This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Fair point, but Guehi is getting in squads and/or a little run out against weak teams at the moment in the same way many young, eligible players do. AWB and Mitchell did, along with all sorts over the years, and most of them do not kick on to the next level. Guehi, like many before him, is getting some England recognition because he has a bit of promise and potential, not because he is already a top-class player. He may never get much better than he is now, but the potential is attractive and therefore expensive. Those few England caps now might make this the best time to cash out, in much the same way we did with AWB, before the player has a chance to plateau. Do United still think £50m was money well spent for AWB? Is he a better player now than he was when they bought him, or was he actually close to his 'finished' level from the outset? Would we have got anything like that money for him 18 months later? I doubt it. Perhaps Guehi is the same. There is a gamble either way of course because he might go on to get 100 England caps and be brilliant, but there is also a gamble in keeping him - his value may never be so high again. Aside from the significance of England caps, another issue is whether Guehi is getting caps where Dann, Tompkins, etc did not because is a better defender than our old guard, or simply a better footballer. For 95% of their games, England need defenders to move the ball quickly and with quality so they can break down stubborn but inferior opponents. Palace, by contrast, need defenders to defend properly, and I'm really not convinced that Guehi (or Andersen for that matter) can. I'm not in favour of Palace selling anyone and have always been concerned about the 'buy young, develop and sell' model, but if I had to choose one or two to sell in order to reinvest then both centre-backs would be my choice. Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 2.48pm) I think AWB and Mitchell were called into one squad each, and in Mitchell's case there was very limited competition in his position - Guehi has made it into 4 or 5 in a row in a very competitive position, so I don't think it's the best comparison. Those two were barely recognised at youth level internationally, Guehi has played and captained at nearly every stage, including the U17 team who won the Euros.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I agree, but we can't play with a high line if at least two (maybe three) of the back four are slow, as has been the case. We also need our forwards to press aggressively for our defence to hold a high line, and Eze, Olise, Edouard, etc seem set to continue the trend set by Zaha and others of not really being any good at (or willing to do) that. I dare say Guehi would fit like a glove at Man City, or Barcelona, but I'm not convinced we get more from him than we would from a cheaper, less glamourous alternative. Olise is one of the best-performing wingers in the league in terms of tackles, interceptions and pressures.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Here's something to make you laugh this morning [Link] someone speculating that maybe Newcastle Arabia could get Andersen for 20m. This rumour has been bouncing around the last few days but seems to have little merit. I think he's been great for us, but I do think we're his level. Well if Newcastle make an approach about signing Andersen, I hope our answer will be the same one the Pope gave the famous Alan Mullery when he went to Rome specifically to see him. Or the slightly longer answer I gave my old man when he told me to be a Brighton fan.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Well if Newcastle make an approach about signing Andersen, I hope our answer will be the same one the Pope gave the famous Alan Mullery when he went to Rome specifically to see him. Or the slightly longer answer I gave my old man when he told me to be a Brighton fan. As an older fan I have to congratulate you
|
|
|
Originally posted by eritheagle
So Brentford now decide to take the p1ss and offer us £20m for one of the best ball playing centre backs outside of the top 6 whom we signed for £17m! We told them where to go but tat club are really starting to get on my nerves! Hope they’re relegation battlers without Toney!!!
Edited by eagleman13 (28 Jun 2023 12.22pm)
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
An interesting read. For me, Andersen and Guehi have been the poster boys for our new identity, leaving behind the old one, where the likes of Dann, Delaney, Cahill, Tomkins etc reigned supreme. A big part of that identity was us being characterised as a team trying to endure all manner of onslaught whilst nicking the odd counter attack goal (usually via Zaha). The older school, blood and guts defenders were much better suited to this. A lot of time is now, sometimes infuriatingly, spent knocking the ball across the backline. This has been the platform for us to play a more proactive, possession based game and one almost universally viewed as an improvement upon our previous existence. I am an advocate of this new approach. Andersen is the long-ball (quarterback) player and Marc the more mobile defender who can move with the ball. Both these players, for me, lack aerial prowess and often leave something to be desired where you just need non-nonsense, bodies on the line defending. Were they able to offer both aspects I'd suggest they would indeed both be plying their trade somewhere more glamorous and for a lot more money than we are paying them. I agree that they may not be the greatest centre-backs in the world and leave enough to be desired however were they to depart that proverbial foundation for our team would be dented and as others have mentioned the domino effect may be catastrophic (on the assumption we struggle to/do not recruit adequate replacement). I'd much rather we brought in adequate support for them, and they remain, however recognise that may well be beyond anyone's control. Agree 100% with the platform that they give the team to play off. So, so important. Of the 2 maybe JA is the one to sell. Potentially easier to replace, older. Last chance for a big 5 year contract. If we could get 40/50 for him I'd test Chelsea's resolve on Colwill. IMO Colwill and Guehi are the future England CB pairing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Fair point, but Guehi is getting in squads and/or a little run out against weak teams at the moment in the same way many young, eligible players do. AWB and Mitchell did, along with all sorts over the years, and most of them do not kick on to the next level. Guehi, like many before him, is getting some England recognition because he has a bit of promise and potential, not because he is already a top-class player. He may never get much better than he is now, but the potential is attractive and therefore expensive. Those few England caps now might make this the best time to cash out, in much the same way we did with AWB, before the player has a chance to plateau. Do United still think £50m was money well spent for AWB? Is he a better player now than he was when they bought him, or was he actually close to his 'finished' level from the outset? Would we have got anything like that money for him 18 months later? I doubt it. Perhaps Guehi is the same. There is a gamble either way of course because he might go on to get 100 England caps and be brilliant, but there is also a gamble in keeping him - his value may never be so high again. Aside from the significance of England caps, another issue is whether Guehi is getting caps where Dann, Tompkins, etc did not because is a better defender than our old guard, or simply a better footballer. For 95% of their games, England need defenders to move the ball quickly and with quality so they can break down stubborn but inferior opponents. Palace, by contrast, need defenders to defend properly, and I'm really not convinced that Guehi (or Andersen for that matter) can. I'm not in favour of Palace selling anyone and have always been concerned about the 'buy young, develop and sell' model, but if I had to choose one or two to sell in order to reinvest then both centre-backs would be my choice. Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 2.48pm) Guehi's selections against the weaker teams are a rites of passage as you say. But it also gives the England manager to get a better idea of him off of the pitch as well as on it. I've seen nothing but positive feedback on him, and I expect him to continue to make the squads and develop into a potential starter in more meaningful games ( as opposed to the 31 year old Dunk suddenly being selected after years in the wilderness, or Falmer as it is properly known ). A bit like Zaha before him, AWB joined United at a bad time. Only in the last few months has he shown the form that triggered the £50m fee. Under Ten Haag i think he now has a chance to improve his game. We shall see. If Palace need the money to generate transfer funds, then yes, selling one of the centre backs is certainly more palatable than cashing in on Eze or Olise. Of the two, Guehi would command the far higher fee but I think Andersen is more easily replaced out of the two. I would not sell both in the same window obviously ! Edited by NEILLO (28 Jun 2023 12.22pm) Edited by NEILLO (28 Jun 2023 12.23pm)
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by eritheagle
So Brentford now decide to take the p1ss and offer us £20m for one of the best ball playing centre backs outside of the top 6 whom we signed for £17m! We told them where to go but tat club are really starting to get on my nerves! Hope they’re relegation battlers without Toney!!! Brentford get on my nerves a lot through no fault of their own. It’s the palace fans who keep bleating on about our lack of progress and ambition using them as an example of where we should be. Just because they’ve gate crashed the top ten for one season!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Guehi's selections against the weaker teams are a rites of passage as you say. But it also gives the England manager to get a better idea of him off of the pitch as well as on it. I've seen nothing but positive feedback on him, and I expect him to continue to make the squads and develop into a potential starter in more meaningful games ( as opposed to the 31 year old Dunk suddenly being selected after years in the wilderness, or Falmer as it is properly known ). A bit like Zaha before him, AWB joined United at a bad time. Only in the last few months has he shown the form that triggered the £50m fee. Under Ten Haag i think he now has a chance to improve his game. We shall see. If Palace need the money to generate transfer funds, then yes, selling one of the centre backs is certainly more palatable than cashing in on Eze or Olise. Of the two, Guehi would command the far higher fee but I think Andersen is more easily replaced out of the two. I would not sell both in the same window obviously ! Edited by NEILLO (28 Jun 2023 12.22pm) Edited by NEILLO (28 Jun 2023 12.23pm) For me, and my often dubious footballing views, I agree with all of this - all three paragraphs. I do wonder if Andersen's departure would change our 'style' however as he is the oft' said 'quarterback' and chief long ball-pinger, however is still my preference. The only argument I'd make against it is if we did sell Marc, it'd be a huge fee plus we could bring in a bit more of a commanding, warrior type CB to partner Andersen (which is something Marc is not, he's very good and very classy but he's not a formidable physical CB). Either way I wish for no departures without expectation of that eventuality.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
For me, and my often dubious footballing views, I agree with all of this - all three paragraphs. I do wonder if Andersen's departure would change our 'style' however as he is the oft' said 'quarterback' and chief long ball-pinger, however is still my preference. The only argument I'd make against it is if we did sell Marc, it'd be a huge fee plus we could bring in a bit more of a commanding, warrior type CB to partner Andersen (which is something Marc is not, he's very good and very classy but he's not a formidable physical CB). Either way I wish for no departures without expectation of that eventuality. Not sure Andersen would be easier to Replace for these very reasons; How may Defenders have his ability to hit a long raking ball and quick;y start a counter? not many. Whilst Guehi - the better defender - is very much in the mould of all modern CBs. they'd be many more to choose from, just need to pick wisely.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
The only argument I'd make against it is if we did sell Marc, it'd be a huge fee plus we could bring in a bit more of a commanding, warrior type CB to partner Andersen (which is something Marc is not, Is Claude still playing?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Is Claude still playing? If he is I'd take him back in a heartbeat Midlands! Him, JA and Anthony Gardener at the back. We'd concede less from corners surely!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Have there been any £60m offers for either player?
|
|
|
Jimmy's been taking a lot of wickets up until now. No need to get rid yet.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Is Claude still playing? Whatever he’s doing, he’ll probably be scaring the crap out of someone, somewhere Edited by monkey (28 Jun 2023 5.15pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Is Claude still playing? Playing is a bit of a euphemism. Last I saw he was lower league. He'd be 40 something now wouldn't he?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.