You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 35 of 91 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >
davehuggins Flag 12 Sep 19 1.48pm

I fully understand the accounts and the losses we made, but I am sure SP said the Stadium money was ring-fenced? Or have I missed something. As for the playing side of things I have no doubt we need wealthy investors to take us forward, these may be keener if our stadium was up to it!! I really do appreciate what SP has done but think he needs, IMO we are a very attractive proposition apart from the ground. Just having a say thats all ....

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 12 Sep 19 2.04pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

I fully understand the accounts and the losses we made, but I am sure SP said the Stadium money was ring-fenced? Or have I missed something. As for the playing side of things I have no doubt we need wealthy investors to take us forward, these may be keener if our stadium was up to it!! I really do appreciate what SP has done but think he needs, IMO we are a very attractive proposition apart from the ground. Just having a say thats all ....

The problem is the revenue I agree. We could be owned by the wealthiest man alive whos willing to spend billions on the club, but it would make zero difference if we dont upgrade the stadium to increase operating revenue, which in turn makes us able to spend more money.
I reckon there is money ring fenced, but the issue is the council guideline that says Palace have to fund and organise the change to public transport routes and community improvement initiatives whilst the disruptive construction process is being carried out... I dont think that was planned for by Parish and thats what the hold up is.

 

davehuggins Flag 12 Sep 19 2.22pm

Brilliant WaRa hit the button on the head mate, I have no wish to knock anybody but if we are going to survive or progress then SP needs to change things asap

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Sep 19 3.15pm

But.....if the Americans investment was ring fenced for stadium development, are those funds still available given that they want out ?

If the answer is “ no “ that would also explain the lack of tangible progress.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

scuffy Flag orpington 12 Sep 19 3.20pm

It's clear from that interview Roy is up for a new contract. Personally I'd give him a year's extension. What's the consensus view?

 

slubglurge Flag welling 12 Sep 19 4.27pm

While hes here we wont go down but his successor may be a problem

 

nead1 Flag 12 Sep 19 4.33pm

I would make it 2 years to provide continuity and time for forward planning. What he has achieved is quite remarkable in my judgement. He is very much a wise old head, extremely good tactically (especially away from home)and never flaps no matter what - even losing to Brighton!

 

davehuggins Flag 12 Sep 19 4.38pm

2 years for me would be good, he needs some money to invest without doubt. Shaun Derry joining is interesting?

 

scuffy Flag orpington 12 Sep 19 5.42pm

Agree, a one year extension while starting to look seriously at future options makes sense.

Originally posted by nead1

I would make it 2 years to provide continuity and time for forward planning. What he has achieved is quite remarkable in my judgement. He is very much a wise old head, extremely good tactically (especially away from home)and never flaps no matter what - even losing to Brighton!

 

scuffy Flag orpington 12 Sep 19 5.44pm

I could see Derry emerging as an option were the worst to happen and we find ourselves in the championship but feel we need a more experienced/proven coach for the premier league.

Originally posted by davehuggins

2 years for me would be good, he needs some money to invest without doubt. Shaun Derry joining is interesting?

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 12 Sep 19 5.50pm

Originally posted by scuffy

I could see Derry emerging as an option were the worst to happen and we find ourselves in the championship but feel we need a more experienced/proven coach for the premier league.

Could be a Freedman / Derry partnership?

 

scuffy Flag orpington 12 Sep 19 6.04pm

If we find ourselves in the championship I wouldn't be surprised but I don't think that will happen.

Originally posted by palace chick

Could be a Freedman / Derry partnership?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 13 Sep 19 10.24pm

Originally posted by RyWa

The problem is the revenue I agree. We could be owned by the wealthiest man alive whos willing to spend billions on the club, but it would make zero difference if we dont upgrade the stadium to increase operating revenue, which in turn makes us able to spend more money.
I reckon there is money ring fenced, but the issue is the council guideline that says Palace have to fund and organise the change to public transport routes and community improvement initiatives whilst the disruptive construction process is being carried out... I dont think that was planned for by Parish and thats what the hold up is.

IIRC the introduction of our American shareholders occurred when the TV money was being renegotiated. Since then it's become apparent that this money is going through the clubs to agents and players. They had to loan money to the club to keep us in the division thanks to Pardew being given too long and the cost of the stadium / stand has increased from previous estimates whether that be economic uncertainty, planning gain or whatever. On top of that it appears they don't have a controlling interest.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 14 Sep 19 5.30am

Said it once, i'll say it again... this summer they should have went into the transfer window with the mindset of completely rebooting the squad. I repeat, months of prep, leading up to the window with targets and plan B's and C's in various roles.
AWB and Zaha should have been sold to generate 100 mil early doors. Had we taken 45/55 from Everton or Arsenal at a push, we would have achieved that. The dead wood should have been cut loose, Benteke, Wickham etc.

We should have shown our intent and extended roy and allowed him to bring in 4 first team challengers and 2 plan b, squad players. 4 decent players at around 20 mil each and two at around 8-9 is the money spent from Zaha and AWB.

Pre season starts and he has a month to get it together, which obviously should be smooth with acquired players.. a new RB, a new Left winger, two new strikers, couple of attacking players.

New look palace, life goes on, we support the palace.

 


This was once a quality forum....

JohnB Flag 14 Sep 19 10.16am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Said it once, i'll say it again... this summer they should have went into the transfer window with the mindset of completely rebooting the squad. I repeat, months of prep, leading up to the window with targets and plan B's and C's in various roles.
AWB and Zaha should have been sold to generate 100 mil early doors. Had we taken 45/55 from Everton or Arsenal at a push, we would have achieved that. The dead wood should have been cut loose, Benteke, Wickham etc.

We should have shown our intent and extended roy and allowed him to bring in 4 first team challengers and 2 plan b, squad players. 4 decent players at around 20 mil each and two at around 8-9 is the money spent from Zaha and AWB.

Pre season starts and he has a month to get it together, which obviously should be smooth with acquired players.. a new RB, a new Left winger, two new strikers, couple of attacking players.

New look palace, life goes on, we support the palace.

I'm not disputing the club needs a refresh and several new additions but I am interested to know which 4 players that we could sign for £20m and 2 at sub £10m that would improve the team.

Looking at the players that moved in the last window, there aren't many in that price bracket that I'd want.

£20m in the last window would have got you a Maupay, Ings, Cutrone, Lookman, Praet, ASM, Mings, Che Adams, McBurnie and Trippier who I doubt would have joined us over Madrid.

Of those I'd maybe want Lookman. The others would have left us pretty underwhelmed and none have really set the world alight so far.

I've left out players like James who we would have never been able to get when competing with the likes of Utd.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 14 Sep 19 1.18pm

From a recent article with SP I think he stated he had a 3 year plan in mind.

I expect the consensus is to extend roy for one more year, sell zaha next summer and then hold out for a total rebuild of the squad whilst trying to find an investor to take over from the Americans. I think it was telling...that from a Roy Hodgson interview in which he said that Palace will always struggle to compete with the top 6 to 8 because of the over inflated prices of players, and that our best bet was to keep investing in our youth development. I expect Parish plans to find the right manager to give a good lump sum of money to create a fresh team with mili at the helm, when Roy retires and that Roy is here to keep us in the premiership long enough to have the money to replace our aging squad.

 

Den1923 Flag 17 Sep 19 1.21pm

Originally posted by Painter

I can’t believe you don’t understand about the investment and ground. It’s been discussed to the death on here. Just read the financial accounts.

to be fair in the accounts it does state that investment in the team is an important part of the clubs strategy to avoid relegation and I think people are rightly saying that have not been happening and would like to know why?

 

est1905 Flag 17 Sep 19 5.50pm

Originally posted by Den1923

to be fair in the accounts it does state that investment in the team is an important part of the clubs strategy to avoid relegation and I think people are rightly saying that have not been happening and would like to know why?

This is a fair enough question/point. Parish has persistently insisted the ground redevelopment monies are ringfenced and in no way linked to the transfer fund nor day to day running costs. If this is indeed the case you have to wonder why Palace have not spent hardly any money but saved on wages with the release of out of contract players as well as brought in 45m from the sale of AWB. And before anyone says targets value goes up when their club know its us because we have the AWB money that is complete rubbish. Clubs will always get what they can for their players regardless of how much money the buying club may or may not have to spend. Its a weak and lame excuse trotted out by an out of his depth Freedman that thinks comments like that pull the wool over fans eys.
Bottom line: If we wanted to sign players in the summer we would have.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 18 Sep 19 9.24am

Originally posted by est1905

This is a fair enough question/point. Parish has persistently insisted the ground redevelopment monies are ringfenced and in no way linked to the transfer fund nor day to day running costs. If this is indeed the case you have to wonder why Palace have not spent hardly any money but saved on wages with the release of out of contract players as well as brought in 45m from the sale of AWB. And before anyone says targets value goes up when their club know its us because we have the AWB money that is complete rubbish. Clubs will always get what they can for their players regardless of how much money the buying club may or may not have to spend. Its a weak and lame excuse trotted out by an out of his depth Freedman that thinks comments like that pull the wool over fans eys.
Bottom line: If we wanted to sign players in the summer we would have.

Cahill, Camarsa and McCarthy were signed in the summer, do you think they play for nothing, any wages saved on players released has been used to pay them.
Did you not realise we had signed them in the summer? Your post indicates you didn’t.

 

cpj Flag Kent 18 Sep 19 9.33am

Originally posted by Painter

Cahill, Camarsa and McCarthy were signed in the summer, do you think they play for nothing, any wages saved on players released has been used to pay them.
Did you not realise we had signed them in the summer? Your post indicates you didn’t.

I think the point is that to most fans those weren't the positions we needed to be getting people in for. We needed a decent striker and 2 full-backs - we got none of those (I still don't count Ayew in that). Camarasa and McCarthy look like they will be squad members at best even though Roy had been after the latter for ages.

 

Page 35 of 91 < 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread