You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Freedman


Page 3 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 Mar 24 2.48pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

The arguments why are there from both buying club and player perspectives.

1) Why take a risk when you have the money to buy a complete player who can fit straight into the first team.
2) Why buy a player who is one level down in ability from what you currently have? Doucoure was a solid defensive midfielder who we did well to identify. Andersen had a great season at Fulham but before that he was pretty average and on a par with numerous other centre half’s.
3) There is of course a maximum number of players you can have. In Guehi’s case everyone (fans included) could see he was an excellent player however Chelsea had no room for him. You could see Chalobah moving on for the same reason.
4) Why go to a club when you’re likely to finish out on loan at some obscure club and disappear into the ether. You can bet your life this is Dougies big selling point whenever he speaks to players. Come and play for us or sit on the bench at a club that might win a trophy.
5) on many occasions career progression goes better starting at a smaller club and building a reputation. Zaha couldn’t make the step up, who is to say Wharton would. It goes back to the point that when you have billions to spend why take risks (unless of course you are Todd Bohely who buys anyone who scores two games on the spin).
6) Eze and Olise both won awards for best player etc etc and were tipped for bright futures. I think we quite simply took the chance of paying fairly substantial fees (for us) and trusting they would come good (which they have). All the top teams will be interested in them now we have turned them into seasoned top tier players.

Dougie has done ok, but I agree with the OP on the centre forward position. It’s the ones that got away that irritate the most. We could have signed Mitrovic, Watkins and Toney and at the time we were connected to them with more than a passing interest and yet they transferred elsewhere for small sums (by centre forward standards anyway).Bamford, Batshuayi, Sorloth, Edouard and Mateta tick the just about PL standard box, but literally only just and in a league that has at any time say 40 plus centre forwards all of ours since Murray would have appeared in the lower mid to bottom quartile performance wise (except perhaps Benteke’s first season for us).

It will be interesting to see how effective Mateta is under Glasner, I think Edouard doesn’t have the determination to make it at this level. I would guess he might be moved on in the summer.

The Striker that got away from us was Borja Mayoral, i championed him so much, 8.5m EUR, top scoring forward in la Liga for Getafe at the moment

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Mar 24 3.10pm

Dougie's job is more than just finding players, it's actually convincing them to join us, among other things. My concern if he went is that we wouldn't have any idea who to replace him with. If United gave him a similar position there to the one he enjoys at Palace then he goes, no doubt in my mind. He'd be mad not to if he has any ambition. If he goes then we have to hope his team already know his summer plans so we're not starting from scratch again.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 05 Mar 24 3.12pm

Huge loss for us if he goes. If they make an official approach you'd assume he's as good as gone as can't turn that down. Awful timing just ahead of such a huge summer.

Just hope Parish has someone in mind to replace him. Knowing us we'll drag our heels for ages, make a token approach to someone and then sign a goalkeeper.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 05 Mar 24 3.25pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think it would be a massive loss for the club, lets hope Glasner knows someone, because i fear it could be Mark Bright, disaster.

Glasner strikes me as someone who wants to be in control, he must have contacts and I’m sure he’d love to put someone he knows in that role

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Mar 24 3.27pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Huge loss for us if he goes. If they make an official approach you'd assume he's as good as gone as can't turn that down. Awful timing just ahead of such a huge summer.

Just hope Parish has someone in mind to replace him. Knowing us we'll drag our heels for ages, make a token approach to someone and then sign a goalkeeper.

I laughed

Freedman will of course be a loss however I wouldn't panic too greatly. I'm sure Glasner himself if not the club may be able to sort something.

We've had a few great buys recently but many, many more duds. Wouldn't be the end of the world in my eyes.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Mar 24 3.36pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The Striker that got away from us was Borja Mayoral, i championed him so much, 8.5m EUR, top scoring forward in la Liga for Getafe at the moment

I can’t recall on this one, was it lack of funds, lack of interest from us, the player or disinterested seller? Our connections to players seem to be mostly click bait and they do rather blend into one another.

Stats certainly look good at the moment but probably missed the boat on price.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Mar 24 4.16pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The Striker that got away from us was Borja Mayoral, i championed him so much, 8.5m EUR, top scoring forward in la Liga for Getafe at the moment

Another player that Palace rejected after being in the Academy & then went to 'Brizzle', rejected us as he went to B'mouth is Antoine Semenyo . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 05 Mar 24 4.21pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Huge loss for us if he goes. .

agreed. I reckon DF & his signings have better statistics than average. EVERY club signs a few lemons & failures.

But by and large DF can identify a diamond in the rough and turn them into Palace legends.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Mar 24 4.26pm

It's interesting that some on here think he'll be no loss to Palace, and yet the new regime at one of the world's biggest clubs want to make him one of their first appointments.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

est1905 Flag 05 Mar 24 5.27pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Freedman to Utd?' by becky

I personally think he does a decent job without being irreplaceable. If he goes I wont really shed any tears and I believe we can find someone equally as good.
From what I have been told there are some world class recruitment specialists in the lower leagues. They dont get the opportunity to show their talent because they all work for clubs that dont have the money to bring in half their suggestions.
I guess time will tell if that turned out to be the case if this rumour developes into fact

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 05 Mar 24 5.32pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Freedman to Utd?' by becky


This is after they've coughed up £20m to get the chief scout from Newcastle? Their scouting team will be worth more than our actual team at this rate.

 

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 05 Mar 24 5.45pm

A big loss in my view and one of our own. So many great memories thanks to this guy and he has brought in some great players.

I think he will go and this is why the rumour never went away, he is also a big admirer of Ferguson. Great opportunity for Dougie.

Of course he can be replaced and hopefully a plan is under way as I am sure Glasner would expect no less.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Mar 24 6.07pm

Originally posted by doombear

And yet, none of the bigger clubs (or our rivals) went for Olise, Eze, Doucoure, Guehi, Andersen, so what stopped these other clubs from signing these players?

If rumours are true, Wharton chose us ahead of Chelsea because of the young talent we'd previously brought in and successfully used.

Because they weren't ready for bigger clubs? Because they didnt need them. Because we could all but guarantee first team football.

Not saying they are bad buys, but he's hardly Dan Ashworth. Nor has he any experience of buying players that are going to walk straight into the very top level.

The rumour just feels so odd to me.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Mar 24 6.33pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Because they weren't ready for bigger clubs? Because they didnt need them. Because we could all but guarantee first team football.

Not saying they are bad buys, but he's hardly Dan Ashworth. Nor has he any experience of buying players that are going to walk straight into the very top level.

The rumour just feels so odd to me.


Perhaps INEOS want to do things differently and stop wasting money on so-called stars who turn out to be barely average PL players.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 05 Mar 24 6.43pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

It's interesting that some on here think he'll be no loss to Palace, and yet the new regime at one of the world's biggest clubs want to make him one of their first appointments.

Mate - historically speaking they maybe one of the biggest clubs in the world but ATM - they are in a real mess..!!

IMO that won’t change until the Glazers exit - whilst they remain the turmoil will remain - IMO now only complicated further by the introduction Radcliffe/Ineos..

Then you’ve got the influence outside of that from the likes of Ferguson, pundits like Neville etc..

Beyond that the Manager position is like a revolving door - think Ten Hag will be jettisoned come the end of the season.

Problem you have is the culture is one where they believe just because they are Man U they have a divine right to be successful - that emanates from Board level down and onto the terraces. Anything else is seen as failure..!!

In that climate/environment again IMO the DoF position is a poison chalice in the ejector seat..!!

Whole thing is so toxic at the moment - wouldn’t go anywhere near it if I were DF..!!

COYP

 

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Mar 24 7.50pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

It's interesting that some on here think he'll be no loss to Palace, and yet the new regime at one of the world's biggest clubs want to make him one of their first appointments.

They have no idea what he actually does, some still ramble on about him walking out, when manager, but it was his team that got us promoted with players he unearthed.
I think Parish will try very hard to keep him, he is obviously highly thought of.

 

EddieMac Flag 05 Mar 24 8.00pm

Telegraph now saying United have distanced themselves from the rumour.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 05 Mar 24 9.14pm

Southampton hired an Austrian manager and lost their doF equivalent the following month; that went OK for a bit but it didn't end well ultimately.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 05 Mar 24 9.15pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Telegraph now saying United have distanced themselves from the rumour.

Interesting; that's what happened last time the story surfaced.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Mar 24 12.07am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Mate - historically speaking they maybe one of the biggest clubs in the world but ATM - they are in a real mess..!!

IMO that won’t change until the Glazers exit - whilst they remain the turmoil will remain - IMO now only complicated further by the introduction Radcliffe/Ineos..

Then you’ve got the influence outside of that from the likes of Ferguson, pundits like Neville etc..

Beyond that the Manager position is like a revolving door - think Ten Hag will be jettisoned come the end of the season.

Problem you have is the culture is one where they believe just because they are Man U they have a divine right to be successful - that emanates from Board level down and onto the terraces. Anything else is seen as failure..!!

In that climate/environment again IMO the DoF position is a poison chalice in the ejector seat..!!

Whole thing is so toxic at the moment - wouldn’t go anywhere near it if I were DF..!!

COYP

It’s messy at United at the moment for sure.

But Radcliffe will be running the football side of the operation, so the Glazers will be less relevant going forward.

It’s a new beginning for them, and Ashworth coming in is a sign of their intent. I think you could view DF’s potential role as a huge opportunity rather than a poison chalice.

In any event, the point I was making is that DF is clearly more highly thought of by Radcliffe and co than he is by some on here.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 3 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman