This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It was a cop out to avoid the SC having to rule on whether Trump is an insurrectionist and thereby expose them to the accusation of becoming involved in politics. The liberal Justices are so furious that there is a serious risk of the Court splitting, primarily because the decision says that such things can only be determined at Federal level and not by individual States. This to them, and to me, goes against the whole underlying principle of their system. It must surely be for the individual States to decide who can be a candidate for President in their State and not to have that imposed on them. And you get that from a unanimous decision? The SC has always been involved in politics or did the 1960's bypass you. The founding fathers created a national election system you must be one of the few people who think that a state can decide the outcome, the SC quite rightly said this should be decided at a national level. Oh and they didn't rule on whether Trump was an insurrectionist or not. Defining what constitutes insurrection is one for the lawyers and courts no doubt at some point that will end up at the SC for them to decide. Edited by Badger11 (07 Mar 2024 8.22am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Civil War would still likely happen. Americans have the right to take up arms to overthrow what they see as a government against its people. You deny people the right to vote for a certain candidate and there’s the excuse… A poll in the last few days says a lot of Americans want succession. Not a majority by any means and not for the same reasons. Democrats want to get away from Republican values and vice versa. The point being there are a lot of unhappy people at the moment and the old days of compromise are long gone. If the current lot of clots continue their lack of tolerance for the other side it is only going to get worse, responsible politicians need to step up.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
And you get that from a unanimous decision? The SC has always been involved in politics or did the 1960's bypass you. The founding fathers created a national election system you must be one of the few people who think that a state can decide the outcome, the SC quite rightly said this should be decided at a national level. Oh and they didn't rule on whether Trump was an insurrectionist or not. Defining what constitutes insurrection is one for the lawyers and courts no doubt at some point that will end up at the SC for them to decide. Edited by Badger11 (07 Mar 2024 8.22am) If my understanding is correct only one Justice wrote the opinion and the others did not enter their own on the basis that there was unanimity on the principle that they cannot involve themselves in politics. That’s for Congress. The Liberal Justices were though outraged at the opinion extending to say that States cannot ban Presidential candidates themselves and that this can only be done at a Federal level. This flies in the face of the whole basis of the way the USA functions. The founding fathers did not create a system in which the overall votes at a national level determine who wins. The system determines who each state wants to win. It must surely therefore be for each State to decide who they will put forward to their electorate.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
A poll in the last few days says a lot of Americans want succession. Not a majority by any means and not for the same reasons. Democrats want to get away from Republican values and vice versa. The point being there are a lot of unhappy people at the moment and the old days of compromise are long gone. If the current lot of clots continue their lack of tolerance for the other side it is only going to get worse, responsible politicians need to step up. I see no lack of tolerance by Democrats for “the other side”! Quite the reverse actually. They put up with a lot. What I see is the law gradually working its way through due process to deal with an ex President who thinks he is above the law and is trying to circumvent the law. I see some democratically elected politicians and officials doing their best to make sure those efforts don’t succeed whilst others try to make sure they do. One side is right. The other is wrong. I know right from wrong and therefore what side I am on.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That though is how they do things. You can argue that the electoral college is a crazy system and I would agree. I think all the votes for the President should be counted nationally and not State by State, but they don’t. Each State decides who they support and if they do then they ought also to decide who they permit to stand. The Founding Fathers were trying to design a democratic process to elect a national leader at a time when most countries were ruled by kings or dictators. They did not anticipate political parties becoming the norm otherwise they might not have gone for an electoral college. The big problem they had was how does the voter know who to pick. No TV or modern media the news would take weeks or months to travel across country and no local party office to spread the good word about the candidate. The Electoral College is just a proxy vote. So hick farmer votes for a local prominent person someone they trust and who is knowledgeable has traveled and may even know the candidate. That person then votes for the candidate. By the way a member of the Electoral College can vote for who they like. So say Biden wins a state with 10 Electoral Votes it is possible that one or more of those could pick Trump. There would be legal challenges but it is not a legal slam dunk that just because Biden won that state all the votes are his. As you say with political parties and mass media this system is no linger fit for purpose and should just be a national election directly voting for the candidate.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The Founding Fathers were trying to design a democratic process to elect a national leader at a time when most countries were ruled by kings or dictators. They did not anticipate political parties becoming the norm otherwise they might not have gone for an electoral college. The big problem they had was how does the voter know who to pick. No TV or modern media the news would take weeks or months to travel across country and no local party office to spread the good word about the candidate. The Electoral College is just a proxy vote. So hick farmer votes for a local prominent person someone they trust and who is knowledgeable has traveled and may even know the candidate. That person then votes for the candidate. By the way a member of the Electoral College can vote for who they like. So say Biden wins a state with 10 Electoral Votes it is possible that one or more of those could pick Trump. There would be legal challenges but it is not a legal slam dunk that just because Biden won that state all the votes are his. As you say with political parties and mass media this system is no linger fit for purpose and should just be a national election directly voting for the candidate.
At least we agree it needs to change. Until it does the States themselves must be the arbiters of who can be a candidate.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I see no lack of tolerance by Democrats for “the other side”! Quite the reverse actually. They put up with a lot. What I see is the law gradually working its way through due process to deal with an ex President who thinks he is above the law and is trying to circumvent the law. I see some democratically elected politicians and officials doing their best to make sure those efforts don’t succeed whilst others try to make sure they do. One side is right. The other is wrong. I know right from wrong and therefore what side I am on. California is a Blue state and about 30% of it's voters would like to secede so they can continue their happy clappy politics. Texas is a red state and would like to secede to stem immigration . Abortion is just one topic that deeply divides the US, both sides are unhappy with the current position so a minority feel that their side would be better off seceding.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
At least we agree it needs to change. Until it does the States themselves must be the arbiters of who can be a candidate. Not according to the Supreme Court. Still you have a track record of claiming to be in the right when the courts say otherwise.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
California is a Blue state and about 30% of it's voters would like to secede so they can continue their happy clappy politics. Texas is a red state and would like to secede to stem immigration . Abortion is just one topic that deeply divides the US, both sides are unhappy with the current position so a minority feel that their side would be better off seceding. As each State already has very significant power over local matters and how to manage national ones would be near to impossible I cannot see it happening.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As each State already has very significant power over local matters and how to manage national ones would be near to impossible I cannot see it happening. The one good thing about the EU was that when they created it they did have a mechanism for a country to leave. The US does not and forced people at the point of a gun to stay. Imagine sending troops into Scotland after they voted for independence and the rest of the UK said no way. Unfortunately the only option left is civil war. It is not likely at the moment but if this divisive politics continue the number of Americans wanting out for entirely different reasons will grow.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The Founding Fathers were trying to design a democratic process to elect a national leader at a time when most countries were ruled by kings or dictators. They did not anticipate political parties becoming the norm otherwise they might not have gone for an electoral college. The big problem they had was how does the voter know who to pick. No TV or modern media the news would take weeks or months to travel across country and no local party office to spread the good word about the candidate. The Electoral College is just a proxy vote. So hick farmer votes for a local prominent person someone they trust and who is knowledgeable has traveled and may even know the candidate. That person then votes for the candidate. By the way a member of the Electoral College can vote for who they like. So say Biden wins a state with 10 Electoral Votes it is possible that one or more of those could pick Trump. There would be legal challenges but it is not a legal slam dunk that just because Biden won that state all the votes are his. As you say with political parties and mass media this system is no linger fit for purpose and should just be a national election directly voting for the candidate.
I'm not very knowledgeable about America's founding fathers but one thing does come quite clear regarding their attitudes and that is that overly powerful government is bad...indeed the second amendment is mostly about that.....this contingency was reflected in their experience with kings and they didn't want a repeat. I doubt they would be happy with how things are progressing. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Mar 2024 9.40am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The one good thing about the EU was that when they created it they did have a mechanism for a country to leave. The US does not and forced people at the point of a gun to stay. Imagine sending troops into Scotland after they voted for independence and the rest of the UK said no way. Unfortunately the only option left is civil war. It is not likely at the moment but if this divisive politics continue the number of Americans wanting out for entirely different reasons will grow. Depressing as it is, long term I can only see civil war emerging from the current situation; hopefully a war of words rather than a repeat of the nineteenth century debacle.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I see no lack of tolerance by Democrats for “the other side”! Quite the reverse actually. They put up with a lot. What I see is the law gradually working its way through due process to deal with an ex President who thinks he is above the law and is trying to circumvent the law. I see some democratically elected politicians and officials doing their best to make sure those efforts don’t succeed whilst others try to make sure they do. One side is right. The other is wrong. I know right from wrong and therefore what side I am on. I know I generally agree your posts - or at least the angle they come from - but I am disagreeing with you twice in as many days. I think this statement about the law is the image the Democrats are desperate to foster, but the US public are not buying it, save those where the door to push is already open. If he committed tax fraud in his business dealings and they can prove it to the criminal standard, then throw the book. However, the Stormy Daniels thing would not have seen the light of day but for the identity of the Defendant (the Democrat prosecutor has all but admitted it is politically motivated). And as for the recent farce of seeking to stop him stand, that was a foolhardy, self-defeating tactic that indicates a great deal of naiveté at the DNC.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The Founding Fathers were trying to design a democratic process to elect a national leader at a time when most countries were ruled by kings or dictators. They did not anticipate political parties becoming the norm otherwise they might not have gone for an electoral college. The big problem they had was how does the voter know who to pick. No TV or modern media the news would take weeks or months to travel across country and no local party office to spread the good word about the candidate. The Electoral College is just a proxy vote. So hick farmer votes for a local prominent person someone they trust and who is knowledgeable has traveled and may even know the candidate. That person then votes for the candidate. By the way a member of the Electoral College can vote for who they like. So say Biden wins a state with 10 Electoral Votes it is possible that one or more of those could pick Trump. There would be legal challenges but it is not a legal slam dunk that just because Biden won that state all the votes are his. As you say with political parties and mass media this system is no linger fit for purpose and should just be a national election directly voting for the candidate.
The founding fathers asked George Washington to be King at one point Surely no one can consider Biden to be capable of a second term
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Trumps is going to win and will be back as POTUS. He has absolutely huge support and the more they try and suppress him and with each additional charge or indictment, his support grows further. Coupled with the fact that Biden isn’t even fit for office NOW, never mind well enough to run for another term. The Democrats had their chance for Biden to step down with grace, but they are now far too late. I wonder if they genuinely believed the legal actions would break Trump so no need to change. After all, the US public - especially the law and order loving Republicans who support him - would never vote for a convicted/charged criminal/fraud. Would they? If so, a colossal blunder for the incumbent party.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Depressing as it is, long term I can only see civil war emerging from the current situation; hopefully a war of words rather than a repeat of the nineteenth century debacle. This time however it is not just one side wanting to split from the other. It seems that some Democrats are just as unhappy as some republicans and believe their state or group of states would be better off alone. So I can see a situation where Texas which briefly was an independent country tries to pull away which in turn provokes blue states to also demand the same. The run up to the civil war was about 40 years of congress and the President trying to stick their finger in the dyke, everyone could see it coming.
Edited by Badger11 (07 Mar 2024 5.13pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Not according to the Supreme Court. Still you have a track record of claiming to be in the right when the courts say otherwise.
I was involved in an incident for which facts exist. Only 2 people know those facts, one being me. The Judge didn’t know any more than you do, or any other poster does. The Court didn’t say I was wrong. It allowed the claimant the benefit of the doubt. I though know they were lying and committing insurance fraud. You can choose to disbelieve me if that makes you feel better but it doesn’t change the facts that I know and neither the Court nor you does.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
The Democrats had their chance for Biden to step down with grace, but they are now far too late. I wonder if they genuinely believed the legal actions would break Trump so no need to change. After all, the US public - especially the law and order loving Republicans who support him - would never vote for a convicted/charged criminal/fraud. Would they? If so, a colossal blunder for the incumbent party. I don’t think they are too late at all. I think it will all be revealed at the Convention.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.