You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Something needs to happen..!!
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Something needs to happen..!!


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jan 23 11.41am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I’m no accountant, so, reading between the lines, how does that impact the value of the club as a saleable asset. I presume buying the club would therefore mean buying more than one business? Would that also make it difficult for the club to borrow funds if the assets are held in a separate business?

There is only one business although it's contained in a number of different limited companies for reasons unknown to me.

The number of companies won't affect the club's ability to borrow as the lender would probably insist on cross company guarantees and cross debentures

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Jan 23 11.45am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

There is only one business although it's contained in a number of different limited companies for reasons unknown to me.

The number of companies won't affect the club's ability to borrow as the lender would probably insist on cross company guarantees and cross debentures

We're already servicing tens of millions of debt.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Den1923 Flag 28 Jan 23 1.41pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Everyone keeps rabbiting on about Brighton as a model to follow, but the fact is they have an owner with a sizeable cheque book and ties to the club. Parish has the latter but perhaps not a big enough cheque book. Harris, Blitzer and Textor have no personal connection to Palace and it is clear we are an investment to them. Without the personal attachment I imagine they are less likely to gamble, like Bloom did with Brighton. Bloom's risk is now paying dividends, with some of his risks now paying off big time. Another thing that taps into Bloom's gambling past is that they have bought a lot of players on relatively low fees from across the globe since he took control with most failing to make it but the ones that do have been standout players. Putting aside the rivalry, there is a lot to be envious of with what they've achieved.

Our investment in young British/Irish players for the academy could bear fruit in a few years time and we could be the the next feeder club for the larger clubs like Brighton or Southampton. Maybe that is the gamble our club have decided to take? Maybe it is a Dougie masterstroke.

Of course we don't want another Goldberg or Jordan situation, but it would be nice to have owners who actually show some public love for Palace, rather than referring to us as a part of some portfolio (as Textor refers to us). Maybe I am just an old romantic. Maybe one of the player's could sh*g one of the owner's wives and then at least we'd have something to sing about them like the good old days.

The graduation from academy football to elite football is very low only 0.5% of 16 year olds make it and kids entering as 9yo the figure reduces to only 0.18% so the chances of running a football club at EPL level, from academy output is very unlikely. The standard these days is extremely high and you only have to look at all levels of EPL and EFL teams to see how cosmopolitan teams are these days compared to the distant past when teams were mainly made up of home produced talent.

You need a worldwide scouting network these days to find the talent at reasonable prices, something we struggle at.

As far as I'm aware the current CP Academy is the combined effort of Derry/Mccarthy and Academy Director Garry Issott, there is no mention of DF being involved and rightly so as its his job to find us the right talent at the right price for the here and now, something that again we struggle to achieve.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Jan 23 2.44pm

In terms of the academy the next step up is for them to go out on loan to Championships clubs, so far Ebiowei is the only one to do so and he's not really our academy.

Far too many are in lower divisions so I doubt they will make it in the PL or be sold for a decent fee.

 


One more point

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jan 23 4.01pm

Originally posted by Badger11

In terms of the academy the next step up is for them to go out on loan to Championships clubs, so far Ebiowei is the only one to do so and he's not really our academy.

Far too many are in lower divisions so I doubt they will make it in the PL or be sold for a decent fee.


Gallagher's first loan was to Charlton in League 1. Harry Kane's first was Leyton Orient.

It's what happens on their subsequent loan that gives a pointer.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 28 Jan 23 8.05pm

Let's be real, academy players rarely go straight into the prem. They need 2/3 years in a the champ or abroad to learn and develop.

Patience is key and also luck... some get sold off and then turn out great - look at Guehi for example. They didn't keep him, made a quick buck and moved on.

The real model is this... for me at least.

You be a successful championship club. You produce your own talent with one or two coming through each year. You enjoy seeing their introduction. You have a good cup run each year and the occasional play off victory.

You make profits from selling on your home gown stars plus the off prem appearance.

That's huge.

or....

you churn out youngsters, loan them out, then bring them back and integrate them and try them in the squad, whilst buying elsewhere which then also allow you to sell those on.

Basically, you need to plan ahead and gamble whilst having the peace of mind that you are mid table safe and don't try anything silly.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Jan 23 10.17pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

If we don't sign at least a right back and a central midfielder by the close of the transfer deadline we are in dire straights..!!

Also looks like Mateta off to Galatasaray - so another forward also required..!!

To me this just smacks of no funds available or certainly not enough to compete..!!

What the hell is going on..??

COYP

I agree but this isn't consistent with some fairly strident opinion expressed after we beat West Ham.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (28 Jan 2023 10.19pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Jan 23 11.25pm

The message was clear - the expectation was set at a couple of loans and possibly a permanent deal if possible.

The 'Window' does not shut until 11 PM on Tuesday and across the board a plethora of deals are concluded at the 'Eleventh hour'.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 29 Jan 23 7.03am

When CPFC 2010 bought the club, wasnt there some agreement with LLoyds bank that the ground was included in the deal at a below market price (to help the deal through) provided that if the ground was ever sold on to a property developer (or for a change of use) there was some profit matrix in place to ensure LLoyds bank received some %age of that profit ?

IDK maybe I am not remembering it clearly or maybe if there was a time limit on that deal which has since passed - ( its now been 12 years & for sure market values for a piece of land in that location will have changed significantly during that period) in any event if it came to selling the ground or using it as an asset / collateral in any modern day loan application having to ring fence some amount for LLoyds probably wouldnt have a dramatic effect on the overall value but perhaps someone with a better memory than me could comment

Originally posted by Den1923

All very sound and logical providing we stay in the EPL,however without strengthening in defence, midfield and at least a striker who can score the survival in the EPL is under threat.

Currently we score on average 0.9 goals per game and let in 1.35, so the issues are clear unless we score more goals I cannot see many points between now and the end of March.

Parish/Blitzer/Harris/Textor own the ground through CPFC Selhurst Park Ltd, that company has a debenture secured against the ground through a company in Luxembourg, this give the debenture holder preferential credit rights should the club ever go bust so it would seem that the ground is a very safe investment to these four no matter what happens to the club in the future!

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 29 Jan 23 7.24am

An article from the time, no real details just an overview that some kind of deal had been done

[Link]


Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

When CPFC 2010 bought the club, wasnt there some agreement with LLoyds bank that the ground was included in the deal at a below market price (to help the deal through) provided that if the ground was ever sold on to a property developer (or for a change of use) there was some profit matrix in place to ensure LLoyds bank received some %age of that profit ?

IDK maybe I am not remembering it clearly or maybe if there was a time limit on that deal which has since passed - ( its now been 12 years & for sure market values for a piece of land in that location will have changed significantly during that period) in any event if it came to selling the ground or using it as an asset / collateral in any modern day loan application having to ring fence some amount for LLoyds probably wouldnt have a dramatic effect on the overall value but perhaps someone with a better memory than me could comment

 

cardiff eagle Flag 29 Jan 23 7.28am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Despite what some are posting here I don’t see anyone clamouring for us to be like Citeh or Chelsea when it comes to buying players, but as a 10 year established PL side I do expect us to have a full competitive squad, which we do not.

We have two senior goalkeepers, one left back, two elderly right backs and a guy who has never played an entire competitive match for us. We can get by with the 4 centre halfs we have but midfield and up front is a bit of a mess. We have two possibly three in midfield who you wouldn’t want to pick in Riedewald, Milivojevic and Schlupp, another who is constantly injured in McArthur and Hughes who for some reason our manager doesn’t like. Doucoure is a nailed on starter and then we have a plethora of talented but who score few goals ‘wide attacking’ players in Eze, Olise, Ayew and Zaha (our top scorer) who is of course now injured. Two strikers, neither of whom score goals and one of them is possibly leaving!

That is supposed to be a team that keeps us competitive in the hardest league in the world. It is little surprise we have scored only 3 goals in our last 6 PL matches and 2 of them were against Bournemouth who looked to be a terrible team and the other was a free kick.

I’m amazed the confidence that some have that we are in no trouble. I reckon we are only a couple of injuries away from being in dire trouble and I would not be surprised to see PV walk as I think he is getting very frustrated, as am I as a supporter.

Rant over. Let’s hope we get some players through the door next couple of days.

Hard to disagree with this. The two goals against Bournemouth were corners too so we haven’t scored in open play since West Ham away I think.

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 29 Jan 23 7.54am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Despite what some are posting here I don’t see anyone clamouring for us to be like Citeh or Chelsea when it comes to buying players, but as a 10 year established PL side I do expect us to have a full competitive squad, which we do not.

We have two senior goalkeepers, one left back, two elderly right backs and a guy who has never played an entire competitive match for us. We can get by with the 4 centre halfs we have but midfield and up front is a bit of a mess. We have two possibly three in midfield who you wouldn’t want to pick in Riedewald, Milivojevic and Schlupp, another who is constantly injured in McArthur and Hughes who for some reason our manager doesn’t like. Doucoure is a nailed on starter and then we have a plethora of talented but who score few goals ‘wide attacking’ players in Eze, Olise, Ayew and Zaha (our top scorer) who is of course now injured. Two strikers, neither of whom score goals and one of them is possibly leaving!

That is supposed to be a team that keeps us competitive in the hardest league in the world. It is little surprise we have scored only 3 goals in our last 6 PL matches and 2 of them were against Bournemouth who looked to be a terrible team and the other was a free kick.

I’m amazed the confidence that some have that we are in no trouble. I reckon we are only a couple of injuries away from being in dire trouble and I would not be surprised to see PV walk as I think he is getting very frustrated, as am I as a supporter.

Rant over. Let’s hope we get some players through the door next couple of days.

spot on

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Jan 23 8.38am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Despite what some are posting here I don’t see anyone clamouring for us to be like Citeh or Chelsea when it comes to buying players, but as a 10 year established PL side I do expect us to have a full competitive squad, which we do not.

We have two senior goalkeepers, one left back, two elderly right backs and a guy who has never played an entire competitive match for us. We can get by with the 4 centre halfs we have but midfield and up front is a bit of a mess. We have two possibly three in midfield who you wouldn’t want to pick in Riedewald, Milivojevic and Schlupp, another who is constantly injured in McArthur and Hughes who for some reason our manager doesn’t like. Doucoure is a nailed on starter and then we have a plethora of talented but who score few goals ‘wide attacking’ players in Eze, Olise, Ayew and Zaha (our top scorer) who is of course now injured. Two strikers, neither of whom score goals and one of them is possibly leaving!

That is supposed to be a team that keeps us competitive in the hardest league in the world. It is little surprise we have scored only 3 goals in our last 6 PL matches and 2 of them were against Bournemouth who looked to be a terrible team and the other was a free kick.

I’m amazed the confidence that some have that we are in no trouble. I reckon we are only a couple of injuries away from being in dire trouble and I would not be surprised to see PV walk as I think he is getting very frustrated, as am I as a supporter.

Rant over. Let’s hope we get some players through the door next couple of days.

Due to over exerting our club financially in the recent past, we have no "transfer money", at the end of the season unless some ridiculous contract extensions are given, we will be in a much better position, and hopefully the boardroom maybe sorted, i of course would like more players, but a couple of loans to buy is our best hope

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Dubai Eagle Flag 29 Jan 23 8.43am

I think that the confidence that we are not in trouble / not in a relegation situation comes from the fact that each season at least 3 clubs have bigger problems than us & that the step up from Championship to PL gets harder each year as the clubs already in the PL strengthen each year -

Whilst this may be OK in as far as it goes it cannot be viewed as a long term plan if we do not strengthen the squad on a regular basis, as many have said on here, if you stand still in the PL you are in reality going backwards-

My feeling is that because we know that we have points on the board & some less difficult games at the end of the season we have enough momentum to stay up without spending in the Jan window - we have a number of players out of contract at the end of the season & whilst a number of them will no doubt be offered extensions we will have to replace some & at the same time somehow try to lower the amount of revenue spent on players wages

Not an easy balancing act - one that I think we will manage this season but for sure sooner or later it will bite us in the bum -

 

Den1923 Flag 29 Jan 23 8.49am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

When CPFC 2010 bought the club, wasnt there some agreement with LLoyds bank that the ground was included in the deal at a below market price (to help the deal through) provided that if the ground was ever sold on to a property developer (or for a change of use) there was some profit matrix in place to ensure LLoyds bank received some %age of that profit ?

IDK maybe I am not remembering it clearly or maybe if there was a time limit on that deal which has since passed - ( its now been 12 years & for sure market values for a piece of land in that location will have changed significantly during that period) in any event if it came to selling the ground or using it as an asset / collateral in any modern day loan application having to ring fence some amount for LLoyds probably wouldnt have a dramatic effect on the overall value but perhaps someone with a better memory than me could comment

F5444E89-60B9-4CE9-BA66-E0F05EA2112D.png Attachment: F5444E89-60B9-4CE9-BA66-E0F05EA2112D.png (786.25Kb)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Jan 23 9.15am

Just a thought, but if Palace were in the bottom three now, would transfer money be found from somewhere ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Jan 23 9.26am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Just a thought, but if Palace were in the bottom three now, would transfer money be found from somewhere ?

Yes we did when we employed allardyce for that reason.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 29 Jan 23 9.28am

Thats a good question - I suspect that the answer would be yes, to protect the investment - no doubt there would be a close inspection of the remaining fixtures & a totting up of the estimated points totals of each club first to see whether it really was required -

Originally posted by NEILLO

Just a thought, but if Palace were in the bottom three now, would transfer money be found from somewhere ?

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Jan 23 9.35am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Just a thought, but if Palace were in the bottom three now, would transfer money be found from somewhere ?

It would have to come from Harris 6.2billion, Blitzer 1.3billion or Textor 270million. i cant see H & B giving any, so it would have to be Textor, by far the least wealthiest of the 3

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Jan 23 9.39am

And as for Parish a P**s poor 50m

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Something needs to happen..!!