You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 34 of 71 < 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 >
bicycle repair man 09 Nov 18 11.13am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

Really ? how so ?

From where I'm sat (not in Block E) you have not come up with one single solitary factually based reason why the singing section should not go ahead. Not on safety, not on law, not even any valid reason as to why people should feel so indignant about moving, other than they have (will have) thier noses put out of joint because they have been asked to move for the benefit of the clubs atmosphere.

But then I'm sure people like you would forgo the clubs famous atmosphere coming back, just to satisfy there own petty self indulgent interests.

I bet you burst little kids footballs when they land on your rhododendrons.

Now I would suggest in the interest of the thread that you either debate properly and come up with a hitherto unmentioned pearl of wisdom in favour of cancelling the singing section, or just get used used to the idea that it will happen and some people will have to be relocated.

Why it's such a big deal I don't know. Just as an aside there is more pages on this "issue" than there is on a much more serious issue of Grooming Gangs, which speaks absolute volumes to me, in that this is a very "self interest at heart" thread, and not necessarily what is best for the club, which surely should be paramount ?

I await with bated breath your pearls of wisdom that will show how I have lost the argument, or alternatively (and more likely) await for you to show that you are the grumpy old git I believe you to be, whose moral outrage is based purely from a self interested view point rather than what would be best for the club.


I have put forward valid arguments, (which are deliberately ignored), in support of those Palace supporters who are being forced to to move,to accommodate a set of fans who had perfectly good seats but voluntarily gave them up,and it is simply not fair.
I have no objection to a "singing section",but these things evovle naturally, manufacturing such an area is wrong,the HF decided to sit in block B in the first place.I bet if the away fans area was put back towards the Holmesdale end the HF would then want move back again.
To be honest I couldn't care less about the HF,or whether they reform or not,but they shouldn't be regarded as superior to other Palace fans,and shouldn't expect,or be given special treatment.
Finally all the childish references about bursting kids balloons,and calling people grumpy old gits,is just pathetic.
And what the heck have discussions about grooming gangs go to do with a debate on a football website.
PS neither do I sit in block E.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 09 Nov 18 11.13am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You really do sound like a stuck record, or one of those sound bites from Points of view " Mr Repair man morally outraged with nothing better to do than read the Mail from London says......... (insert above)

Your (potentially) being asked to move seats at a football match, where you spend a couple of hours every other week (on average) to watch Palace. No one is asking you to sell a kidney and give your offspring to a Romanian human trafficking gang.

I think a sense of perspective is required here people as from some of the comments it would appear it has been lost.

The singing section was always the Arthur years ago, then the Holmesdale got developed, and the singing section became the lower Holmesdale, I don't recall all this sissiness back then. You'll end up having to move seats big deal get over it.

There probably was 'sissiness' - if that's what you want to call it - but what there wasn't were social media sites that allowed those unfairly treated to vent their disgust/raise awareness of their plight.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

est1905 Flag 09 Nov 18 5.57pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

This type of ludicrous comment is exactly why you are not worth debating with.

You are Victor Meldrew, I claim my prize.

Whats wrong with his comment? None of what he says is untrue so whats your point?

 

est1905 Flag 09 Nov 18 5.59pm

Originally posted by A89M

And to add to this, a quote from RLC about our atmosphere.

Speaking to &#8203;Football.London about the affection shown to him, Loftus-Cheek said: "It was a really good reception from the Palace fans and when I was there, it was great.

"The fans were great and it is one of the best atmospheres I have played in front of, so to hear them sing my name was a warming feeling."

Meaning they likely do prefer to play in front of singing fans, rather than quiet.

Oh so it was only the HF singing RLC name. Right, I got it now.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 09 Nov 18 6.53pm

Originally posted by est1905

Oh so it was only the HF singing RLC name. Right, I got it now.

That’s not what he’s said. You’re attempting to twist it to suit your view. He didn’t mention the HF.

He has said that RLC’s comments suggest that players like to play in stadiums with atmospheres. The point being that the SP atmosphere has suffered since the HF have gone.

 

ballboy1975 Flag 09 Nov 18 8.50pm

Right , i get it now, its the fault of the e400 the atmosphere is not good, Not the hf
Iam losing the seat i have had for 20 plus years, is all my fault , just because i dont choose to jump up and down and bang my drum,

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 09 Nov 18 8.52pm

Originally posted by ballboy1975

Right , i get it now, its the fault of the e400 the atmosphere is not good, Not the hf
Iam losing the seat i have had for 20 plus years, is all my fault , just because i dont choose to jump up and down and bang my drum,

Where did anyone say it’s your fault or the fault of those in block E?

 

Glazed Over Flag Sevenoaks 10 Nov 18 6.41am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2
But then I'm sure people like you would forgo the clubs famous atmosphere coming back, just to satisfy there own petty self indulgent interests.

Just to confirm, there's only one group of people who have got rid of "the clubs famous atmosphere".

Nobody seems to be able to clarify why the HF have to move from Block B.

Signing section - tick
Improves atmosphere - tick
Gets good TV coverage - tick
Mentioned regularly by commentators - tick
Existing ST holders sit in this area - tick
Don't have to move long term ST holders from the seats they've had for years to various other parts of the ground, where there is no guarantee the can sit next to family or friends - tick

Why not just reserve 400 seats in Block B for HF?

Cant wait for these HF to get 'removed' from Block E in a few years time when they're too old or too pissed off with the Club to continue singing in this section.

"Sorry son, but you're not loud enough - off to the Sainsburys end for you".

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Nov 18 7.12am

Originally posted by Glazed Over

Just to confirm, there's only one group of people who have got rid of "the clubs famous atmosphere".

Nobody seems to be able to clarify why the HF have to move from Block B.

Signing section - tick
Improves atmosphere - tick
Gets good TV coverage - tick
Mentioned regularly by commentators - tick
Existing ST holders sit in this area - tick
Don't have to move long term ST holders from the seats they've had for years to various other parts of the ground, where there is no guarantee the can sit next to family or friends - tick

Why not just reserve 400 seats in Block B for HF?

Cant wait for these HF to get 'removed' from Block E in a few years time when they're too old or too pissed off with the Club to continue singing in this section.

"Sorry son, but you're not loud enough - off to the Sainsburys end for you".

Top post! What gives them the right to "sing" in their own designated "singing section"? Anyone can sing at any given time, in any part of the ground. What a farce, you couldn't make it up.
Parish, hang your head in shame.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Nov 2018 7.13am)

 

bicycle repair man 10 Nov 18 8.24am

Originally posted by Glazed Over

Just to confirm, there's only one group of people who have got rid of "the clubs famous atmosphere".

Nobody seems to be able to clarify why the HF have to move from Block B.

Signing section - tick
Improves atmosphere - tick
Gets good TV coverage - tick
Mentioned regularly by commentators - tick
Existing ST holders sit in this area - tick
Don't have to move long term ST holders from the seats they've had for years to various other parts of the ground, where there is no guarantee the can sit next to family or friends - tick

Why not just reserve 400 seats in Block B for HF?

Cant wait for these HF to get 'removed' from Block E in a few years time when they're too old or too pissed off with the Club to continue singing in this section.

"Sorry son, but you're not loud enough - off to the Sainsburys end for you".


This is a great post,which would be hard to argue against.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Nov 18 9.00am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

This is a great post,which would be hard to argue against.

I'm sure that someone will

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Nov 18 9.07am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Top post! What gives them the right to "sing" in their own designated "singing section"? Anyone can sing at any given time, in any part of the ground. What a farce, you couldn't make it up.
Parish, hang your head in shame.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Nov 2018 7.13am)

It has been branded the 'Singing section' when we are all aware this is a euphemism for 'HF section'.In the final analysis the HF have protested by their actions in not continuing their support from Block B and have got what they want.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 10 Nov 18 9.13am

Originally posted by Willo

It has been branded the 'Singing section' when we are all aware this is a euphemism for 'HF section'.In the final analysis the HF have protested by their actions in not continuing their support from Block B and have got what they want.

And, having done so, the next important question is what will they want next?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 18 9.43am

Originally posted by Willo

It has been branded the 'Singing section' when we are all aware this is a euphemism for 'HF section'.In the final analysis the HF have protested by their actions in not continuing their support from Block B and have got what they want.

The whole tier should be reset. I think this is going to be farcical for at least one season, probably quite a few more. Parish doesn’t want to upset any more people himself now, so is limiting it to 400, and in time there’ll be seat swaps so fans in B or C who want to sing can swap with fans who don’t want to sing in F or D. But I don’t think the sight lines are going to be affected by a back half of E standing as people think. It may only be a square patch by the corner flag and penalty box that’s obscured.

I don’t think you can say the HF have got what they want. I think the club don’t want to take on too much or upset any more than a minimum, however, more probably won’t be happy with how it turns out, with 400 singers surrounded by quiet sitters and standers with the other singers over at the corner flag blocks of B and A.

Having 250 added to the HF regulars I’m not happy with, but I suspect if you’re in B block or they recognise you from away games you’d get in the 400 if you asked. I don’t buy that 250 mates suddenly want to buy a ST because they’ve moved to the centre. Some might and gradually add to the numbers but not instantly.

 


COYP

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 9.55am

It's crazy because at one stage so many people seemed bbehind it because they wanted the HF back instantly, but now everyone's finally realised they are gone fill next year everyone seems against the plan. I think we can all understand it's not fair on those in block E, but if the club want a singing section then can't we just accept it now.

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 9.57am

And additionally the atmosphere is our 12th man imo, whilst we've had a poor home record since we've been up, we haven't won a single game at home yet this season!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Nov 18 10.06am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The whole tier should be reset. I think this is going to be farcical for at least one season, probably quite a few more. Parish doesn’t want to upset any more people himself now, so is limiting it to 400, and in time there’ll be seat swaps so fans in B or C who want to sing can swap with fans who don’t want to sing in F or D. But I don’t think the sight lines are going to be affected by a back half of E standing as people think. It may only be a square patch by the corner flag and penalty box that’s obscured.

I don’t think you can say the HF have got what they want. I think the club don’t want to take on too much or upset any more than a minimum, however, more probably won’t be happy with how it turns out, with 400 singers surrounded by quiet sitters and standers with the other singers over at the corner flag blocks of B and A.

Having 250 added to the HF regulars I’m not happy with, but I suspect if you’re in B block or they recognise you from away games you’d get in the 400 if you asked. I don’t buy that 250 mates suddenly want to buy a ST because they’ve moved to the centre. Some might and gradually add to the numbers but not instantly.

My comment was made on the basis that the HF wanted to move to Block B and their wishes have been granted.

This whole 'Singing section' has been created with the acceptance that they will all stand persistently and that the club will simply not enforce the ground regulations.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 18 10.13am

Originally posted by tinribzzz

It's crazy because at one stage so many people seemed bbehind it because they wanted the HF back instantly, but now everyone's finally realised they are gone fill next year everyone seems against the plan. I think we can all understand it's not fair on those in block E, but if the club want a singing section then can't we just accept it now.

Have you asked the 17,000 approx season ticket holders?

‘Everyone’ is not against it.

 


COYP

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 10.29am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Have you asked the 17,000 approx season ticket holders?

‘Everyone’ is not against it.

Perhaps I am basing my findings on the general consensus of the Holmesdale.net and BBS. But even on here before there was backing for the HF but as soon as people realised that they weren't coming back this season it appears most people think "f**k them".

I for one am for the singing section or "HF Section". You've only got to look at the wonderful displays and tributes they've organised over the years to see they are something great for the premier league.

I'm sure the players are grateful for all of the fans that turn up every week but historically they've always ran to that corner when scoring and furthermore there has been occasions over the years when players have actually gone to the HF specific pubs.

Thoughts go out to those in Block E that are being inconvenienced by this, and I will use the word inconvenience because really that's all it is.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Nov 18 10.42am

Originally posted by tinribzzz

Perhaps I am basing my findings on the general consensus of the Holmesdale.net and BBS. But even on here before there was backing for the HF but as soon as people realised that they weren't coming back this season it appears most people think "f**k them".

I for one am for the singing section or "HF Section". You've only got to look at the wonderful displays and tributes they've organised over the years to see they are something great for the premier league.

I'm sure the players are grateful for all of the fans that turn up every week but historically they've always ran to that corner when scoring and furthermore there has been occasions over the years when players have actually gone to the HF specific pubs.

Thoughts go out to those in Block E that are being inconvenienced by this, and I will use the word inconvenience because really that's all it is.

Try telling that to the loyal season-ticket holders who have occupied their seats for many,many years and are now being re-located to accommodate what they probably view as an HF who threw a strop, decided not to continue their support as a group in order to force the hand of the club.

Had the club decided to introduce a 'Singing section' in Block B without any pressure from the HF who were content to continue their support from Block B and as such continued to do so this season, I suspect there wouldn't be the same ill-feeling amongst those affected and those not affected but who empathize with those who are.

 

Page 34 of 71 < 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic