You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 9.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wayne Hennessey (LOCKED)


Page 35 of 132 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >
cpj Flag Kent 02 May 17 9.53am

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Against Burnley, he let in 3 goals at his near post (including the one disallowed). That's unacceptable. And, rightly chalked off as it was, his "effort" at the handled goal was abject; he flapped around lik a dancing clown while the ball trickled under his body and in.

I have praised Hennessey for his better play of late but much of that appears to have been the result of having Sakho around who is so good he takes the pressure off everyone (Kelly, for example, was notably worse again this weekend). But let's not forget, this is still the goalkeeper who nutmegged himself after a simple catch at Villa to lose us that game. He doesn't have the mental or physical toughness required at this level, and a new 'keeper is #1 on my summer wish list.

It says a lot about his improved performances this season that you're having to use an example from the middle of last season for where he made a major mistake. Yes, he's an average keeper, certainly not one of the PL's best, although neither is he the worst, and he doesn't generally make match-winning saves. But neither does he cost us points every game as some on here would suggest.

As I said, he will be in goal for the next 3 games. What happens in the Summer depends on whether Mandanda goes, whether Speroni gets yet another 1 year deal (I hope not) and what other positions need filling, such as CB, at least 1 more forward and a good number 10. Posters have suggested Pickford - if he is so great, how come Sunderland are already down? Or is it that a keeper is only as good as the defence in front of him?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 02 May 17 10.01am

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

It's not your job or mine to find a quality keeper who fits Palace's budget, it's Allardyce's. Mandanda was brought in by Pardew, who is a fan of expensive / flashy things; Big Sam has shown a much more discerning eye for reasonably-priced quality.

We needed a CB, LB and a defensive midfielder. Sam brought in Sakho (loan), Schlupp, van Aarnholt and Milivojevic. All of them have made a positive impact to a greater or lesser extent. I have faith that he knows where to go get a shot-stopper too.

A bit harsh on Pardew, anyone who had the temerity to question whether Mandanda would be any good was shot down on here. And as Ligue 1 top keeper for a few seasons, it wasn't unreasonable to expect him to do well. He was also incredibly cheap - at the time roughly €1 million?

The point remains, there's probably 7-8 teams that want /need to to upgrade their No 1 keeper. Like 20 goal a season strikers, easier said than done.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 05 May 17 12.15am

Originally posted by cpj

Yes he can. He wasn't good enough two years ago so why would he be now?

What are you talking about? He had below par season, it was not as bad a the nightmare seasons Hennessy has had. Despite not being at his best that season, he still was better than Wayne has been


Edited by Shifty97 (05 May 2017 12.37am)

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 05 May 17 12.25am

Could you Hennessy lovers please explain one thing to me

It seems that in your eyes...
When McCarthy made mistakes he was not good enough
If Jules makes a mistake he is too old and not good enough
If Mandanda makes a mistake he is not good enough and a waste of money

So why is it that when Hennessy makes basic errors, you defend him?

Edited by Shifty97 (05 May 2017 12.26am)

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 05 May 17 7.28am

Originally posted by Shifty97

Could you Hennessy lovers please explain one thing to me

It seems that in your eyes...
When McCarthy made mistakes he was not good enough
If Jules makes a mistake he is too old and not good enough
If Mandanda makes a mistake he is not good enough and a waste of money

So why is it that when Hennessy makes basic errors, you defend him?

Edited by Shifty97 (05 May 2017 12.26am)

It's not such a simple issue.

McCarthy was given a run in goal and moved on by management.

Mandanda started the season has suffered a mysterious injury and from what is being reported in the press wants out. Whatever the truth in that he has in the past demonstrated he is a good keeper but for some reason isn't even on the bench.

Speroni comes with a huge amount of nostalgic support from fans but has suggested when given the chance recently that his best days are behind him.

Right now WH is the only real option we have. I suspect we willmake our annual keeper signing and pity whoever it is as within a week or two these boards will be baying for his head.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 05 May 17 7.33am

Originally posted by Shifty97

Could you Hennessy lovers please explain one thing to me

It seems that in your eyes...
When McCarthy made mistakes he was not good enough
If Jules makes a mistake he is too old and not good enough
If Mandanda makes a mistake he is not good enough and a waste of money

So why is it that when Hennessy makes basic errors, you defend him?

Edited by Shifty97 (05 May 2017 12.26am)

People are just trying to say to you Hennessy Haters that he is not quite as bad as you think, and he does not deserve the blame for every goal we concede.
I think everyone recognises that the goalie situation needs addressing , we tried it with Mandanda and that has not gone well , in the meantime we should get behind the keeper we have.
The problem is when anyone tries to explain or use examples of the other keepers help you understand, you just call them a Hennessey lover and bang on about the same points that everybody already recognises and understands and the same debate continues every week.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 05 May 17 8.51am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

It's not such a simple issue.

McCarthy was given a run in goal and moved on by management.

Mandanda started the season has suffered a mysterious injury and from what is being reported in the press wants out. Whatever the truth in that he has in the past demonstrated he is a good keeper but for some reason isn't even on the bench.

Speroni comes with a huge amount of nostalgic support from fans but has suggested when given the chance recently that his best days are behind him.

Right now WH is the only real option we have. I suspect we willmake our annual keeper signing and pity whoever it is as within a week or two these boards will be baying for his head.

I expect things will be different this time around. Hennesey has acted as a good buffer between a legend being replaced in goal. And I imagine most will be only to pleased to see a new long term number one in place.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

whitehorselane Flag 05 May 17 9.41am

Hennessey and Ledley I think are out of contract at the end of the season and it would not be a surprise I they ended up at Wba next season

Think Hennessey has been better than Mandanda, and a bit like Kelly gets unfair blame for any game we lose.

 

dg1937 Flag 05 May 17 9.45am

Thanks to Ray in Houston for posting the link to the stats. I suppose you could argue that Begovic is the worst keeper to have appeared in the PL this season as he is 39 out of 39. I know no one has argued that and nor are they likely to, but it does show the risk of relying just on the stats.

WH simply doesn't inspire confidence and there is plenty of evidence as to why that is. But I absolutely agree that at the moment he is the best we have and, regardless of anything anyone on here thinks, Sam will choose him for our remaining fixtures and we should all get 100% behind him.

We will then see what the summer brings.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 05 May 17 9.45am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

People are just trying to say to you Hennessy Haters that he is not quite as bad as you think, and he does not deserve the blame for every goal we concede.
I think everyone recognises that the goalie situation needs addressing , we tried it with Mandanda and that has not gone well , in the meantime we should get behind the keeper we have.
The problem is when anyone tries to explain or use examples of the other keepers help you understand, you just call them a Hennessey lover and bang on about the same points that everybody already recognises and understands and the same debate continues every week.

The voice of reason. Couldn't have put it better myself.

 

cpj Flag Kent 05 May 17 9.48am

Originally posted by Shifty97

What are you talking about? He had below par season, it was not as bad a the nightmare seasons Hennessy has had. Despite not being at his best that season, he still was better than Wayne has been


Edited by Shifty97 (05 May 2017 12.37am)

Speroni didn't have a clean sheet in his last 12 games of that season and spent most of the year pushing out shots for the follow-up attacker to tap in, or flapping at crosses.

You talk in your subsequent post about 'Hennesey-lovers' - I doubt there are such tings. He makes mistakes, yes, like all keepers do, but not 'basic' mistakes all the time like you are suggesting.

As I have said many times on here, best if Speroni retires in the summer, and Hennessey and Mandanda both go, and we start afresh with someone next season who we can all get behind without being influenced either way by who has gone before.

 

vflynn Flag Perth 05 May 17 11.29am

Looks like Hennessy is on the outer next season

IMG_2708.PNG Attachment: IMG_2708.PNG (400.78Kb)

 


"If you wana get ahead............Get a hat.....
Malcom Allison 1975-76 the glory year.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 05 May 17 12.27pm

Originally posted by cpj

Speroni didn't have a clean sheet in his last 12 games of that season and spent most of the year pushing out shots for the follow-up attacker to tap in, or flapping at crosses.

You talk in your subsequent post about 'Hennesey-lovers' - I doubt there are such tings. He makes mistakes, yes, like all keepers do, but not 'basic' mistakes all the time like you are suggesting.

As I have said many times on here, best if Speroni retires in the summer, and Hennessey and Mandanda both go, and we start afresh with someone next season who we can all get behind without being influenced either way by who has gone before.

Just remind us of our league positions when Speroni was in goal since our return to the top flight please CPJ. Do you feel that those goals conceded effected that at all?

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 05 May 17 2.29pm

Originally posted by vflynn

Looks like Hennessy is on the outer next season

I doubt we're in the hunt for someone like Heaton. At 31, he's hardly a long term solution.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Painter Flag Croydon 05 May 17 3.20pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I doubt we're in the hunt for someone like Heaton. At 31, he's hardly a long term solution.

Surprising comment, as everyone should realise there is nothing long term in the current football era.
Heaton would be an excellent acquisition for Palace, but I doubt we will get him.

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 05 May 17 4.11pm

Originally posted by cpj

Speroni didn't have a clean sheet in his last 12 games of that season and spent most of the year pushing out shots for the follow-up attacker to tap in, or flapping at crosses.

You talk in your subsequent post about 'Hennesey-lovers' - I doubt there are such tings. He makes mistakes, yes, like all keepers do, but not 'basic' mistakes all the time like you are suggesting.

As I have said many times on here, best if Speroni retires in the summer, and Hennessey and Mandanda both go, and we start afresh with someone next season who we can all get behind without being influenced either way by who has gone before.

That is an exaggeration but even so, Hennessy does the same and worse so I don't understand how he is an improvement


Edited by Shifty97 (05 May 2017 4.11pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 May 17 8.43pm

Don't think either of the goals were particularly Hennessey's fault last week as both the chances presented were gilt edged and driven low and hard from close range. But yet another below average performance with question marks.

He's not been good enough overall and is one of the reasons we've ended up where we are. There's no disguising or deflecting that with stupid comments like "haters" and "fan boys" he's not been good enough end of.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 May 17 8.48pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I doubt we're in the hunt for someone like Heaton. At 31, he's hardly a long term solution.

Really? Good for a 5 yr contract at that age

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 05 May 17 8.56pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Really? Good for a 5 yr contract at that age

36 is no age for a goalie.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 05 May 17 9.54pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He's not been good enough overall and is one of the reasons we've ended up where we are. There's no disguising or deflecting that with stupid comments like "haters" and "fan boys" he's not been good enough end of.

The first goal went right through him. The second goal - that was disallowed for a handball - went right through him at about 1 mph. The third goal (second legit goal) went in through the giant gap at his near post after he'd had plenty of time to set his angle.

No, he wasn't well protected by his defense on the goals that counted, but his efforts at saving them were poor and his "effort" at the disallowed goal was comedically bad.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Page 35 of 132 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic