You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 33 of 65 < 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 >
kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 18 Mar 19 12.55pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Hodgson and Trump.....

Not a lot in common there. However yes a 72 year old can have a few years left in a career but it’s not age that is the problem for me it’s that Roy is getting found out by certain teams this season and has no answer.

You don’t lose 3 times to Watford or twice to Brighton through just bad luck. We are player for player easily superior to both of those sides but come away with 5 losses to those outfits this campaign.

For those saying Roy should have gone at the end of last year, they must have missed his words at the last game. Kicking on and not being perennial relegation fodder was the general jist. Quite a speech it was. He was going nowhere at that point.

It seems things have run their course but parish flogs dead horses regularly, and he loves an older manager it seems. The only thing that can retire Hodgson, is Hodgson.

I totally agree with this... I'm the same as you. When I look at the players we have I find it hard to believe we are in a relegation battle.
People on here say Meyer has been a disappointment... It's not that at all... The lad oozes class we can all see it but clearly he's not liked by Roy and he's not allowed to express himself.

Look at Wolves... A quality side but are they better than us player for player??... Not a chance... But they have a quality manager who likes playing quality football and can clearly get the best out of his players.

This is our sixth season in the Prem... We are spending lots of money on transfers and wages yet every season is the same... A relegation battle.
You would like to think we might have at least progressed to a mid table side by now... Ok not exactly thrilling but a hell of alot better than battling relegation every year.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

The Dolphin Flag 18 Mar 19 5.17pm

I can't face another season with Roy in charge.
Lovely man but he has no dynamism and lacks ability to change things when action is needed.
He is getting out thought by other Managers now and there is no sign it will change.
He has had all season to work it out but things are still the same.
It is dull at home and I believe that he should retire.
We will likely lose Wilf, Wan B and Sakho (subject to his injury) in the Summer and you cannot trust him to rebuild the side with those kinds of funds in my opinion.

 

Kant Flag exeter 18 Mar 19 5.30pm

This idea of ‘progression’ in the EPL is a myth.

Sides like ours don’t ‘progress’. They bob about for a few years if they are lucky and then get relegated.

One season’s performance rarely impacts on the following season’s in any material way. Last year Burnley did well; this year they are dire. Watford were tipped for relegation at the start of the season, but now look at them. Next year they will probably struggle, and someone else will enjoy their day in the sun.

A few years ago Swansea, Stoke and West Brom were held out as models of success. Teams who had built, who had ‘progressed’. And now look where they are.

And have a look too at the league table for the first season we were in the PL this time round. Which of those teams have ‘progressed’? We are one of the few who have not been relegated!

Just enjoy the ride for as long as it lasts and don’t worry about ‘progressing ‘. It ain’t gonna happen.

 

est1905 Flag 18 Mar 19 5.34pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Surely even Roy’s most fervent admirers can’t want another season of home displays like this season?
For people who say he hasn’t had strikers fit both Wickham and Benteke have largely been fit since January and he still hasn’t really used them.
I’m not necessarily advocating him being sacked but I would expect to see an improvement or else he should be under the same pressure as any other manager.

I think this is a fair post.

 

est1905 Flag 18 Mar 19 5.39pm

Originally posted by Kant

This idea of ‘progression’ in the EPL is a myth.

Sides like ours don’t ‘progress’. They bob about for a few years if they are lucky and then get relegated.

One season’s performance rarely impacts on the following season’s in any material way. Last year Burnley did well; this year they are dire. Watford were tipped for relegation at the start of the season, but now look at them. Next year they will probably struggle, and someone else will enjoy their day in the sun.

A few years ago Swansea, Stoke and West Brom were held out as models of success. Teams who had built, who had ‘progressed’. And now look where they are.

And have a look too at the league table for the first season we were in the PL this time round. Which of those teams have ‘progressed’? We are one of the few who have not been relegated!

Just enjoy the ride for as long as it lasts and don’t worry about ‘progressing ‘. It ain’t gonna happen.

I tend to agree with this although I will say a spending spree from a manager/coach who really understands what the team needs to move forward is likely to give us two or three seasons up at 12th/11th where the pressure eases a little.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 18 Mar 19 10.13pm

Originally posted by Kant

This idea of ‘progression’ in the EPL is a myth.

Sides like ours don’t ‘progress’. They bob about for a few years if they are lucky and then get relegated.

One season’s performance rarely impacts on the following season’s in any material way. Last year Burnley did well; this year they are dire. Watford were tipped for relegation at the start of the season, but now look at them. Next year they will probably struggle, and someone else will enjoy their day in the sun.

A few years ago Swansea, Stoke and West Brom were held out as models of success. Teams who had built, who had ‘progressed’. And now look where they are.

And have a look too at the league table for the first season we were in the PL this time round. Which of those teams have ‘progressed’? We are one of the few who have not been relegated!

Just enjoy the ride for as long as it lasts and don’t worry about ‘progressing ‘. It ain’t gonna happen.

The voice of reason.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Mar 19 10.37pm

Originally posted by Kant

This idea of ‘progression’ in the EPL is a myth.

Sides like ours don’t ‘progress’. They bob about for a few years if they are lucky and then get relegated.

One season’s performance rarely impacts on the following season’s in any material way. Last year Burnley did well; this year they are dire. Watford were tipped for relegation at the start of the season, but now look at them. Next year they will probably struggle, and someone else will enjoy their day in the sun.

A few years ago Swansea, Stoke and West Brom were held out as models of success. Teams who had built, who had ‘progressed’. And now look where they are.

And have a look too at the league table for the first season we were in the PL this time round. Which of those teams have ‘progressed’? We are one of the few who have not been relegated!

Just enjoy the ride for as long as it lasts and don’t worry about ‘progressing ‘. It ain’t gonna happen.

It is very difficult when you have clubs sitting at the very top licking their lips every time they spy an exceptional talent.

Leicester back up your post.

 

jeeagles Flag 18 Mar 19 10.44pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

The voice of reason.

Fair to say too many people rush to say, we should be at pushing for the "next level" and then things fall apart and clubs get relegated. But we've gone from dead certainty for relegation to expecting to stay up each season. Isn't that progress?

We could list out every season since CPFC2010 took over but that would turn this into a "look how far we've come thread".

For me this has been the most lethargic season since we got promoted. The fight and desire just don't seem to be there even though this is arguably the best squad we've had since the early 90's.

Home games against Wolves, Watford, Cardiff, Newcastle, Brighton, Southampton simply weren't good enough.

They can't all put be put down to just a bad day at the office.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 18 Mar 19 10.47pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

I don't like to compare to other 'similar' clubs, as circumstance, luck plays into it, but i really feel that out of the brighton's, wolves, watfords, leicester (minus that year) we are trailing.

7 years in the prem and if we get relegated this season, nothing but a huge wage bill to show for it and a massive exodus.

Watford's 2nd goal, Pererya about £12 million and Andre Gray around £18.5 million. They have good contacts in Italy and willing to bring in proven PL goalscorers for their bench. Made a healthy profit on Richarlison from Brazil as well. Unfortunately our recent transfer activity isn't great and we are lumbered with the likes of the Tekker's deadweight around our necks. Unless we start to get somebody who can at least pick out a few gems in the transfer market, particularly abroad, then we will struggle around these teams like Watford.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 18 Mar 19 11.03pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Fair to say too many people rush to say, we should be at pushing for the "next level" and then things fall apart and clubs get relegated. But we've gone from dead certainty for relegation to expecting to stay up each season. Isn't that progress?

We could list out every season since CPFC2010 took over but that would turn this into a "look how far we've come thread".

For me this has been the most lethargic season since we got promoted. The fight and desire just don't seem to be there even though this is arguably the best squad we've had since the early 90's.

Home games against Wolves, Watford, Cardiff, Newcastle, Brighton, Southampton simply weren't good enough.

They can't all put be put down to just a bad day at the office.

I agree with a lot of what you say and don’t think everything Roy does is right. As other have alluded to I’d like to see more aggression when the opposition take liberties and perhaps see a bit more use made of Meyer although he’s had plenty of chances.

I really disagree about the strength of the squad, particularly the lack of any quick, skilful ball carriers in midfield and our aerial weakness. That aside,Take Wilf and Sakho from the the team and we’re absolutely knackered.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (18 Mar 2019 11.18pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Mar 19 11.44pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Fair to say too many people rush to say, we should be at pushing for the "next level" and then things fall apart and clubs get relegated. But we've gone from dead certainty for relegation to expecting to stay up each season. Isn't that progress?

We could list out every season since CPFC2010 took over but that would turn this into a "look how far we've come thread".

For me this has been the most lethargic season since we got promoted. The fight and desire just don't seem to be there even though this is arguably the best squad we've had since the early 90's.

Home games against Wolves, Watford, Cardiff, Newcastle, Brighton, Southampton simply weren't good enough.

They can't all put be put down to just a bad day at the office.

Wolves 67% 11 shots 4 on
Watford 55% 15 shots 6 on ... Foster MOTM
Cardiff 62% 31 shots 5 on
Newcastle 62% 16 shots 4 on ... Durravka MOTM
Brighton 63% 15 shots 3 on
Saints 51% 20 shots 6 on ... McCarthy MOTM

Edited by Tickled pink (18 Mar 2019 11.48pm)

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 19 Mar 19 1.18am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Watford's 2nd goal, Pererya about £12 million and Andre Gray around £18.5 million. They have good contacts in Italy and willing to bring in proven PL goalscorers for their bench. Made a healthy profit on Richarlison from Brazil as well. Unfortunately our recent transfer activity isn't great and we are lumbered with the likes of the Tekker's deadweight around our necks. Unless we start to get somebody who can at least pick out a few gems in the transfer market, particularly abroad, then we will struggle around these teams like Watford.

yup, that's why we are trailing behind... the whole set up isn't good enough or as expected for 7 years in prem.

 


This was once a quality forum....

The Dolphin Flag 19 Mar 19 7.38am

The next level is not the be all and end all but I want to enjoy what I watch and I want to see the players enjoy it as much as possible.
I am not enjoying it much right now because we are not close to fulfilling our potential and we are likely to lose our best players in the Summer which will be an important point - how do we spend the cash to progress just a little.
With Roy in charge he is really only a short term placement and if we are building for the future we need the man in charge who might see that through.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Mar 19 8.03am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

The next level is not the be all and end all but I want to enjoy what I watch and I want to see the players enjoy it as much as possible.
I am not enjoying it much right now because we are not close to fulfilling our potential and we are likely to lose our best players in the Summer which will be an important point - how do we spend the cash to progress just a little.
With Roy in charge he is really only a short term placement and if we are building for the future we need the man in charge who might see that through.

The last 2 results have made a mediocre season feel even worse. Personally, I'm looking forward to the end of the season.

Had our away results and performances been at Selhurst then I wonder whether our collective mood would be so downbeat ?

As for losing our best players in the summer, I'm not so sure. It is starting to become a ' now or never ' for Zaha, but unless Spurs come in for him, it's difficult to see where he would go. Wan Bissaka could do with at least another year at Palace in my opinion, but a silly money offer would fund overall squad strengthening.

Which brings us to how that money would be spent. I do question how much influence Hodgson has on that and as you point out, he's only contracted for another year, so short term.

One person that will be having a busy summer is Steve Parish, because I think there are a number of important issues to be resolved.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Mar 19 8.16am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

The next level is not the be all and end all but I want to enjoy what I watch and I want to see the players enjoy it as much as possible.
I am not enjoying it much right now because we are not close to fulfilling our potential and we are likely to lose our best players in the Summer which will be an important point - how do we spend the cash to progress just a little.
With Roy in charge he is really only a short term placement and if we are building for the future we need the man in charge who might see that through.

I for one am expecting, nor calling for us to improve positionally season-on-season - if we did that we would end up as Champions !

I would like to be in the position each season when after 30 games we are reasonably comfortable and not just 5 pts clear of the relegation zone as we are now.

We are however better off than at the same juncture last season, when after 30 games we had just 27 pts and were in 18th place.The season before that we had 31 pts and just 3 clear points clear of the drop-zone so we are better off now then we were then after 30 games.

Progress I suppose but marginally, however a lot of supporters I have talked to are of the opinion that with our squad we should be far better off and this is echoed by those I have spoken to who are not Palace supporters.

Edited by Willo (19 Mar 2019 8.19am)

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 19 Mar 19 8.31am

Wake up call....Meyer no good enough. I look at the impact he has had compared to Jeffrey Schlupp and he just isn’t good enough. That’s despite schlupp being asked to play in 5-6 positions.

Watford have signed 60 odd players from over seas since they got promoted and two of them have been good. Arguably, Foster is equally a good signing. How many youth players have they promoted through their academy.

Every bit of success the club gets, its looked upon like lucky. Roy gave AWB his chance and he has done unbelievable well. SP has signed Zaha long term deal. (Two brilliant players we get to watch every week) We on target for biggest points total in 30 years.

I want to win things aswell, but I don’t think we are a million miles off for doing something special.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Mar 19 8.44am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Wake up call....Meyer no good enough. I look at the impact he has had compared to Jeffrey Schlupp and he just isn’t good enough. That’s despite schlupp being asked to play in 5-6 positions.

Watford have signed 60 odd players from over seas since they got promoted and two of them have been good. Arguably, Foster is equally a good signing. How many youth players have they promoted through their academy.

Every bit of success the club gets, its looked upon like lucky. Roy gave AWB his chance and he has done unbelievable well. SP has signed Zaha long term deal. (Two brilliant players we get to watch every week) We on target for biggest points total in 30 years.

I want to win things aswell, but I don’t think we are a million miles off for doing something special.

By my reckoning 15 players who have made the first team squad this season were signed from overseas clubs.Think there were more last season.

Don't think any of those who have featured this season have come through the academy.I recall seeing youth product Tommie Hoban a few seasons back but he is now on loan at Aberdeen.

Edited by Willo (19 Mar 2019 8.47am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 19 Mar 19 12.38pm

As some of you have said - with our squad we should be doing better than we are.
No centre forward for months has not helped but we did have Benteke for many games and we still couldn't score.
Are Roy's hands tied on that one - probably?
We can all be armchair fans and feel we can see what the Manager can't but pretty much all of us agree that
1. We have no plan B
2. Roy doesn't use his subs wisely
3. We are unable to and have yet to find a way to break down packed defences at home and we should have worked it out by now.
A real shame as many of our players would get in to most Premier League teams and some into all.
Potential is great but it has to be fulfilled - use it or lose it!
On players going in the Summer
- Wilf - he must surely go at the right price - I so hope he doesn't but this season will likely have persuaded him that his future lies elsewhere.
- Wan B - Manchester United need a new right back asap and he would get good money and top football every week sadly!
Sakho - meant to be leaving apparently although his injury may prevent that which would be good news for us.

 

jeeagles Flag 19 Mar 19 5.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

We are however better off than at the same juncture last season, when after 30 games we had just 27 pts and were in 18th place.The season before that we had 31 pts and just 3 clear points clear of the drop-zone so we are better off now then we were then after 30 games.

Edited by Willo (19 Mar 2019 8.19am)

Another fair point, but this time last year we were on the ascendancy and showing a fighting spirit with every game.

This season the opposite is true.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Mar 19 5.35pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Another fair point, but this time last year we were on the ascendancy and showing a fighting spirit with every game.

This season the opposite is true.

Last season at this stage (30 games) we had only won 2 of our previous PL 10 games.
At the present time we have won 4 of our previous 10 PL games.


 

Page 33 of 65 < 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread