You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 35 of 65 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >
ChrisGC Flag Wantage 31 Mar 19 2.31pm

Originally posted by DeanMiles

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Hodgson and replacement.' by Midlands Eagle

I'd like Benitez when the season finishes.

I'd love to see Benitez. Other quality managers that we have no chance of getting include Dyche and Howe.

Lampard all the way for me.

Edited by ChrisGC (31 Mar 2019 2.31pm)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 31 Mar 19 2.44pm

No thanks. Nothing to suggest Dougie has any PL managerial qualities

SP will doubtless get him as cheap and SP loves a legend

never achieved a 34% win percentage at three Championship clubs

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Hodgson and replacement.' by Midlands Eagle

I'd put money on Dougie as new manager when the time comes ..Parish will now want to pay for a good manager

Edited by HKOwen (31 Mar 2019 2.49pm)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 31 Mar 19 4.44pm

I wouldn't be so anti Dougie stepping up if Roy calls it day. Yes Dougie made a mistake which he has freely addmitted. He knows how to coach players and has long history with our club

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Apr 19 9.06pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Arsen Wenger' by bexleydave

I see the old french bloke is looking to buy in the Croydon area. He is younger than Roy

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 01 Apr 19 9.16pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Arsen Wenger' by bexleydave

April fools is supposed to be before midday.

 

Deabo2030 Flag Ipswich. Suffolk 01 Apr 19 9.58pm

Hodgson played the team the fans wanted on Saturday, but still no real passion from those who played.
No one including the manager can do anything to get the players to play with guts and belief... I'm not a Hodgson fan and didn't want him to come to Palace in the first place, but getting rid of him now is relegation for certain.

 

Kant Flag exeter 01 Apr 19 10.52pm

I don’t think raw passion is the missing ingredient. The players look like they care to me. I wonder if in fact the litany of stray passes and poor finishing at home this Saturday and in previous games is in fact indicative of players who are trying too hard? It might seem counterintuitive but it could explain our poor home form. Maybe we just need to relax a little; play with a bit of freedom.

When Roy made his end of season speech last year he clearly indicated that he thought the team had the potential to really do something special, so I suspect he is privately as frustrated as anyone.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Apr 19 11.50pm

Originally posted by Kant

I don’t think raw passion is the missing ingredient. The players look like they care to me. I wonder if in fact the litany of stray passes and poor finishing at home this Saturday and in previous games is in fact indicative of players who are trying too hard? It might seem counterintuitive but it could explain our poor home form. Maybe we just need to relax a little; play with a bit of freedom.

When Roy made his end of season speech last year he clearly indicated that he thought the team had the potential to really do something special, so I suspect he is privately as frustrated as anyone.

There are some Roy shackles the team are carrying. Training is apparently regimented and repetitive, going over positioning and exactly what is expected. That was fine god the Pulis era but now when some creativity and freedom of expression is needed the players are possibly tense and frustrated. Maybe they have all a private W&nk just before kick off to relax a bit.

 


COYP

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Apr 19 7.27am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There are some Roy shackles the team are carrying. Training is apparently regimented and repetitive, going over positioning and exactly what is expected. That was fine god the Pulis era but now when some creativity and freedom of expression is needed the players are possibly tense and frustrated. Maybe they have all a private W&nk just before kick off to relax a bit.

That will be the training that has seen us play pretty well away from home and gather a healthy number of points.

We all know it's the home form that needs improvement and that's largely down to chance conversion.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 02 Apr 19 7.39am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There are some Roy shackles the team are carrying. Training is apparently regimented and repetitive, going over positioning and exactly what is expected. That was fine god the Pulis era but now when some creativity and freedom of expression is needed the players are possibly tense and frustrated. Maybe they have all a private W&nk just before kick off to relax a bit.


This is how it looks to me. They're shackled and scared to put a foot out of line because they know they won't play again if they're disobedient and, god forbid, try something off script.
This only ever goes on of two ways: terrible performances and results (already happening) or players down tools.

Either way the manager eventually gets sacked.

 

jeeagles Flag 02 Apr 19 8.28am

Originally posted by Deabo2030

Hodgson played the team the fans wanted on Saturday, but still no real passion from those who played.
No one including the manager can do anything to get the players to play with guts and belief... I'm not a Hodgson fan and didn't want him to come to Palace in the first place, but getting rid of him now is relegation for certain.

We are 8 points clear. Even as one of the most pessimistic supporters I think it's very likely we won't go down.

If players have freedom and confidence it's then passion, guts, and belief will come.

You can also train to improve composure in front of goal. Thinking clearly under pressure or owning the moment are two well used terms to describe it.

If the players are drilled again and again and told not to break rank then it's no wonder they down have freedom, or confidence, and aren't composed when they find themselves out of position.

Keep Roy to the end of the year, but it's time to start looking for someone new.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Apr 19 8.56am

Originally posted by Deabo2030

Hodgson played the team the fans wanted on Saturday, but still no real passion from those who played.
No one including the manager can do anything to get the players to play with guts and belief... I'm not a Hodgson fan and didn't want him to come to Palace in the first place, but getting rid of him now is relegation for certain.

Of course they can. A major part of a managers job is to get them to do exactly that.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 02 Apr 19 9.32am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There are some Roy shackles the team are carrying. Training is apparently regimented and repetitive, going over positioning and exactly what is expected. That was fine god the Pulis era but now when some creativity and freedom of expression is needed the players are possibly tense and frustrated. Maybe they have all a private W&nk just before kick off to relax a bit. [/quote]

Might try that myself before the next home game ...

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 02 Apr 19 11.21am

While this season might seem a bit 'meh' we nevertheless have the highest points tally we have had after 31 games since promotion (with the exception of Pardew's first season, where we had 39). I am disappointed to a degree, as I think we could be doing better. But to say that we are definitely dreadful under Roy is just nonsense and, while I DO think we should be looking to improve year on year, we really have to be wary of just expecting top half finishes. Rather, we should be happy with such a finish if that makes sense.

I think we are probably achieving parity with Roy. I think we wouldn't go down with him in charge but I also don't think we'd break the top 8.

The idea that relegation is a certainty if we get rid of Roy now, on the other hand, is laughable. We could put a chimp in charge and stay up currently.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 02 Apr 19 11.57am

Originally posted by ChrisGC


This is how it looks to me. They're shackled and scared to put a foot out of line because they know they won't play again if they're disobedient and, god forbid, try something off script.
This only ever goes on of two ways: terrible performances and results (already happening) or players down tools.

Either way the manager eventually gets sacked.


Ok so whilst most on here are complaining that Roy has his favourites and wont change the players even if they're playing badly, you are saying Roy is at fault because he changes out players that make mistakes.
What I say is that whatever Roy does with the team people on here will find a way to criticise him and for me that is just for the sake of it most of the time.
Now I do not think Roy is beyond criticism but I do think that overall he is doing a good job

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 02 Apr 19 12.06pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster


Ok so whilst most on here are complaining that Roy has his favourites and wont change the players even if they're playing badly, you are saying Roy is at fault because he changes out players that make mistakes.
What I say is that whatever Roy does with the team people on here will find a way to criticise him and for me that is just for the sake of it most of the time.
Now I do not think Roy is beyond criticism but I do think that overall he is doing a good job

I didn't say that at all. I said he drops players that disobey him.

Clearly, you can play as terribly as you want and make as many mistakes as you want so long as you don't go off script.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 02 Apr 19 12.29pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I didn't say that at all. I said he drops players that disobey him.

Clearly, you can play as terribly as you want and make as many mistakes as you want so long as you don't go off script.


I think you've nailed it. Roy believes in his system before any individuals and tbh who can argue with it when - by the looks - he/it keeps us up again.

Lots of talk before about looking at the Bournemouth model but we are currently behind them and could finish top.

Roy's biggest mistakes this season were losing to Brighton. If we'd of won both those games then they'd be comfortably 3rd from bottom and we'd be squabbling about why we're not fighting for a top 4 place!

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 02 Apr 19 12.50pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I didn't say that at all. I said he drops players that disobey him.

Clearly, you can play as terribly as you want and make as many mistakes as you want so long as you don't go off script.

I just don't think the facts bear you out, unless I misunderstand what you mean by the script. PVA has gone missing many times this season and never gets dropped. AWB went missing for Watford's second goal and didn't get dropped. Who do you think got dropped for not doing as he was told?

I do agree that Roy likes to play a specific shape and wants players to fit into that (and most of ours do perchance) but that seems to be the case with a lot of managers. Difference for me is that better quality players can adapt to a managers style and I think many of ours are lacking in that respect.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Apr 19 12.55pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There are some Roy shackles the team are carrying. Training is apparently regimented and repetitive, going over positioning and exactly what is expected. That was fine god the Pulis era but now when some creativity and freedom of expression is needed the players are possibly tense and frustrated. Maybe they have all a private W&nk just before kick off to relax a bit. [[/quote]

Might try that myself before the next home game ...

That’s why the men’s cubicles have such a long queue outside. A powder of the nose and a turbo w@nk.

 


COYP

eaglesdare Flag 02 Apr 19 1.03pm

I just dont think we fully recovered from loosing cabaye and RLC.....

 

Page 35 of 65 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread