You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another black man shot by police in USA


Page 35 of 36 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 >
Kermit8 Flag Hevon 12 Dec 17 8.54pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Not everything I say is right, but I do my research.

Calling out Ray on his bullshine takes my mind off Palace.


I just wonder why you are always so down on black people? I respect you have way more environmental experience but still. That's why I posted about the child genius kids way back who had black parentage. Just to stop all the negativity.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


7mins Flag In the bush 12 Dec 17 9.06pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

I just wonder why you are always so down on black people? I respect you have way more environmental experience but still. That's why I posted about the child genius kids way back who had black parentage. Just to stop all the negativity.

I’m a champion for black people... my views are from frustration. I feel black people massively underachieve. I feel my views are consistent. This discussion started about a white man being shot... my views are similar to when young black males get shot.

Being mixed race gives me a foot in both camps.

If we were discussing diet... I’d say black people eat far better. If we were discussing health... I’d say black people take care of their health better, if we were discussing care for the elderly... I’d say black people care for their elders better. If we’re talking education, I’d say whites take it more seriously. If we’re discussing crime, I’d say black people get involved in more crime. I can pretend I don’t see these things... but I believe the most bitter truth (as I see it) is better than the sweetest lie.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 12 Dec 17 9.15pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I’m a champion for black people... my views are from frustration. I feel black people massively underachieve. I feel my views are consistent. This discussion started about a white man being shot... my views are similar to when young black males get shot.

Being mixed race gives me a foot in both camps.

If we were discussing diet... I’d say black people eat far better. If we were discussing health... I’d say black people take care of their health better, if we were discussing care for the elderly... I’d say black people care for their elders better. If we’re talking education, I’d say whites take it more seriously. If we’re discussing crime, I’d say black people get involved in more crime. I can pretend I don’t see these things... but I believe the most bitter truth (as I see it) is better than the sweetest lie.

Fair enough. Think i will just stick to my treat each individual as you find philosophy rather than judge by race or religion.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


7mins Flag In the bush 12 Dec 17 9.23pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Fair enough. Think i will just stick to my treat each individual as you find philosophy rather than judge by race or religion.

That’s a great philosophy. One I try to adhere to... but experiences in my family (that I’ve posted on here) and living in Hackney for a while, told me I need to be more proactive... I live in East Sussex now, I tried mentoring... but no call for it down here.

 

wordup Flag 12 Dec 17 10.10pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I’m a champion for black people... my views are from frustration. I feel black people massively underachieve. I feel my views are consistent. This discussion started about a white man being shot... my views are similar to when young black males get shot.

Being mixed race gives me a foot in both camps.

If we were discussing diet... I’d say black people eat far better. If we were discussing health... I’d say black people take care of their health better, if we were discussing care for the elderly... I’d say black people care for their elders better. If we’re talking education, I’d say whites take it more seriously. If we’re discussing crime, I’d say black people get involved in more crime. I can pretend I don’t see these things... but I believe the most bitter truth (as I see it) is better than the sweetest lie.

We're all a victim of our circumstances in a way. We all have our issues and clearly you're sick to death of BLM vs the police because it's overly simplified and in fact I agree that the police don't 'have it in for black people'. However, you appear to have lurched to the opposite extreme of a 'defend police at all costs' attitude, since we often unfortunately become a shadow or mirror image of the injustice or problem we highlight. It might be better to see that there is indeed a pretty serious issue with policing in the US, but it is both blacks and whites that suffer because of it.

Your take on the example that clearly shows a sadistic, gun happy cop waiting for an opportunity to unload his gun into a crying man begging for his life.. and indeed that is what he did.. is a bit sad really. The language he uses isn't something that a professional worrying that he might be shot uses. It's the language and behaviour of someone who knows that they are wearing a 'get out of jail free' card.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 12 Dec 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by wordup

We're all a victim of our circumstances in a way. We all have our issues and clearly you're sick to death of BLM vs the police because it's overly simplified and in fact I agree that the police don't 'have it in for black people'. However, you appear to have lurched to the opposite extreme of a 'defend police at all costs' attitude, since we often unfortunately become a shadow or mirror image of the injustice or problem we highlight. It might be better to see that there is indeed a pretty serious issue with policing in the US, but it is both blacks and whites that suffer because of it.

Your take on the example that clearly shows a sadistic, gun happy cop waiting for an opportunity to unload his gun into a crying man begging for his life.. and indeed that is what he did.. is a bit sad really. The language he uses isn't something that a professional worrying that he might be shot uses. It's the language and behaviour of someone who knows that they are wearing a 'get out of jail free' card.

I haven't defended the cop...I've been critical of trial by media, and have stuck to the facts... I don't know what info the cop was given, I don't know what training and instructions the cop has been given. So it's impossible for me to make a judgement on a 5 min youtube clip. I disputed the use of the word "murder" and used BLM as a example of what can happen when people make s*** up (Murder is premeditated)

It seems my refusal to blame the cop due to lack of available information, makes people think I believe he is not guilty.

What I do know... is he gave clear instructions not to move his hands... he told him he would be shot if he did. The poor kid moved his hand towards his waistband, the cop shot him.

Is that how he was trained?
Did he give enough warning?
What info was he given before arriving?

It seems social media makes some people qualified to make judgements without further information.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Dec 17 1.07pm

Ray in Houston and 7 Mins - Time out please before I end up having to card you.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Dec 17 1.20pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I haven't defended the cop...I've been critical of trial by media, and have stuck to the facts... I don't know what info the cop was given, I don't know what training and instructions the cop has been given. So it's impossible for me to make a judgement on a 5 min youtube clip. I disputed the use of the word "murder" and used BLM as a example of what can happen when people make s*** up (Murder is premeditated)

It seems my refusal to blame the cop due to lack of available information, makes people think I believe he is not guilty.

What I do know... is he gave clear instructions not to move his hands... he told him he would be shot if he did. The poor kid moved his hand towards his waistband, the cop shot him.

Is that how he was trained?
Did he give enough warning?
What info was he given before arriving?

It seems social media makes some people qualified to make judgements without further information.

It doesn't require pre-meditation, it requires deliberate action and 'malicious intent' - although in the US you have degrees of murder (1st Degree, 2nd Degree and 3rd degree - a form of manslaughter - which are slightly different).

Whether the cop actually murdered the guy, is difficult questions from an objective point of view. At what point is it acceptable to shoot someone for moving their hands? You can't really just take that action out of the context of both sides actions - Was it even reasonable the degree of aggression and threat being presented by the officer prior to that.

Sure they were responding to a call about a rifle. But at no point is the officer even asking the guy if he has a gun, or is armed or trying to engage in a reasonable dialogue with the 'suspect' to control the situation.

I'd say that the only person who is innocent in this is the guy who was shot - Watch the video, and he has done nothing but try to comply and follow instructions - There is no feasible reason for the cop to consider him an immanent threat. Even when he moves his hands towards his waistband, its pretty clear he's not going for a gun (and if you've got an assault rifle pointed at a guy, even if they try to whip out a pistol, you're still going to be able to put them down, before its cleared their trousers).

The cop failed to control the situation, and ironically, a cop who cannot do that is going to put himself and others in harms way.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

npn Flag Crowborough 13 Dec 17 1.45pm

The kid clearly reaches behind him despite being explicitly told if he does so, he will be shot, however, in my opinion, that's no excuse to actually shoot him as he appears to be no threat. My biggest worry in the footage is just how confusing the instructions seemed to be: "cross your legs, now crawl towards me, DON'T UNCROSS YOUR LEGS". Surely once the man is prone, arms and legs stretched out, it would be safe to approach under cover? It's getting him down and then asking him to move which seems to cause the issue (in a man obviously terrified).

I'd like to know what they are trained to say and do and if there's a reason for it

 

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Dec 17 2.58pm

Originally posted by npn

The kid clearly reaches behind him despite being explicitly told if he does so, he will be shot, however, in my opinion, that's no excuse to actually shoot him as he appears to be no threat. My biggest worry in the footage is just how confusing the instructions seemed to be: "cross your legs, now crawl towards me, DON'T UNCROSS YOUR LEGS". Surely once the man is prone, arms and legs stretched out, it would be safe to approach under cover? It's getting him down and then asking him to move which seems to cause the issue (in a man obviously terrified).

I'd like to know what they are trained to say and do and if there's a reason for it

This is key, we need to know if the officer followed protocol.

Screaming “murderer” after watching a 5min video clip is utterly stupid.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 13 Dec 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It doesn't require pre-meditation, it requires deliberate action and 'malicious intent' - although in the US you have degrees of murder (1st Degree, 2nd Degree and 3rd degree - a form of manslaughter - which are slightly different).

Whether the cop actually murdered the guy, is difficult questions from an objective point of view. At what point is it acceptable to shoot someone for moving their hands? You can't really just take that action out of the context of both sides actions - Was it even reasonable the degree of aggression and threat being presented by the officer prior to that.

Sure they were responding to a call about a rifle. But at no point is the officer even asking the guy if he has a gun, or is armed or trying to engage in a reasonable dialogue with the 'suspect' to control the situation.

I'd say that the only person who is innocent in this is the guy who was shot - Watch the video, and he has done nothing but try to comply and follow instructions - There is no feasible reason for the cop to consider him an immanent threat. Even when he moves his hands towards his waistband, its pretty clear he's not going for a gun (and if you've got an assault rifle pointed at a guy, even if they try to whip out a pistol, you're still going to be able to put them down, before its cleared their trousers).

The cop failed to control the situation, and ironically, a cop who cannot do that is going to put himself and others in harms way.

At very best, this incident could be Voluntary Man slaughter

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Dec 17 3.34pm

Originally posted by 7mins

At very best, this incident could be Voluntary Man slaughter

Objectively, I think your probably right, although dependent on the case that can be made in terms of prosecution, it could be second degree murder (if they could show that there was a malicious intent, or that the individual had orchestrated a situation in which he could shoot the suspect).

That said, including evidence like the engraving on his gun, or documented police procedure for the situation could also swing it towards 2nd degree Murder (for example, if the actions of the police officer were completely contrary to procedure - then the case for constructing an excuse to shoot someone makes it malicious intent, and 2nd degree murder - possibly 1st degree - but that would require exceptional proof).

Problem is, again, that the police is 'marking its own homework' and the legal system is protecting that. The question really should be about what procedure and training is, and whether the police officer's actions were reasonable and proportional to the situation.

We often criticise the IPCC in the UK, but in the US it seems that the role of oversight is to protect the police department from blame and where ever possible protect the police officers from accountability.

No way this guy should have been an police officer, armed with an assault rifle.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 15 Dec 17 4.54pm

In the Netherlands the police have managed to shoot a, non-compliant, knife wielding, person 3 times at Schiphol airport and he's still alive.

[Link]

 


Optimistic as ever

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 17 11.25am


Yesterday, we had our usual family gathering.... We exchange presents. A family member who lives near Horsham (I've mentioned on here that his mum moved him outta London due to him getting in trouble) got pulled over by police for having no tax and insurance, he also got done for being under the influence of drugs or in possession...i'm not sure as he stormed out the room halfway through our discussion. Straight forward right? Can't complain,.. You broke the law....take the punishment?
Noooooooo, this copper pulled him over because he was black. I explained that cop cars have number plate recognition, and that's what tell the coppers to pull cars, (he also got done for driving off from a petrol station without paying in May). He then said... I bet they don't pull white drivers over... I asked for evidence of this, as I've known white drivers to get pulled for not having MOT. He then mentions something about the copper finding weed.... His mum then says.... Maybe police shouldn't pull black drivers over for minor (?) issues, she then defended her son, by saying the drug charge should be dropped, because drugs are rife... Its unfair to single her son out.... He's a good kid... And this is almost police harassment... They should be out catching peados.
I'm guessing there's white kids out there that do the same, but they can't blame their skin colour... The point of this isn't to get in to a slanging match, but to point out the role of parents in bringing up their kids. Don't break the law, if you do...accept the consequences.

I used to work (quite high up) for a Train Operating Company, this kids mum has always put pressure on me to get him a job (she works for London Underground, knows its a secure industry), found out yesterday he has been done countless times for ticketless travel, so they have his details,,.. No way can I get him a job now.

This tale has a little bit of hope... My new career is doing up houses and selling them, I absolutely love doing it... I've agreed to give this young kid a bit of weekend work, just labouring...nowt special... I have set him ground rules.

- turn up on time
- no drugs
- listen and learn
- any further arrests, he's sacked.

I am determined to give this kid a chance.. Its up to him if he takes it.
I've explained it's hard work, he says he can deal with it... I will post updates. It would be good, if this was the start of something good for him.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 19 Dec 17 12.24pm

Originally posted by 7mins


Yesterday, we had our usual family gathering.... We exchange presents. A family member who lives near Horsham (I've mentioned on here that his mum moved him outta London due to him getting in trouble) got pulled over by police for having no tax and insurance, he also got done for being under the influence of drugs or in possession...i'm not sure as he stormed out the room halfway through our discussion. Straight forward right? Can't complain,.. You broke the law....take the punishment?
Noooooooo, this copper pulled him over because he was black. I explained that cop cars have number plate recognition, and that's what tell the coppers to pull cars, (he also got done for driving off from a petrol station without paying in May). He then said... I bet they don't pull white drivers over... I asked for evidence of this, as I've known white drivers to get pulled for not having MOT. He then mentions something about the copper finding weed.... His mum then says.... Maybe police shouldn't pull black drivers over for minor (?) issues, she then defended her son, by saying the drug charge should be dropped, because drugs are rife... Its unfair to single her son out.... He's a good kid... And this is almost police harassment... They should be out catching peados.
I'm guessing there's white kids out there that do the same, but they can't blame their skin colour... The point of this isn't to get in to a slanging match, but to point out the role of parents in bringing up their kids. Don't break the law, if you do...accept the consequences.

I used to work (quite high up) for a Train Operating Company, this kids mum has always put pressure on me to get him a job (she works for London Underground, knows its a secure industry), found out yesterday he has been done countless times for ticketless travel, so they have his details,,.. No way can I get him a job now.

This tale has a little bit of hope... My new career is doing up houses and selling them, I absolutely love doing it... I've agreed to give this young kid a bit of weekend work, just labouring...nowt special... I have set him ground rules.

- turn up on time
- no drugs
- listen and learn
- any further arrests, he's sacked.

I am determined to give this kid a chance.. Its up to him if he takes it.
I've explained it's hard work, he says he can deal with it... I will post updates. It would be good, if this was the start of something good for him.

I don't think the excuses are specifically a colour thing, just a young "poor me, life's soooo unfair" thing. Most of us do/did it when caught bang to rights by teachers, parents, authority figures, or whatever, the first reaction is "but, but, but, it's not my fault because...{insert ridiculous reason here}", it's just that being black is an easy fall back when you have nothing else.

I hope it works out with him working for you - some will take the opportunity and thrive on it (and just end up with a few tales to tell later in life), some will throw it back in your face because it's easier. Hope he's in the former camp for both your sakes.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Dec 17 12.51pm

I agree with npn and 7mins.

We have a victim culture in this country which cuts across race, gender, orientation etc. It is way to easy to blame the other guy rather than accept responsibility for your own actions. I have seen plenty of white guys with this attitude.

My best friend is from Nigeria he reminds me of one of those inflatable clowns. If you knock him down he just bounces back up. I guess that is why I like him because of his can do attitude. Whatever happened to "we shall overcome?"

7mins all kudus to you for giving this young man a chance. Maybe by working with you and seeing the daily challenges you face will teach him that life may not be fair but you get nothing unless you put the effort in.

Please do keep us posted.

 


One more point

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 17 1.53pm

Originally posted by npn

I don't think the excuses are specifically a colour thing, just a young "poor me, life's soooo unfair" thing. Most of us do/did it when caught bang to rights by teachers, parents, authority figures, or whatever, the first reaction is "but, but, but, it's not my fault because...{insert ridiculous reason here}", it's just that being black is an easy fall back when you have nothing else.

I hope it works out with him working for you - some will take the opportunity and thrive on it (and just end up with a few tales to tell later in life), some will throw it back in your face because it's easier. Hope he's in the former camp for both your sakes.

I hear ya, every time I fukked up in my yoot, I blamed everyone but myself. The difference being, my parents made me take responsibility... his mum suggests that black kids be exempt from being prosecuted for low level crime... what chance has the kid got with a mum like that?

I'm gonna make sure he sees all sides of what I do... from the hard graft, dealing with tradesmen/mortgage advisers to tax returns.

I'm gonna try and make him see that earning a decent wage involves hard work, intelligence and sometimes a level of diplomacy (dealing with tradesmen can be difficult)... at the moment, he is impressed by the gangsta lifestyle... well he is gonna realise that what I do is as far from the gangsta lifestyle as you can get.

The worst part of the whole day.... was this was the first time my GF has met this side of the family... I asked her afterwards what she thought... I said be honest.

"They're of sub-normal intelligence"

Edited by 7mins (19 Dec 2017 1.53pm)

Edited by 7mins (19 Dec 2017 2.13pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Dec 17 1.53pm

Originally posted by 7mins

This is key, we need to know if the officer followed protocol.

Screaming “murderer” after watching a 5min video clip is utterly stupid.

He didn't, the police department fired him. Standard protocol is for a suspect to lay face down with his arms spread. The officers then approach them, folding one hand behind their back, then the other, applying restraints such as hand cuffs, all the while covered by the second officer.

If you're face down, with star spread arms, its almost impossible to get to a gun, let alone bring it to bear, aim and fire before an officer can fire off a shot.

Nothing in that clip should be protocol, except maybe crossing your legs, behind you.

If he'd been an active serviceman, rather than a police officer, he'd likely have been convicted based on the video.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Dec 17 1.55pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I hear ya, every time I fukked up in my yoot, I blamed everyone but myself. The difference being, my parents made me take responsibility... he's mum suggests that black kids be exempt from being prosecuted for low level crime... what chance has the kid got with a mum like that?

I'm gonna make sure he sees all sides of what I do... from the hard graft, dealing with tradesmen/mortgage advisers to tax returns.

I'm gonna try and make him see that earning a decent wage involves hard work, intelligence and sometimes a level of diplomacy (dealing with tradesmen can be difficult)... at the moment, he is impressed by the gangsta lifestyle... well he is gonna realise that what I do is as far from the gangsta lifestyle as you can get.

The worst part of the whole day.... was this was the first time my GF has met this side of the family... I asked her afterwards what she thought... I said be honest.

"They're of sub-normal intelligence"

Edited by 7mins (19 Dec 2017 1.53pm)

Kudos to you. I believe in second chances and setting an example, but rarely have the opportunity to do this these days (although I used to volunteer at our local prison teaching IT skills).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

7mins Flag In the bush 19 Dec 17 2.07pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

He didn't, the police department fired him. Standard protocol is for a suspect to lay face down with his arms spread. The officers then approach them, folding one hand behind their back, then the other, applying restraints such as hand cuffs, all the while covered by the second officer.

If you're face down, with star spread arms, its almost impossible to get to a gun, let alone bring it to bear, aim and fire before an officer can fire off a shot.

Nothing in that clip should be protocol, except maybe crossing your legs, behind you.

If he'd been an active serviceman, rather than a police officer, he'd likely have been convicted based on the video.

On the radio (770 KTTH, I'll admit they're a little right of centre) they said the officer was trying to move him away from the room, he also said the training scenarios involve people suddenly reaching for firearms, he said until you know what you're dealing with (1,2,3 or more suspects), you think worse case scenario. They asked him if he would do anything different, he said the only thing he would have done different is he would have created a barrier, they're trained to first take cover... he doesn't think the copper did this.
He did say you give direct and explicit orders and let the suspect know in no uncertain terms failure to follow these instructions could lead to them being shot.He then said if the suspect makes a sudden movement, the copper has a split second to make a choice to shoot.
What he did say.... in all the training... they're never told how much or how little to shoot... you're told fire until he is no longer a threat.

 

Page 35 of 36 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA