You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Alexi Navalny -dead.
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexi Navalny -dead.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
beak Flag croydon 16 Feb 24 1.02pm

[Link] The West must respond by doubling Ukranian aid and allowing the Ukraine to attack military targets in Russia.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Feb 24 1.04pm

Originally posted by beak

[Link] The West must respond by doubling Ukranian aid and allowing the Ukraine to attack military targets in Russia.

You must be young.

 

beak Flag croydon 16 Feb 24 1.15pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

You must be young.

I know that A line must be drawn and this is the time.I'm younger than you but the vast majority of people are.

Edited by beak (16 Feb 2024 1.16pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Feb 24 1.19pm

I'm surprised he lasted this long.

A brave man for sure.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Feb 24 1.20pm

Of course, Putin had nothing to do with this, that must be obvious to every fair-minded person.

Putin is a strong, but trustworthy, leader who we are foolish not to do deals with. Deals he would always respect and honour and never take them as a sign of weakness to be exploited.

Putin doesn't fear opponents. He just kills them.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 16 Feb 24 2.09pm

Yep, I've just seen this. Shocking. The man stood up for his beliefs and paid the ultimate price. You're right Hrolf, he was a very brave man.

Similar theme, I watched a film last night - ICON, based on a Frederick Forsyth book. An oligarch aiming to become President of Russia. Scarily reminiscent of what's going on with Putin.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 16 Feb 24 2.21pm

Prisons are dangerous places. Ask Max Clifford, John McAfee and Jeffrey Epstein

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Feb 24 2.34pm

There should be questions raised about this and I agree with the criticisms of the Putin regime in regards to political opponents...just as I do with Ukraine.

No one gave a feck about Gonzalo Lira dying in Ukrainian captivity did they..

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

snytaxx Flag London 16 Feb 24 4.04pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

There should be questions raised about this and I agree with the criticisms of the Putin regime in regards to political opponents...just as I do with Ukraine.

No one gave a feck about Gonzalo Lira dying in Ukrainian captivity did they..

Yet you continuously spread pro russian propaganda points with little to no scrutiny?

Regarding Mr. Lira, nor should they as they are false equivalents. The man was a criminal antisemitic grifter beautified by the pro russian's as a 'journalist'. While any form of state violence would be reprehensible, a 55 year old chain smoker dying of pneumonia doesnt quite have the same level of smoking gun foul play vs a man getting nerve gassed on a plane.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Feb 24 7.35pm

Originally posted by snytaxx

Yet you continuously spread pro russian propaganda points with little to no scrutiny?

Regarding Mr. Lira, nor should they as they are false equivalents. The man was a criminal antisemitic grifter beautified by the pro russian's as a 'journalist'. While any form of state violence would be reprehensible, a 55 year old chain smoker dying of pneumonia doesnt quite have the same level of smoking gun foul play vs a man getting nerve gassed on a plane.

Normally I ignore you but as this is about someone's death so here I won't let you put out this statement without reply.

You come on here and present claims from Ukraine as facts and then smear someone who died in Ukrainian captivity because you didn't like their personality.

Sorry but you don't get to present claims as facts.

He was a journalist and the how and the why and circumstances of why he died is....as with this Russian...purely reliant upon information coming from the authority responsible for his safety.

There is an obvious conflict of interest with both of them and questions and criticisms in both circumstances are valid. You however are.......Well, I'll let others judge.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Feb 2024 7.38pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 Feb 24 7.49pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'm surprised he lasted this long.

A brave man for sure.

what some would call brave, i would call Foolhardy.

Vlad Putin has a long history of his political opponents accidentally cutting their heads off while shaving. duh !

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Matov Flag 16 Feb 24 8.36pm

Originally posted by beak

[Link] The West must respond by doubling Ukranian aid and allowing the Ukraine to attack military targets in Russia.

I know. Imagine the pressure being ramped up now. Putin must be insane to have the man killed.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Feb 24 9.13pm

Originally posted by Matov

I know. Imagine the pressure being ramped up now. Putin must be insane to have the man killed.

People don't really understand just how dire the financial situation is in Ukraine.

The fifty billion the EU just gave to them is for over four years...it's not a lump sum and it's just to run their state. However, that is far less than half what they really need to pay teachers and keep the lights on so to speak.

In terms of military aid, the House has just rejected the 60 billion aid bill and is now away from business till the end of the month I think.

Even if they pass that bill I doubt they will get the supplies they need for weeks.

The Americans are using the delay in military funding as an excuse for Ukraine losing....and there is no doubt that the lack of funding Ukraine's fight is ensuring that they lose faster.

However, Ukraine lost three cities before this over two years without any breaks in funding. So in reality what is happening is an increase in speed of collapse.

I would put the likelihood of Congress passing that funding at 70/30 against unless the Democrats move significantly on the US border.

Ukraine are literally days away from losing the city of Avdiivka and that might have repercussions within the Ukrainian army and a lot of finger pointing is going to happen.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Feb 2024 9.13pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

eaglesdare Flag 16 Feb 24 11.37pm

The US government can solve a murder mystery in a Russian prison, but has no answers about a high profile prisoner, in a US Federal prison, committing suicide while in protective custody......

 

snytaxx Flag London 17 Feb 24 12.02am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Normally I ignore you but as this is about someone's death so here I won't let you put out this statement without reply.

You come on here and present claims from Ukraine as facts and then smear someone who died in Ukrainian captivity because you didn't like their personality.

Sorry but you don't get to present claims as facts.

He was a journalist and the how and the why and circumstances of why he died is....as with this Russian...purely reliant upon information coming from the authority responsible for his safety.

There is an obvious conflict of interest with both of them and questions and criticisms in both circumstances are valid. You however are.......Well, I'll let others judge.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Feb 2024 7.38pm)

Not even remotely true and alot of hypocracy here.

Lira was well known grifter. He wrote a book which flopped in the 90s.

[Link]

Turned up in the naughties as a 'film director'. That flopped.

[Link]

He then moved on to giving financial advise as a blogger.

[Link]

This is about as close to 'journalism' as you could argue he ever got before the drift right into the manophere.

He rebranded himself 'coach red bill'and moved to Ukraine. Here is his Patreon channel which even still holds the name where he used to beg for money.

[Link]

At this point he was in his 50's coming out with lines such as:

"Women over 30 are ruined"
"all women only truly desire money"
"the degenerate Western culture pushes them to chase only the hottest 15 % guys for meaningless sex".

Some real Andrew Tate stuff

He then journied through the typical anti vax and 'Russia wont invade' malarky. Then became an apologist / 5th columnist when they did.

You claim I accept whatever Ukraine says 'verbatim' even thought 1. I dont and 2. you seem to do the exact same for pro Russian propaganda points consistenly touting Mr. Lira's journalistic credentials and information despite it all being dubious at best.

Ukraine arrested Lira for violating the countries criminal code Article 436-2 of Ukraine’s Criminal Code — justifying Russian aggression against Ukraine. Thats what Ukraine said the reason was for arresting him.

Here is Lira doing just that.

Not to mention passing off Russian war crimes as Ukrainian ones

[Link]
[Link]

And for good measure, live streaming the positions of Ukrainian military assets to his pro russian audience.

[Link]

Did you want me to also show you the antisemitism or have you had enough?

So yes, I do get to cast considerable doubt onto the narrative that Lira was 'murdered' given the reasons for doing so are significantly less worth it and the evidence that he was flimsy at best vs a guy who was literally poisoned in broad day light (first attempt at his life) and could act as a closest thing to opposition Putin actually had. That is what makes this a false equivalent as previously stated. The fact you choose to compare these two as remotely equal is really what people should judge.

Edited by snytaxx (17 Feb 2024 12.10am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Feb 24 3.46am

Originally posted by snytaxx

Not even remotely true and alot of hypocracy here.

Lira was well known grifter. He wrote a book which flopped in the 90s.

[Link]

Turned up in the naughties as a 'film director'. That flopped.

[Link]

He then moved on to giving financial advise as a blogger.

[Link]

This is about as close to 'journalism' as you could argue he ever got before the drift right into the manophere.

He rebranded himself 'coach red bill'and moved to Ukraine. Here is his Patreon channel which even still holds the name where he used to beg for money.

[Link]

At this point he was in his 50's coming out with lines such as:

"Women over 30 are ruined"
"all women only truly desire money"
"the degenerate Western culture pushes them to chase only the hottest 15 % guys for meaningless sex".

Some real Andrew Tate stuff

He then journied through the typical anti vax and 'Russia wont invade' malarky. Then became an apologist / 5th columnist when they did.

You claim I accept whatever Ukraine says 'verbatim' even thought 1. I dont and 2. you seem to do the exact same for pro Russian propaganda points consistenly touting Mr. Lira's journalistic credentials and information despite it all being dubious at best.

Ukraine arrested Lira for violating the countries criminal code Article 436-2 of Ukraine’s Criminal Code — justifying Russian aggression against Ukraine. Thats what Ukraine said the reason was for arresting him.

Here is Lira doing just that.

Not to mention passing off Russian war crimes as Ukrainian ones

[Link]
[Link]

And for good measure, live streaming the positions of Ukrainian military assets to his pro russian audience.

[Link]

Did you want me to also show you the antisemitism or have you had enough?

So yes, I do get to cast considerable doubt onto the narrative that Lira was 'murdered' given the reasons for doing so are significantly less worth it and the evidence that he was flimsy at best vs a guy who was literally poisoned in broad day light (first attempt at his life) and could act as a closest thing to opposition Putin actually had. That is what makes this a false equivalent as previously stated. The fact you choose to compare these two as remotely equal is really what people should judge.

Edited by snytaxx (17 Feb 2024 12.10am)


I'll state once again, you present claims made by Ukraine as facts and yet accuse me of 'Russian propaganda'.

Once again here...and as I previously stated, you present reasons why you don't like Lira's personality. I find that irrelevant to what happened to him. He didn't deserve to die.

None of that has any relevance to the fact he died in Ukrainian captivity. You don't address the claims made by himself and his father on the torture and financial extortion while there but instead accept as fact Ukraine's claims....when you have no way of knowing either way.

I watched some Lira videos before he died. People can do the same if they wish. That will prove the fact that he was an opinion journalist of that war. People can argue about the definition of journalist if they wish but he does fit a definition for me and people can make their own mind up.

People can speculate that doing a hit job on someone like this to justify not liking them and thus presenting the idea that what happened to them was unimportant could be seen as rather tactless.

Now moving onto Navalny.

I don't regard this man's politics as migrating reasons for not caring that he's died in Russian captivity. I find no reason to believe Russia and all the reasons you give for accepting an innocent demise of Lira falls under the same unknowable category.

As you spent rather a lot of time slagging off Lira because of...in some ways I'd agree...his questionable behaviour I'll do the same for Navalny.

Not for the same purpose that you did....to suggest that someone holding controversial views doesn't matter when captive but for the reason that he also...at one point as a prominent activist...held views quite more controversial than Lira.

Before 2012 Navalny was a Russian nationalist who regularly attended what you'd regard as extreme marches and it's reported that he wanted to strip Chechens, Dargins, and all other nations in the Caucasus of their Russian citizenship and compared them to cockroaches and flies and he held strong anti Islamic and immigration views. The behaviour of the marches he attended and helped organise is on video....I'll attach a video of this below.

Why he changed to the rainbow loving western pipedream?....I don't know, CIA money maybe, that's not important. He didn't deserve to die and Russia were responsible for his safety.

To me it makes no difference what their political opinions are. When the mainstream media crafts a message that presents a 'goodies and baddies' choice between regimes I am sufficiently interested to look. Ukraine and Russia can be what they are, however as we are being asked to believe narratives and pay tens of billions to one side and possibly enter a war against Russia I feel more objectivity on claims is a valid pursuit.

You make great play of saying there is a false equivalence between these men's deaths. I on the other hand see that they were both single men held by regimes punishing them. They are both dead and unlike you I criticise both regimes for this.

One man's death was ignored by mainstream western media, despite his captivity and lack of American action (he held an American passport) and his treatment having been raised at the Biden press briefing room by a journalist and his cause being raised by, booted out of the mainstream' journalists like Tucker Carlson....probably the single most popular journalist in the world.

I suspect that what happened to both these men was wrong. However, one man's death is ignored by the mainstream and the other man's death is spread far and wide across media outlets across the world.

People can draw their own conclusions.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

Attachment: navalny.mp4 (5,592.15Kb)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 17 Feb 24 4.19am

Originally posted by eaglesdare

The US government can solve a murder mystery in a Russian prison, but has no answers about a high profile prisoner, in a US Federal prison, committing suicide while in protective custody......

Quite, ^^^

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Feb 24 5.11am

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 17 Feb 24 8.28am

Assange and Alexi Navalny were in prison to try and break them.
Russia decided it couldn't break Navalny,...Assange may come to a similar fate.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Feb 24 8.50am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Assange and Alexi Navalny were in prison to try and break them.
Russia decided it couldn't break Navalny,...Assange may come to a similar fate.

Indeed.

I have little doubt that US intelligence have discussed killing Assange. At the moment they are ensuring a living death.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Alexi Navalny -dead.