You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 35 of 71 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >
tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 10.46am

Originally posted by Willo

Try telling that to the loyal season-ticket holders who have occupied their seats for many,many years and are now being re-located to accommodate what they probably view as an HF who threw a strop, decided not to continue their support as a group in order to force the hand of the club.

Had the club decided to introduce a 'Singing section' in Block B without any pressure from the HF who were content to continue their support from Block B and as such continued to do so this season, I suspect there wouldn't be the same ill-feeling amongst those affected and those not affected but who empathize with those who are.

I completely get your point, but let's look at this another way. What if you have had that seat for 20+ years, surely you can be grateful for having great views for all those years and now give someone else a chance at the seat?

End of the day we all pay the same for a seat in the LH, if once in a blue moon the club decide they want those allocated seats used for a different set of fans ins't that fair? or are the current Block E'ers the only guys that are ever allowed access to those seats because they have had them for a long time?

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Nov 18 11.00am

Originally posted by tinribzzz

Perhaps I am basing my findings on the general consensus of the Holmesdale.net and BBS. But even on here before there was backing for the HF but as soon as people realised that they weren't coming back this season it appears most people think "f**k them".

I for one am for the singing section or "HF Section". You've only got to look at the wonderful displays and tributes they've organised over the years to see they are something great for the premier league.

I'm sure the players are grateful for all of the fans that turn up every week but historically they've always ran to that corner when scoring and furthermore there has been occasions over the years when players have actually gone to the HF specific pubs.

Thoughts go out to those in Block E that are being inconvenienced by this, and I will use the word inconvenience because really that's all it is.

Sorry, but that is not true, they only started to do that since the HF formed there. Before circa HF, they usually ran to wherever the loudest (home) fans were at the time, be it, Holmesdale, Whitehorse, The Arthur & yes, even Main Stand.

They hardly ever ran to that corner of the ground, as that's where the Away fans were situated. Just saying.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Nov 18 11.01am

Originally posted by tinribzzz

I completely get your point, but let's look at this another way. What if you have had that seat for 20+ years, surely you can be grateful for having great views for all those years and now give someone else a chance at the seat?

End of the day we all pay the same for a seat in the LH, if once in a blue moon the club decide they want those allocated seats used for a different set of fans ins't that fair? or are the current Block E'ers the only guys that are ever allowed access to those seats because they have had them for a long time?

All down to the circumstances behind such a re-location.

I suspect if long-term supporters were informed that they needed to be moved to accomodate Away supporters as their section was being moved away from a family area or that the away section was adjacent to fervent home supporters resulting in foul-mouthed ordure and aggressive behaviour,our supporters would of course be disappointed but more understanding and less-inclined to get in a hissy fit about their move.

I suspect that they see the HF as protesting, throwing toys out of prams, NOT continuing their support as normal and in doing so forcing the club to give in to their wishes resulting in these long-term season ticket holders having to move elsewhere.

All down to circumstances,events etc etc.

Edited by Willo (10 Nov 2018 11.06am)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Nov 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Glazed Over

Just to confirm, there's only one group of people who have got rid of "the clubs famous atmosphere".

Nobody seems to be able to clarify why the HF have to move from Block B.

Signing section - tick
Improves atmosphere - tick
Gets good TV coverage - tick
Mentioned regularly by commentators - tick
Existing ST holders sit in this area - tick
Don't have to move long term ST holders from the seats they've had for years to various other parts of the ground, where there is no guarantee the can sit next to family or friends - tick

Why not just reserve 400 seats in Block B for HF?

Cant wait for these HF to get 'removed' from Block E in a few years time when they're too old or too pissed off with the Club to continue singing in this section.

"Sorry son, but you're not loud enough - off to the Sainsburys end for you".

Good post.

We must be the only club that is proposing that you can choose where to sit on the basis of how loud you sing and how many banners you wave.

All this "famous atmosphere" stuff is nonsense, its in our fans imagination.

 

bicycle repair man 10 Nov 18 11.24am

Originally posted by Painter

Good post.

We must be the only club that is proposing that you can choose where to sit on the basis of how loud you sing and how many banners you wave.

All this "famous atmosphere" stuff is nonsense, its in our fans imagination.


You are so right, it's totally ludicrous.
There are a lot of deluded people out there.

 

bicycle repair man 10 Nov 18 11.42am

Originally posted by tinribzzz

I completely get your point, but let's look at this another way. What if you have had that seat for 20+ years, surely you can be grateful for having great views for all those years and now give someone else a chance at the seat?

End of the day we all pay the same for a seat in the LH, if once in a blue moon the club decide they want those allocated seats used for a different set of fans ins't that fair? or are the current Block E'ers the only guys that are ever allowed access to those seats because they have had them for a long time?


But the fans the Block E guys are being turfed out for are people who already had perfectly good seats in Block B,and they voluntarily gave them up.
If the average fan wanted to change seats he'd have to wait for a vacancy to occur.
We should all be treated equally,with no special treatment for a select few.


 

Palace in the Blood Flag 10 Nov 18 11.43am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Have you asked the 17,000 approx season ticket holders?

‘Everyone’ is not against it.

You have completely undermined your position with this statement. The fact is the club didn't ask the 17,000 they decided on the basis of a flawed survey, a vociferous group who boycotted the club and possibly others who contacted club. The club should have asked all season ticket holders as then they would have had a mandate to enact the outcome.

You are right that not everyone is against the idea, however we have no idea if that is a majority.

My gut feel is that if the club had initially asked about a singing section they would have got a positive response. However if they were to ask now they would find many have changed their view.

The only way the club and its owners can get back any credibility is to have the survey now based on the plans they have put forward. If it is in favour of the plans then Block E season ticket holders can be moved as it has the majority of the supporters support if not the club should abandon the move.

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 11.54am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


You are so right, it's totally ludicrous.
There are a lot of deluded people out there.

I'm sorry but how can anyone deny that the support at Selhurst has been deluded? Whilst it has gotten worse in recent years it was significantly better than most other premiership grounds.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 10 Nov 18 11.58am

Can we put the HF in charge of Brexit please?

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 12.03pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Can we put the HF in charge of Brexit please?

Depends if you're a remainer or not! But I could see them getting a better deal than May will!

 

bicycle repair man 10 Nov 18 12.08pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Can we put the HF in charge of Brexit please?

They are certainly experienced flag wavers.
Maybe we could export them to Brussels.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 18 12.23pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


But the fans the Block E guys are being turfed out for are people who already had perfectly good seats in Block B,and they voluntarily gave them up.
If the average fan wanted to change seats he'd have to wait for a vacancy to occur.
We should all be treated equally,with no special treatment for a select few.


I’m sure you’ve said this 1,379 times.

 


COYP

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Nov 18 12.31pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm sure that someone will

wp Dnny H or Rudi will be along soon to lecture us on why it,s for greater good.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 10 Nov 18 12.34pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


But the fans the Block E guys are being turfed out for are people who already had perfectly good seats in Block B,and they voluntarily gave them up.
If the average fan wanted to change seats he'd have to wait for a vacancy to occur.
We should all be treated equally,with no special treatment for a select few.


No. The club is creating a singing section.
Just like they moved people to move the away fans.
Just like they moved people out of the executive seats
Just like they moved people for the gantry
Just like they made the whitehorse a family stand.

The club are making a change to quadruple (???) the amount of singers, hoping it will have a knock on effect to the rest of the stand.

Its a progressive change, it's a new initiative. People are having to move and lets all hope they get looked after, I know I wouldn't be happy of course, but in big changes people will be affected.
Let's just hope it is successful and makes Selhurst a positive place next season.

Edited by Dean_CPFC (10 Nov 2018 12.36pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 18 12.36pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

You have completely undermined your position with this statement. The fact is the club didn't ask the 17,000 they decided on the basis of a flawed survey, a vociferous group who boycotted the club and possibly others who contacted club. The club should have asked all season ticket holders as then they would have had a mandate to enact the outcome.

You are right that not everyone is against the idea, however we have no idea if that is a majority.

My gut feel is that if the club had initially asked about a singing section they would have got a positive response. However if they were to ask now they would find many have changed their view.

The only way the club and its owners can get back any credibility is to have the survey now based on the plans they have put forward. If it is in favour of the plans then Block E season ticket holders can be moved as it has the majority of the supporters support if not the club should abandon the move.

I haven’t undermined my position because I said a while ago when the HF mock brochure came out the club handled it appallingly and should’ve surveyed everyone instead of losing it because they got a few letters or tweets from fans in E block.

I agree if they did ask in the first place they would’ve got a positive response. When the mock up brochure came out the response was more positive than after the rumours and twitter outrage. The reason people aren’t as thrilled with the idea now is that it’s just 400 being dropped in between hundreds of silent or quiet sitters or standers when what they should be doing is resetting the whole tier, but the club can’t be bothered, or think they’re upsetting fewer fans by dropping 400 in, only they’re probably upsetting or disillusioning more. Read the club statement claiming it can’t be done, only it can. I think the E400 would probably prefer a reset rather than the Arfur, plus it gives them a feeling of being more equal rather than the fall guys.

I hope this clarifies things with me looking at it more laterally. Something the club refuse to do, but I’m not surprised.

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 10 Nov 18 12.59pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

No. The club is creating a singing section.
Just like they moved people to move the away fans.
Just like they moved people out of the executive seats
Just like they moved people for the gantry
Just like they made the whitehorse a family stand.

The club are making a change to quadruple (???) the amount of singers, hoping it will have a knock on effect to the rest of the stand.

Its a progressive change, it's a new initiative. People are having to move and lets all hope they get looked after, I know I wouldn't be happy of course, but in big changes people will be affected.
Let's just hope it is successful and makes Selhurst a positive place next season.

Edited by Dean_CPFC (10 Nov 2018 12.36pm)


Progressive change ? New initiative ?
Since time began there has always been a part of the ground where the more vocal supporters gathered.But it didn't involve them getting any sort of special treatment at the expense of other Palace fans.

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 10 Nov 18 1.03pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


Progressive change ? New initiative ?
Since time began there has always been a part of the ground where the more vocal supporters gathered.But it didn't involve them getting any sort of special treatment at the expense of other Palace fans.

But our atmosphere has become to reliant on having the HF as a driving force behind it.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 18 1.06pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


Progressive change ? New initiative ?
Since time began there has always been a part of the ground where the more vocal supporters gathered.But it didn't involve them getting any sort of special treatment at the expense of other Palace fans.

Where were you not long after the Holmesdale was seated? The atmosphere was shocking, and it had been dead in the Arfur a long time as well.

‘You’re not very good, you’re not very good, you’re not very, you’re not very, you’re not very good.’’

Change to ‘’dodgy keeper, dodgy keeper, takes it up the a rse.’’

We just watched it be so sh1t for so long before the HF woke everyone up.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (10 Nov 2018 1.33pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 18 1.07pm

Points being made to the cobbler bicycle chap for the 1,234th time.

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 10 Nov 18 1.15pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Points being made to the cobbler bicycle chap for the 1,234th time.


Bring it on, I'm right,you know I am.

 

Page 35 of 71 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic