighting back first and then talk after.
If not, then make them go back their offices before anything will even be discussed - that applies to every one of them throughout the Country.
I am not sure our government has the bottle for the fight but they should issue a statement now that sets out our rules before anything else will be so much as thought about let alone negotiated.
I am just sick of public servants now.
They generally don't do what it says on the tin and yet they want even more for less - reward for failure yet again!

Sorry to burst your bubble but civil servants cannot all go back to the office 5 days a week as the government has sold off so many buildings that there is just not enough room to accommodate them all at once.

Most buildings have around 3 times the staff allocated to them than there is actual room to accommodate them so if all staff turned up at once they would have to turn 2/3 approx away.

Many other office based workers now work entirely at home and have seen no detriment to their wages etc. This working in the office is a fallacious position put about by the former Minister for Victoriana Jacob Rees Mogg.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Nov 22 1.00pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman


If we cannot produce and keep our own staff in our own healthcare service and have to import people then there is something very wrong going on and it contradicts the opinion to deal with numbers of immigration.

I have said on more than one occasion that part of the reason for the low take up of nursing as a career is the RCN's increasing of educational qualifications for entrance thus ruling out many people who not only wish to become nurses but also have the aptitude to do the job but they can't as they don't have a university degree

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > State workers