You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 32 of 65 < 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Mar 19 6.02pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

and how much money do you think it would take us to acheive 8th place the PL?

Burnley finished in 7th place last season having finished the season before in 16th place.Their net spend last season was just short of £13 Mill.Just an example that's all.

Edited by Willo (17 Mar 2019 6.03pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 17 Mar 19 6.07pm

I understand that some are happy to settle for mediocrity and wouldn’t mind finishing fourth from bottom every season as long as we stay up.
For me I would like to see evidence of progress which doesn’t seem unreasonable.
People say Roy hasn’t been backed in the transfer market, but we have retained all of our star players unlike say Watford, Leicester and Everton who have lost Richarlison, Mahrez, Kante, Lukaku, Stones.
Roy himself is adamant about the strength of our squad.
People are entitled to ask questions about our appalling home form and why we are so poor on set pieces (defending and attacking).
I’m not saying he’s a bad manager but this season I would like to have seen more evidence of his tactical prowess and ability to positively influence games.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Mar 19 6.19pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

madness innit...and all because people think we have this god given right to challenge for 8th position, which in reality means f*** all difference from finishing 14th.

it's all about mindset.

8th is a better reward in terms of prize money.

8th is a better platform to build on in terms of finishing 14th

8th position each year could attract a certain type of player, than say 14th which is almost flirting with relegation.

looking up is far better than treading water.

The mindset at palace should be to get to 40 points at record speed each year, wether it's after 31 games, 30 games, that should always be the goal. It would show progress from escaping the relegation zone, it would also show progress in climbing up the table - but the beauty in that goal is it doesn't purposely state 'we don't want a relegation scrap' or 'we are in a relegation and need to look up' it also doesn't say 'we want a top 8 or 6 finish' it just states we want to do better each season, which is the ultimate goal for any club.

Parish, however doesn't have the funds to sustain the club in the prem - it gets better each year, the prem, stakes are higher each year and the small blinds, big blinds are the base line that parish can't keep up with. Any major investor will want to play the hand they are dealt with, which is probably why the americans want out as parish is holding their chips.... damn poker advert next to me has influenced by metaphors.

 


This was once a quality forum....

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 17 Mar 19 6.39pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

A lot of people are assuming - we don't really know anything, however, parish has got to have a plan b lined up, or at least looking forward otherwise he is failing at his job.

It's plain to see that nothing is changing - until a manager is backed and trusted with money to implement his plan, all we are doing is treading water.

It seems like a change is coming, players out in jan, only limited signings made and loans, this summer needs to be on point. Let Roy (or any manager) get his players, or he may as well be let go.

Until we massively reduce our wage bill, this isn’t going to happen.

 


Bring back Brolin

Curlyeagle 2 Flag Crowborogh 17 Mar 19 6.40pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

How many other managers would have poked up with last three transfer windows and relative lack of control over transfers ?

Could not agree more. And this is the reason we are not in a position to cherry pick a replacement for Roy.

Mate of mine is an Ipswich fan and was saying this time last year they couldn’t wait for Mick Mcarthy to be replaced!!!

They got their wish and just look at the position they now find themselves in.

Like many I am an ambitious fan but Roy is steady and as frustrating as his tactics/decisions can be in my opinion he has not done to bad.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Mar 19 7.01pm

Squad is laughably weak and lacking in balance. Also looking a bit old. But don't let that detract from blaming Roy. SP and the flaky Americans must be pissing themselves that they've got Roy copping it.

All we need is a striker my arse.

 

jeeagles Flag 17 Mar 19 7.01pm

Originally posted by Curlyeagle 2

Could not agree more. And this is the reason we are not in a position to cherry pick a replacement for Roy.

Mate of mine is an Ipswich fan and was saying this time last year they couldn’t wait for Mick Mcarthy to be replaced!!!

They got their wish and just look at the position they now find themselves in.

Like many I am an ambitious fan but Roy is steady and as frustrating as his tactics/decisions can be in my opinion he has not done to bad.

I agree with you to an extent. I am concerned about who is available to replace Hodgson and the lack of money that has been made available.

I would say that Roy, Pardew (at Newcastle and Palace), and Big Mick all made the same mistake with transfers.

They are all pretty average managers with a limited shelf life. They all had good starts but didn't challenge the board for extra transfer money. Not getting in new talent is certainly a contributory factor in things become stale.

Big Sam and Pulis may have both left after not getting what they want, but I would like to see the manager be a bit firmer with the board to get new players in.

Hodgson has been our worst manager in the transfer market since we were promoted. He has not signed a single player that's become a first team regular.

I don't think Roy will kick up a fuss either as he knows if threatens to resign like Pulis or BFS then it's most likely that he'll be shown the door.

If Roy, Pardew, or McCarthy had kicked up a fuss when they had Palace/Newcastle/Ipswich playing well then their future career options would probably look brighter too.


 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 17 Mar 19 7.01pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

it's all about mindset.

8th is a better reward in terms of prize money.

8th is a better platform to build on in terms of finishing 14th

8th position each year could attract a certain type of player, than say 14th which is almost flirting with relegation.

looking up is far better than treading water.

The mindset at palace should be to get to 40 points at record speed each year, wether it's after 31 games, 30 games, that should always be the goal. It would show progress from escaping the relegation zone, it would also show progress in climbing up the table - but the beauty in that goal is it doesn't purposely state 'we don't want a relegation scrap' or 'we are in a relegation and need to look up' it also doesn't say 'we want a top 8 or 6 finish' it just states we want to do better each season, which is the ultimate goal for any club.

Parish, however doesn't have the funds to sustain the club in the prem - it gets better each year, the prem, stakes are higher each year and the small blinds, big blinds are the base line that parish can't keep up with. Any major investor will want to play the hand they are dealt with, which is probably why the americans want out as parish is holding their chips.... damn poker advert next to me has influenced by metaphors.

so by your own reconing...we are currently at our highest points tally for this stage in a PL season, bearing in mind we have had no fit strikers that means that so far this has been a successful season? right?

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Mar 19 7.22pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I agree with you to an extent. I am concerned about who is available to replace Hodgson and the lack of money that has been made available.

I would say that Roy, Pardew (at Newcastle and Palace), and Big Mick all made the same mistake with transfers.

They are all pretty average managers with a limited shelf life. They all had good starts but didn't challenge the board for extra transfer money. Not getting in new talent is certainly a contributory factor in things become stale.

Big Sam and Pulis may have both left after not getting what they want, but I would like to see the manager be a bit firmer with the board to get new players in.

Hodgson has been our worst manager in the transfer market since we were promoted. He has not signed a single player that's become a first team regular.

I don't think Roy will kick up a fuss either as he knows if threatens to resign like Pulis or BFS then it's most likely that he'll be shown the door.

If Roy, Pardew, or McCarthy had kicked up a fuss when they had Palace/Newcastle/Ipswich playing well then their future career options would probably look brighter too.


A pair of slags who served their purpose. Know a Boro fan reckons their fans hate Pulis.

 

jeeagles Flag 17 Mar 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

A pair of slags who served their purpose. Know a Boro fan reckons their fans hate Pulis.

Fair point, excellently made.

Last year they loved Pulis at Boro.
This year they are fed up.

I think it goes back to the limited shelf life these managers have and the need to keep things fresh.

If Pardew had left after his first (or second) season we would have thought of him differently.

Also, if Pardew and Hodgson had both left at the end of their first season, with the club in a decent position, it would be a lot easier to recruit a replacement.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 17 Mar 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

A pair of slags who served their purpose. Know a Boro fan reckons their fans hate Pulis.

Disagree, had we kept both I am sure that we wouldn’t be where we are now..... higher. Of course could be wrong but that’s my opinion.

 


Bring back Brolin

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 17 Mar 19 7.39pm


It’s not Roy making the transfers though is it?


Originally posted by jeeagles

I agree with you to an extent. I am concerned about who is available to replace Hodgson and the lack of money that has been made available.

I would say that Roy, Pardew (at Newcastle and Palace), and Big Mick all made the same mistake with transfers.

They are all pretty average managers with a limited shelf life. They all had good starts but didn't challenge the board for extra transfer money. Not getting in new talent is certainly a contributory factor in things become stale.

Big Sam and Pulis may have both left after not getting what they want, but I would like to see the manager be a bit firmer with the board to get new players in.

Hodgson has been our worst manager in the transfer market since we were promoted. He has not signed a single player that's become a first team regular.

I don't think Roy will kick up a fuss either as he knows if threatens to resign like Pulis or BFS then it's most likely that he'll be shown the door.

If Roy, Pardew, or McCarthy had kicked up a fuss when they had Palace/Newcastle/Ipswich playing well then their future career options would probably look brighter too.


 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Mar 19 7.41pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Disagree, had we kept both I am sure that we wouldn’t be where we are now..... higher. Of course could be wrong but that’s my opinion.

Their previous records suggest we would be no better off in the table and probably skint.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 17 Mar 19 7.57pm

Looking at yesterday's game you have to wonder what was the thinking on the wings with Wilf injured and Sako cup tied ? If we wished to play with 2 wingers then slot AWB on the wing with Ward behind. Stick Bats and Tekkers up front, Kouyate and Luka in midfield. Whilst everybody might poo poo 442 for us at the moment might be a revelation. Overall where our season is heading it looks likely to be disappointing. With 2 dire teams this season and another straight up but with a lot to do, it clearly isn't going to be like that next season with the likes of Leeds, Norwich and Villa coming up. We talk about our counter attacking abilities but when you look at Wolves first season you have to think compared to us in our 6th season we haven't developed very well. Okay it is apples and pears due to finances but they look far more capable in their first PL season than we did, and more worringly us presently. Have to worry about us next season as there doesn't seem to be a lot of improvement in much of our squad, which also looks at the moment very disjointed and consequently unsure of what they are doing. Love to be looking forward but unless we try to move away from our rigidity and/or get some good quality playable talent into the squad think we will be more likely going backwards.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 17 Mar 19 8.14pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

it's all about mindset.

8th is a better reward in terms of prize money.

8th is a better platform to build on in terms of finishing 14th

8th position each year could attract a certain type of player, than say 14th which is almost flirting with relegation.

looking up is far better than treading water.

The mindset at palace should be to get to 40 points at record speed each year, wether it's after 31 games, 30 games, that should always be the goal. It would show progress from escaping the relegation zone, it would also show progress in climbing up the table - but the beauty in that goal is it doesn't purposely state 'we don't want a relegation scrap' or 'we are in a relegation and need to look up' it also doesn't say 'we want a top 8 or 6 finish' it just states we want to do better each season, which is the ultimate goal for any club.

Parish, however doesn't have the funds to sustain the club in the prem - it gets better each year, the prem, stakes are higher each year and the small blinds, big blinds are the base line that parish can't keep up with. Any major investor will want to play the hand they are dealt with, which is probably why the americans want out as parish is holding their chips.... damn poker advert next to me has influenced by metaphors.

8th position would be a good target but not sure how that equates to getting to 40 points quickly as a very good run at the death might lift you there. Personally I'd like us to be dominating more games, consequently making us more consistent and producing a good run in the PL. The number of games which we have been on top and comfortable this season have been very small.

Edited by Booted Eagle (17 Mar 2019 8.15pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

jeeagles Flag 17 Mar 19 8.32pm

Originally posted by Harry Beever


It’s not Roy making the transfers though is it?


No one seems to be sure on this point.

But if I didn't have the support in my job that I required, I'd kick up a fuss until I got it, or leave.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Mar 19 10.26pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Excellent point. Unfortunately there appears to currently be a momentum heading in the wrong direction - losses to Brighton and Watford should be a wake up call.

I don't like to compare to other 'similar' clubs, as circumstance, luck plays into it, but i really feel that out of the brighton's, wolves, watfords, leicester (minus that year) we are trailing.

7 years in the prem and if we get relegated this season, nothing but a huge wage bill to show for it and a massive exodus.

 


This was once a quality forum....

PatrickA Flag London 17 Mar 19 10.39pm

Surely even Roy’s most fervent admirers can’t want another season of home displays like this season?
For people who say he hasn’t had strikers fit both Wickham and Benteke have largely been fit since January and he still hasn’t really used them.
I’m not necessarily advocating him being sacked but I would expect to see an improvement or else he should be under the same pressure as any other manager.

 

Deabo2030 Flag Ipswich. Suffolk 17 Mar 19 10.51pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Surely even Roy’s most fervent admirers can’t want another season of home displays like this season?
For people who say he hasn’t had strikers fit both Wickham and Benteke have largely been fit since January and he still hasn’t really used them.
I’m not necessarily advocating him being sacked but I would expect to see an improvement or else he should be under the same pressure as any other manager.

I agree with PatrickA. Whatever the team selection its not managers fault if they don't play with passion. The FA Cup game was case in point, the players know the importance of the FA Cup, but there was no passion against Watford... Can't keep relying on Zaha..

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Mar 19 11.25pm

Originally posted by Deabo2030

I agree with PatrickA. Whatever the team selection its not managers fault if they don't play with passion. The FA Cup game was case in point, the players know the importance of the FA Cup, but there was no passion against Watford... Can't keep relying on Zaha..

I reckon they train while they are tied together with string.
Its not about passion.
If you know you are driopped for going out of position to try something different , why would you.
Its about morale and atm its on the floor.
Roy chooses favourites who conform in training.
Not necessarily players who can create decent moves together.

 

Page 32 of 65 < 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread