You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Squad for 23/24
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Squad for 23/24


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
DANGERCLOSE Flag London 17 Jul 23 1.59pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Johnston

Ward
Guehi
Andersen
Riedewald

Doucoure
Lerma
Ahamada

Eze
Olise

Ayew

Subs

Clyne Hughes Guaita Mateta Richards Edouard Rak-Sakyi tomkins Mitchell Schlupp

Looking at it we defo need a Zaha and a proven goalscorer

Made 1 or 2 changes

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 20 Jul 23 8.04pm

If we do get the signings the team should look like this when everyone is fit

Johnston

Ward
Guehi
Andersen
Mitchell

Doucoure
Lerma

Eze

Olise
Franca

Zaha

Subs

Clyne Hughes Guaita Mateta Richards Ahamada Riedewald Edouard Rak-Sakyi tomkins Ayew Schlupp

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jul 23 9.25pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

If we do get the signings the team should look like this when everyone is fit

Johnston

Ward
Guehi
Andersen
Mitchell

Doucoure
Lerma

Eze

Olise
Franca

Zaha

Subs

Clyne Hughes Guaita Mateta Richards Ahamada Riedewald Edouard Rak-Sakyi tomkins Ayew Schlupp


If Franca comes, I would expect JRS to go out on loan to a Championship club not waste his time on the bench.

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Jul 23 8.56am

Looking at the squad travelling to America there are clear gaps in the squad.
Matthews is the second keeper in the continued mysterious absence of Guiata.
Ayew, Mateta and Edouard are the only forward options which looks weak by Premier League standards.
We look relatively strong in central defence but that could change with the supposed interest in our two first choice central defenders.
We are likely to start the season without our two first choice wide players in Olise (injury) and Zaha (injury/contract uncertainty).
There is clearly work to do in the market and this means players who can make an immediate impact as opposed to squad players like Plange and Ebiowei who are not travelling and are seemingly not considered near the first team at this stage.
The full back position is just about adequate but there is still no real competition for Mitchell meaning a patch up solution if Mitchell is absent.

Of course the situation could change if we hold off interest in Anderson, Guehi and Doucoure and if Zaha signs a new contract and retains fitness quickly and if we sign Franca and if Guiata re-emerges…..

But there’s a lot of ‘ifs’ there.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 23 Jul 23 10.05am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Looking at the squad travelling to America there are clear gaps in the squad.
Matthews is the second keeper in the continued mysterious absence of Guiata.
Ayew, Mateta and Edouard are the only forward options which looks weak by Premier League standards.
We look relatively strong in central defence but that could change with the supposed interest in our two first choice central defenders.
We are likely to start the season without our two first choice wide players in Olise (injury) and Zaha (injury/contract uncertainty).
There is clearly work to do in the market and this means players who can make an immediate impact as opposed to squad players like Plange and Ebiowei who are not travelling and are seemingly not considered near the first team at this stage.
The full back position is just about adequate but there is still no real competition for Mitchell meaning a patch up solution if Mitchell is absent.

Of course the situation could change if we hold off interest in Anderson, Guehi and Doucoure and if Zaha signs a new contract and retains fitness quickly and if we sign Franca and if Guiata re-emerges…..

But there’s a lot of ‘ifs’ there.

There is a pic of Guaita on his twitter/instagram thingys of him in the gym stating that he's back. Seems he may have been injured & was better. As for Luke Plange, he is already out in the US with the U21's for a tournament. Ebiowei, i agree, doesn't look like 1st team material. In the couple of pre-season games he has featured, to me, he was all 'flicks n tricks' like someone who was really trying to impress & failing badly, just my opinion.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 23 Jul 23 7.19pm

If everyone rumoured to be going leaves:

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Johnston

Ward
Tomkins
Richards
Mitchell

Schlupp
Lerma

Eze

Ayew
Edouard

Mateta (of all the rumours this isn't one I took any part seriously)

Subs

Clyne Guaita Ahamada Riedewald Rak-Sakyi Hughes U-21s

Edited by Daddyorc (23 Jul 2023 7.19pm)

 

Zaha127 Flag 23 Jul 23 7.46pm

Edouard looked good so far hopefully he has a really good season and gets over 13 EPL goals. 7 last year and he was not at his best so 13+ is not impossible. With Olise being injured, maybe Rak Sakyi will get more minutes and he can do well.

Lerma is a good signing and Ahamada will have a better season this year.


Edited by Zaha127 (23 Jul 2023 7.47pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Jul 23 12.54pm

Anyone know what's going on with Ebiowei?

Not in the US squad...

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 09 Aug 23 12.01pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

By my logic this, as it stands, is our squad for next season...

GK

Johnstone, Guaita, Whitworth

CB

Guehi, Andersen, Richards

RB

N/A

LB

Mitchell

MF

Doucoure, Riedewald, Ahamada, Hughes, Eze, Schlupp

WF

Olise, Ebiowei, Rak-Sakyi

FW

Mateta, Eduoard, Ayew

Out of Contract

Zaha, McArthur, Tomkins, Milovojevic, Clyne, Ward, Ferguson, Butland

You'd assume that McArthur, Tomkins, Clyne and Ward will stay on and possibly Zaha. Ebiowei and Rak-Sakyi probably out on loan again.

However, with the exception of the goalkeepers and maybe central defence if Guehi and Tomkins stay, we pretty much need another RB, LB, CM, WF and FW, is that fair? Big summer ahead.


Nearly three months on from this, here's the updated squad with a couple of days until the season begins.

GK

Johnstone, Mathews, Whitworth

CB

Guehi, Andersen, Richards, Tomkins

RB

Clyne, Ward, Ferguson

LB

Mitchell, Hall (looks set to sign)

MF

Doucoure, Lerma, Riedewald, Ahamada, Hughes, Eze, Schlupp

WF

Olise, Franca, Ebiowei, Rak-Sakyi

FW

Mateta, Eduoard, Ayew


Have left Guaita out as that seems untenable. We are clearly still extremely light in attacking positions given that Ebiowei seems to have disappeared, JRS will surely go on loan and Franca is inexperienced. Would argue that we still need two wide players, a goalkeeper and a forward at a minimum.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Aug 23 12.50pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


Nearly three months on from this, here's the updated squad with a couple of days until the season begins.

GK

Johnstone, Mathews, Whitworth

CB

Guehi, Andersen, Richards, Tomkins

RB

Clyne, Ward, Ferguson

LB

Mitchell, Hall (looks set to sign)

MF

Doucoure, Lerma, Riedewald, Ahamada, Hughes, Eze, Schlupp

WF

Olise, Franca, Ebiowei, Rak-Sakyi

FW

Mateta, Eduoard, Ayew


Have left Guaita out as that seems untenable. We are clearly still extremely light in attacking positions given that Ebiowei seems to have disappeared, JRS will surely go on loan and Franca is inexperienced. Would argue that we still need two wide players, a goalkeeper and a forward at a minimum.

The Problem is that we have to sell one of the 3 strikers first, Ayew and Schlupp are really wide players and are ok as a back up to Olise and probably Franca, Lewis solves the Left back problem, if nobody leaves then a CF is the only a must, unless the Guaita situation is not resolved,then a keeper.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 11 Aug 23 2.02pm

Our squad depth is so thin going into the opening game of the season.

Out has gone Zaha, McArthur, Milojovic, Butland
In has come Lerma, Franca

Academy players out : Phillips (loan), Plange (loan(, Boateng (loan), o,Brien (looks like about to be sold), Kymani-Gordon(looks to be going on loan).

Injured, Olise, Hughes, Franca, Ferguson (must still be injured as he hasn't featured), not sure if Mitchell is fit yet.
Add to that Guiata is refusing to play, Lewis Hall hasn't yet joined on loan.

We are 1 key injury or suspension away from being right in trouble.


 

PatrickA Flag London 11 Aug 23 2.17pm

Hodgson was asked about the squad weakness at the press conference and said that the Chairman and DOF were seeking to address the matter.
He was also asked about uncertainty around the futures of some of the squad.
He said he took the job hoping to have the same squad at least as finished last season, with the exception of the uncertainty around Zaha.
In fact he said that he hoped that squad would be added to.
He did seem a bit downbeat about this as if he wasn't that confident about retaining/building the squad, but on the other hand said he felt positive about the prospects for the season.
The Hughes injury sounds long termish and Franca can't even train yet and will not be able to for some weeks.

 

steveeagle67 Flag london 15 Aug 23 9.33pm

The squad getting smaller and smaller now as o’brien has left and olise on verge of leaving
3 goalies(2 youngsters) , 7 def , 11 midfielders which inc amahada, eboiwei, riedewald,franca and rak sakyi who aren’t exactly regulars and 2 forwards with Mateta linked away too.
Roy said the squad is light but now we’re straw weight
Let’s hope for more than 2 players in this window!!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 15 Aug 23 9.49pm

Originally posted by steveeagle67

The squad getting smaller and smaller now as o’brien has left and olise on verge of leaving
3 goalies(2 youngsters) , 7 def , 11 midfielders which inc amahada, eboiwei, riedewald,franca and rak sakyi who aren’t exactly regulars and 2 forwards with Mateta linked away too.
Roy said the squad is light but now we’re straw weight
Let’s hope for more than 2 players in this window!!


I wouldn't class Matthews as a youngster. But you are right we need more than 2 incoming. I suspect we'll get them before the window closes.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 15 Aug 23 11.30pm

GK

Johnstone, Mathews, Whitworth

CB

Guehi, Andersen, Richards, Tomkins

RB

Clyne, Ward,

LB

Mitchell,

CDM

Doucoure, Lerma, Riedewald, Ahamada, Hughes

CAM

Eze

RW

Rak-Sakyi, Ayew

LW

Franca, Schlupp

ST

Mateta, Eduoard,

Squad still looks decent..we just need another ST, winger and LB

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 Aug 23 9.09am

We've lost Butland, Zaha, McArthur, Luka and potentially Olise and Guiata.
I know the argument would be that only Zaha, Olise and Guiata would be regulars, but it does point to an overall weakening of the squad.
I would prefer to have Guiata or Butland on the bench than Matthews .
I would prefer to have Zaha and Olise on the wings than Ayew and Schlupp.
We've lost a lot of experience from the squad.
So far only Lerma has come in to strengthen the squad , with Franca yet to be able to show what he can add.

I don't think the club anticipated losing Zaha,Olise or Guiata and seem to have been taken by surprise.
For example would we have tried harder for long term target Sarr if we thought we'd have these gaps?
He's not pulled up any trees recently, but he could have been an option in the light of unfolding events.
It all comes across now as a bit last minute as opposed to properly planned.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 16 Aug 23 9.55am

In this case isn't the use of the word "squad" an oxymoron?

 

terryriker Flag Newport Beach 17 Aug 23 2.31am

I say to myself,”it will be okay,” every time we lose a quality player. At this point it’s gone too far. Lerma, Schlupp, Doucoure, and Hughes were a top half group. Attack with Eze, Olise, Mateta, Edouard, are bang mid table. Back line is top 8 in the league, with Andersen and Guehi anchoring. With Franca, this team could push for Europe.
Now to the reality of the situation, we are a gutted squad. Olise and Doucoure will be gone before Matchday 2. Who knows what Franca is and if Guehi will be around. Instead of eyeing a top 6 spot we will be battling for 15-17 just keeping our noses ahead of SU,Luton,and Burnley.

 

Wright stuff Flag Bexley 17 Aug 23 7.21am

I thought even if we keep hold of Olise & Doucoure we would not finish much better than 14th. The front line is woeful even though we beat Sheffield. We cannot expect Eze to carry the team every game.
Lose both Olise & Doucoure and it is a relegation scrap.
Luton & Sheffield should occupy the bottom 2 and then it’s a scrap for the other place with a fair few clubs involved IMO.
Hall has been put up for sale for £ 30 million, no loan deal. I think it is time to stop doing business with the Scum club Chelsea after the alleged approach of Olise.
The depth of the squad is extremely thin, a couple of injuries to key players & we are championship standard.
Another season of hoping we reach January in a fair position and if not panic loan or buy, even though it’s known the January transfer is the wrong time to do business, is not the right approach to a new season.
The gulf in investment between the top 8 & the rest has grown beyond our current misery investment and something needs to give.
Not the way to run a Premier league club.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 17 Aug 23 7.29am

Originally posted by Wright stuff

I thought even if we keep hold of Olise & Doucoure we would not finish much better than 14th. The front line is woeful even though we beat Sheffield. We cannot expect Eze to carry the team every game.
Lose both Olise & Doucoure and it is a relegation scrap.
Luton & Sheffield should occupy the bottom 2 and then it’s a scrap for the other place with a fair few clubs involved IMO.
Hall has been put up for sale for £ 30 million, no loan deal. I think it is time to stop doing business with the Scum club Chelsea after the alleged approach of Olise.
The depth of the squad is extremely thin, a couple of injuries to key players & we are championship standard.
Another season of hoping we reach January in a fair position and if not panic loan or buy, even though it’s known the January transfer is the wrong time to do business, is not the right approach to a new season.
The gulf in investment between the top 8 & the rest has grown beyond our current misery investment and something needs to give.
Not the way to run a Premier league club.

Squads paper thin. Can’t see any major money being spent until the new long term manager is appointed at the end of the season. With respect to Roy he’s just a stop gap and it won’t do us any favours trying to get players in.

Mysterious decisions selling young talent to top European clubs ….he could have been a valuable squad member…..Tomkins and Richard’s are more than likely going to be injured when needed.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Squad for 23/24