This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's all nuts. While I don't agree with racial language....and that should be sorted out in-house I have to say the idea that people can't have fun and blow off steam because others take offence is similarly out of order....it should have all been sorted out with apologies...but I don't think this has been up front and honest. Words are words and intent and context matters......A world where the race card is accepted for every perceived slight has led to the current 'witch trial' culture. What is really evil about all this is that if you think like me but are say really good at cricket or football then you are persecuted out of the game. It's the opposite of meritocracy. I'll make the point again.....When the social conservatives ruled these institutions....back when Botham, Gower and Boycott were playing if you held the opposite opinions....no one stopped you making a living. This point really needs forcing home because what is happening isn't good and it isn't progress, in fact I regard it as authoritarianism and anti western.
You are wrong. It's the prevailing culture which needs to be addressed first. Once that's done, the other issues can follow. It is my understanding that in, for instance Yorkshire, there is a very high percentage of ethnically Asian men playing cricket at club level, but only a small percentage playing cricket at County level. Why is this? Are the Asians largely useless, or is it because the culture at County selection level excludes them?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You are wrong. It's the prevailing culture which needs to be addressed first. Once that's done, the other issues can follow. It is my understanding that in, for instance Yorkshire, there is a very high percentage of ethnically Asian men playing cricket at club level, but only a small percentage playing cricket at County level. Why is this? Are the Asians largely useless, or is it because the culture at County selection level excludes them? I don’t know the reason but there aren’t many Asians are on Palace’s books either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
I posted that 'the word "racism" has now no meaning except in so far as it more or less signifies "something not desirable"'. Clearly you said everything of the sort. Edited by georgenorman (19 Nov 2021 2.20pm) What you actually said I said, was "people are racists because he believe that they think racist thoughts!" Now just compare the two! Beliefs are quite a lot more than just having thoughts. They usually involve actions, too. Thinking about something doesn't mean you believe it. It can sometimes mean the precise opposite.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You are wrong. It's the prevailing culture which needs to be addressed first. Once that's done, the other issues can follow. It is my understanding that in, for instance Yorkshire, there is a very high percentage of ethnically Asian men playing cricket at club level, but only a small percentage playing cricket at County level. Why is this? Are the Asians largely useless, or is it because the culture at County selection level excludes them? I am right, persecution for beliefs isn't acceptable first, second or third. The fact that you are willing to accept it over bs conceptual that can never be squarely enforced shows just how dangerous your nonsense is. Are your stats on south Asians even proportionally correct? More south Asians have joined IS than the British Army? Perhaps you should get out of your incredibly white Cornwall and ask them what the answers are.....perhaps swap your Cornwall for Oldham and give them a leg up. Besides do you go around asking why a far higher percentage of non whites are playing in the England team than is representative for England? Why not? Surely you're not a hypocrite to only focus one way. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Nov 2021 6.59pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
We were having quite a good laugh until old miserly guts turned up.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Orange1290
"Azeem Rafiq racism case: Cricket chiefs 'apologise unreservedly' for 'blight' of racism" You post that like there was ever any doubt as to what the outcome would be. Cricket relies on sponsorship and sponsors are spineless money orientated sheep. This is not a trial to discover what is true, just an exercise in appearances. It is about the power of money and the fear of losing your livelihood and reputation. It is about politicians looking like they care about 'racism'. The truth never mattered, just like it doesn't matter to you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What you actually said I said, was "people are racists because he believe that they think racist thoughts!" Now just compare the two! Beliefs are quite a lot more than just having thoughts. They usually involve actions, too. Thinking about something doesn't mean you believe it. It can sometimes mean the precise opposite. Of course the implication of your statement: "it is the belief that matters. Not whether it is openly stated." is that you would consider someone racist without them actually expressing any racism if you harboured a belief that they thought racist thoughts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Two wrongs don’t make a right do they? He’s used awful language in the past which doesn’t do him any favours whatsoever but it doesn’t make his case or testimony against Yorkshire any less valid.
Excuse the length of this post. I wanted to make a point on this, as my first instinct was the same as Dan's observation above. I agree that Rafiq's 'previous' doesn't mean he didn't experience, or has any less right to call out, racist treatment at Yorkshire CCC. However... If everything Rafiq says about Yorkshire is accurate then we have to some extent to address the age-old and unfortunate problem of distinguishing, after the event and out of context, between abuse and 'banter'. This is a nightmare to do, and there are plenty of people who refuse to. Some will pass off even the worst abuse as playful banter, whilst others (equally unreasonably) do the polar opposite. For me, anyone refusing to recognise the possibility of some graded distinction between the extremes is not only failing to solve the problem at hand, but is also contributing to a different, wider one. Ultimately, if you want to fairly judge individual people (which is quite important) then you have to try to tease out the facts and context (including intention) of each of the acts Rafiq recounts, as well as the impacts. This is where the difficulty arises. We can only rely on the evidence of the individuals, and how they describe their experiences, especially when it comes to the potentially critical matters of context and tone. The integrity of the witness becomes paramount, therefore. Are they a reasonable person, whose judgement one can fully trust? Now include Rafiq's recently uncovered 'previous'. Two things arise: Firstly, simply: Is Rafiq's judgment sound? He seemingly alleges a culture of racism, without any distinction of category within that. Perhaps it's not his job to distinguish between a bad joke, something that someone else (Asian or otherwise) might find reasonable but which he doesn't, dirty low-down bullying, or even racial supremacist or separatist mindsets, especially if the sum total is awful anyway, but individual people and instances are named in his evidence so they should be addressed individually if possible. Also, there will inevitably be recommendations for improvements after this, and solutions are only effective if the problems are properly identified, and not oversimplified. So, has Rafiq been able or willing to distinguish between a person making a joke designed to include him in the group, another making one less clearly intended to include him, one making a joke at his expense, and one intending to degrade and humiliate him? Any of these things might be hurtful and require action, but they are not the same. Can he tell the difference? If not, and if he puts all his negative experiences at Yorkshire (which seem so awful when he recounts them, but which may have been said in a range of tones, contexts and settings by very different people for different reasons) into the same narrow category marked 'Racism in Action', and none of them into categories marked 'Ill-Advised Humour' or 'Just Talking S***e, Don’t Take Seriously’ but yet he indulges in (at very best) that same brand of humour or s***-talking himself, then there is an issue. That issue is not hypocrisy, but credibility. He becomes a less obviously reasonable and fair person whose account not of the facts but of the context I can trust in full. If on the other hand, he does recognise the difference, then why is he apologising so fully for what would seem quite plainly to be a joke in private made ten years ago? If he said 'Yeah I wrote that message, but it was a joke in the context of a private conversation with someone I trusted to know that I'm not racist' then frankly I'd trust his judgement regarding the things that were said to him at Yorkshire a lot more. His apology just makes me concerned that he sees all racist language as equal and without category - that his approach is too simplified to be relied upon. Secondly, more importantly, what does this do to the mindset of the investigating bodies (be that select committee, ECB, the media, social media or the public)? Should Rafiq face penalties for his own errors? Possibly. Do we accept that they were just poorly considered ‘banter’? Dunno. Does the fact that he is an Asian Muslim cast his anti-Semitic comments in a different, darker light? Possibly? His apology seems genuine, but should he be asked to confirm his position on the validity of the creation of a Jewish State, or do we just leave that off the menu and ask for that sort of policy-position statement when other types of racism are alleged? If so, why? If Marie van der Zyl, president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews (Not sure what that means - is she entitled to speak for others simply because she shares their racial category?) can find that: “Azeem Rafiq has suffered terribly at the hands of racists in cricket so he will well understand the hurt this exchange will cause to Jews who have supported him. His apology certainly seems heartfelt and we have no reason to believe he is not completely sincere”, then can some of the people Rafiq names not also offer a heartfelt and sincere apology, and would that be sufficient? The notion that there is only racism and non-racism, that there is no need to trouble ourselves with nuance, intention, and vague and blurry subcategories, or to wrestle with inconsistencies and paradoxes within that simplified approach is upheld by some at all costs, and has the force of law to some extent precisely because the nuances are too fine and varied to regulate for. Surely, however, that simplified mindset cannot survive the realities of the real world when the highest-profile victim of the day is also a guilty party? Rafiq should have justice, but not blindly so. The same complexities that surround his actions must be recognised in the actions of those he accuses, for everyone's sake. Edited by TheBigToePunt (19 Nov 2021 7.39pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
I don’t know the reason but there aren’t many Asians are on Palace’s books either. I suspect that's historical. It's cricket, not football, which is the big sport in India and pakistan, so in the culture. Maybe that will change in time.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Orange1290
"Azeem Rafiq racism case: Cricket chiefs 'apologise unreservedly' for 'blight' of racism" You post that like there was ever any doubt as to what the outcome would be. Cricket relies on sponsorship and sponsors are spineless money orientated sheep. This is not a trial to discover what is true, just an exercise in appearances. It is about the power of money and the fear of losing your livelihood and reputation. It is about politicians looking like they care about racism The truth never mattered, just like it doesn't matter to you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I am right, persecution for beliefs isn't acceptable first, second or third. The fact that you are willing to accept it over bs conceptual that can never be squarely enforced shows just how dangerous your nonsense is. Are your stats on south Asians even proportionally correct? More south Asians have joined IS than the British Army? Perhaps you should get out of your incredibly white Cornwall and ask them what the answers are.....perhaps swap your Cornwall for Oldham and give them a leg up. Besides do you go around asking why a far higher percentage of non whites are playing in the England team than is representative for England? Why not? Surely you're not a hypocrite to only focus one way. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Nov 2021 6.59pm) I think we need to agree to disagree. If the desired cultural change is achieved, then any chance of "persecution" disappears. I think anyway that there is now a growing recognition that individuals immersed in a culture cannot Why you think ISIS recruitment has any relevance to cricket in Yorkshire beats me. Almost as much as why me living in Cornwall does. But let me tell you something. Having lived in Wisbech myself for more than a decade, I saw fewer Asian people there than I do here in Truro. I also don't know why you are introducing the football team into the argument! I don't have the stats, but I get the sense that not too many Asians play football. Cricket is their sport of choice. The stats on the situation in Yorkshire I heard immediately after the Rafiq testimony. I cannot find it now, but these pieces tell the story. The first is from 2020, before the Rafiq story broke:-
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect that's historical. It's cricket, not football, which is the big sport in India and pakistan, so in the culture. Maybe that will change in time. It is probably because they are not very good at it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Of course the implication of your statement: "it is the belief that matters. Not whether it is openly stated." is that you would consider someone racist without them actually expressing any racism if you harboured a belief that they thought racist thoughts. What anyone thinks is their business. It's only what they do that matters. If they harbour racist thoughts but don't express, or act on them, then firstly no-one will know, and secondly it doesn't matter. So thoughts are irrelevant. Beliefs, when acted upon, are relevant. Not, I suspect, you will appreciate the difference, given your previous posts.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It is probably because they are not very good at it. Is there any logical reason why not? Good footballers seem to come in all sizes.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Is there any logical reason why not? Good footballers seem to come in all sizes. Sure, but they seem to prefer supermodels. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Nov 2021 8.01pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think we need to agree to disagree. A sentence on which we can concur.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect that's historical. It's cricket, not football, which is the big sport in India and pakistan, so in the culture. Maybe that will change in time. It’s possible but there are a lot of kids who’ve grown up in London playing football in the past 40 years. Whatever the reason all I’m saying is it’s probably not due to discrimination on the club’s part.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
It’s possible but there are a lot of kids who’ve grown up in London playing football in the past 40 years. Whatever the reason all I’m saying is it’s probably not due to discrimination on the club’s part. I am confident that the club doesn't discriminate. Indeed, I would be confident about professional football in general. This seems to be cricket's problem. It would be interesting to know just what proportion of Asian youth play football after their school years, and whether there is a hidden problem at amateur level.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You post that like there was ever any doubt as to what the outcome would be. Cricket relies on sponsorship and sponsors are spineless money orientated sheep. This is not a trial to discover what is true, just an exercise in appearances. It is about the power of money and the fear of losing your livelihood and reputation. It is about politicians looking like they care about racism The truth never mattered, just like it doesn't matter to you.
Pro China, EU & Palestine |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.