You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher
November 19 2026 6.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Margaret Thatcher


Page 36 of 76 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >
SpikeyMatt Flag Fishing for condiments 10 Apr 13 3.51pm

Quote The Sash at 10 Apr 2013 3.33pm

Quote SpikeyMatt at 10 Apr 2013 3.21pm

I think we've now reached the thread's Thatcheration point.

Three days and thats the best you can come up with


I'm out of my depth on this thread so here's a picture of a an inbred cat.

cat bread rawr.jpg Attachment: cat bread rawr.jpg (37.33Kb)

 


Twitter!

Justin Bieber: the singing amoeba

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Apr 13 3.53pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Apr 2013 3.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 3.24pm

Why, the teachers pension fund is in rude health.

It seems like people have run out of good things to say about Thatch, seeing as this has turned into a have a go at Gusset fest.
Poor debating skills and a lack of arguments always leads to personal attacks I've found.


That sums up all your posts for weeks now sunshine.

It wasn't a personal attack either on your pension, it was what should apply to all public pensions.

I wasn't referring to the pensions remark, it was the earlier stuff.

 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 10 Apr 13 4.09pm

Anyone else going to her funeral on the 17th ?..........just me then.

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 Apr 13 4.13pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 11.55am

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 7.54am

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 11.38pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 10.56pm

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 10.11pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 8.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2013 6.26pm

Quote Willo at 09 Apr 2013 6.23pm

Quote

If you didnt know who she was but saw the list of 'anti's' getting their two penneth in over her corpse then you would have a natural instinct to be on her side purely because of the odious collection lining up

I ask - Where does it come from, this vitriloic loathing? Anti-Thatcherites tell you that it’s because she closed down the old industries. (She didn’t, of course, she simply stopped obliging everyone else to support them.)

Yet it must surely be patently obvious by now that nothing would have kept the dockyards and coalmines and steel mills open. A similar process of de-industrialisation has unfolded in every other Western European country, and the only parties that still talk of “reviving our manufacturing base” are Respect, the Scottish Socialists and the BNP !!!!

RIP

Willo


Its not so much the closing down, its the manner in which they were closed down, and the population, few of whom voted conservative, were just left to deal with the fact that employment was ripped out almost overnight, leaving hundreds chasing single jobs.



Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit ofNorth Sea oil and gas?


Simply untrue! Although some exploration of oil and gas fields went on from 60s, the Brent field in UK waters wasn't even discovered until 1971, and the first oil wasn't pumped (at a relatively modest level initially) from the Argyl field until 1975. Revenue from the taxation of oil commenced in a significant way from 1980 onwards.

The revenue from oil and the proceeds of privatisations could have been used b Hesletine to regenerate the country, but were instead used to fund income tax cuts for the higher paid instead.

Edited by Moose (09 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


West Sole came onstream in 1967.


The income to the exchequer from West Sole was insignificant, as was the amount of gas it produced. Oil and gas revenues from licensing and taxation only made any difference from 1980 onward.


The comment was that what I'd said was simply untrue, it was not untrue at all, and my point stands.


The key word in your post is "benefit". I would suggest that it is untrue to say that we had the "benefit" of north sea oil and gas.

There were in the 60's and 70's no actual material benefits of north sea oil and gas for the UK. Oil wasn't produced in any quantities as the technology for doing so at the depth of the north sea was in it's infancy, and many many lives were lost in securing what little production there was on line at that time.

Gas was being produced in greater quantity, but as almost all gas appliances had to be converted to be able to use natural gas at great cost, and relatively few people had gas central heating at that time, the benefits to consumers and the exchequer were, at best,at the margin.


I didn't say material benefit, I said benefit.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Apr 13 4.30pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Apr 2013 3.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 3.13pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 Apr 2013 3.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 10.35am

I don't want to pay for her funeral.


A lot of people don't want to pay for your pension.

Terms an conditions of employment. If you want me to sort out my own pension, give me a pay rise commensurate with the payments. Or don't you think those that work for the public should be looked after in old age?
Anyway, yer changing the subject.

Just heard Milliband, what a wormy c***, he should be unleashing the wrath on behalf of the millions who will never forgive her.

You should get the same state pension as the rest of us and your own personal plan if you want it.

People who signed a contracted work pension plan should get what was contracted. Its not their fault that the assorted employers got it wrong.

Same with salary, if I signed a contract for x amount a year, they shouldn't be pressred into accepting less because other people have f**Ked up.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Apr 13 4.33pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 10 Apr 2013 4.09pm

Anyone else going to her funeral on the 17th ?..........just me then.

And about 10,000 riot cops, two dissident IRA groups. I'm thinking I might go.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 Apr 13 4.34pm

Quote Willo at 10 Apr 2013 1.57pm

Quote Jimenez
.....awaits link from The Ciabatta Bread famine of Chislehurst circa 1987....

I used to enjoy many a good wine and beer in Chislehurst in the 80s and 90s at the 'Bull' and 'Tigers Head' Also frequented the 'Sydney Arms' on a few occasions.



And the Rambler's - tv guys used to show up on budget day to gauge views on the penny on a pint.

 

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 10 Apr 13 4.36pm

Quote Bin Liner at 08 Apr 2013 9.32pm

Quote rednblue4eva at 08 Apr 2013 8.43pm

I was on a safety course at work & to give us something to think about the trainer said there are hundreds of men who owe their lives to Maggie

When asked how he pointed out the death rate of miners was hundreds a year, she closed the mines so the miners didn't die

They have no jobs but are still alive


a plain daft statement, might as well commend a prime minister who outlaws the motor vehicle

Edited by Bin Liner (08 Apr 2013 9.34pm)

He used it to show how you can put a "spin" on anything - daft, but correct

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Apr 13 4.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 Apr 2013 3.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 10.35am

I don't want to pay for her funeral.


A lot of people don't want to pay for your pension.

Its not what she'd have wanted surely. If Thatcher was about one thing it was cutting the costs of state and public waste.

Surely its an insult to have the state pay for the funeral of a woman who embodied the idea of individal provision and utilisation of the public sector.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 10 Apr 13 4.41pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Apr 2013 2.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 2.25pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 2.21pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 2.20pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 2.16pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Apr 2013 2.06pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 2.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Apr 2013 2.02pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 1.59pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 1.54pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 10 Apr 2013 1.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 1.46pm

Quote Willo at 10 Apr 2013 1.44pm

Quote DanH

You're quoting the Mail and saying the Beeb is biased?

The BBC should of course be impartial.
In many of the television and radio news bulletins it appeared that Margret Thatcher was on trial and the case for the prosecution was gathering force.


To show Thatcher was anything other than a bitchc*** would be biased.


link?


.....awaits link from The Ciabatta Bread famine of Chislehurst circa 1987....

Was there? Pray tell me about it Quentin Crisp.


Nick - I can't really be bothered to read all of this but do you really live in the 'workers paradise' of Chislehurst?


Indeed Matt...


That is one of the funniest things I have ever read on this site.

Yep, I got a key worker grant towards my mortgage. Thanks Tony.
Is there a problem with a socialist living in a Tory area?


No not at all. I wouldn't mind one of these though...http://www.chislehurst.co.uk/property/#/requested_page=1&sort_order=ASC&sort_by=price&i=1


Apologies

[Link]


Nice gaffs. Way outta my league, my house cost about a tenth of the value of those...
No old money in the Hurst...


It's absolutely effing hilarious.

You, berating Thatcher and the Tory's, yet adopting Tory values and taking what you can in 'leg ups' in order to join the aspirational classes.

Enjoy your trip to Chiselhurst Strada.


Nick Gusset speaks up for the working class and extols the virtues of immigration, (old) Labour and yet he lives in an extremely middle class, white, Tory area.

Practise what you preach mate! Or is living in somewhere like Penge too working class and diverse for you?

Also Nick lives in an ex-council house, however he has admitted in the past that he feels bad about that. A legacy from Thatcher's 'right to buy' scheme. Would he be able to live in such a nice area otherwise??

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 10 Apr 13 4.42pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Apr 2013 4.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 Apr 2013 3.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 10.35am

I don't want to pay for her funeral.


A lot of people don't want to pay for your pension.

Its not what she'd have wanted surely. If Thatcher was about one thing it was cutting the costs of state and public waste.

Surely its an insult to have the state pay for the funeral of a woman who embodied the idea of individal provision and utilisation of the public sector.


You are right. From what I have read, neither Thatcher or her two kids wanted this.

 

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 10 Apr 13 4.49pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.13pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 11.55am

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 7.54am

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 11.38pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 10.56pm

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 10.11pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 8.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2013 6.26pm

Quote Willo at 09 Apr 2013 6.23pm

Quote

If you didnt know who she was but saw the list of 'anti's' getting their two penneth in over her corpse then you would have a natural instinct to be on her side purely because of the odious collection lining up

I ask - Where does it come from, this vitriloic loathing? Anti-Thatcherites tell you that it’s because she closed down the old industries. (She didn’t, of course, she simply stopped obliging everyone else to support them.)

Yet it must surely be patently obvious by now that nothing would have kept the dockyards and coalmines and steel mills open. A similar process of de-industrialisation has unfolded in every other Western European country, and the only parties that still talk of “reviving our manufacturing base” are Respect, the Scottish Socialists and the BNP !!!!

RIP

Willo


Its not so much the closing down, its the manner in which they were closed down, and the population, few of whom voted conservative, were just left to deal with the fact that employment was ripped out almost overnight, leaving hundreds chasing single jobs.



Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit ofNorth Sea oil and gas?


Simply untrue! Although some exploration of oil and gas fields went on from 60s, the Brent field in UK waters wasn't even discovered until 1971, and the first oil wasn't pumped (at a relatively modest level initially) from the Argyl field until 1975. Revenue from the taxation of oil commenced in a significant way from 1980 onwards.

The revenue from oil and the proceeds of privatisations could have been used b Hesletine to regenerate the country, but were instead used to fund income tax cuts for the higher paid instead.

Edited by Moose (09 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


West Sole came onstream in 1967.


The income to the exchequer from West Sole was insignificant, as was the amount of gas it produced. Oil and gas revenues from licensing and taxation only made any difference from 1980 onward.


The comment was that what I'd said was simply untrue, it was not untrue at all, and my point stands.


The key word in your post is "benefit". I would suggest that it is untrue to say that we had the "benefit" of north sea oil and gas.

There were in the 60's and 70's no actual material benefits of north sea oil and gas for the UK. Oil wasn't produced in any quantities as the technology for doing so at the depth of the north sea was in it's infancy, and many many lives were lost in securing what little production there was on line at that time.

Gas was being produced in greater quantity, but as almost all gas appliances had to be converted to be able to use natural gas at great cost, and relatively few people had gas central heating at that time, the benefits to consumers and the exchequer were, at best,at the margin.


I didn't say material benefit, I said benefit.


So it was an immaterial benefit? Doesn't sound very useful, does it?

 


I used to be immortal

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 Apr 13 4.53pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 4.49pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.13pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 11.55am

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 7.54am

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 11.38pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 10.56pm

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 10.11pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 8.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2013 6.26pm

Quote Willo at 09 Apr 2013 6.23pm

Quote

If you didnt know who she was but saw the list of 'anti's' getting their two penneth in over her corpse then you would have a natural instinct to be on her side purely because of the odious collection lining up

I ask - Where does it come from, this vitriloic loathing? Anti-Thatcherites tell you that it’s because she closed down the old industries. (She didn’t, of course, she simply stopped obliging everyone else to support them.)

Yet it must surely be patently obvious by now that nothing would have kept the dockyards and coalmines and steel mills open. A similar process of de-industrialisation has unfolded in every other Western European country, and the only parties that still talk of “reviving our manufacturing base” are Respect, the Scottish Socialists and the BNP !!!!

RIP

Willo


Its not so much the closing down, its the manner in which they were closed down, and the population, few of whom voted conservative, were just left to deal with the fact that employment was ripped out almost overnight, leaving hundreds chasing single jobs.



Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit ofNorth Sea oil and gas?


Simply untrue! Although some exploration of oil and gas fields went on from 60s, the Brent field in UK waters wasn't even discovered until 1971, and the first oil wasn't pumped (at a relatively modest level initially) from the Argyl field until 1975. Revenue from the taxation of oil commenced in a significant way from 1980 onwards.

The revenue from oil and the proceeds of privatisations could have been used b Hesletine to regenerate the country, but were instead used to fund income tax cuts for the higher paid instead.

Edited by Moose (09 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


West Sole came onstream in 1967.


The income to the exchequer from West Sole was insignificant, as was the amount of gas it produced. Oil and gas revenues from licensing and taxation only made any difference from 1980 onward.


The comment was that what I'd said was simply untrue, it was not untrue at all, and my point stands.


The key word in your post is "benefit". I would suggest that it is untrue to say that we had the "benefit" of north sea oil and gas.

There were in the 60's and 70's no actual material benefits of north sea oil and gas for the UK. Oil wasn't produced in any quantities as the technology for doing so at the depth of the north sea was in it's infancy, and many many lives were lost in securing what little production there was on line at that time.

Gas was being produced in greater quantity, but as almost all gas appliances had to be converted to be able to use natural gas at great cost, and relatively few people had gas central heating at that time, the benefits to consumers and the exchequer were, at best,at the margin.


I didn't say material benefit, I said benefit.


So it was an immaterial benefit? Doesn't sound very useful, does it?


Why are you spinning what I said? West Sole gas came onstream in 1967.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Apr 13 4.55pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 10 Apr 2013 4.41pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Apr 2013 2.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 2.25pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 2.21pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 2.20pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 2.16pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Apr 2013 2.06pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 2.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Apr 2013 2.02pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 1.59pm

Quote Jimenez at 10 Apr 2013 1.54pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 10 Apr 2013 1.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Apr 2013 1.46pm

Quote Willo at 10 Apr 2013 1.44pm

Quote DanH

You're quoting the Mail and saying the Beeb is biased?

The BBC should of course be impartial.
In many of the television and radio news bulletins it appeared that Margret Thatcher was on trial and the case for the prosecution was gathering force.


To show Thatcher was anything other than a bitchc*** would be biased.


link?


.....awaits link from The Ciabatta Bread famine of Chislehurst circa 1987....

Was there? Pray tell me about it Quentin Crisp.


Nick - I can't really be bothered to read all of this but do you really live in the 'workers paradise' of Chislehurst?


Indeed Matt...


That is one of the funniest things I have ever read on this site.

Yep, I got a key worker grant towards my mortgage. Thanks Tony.
Is there a problem with a socialist living in a Tory area?


No not at all. I wouldn't mind one of these though...http://www.chislehurst.co.uk/property/#/requested_page=1&sort_order=ASC&sort_by=price&i=1


Apologies

[Link]


Nice gaffs. Way outta my league, my house cost about a tenth of the value of those...
No old money in the Hurst...


It's absolutely effing hilarious.

You, berating Thatcher and the Tory's, yet adopting Tory values and taking what you can in 'leg ups' in order to join the aspirational classes.

Enjoy your trip to Chiselhurst Strada.


Nick Gusset speaks up for the working class and extols the virtues of immigration, (old) Labour and yet he lives in an extremely middle class, white, Tory area.

Practise what you preach mate! Or is living in somewhere like Penge too working class and diverse for you?

Also Nick lives in an ex-council house, however he has admitted in the past that he feels bad about that. A legacy from Thatcher's 'right to buy' scheme. Would he be able to live in such a nice area otherwise??

I'd say about 25% of the residents on my street are what you'd term middle class. The rest are as working class as they come. Most of the street is still owned by housing associations.

Clearly you think that I should live in a commune, rather than a suburb.

I moved here because it was cheaper than renting in Brockley and because I wanted a nice place for my kids to grow up. In an ideal world I'd rather be living somewhere with an affordable rent, but alas I took what was the most viable option.
Once again, you are engaging in personal digs, rather than sticking to the point of the topic, which is how much of a bitch Thatcher was to the nation.


Edited by nickgusset (10 Apr 2013 4.57pm)

 

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 10 Apr 13 5.00pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.53pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 4.49pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.13pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 11.55am

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 7.54am

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 11.38pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 10.56pm

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 10.11pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 8.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2013 6.26pm

Quote Willo at 09 Apr 2013 6.23pm

Quote

If you didnt know who she was but saw the list of 'anti's' getting their two penneth in over her corpse then you would have a natural instinct to be on her side purely because of the odious collection lining up

I ask - Where does it come from, this vitriloic loathing? Anti-Thatcherites tell you that it’s because she closed down the old industries. (She didn’t, of course, she simply stopped obliging everyone else to support them.)

Yet it must surely be patently obvious by now that nothing would have kept the dockyards and coalmines and steel mills open. A similar process of de-industrialisation has unfolded in every other Western European country, and the only parties that still talk of “reviving our manufacturing base” are Respect, the Scottish Socialists and the BNP !!!!

RIP

Willo


Its not so much the closing down, its the manner in which they were closed down, and the population, few of whom voted conservative, were just left to deal with the fact that employment was ripped out almost overnight, leaving hundreds chasing single jobs.



Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit ofNorth Sea oil and gas?


Simply untrue! Although some exploration of oil and gas fields went on from 60s, the Brent field in UK waters wasn't even discovered until 1971, and the first oil wasn't pumped (at a relatively modest level initially) from the Argyl field until 1975. Revenue from the taxation of oil commenced in a significant way from 1980 onwards.

The revenue from oil and the proceeds of privatisations could have been used b Hesletine to regenerate the country, but were instead used to fund income tax cuts for the higher paid instead.

Edited by Moose (09 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


West Sole came onstream in 1967.


The income to the exchequer from West Sole was insignificant, as was the amount of gas it produced. Oil and gas revenues from licensing and taxation only made any difference from 1980 onward.


The comment was that what I'd said was simply untrue, it was not untrue at all, and my point stands.


The key word in your post is "benefit". I would suggest that it is untrue to say that we had the "benefit" of north sea oil and gas.

There were in the 60's and 70's no actual material benefits of north sea oil and gas for the UK. Oil wasn't produced in any quantities as the technology for doing so at the depth of the north sea was in it's infancy, and many many lives were lost in securing what little production there was on line at that time.

Gas was being produced in greater quantity, but as almost all gas appliances had to be converted to be able to use natural gas at great cost, and relatively few people had gas central heating at that time, the benefits to consumers and the exchequer were, at best,at the margin.


I didn't say material benefit, I said benefit.


So it was an immaterial benefit? Doesn't sound very useful, does it?


Why are you spinning what I said? West Sole gas came onstream in 1967.


And Dover Sole are available in my local fishmongers, so what?

I'm saying that north sea oil and gas provided little or no benefit to the UK until 1980. To say we had a "benefit" suggests that the exchequer received a positive inflow of revenue or that the people of the UK had a readily available source of cheap energy, neither of which are remotely true. That isn't spin, it's fact.

 


I used to be immortal

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 10 Apr 13 5.04pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.53pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 4.49pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.13pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 11.55am

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 7.54am

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 11.38pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 10.56pm

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 10.11pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 8.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2013 6.26pm

Quote Willo at 09 Apr 2013 6.23pm

Quote

If you didnt know who she was but saw the list of 'anti's' getting their two penneth in over her corpse then you would have a natural instinct to be on her side purely because of the odious collection lining up

I ask - Where does it come from, this vitriloic loathing? Anti-Thatcherites tell you that it’s because she closed down the old industries. (She didn’t, of course, she simply stopped obliging everyone else to support them.)

Yet it must surely be patently obvious by now that nothing would have kept the dockyards and coalmines and steel mills open. A similar process of de-industrialisation has unfolded in every other Western European country, and the only parties that still talk of “reviving our manufacturing base” are Respect, the Scottish Socialists and the BNP !!!!

RIP

Willo


Its not so much the closing down, its the manner in which they were closed down, and the population, few of whom voted conservative, were just left to deal with the fact that employment was ripped out almost overnight, leaving hundreds chasing single jobs.



Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit ofNorth Sea oil and gas?


Simply untrue! Although some exploration of oil and gas fields went on from 60s, the Brent field in UK waters wasn't even discovered until 1971, and the first oil wasn't pumped (at a relatively modest level initially) from the Argyl field until 1975. Revenue from the taxation of oil commenced in a significant way from 1980 onwards.

The revenue from oil and the proceeds of privatisations could have been used b Hesletine to regenerate the country, but were instead used to fund income tax cuts for the higher paid instead.

Edited by Moose (09 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


West Sole came onstream in 1967.


The income to the exchequer from West Sole was insignificant, as was the amount of gas it produced. Oil and gas revenues from licensing and taxation only made any difference from 1980 onward.


The comment was that what I'd said was simply untrue, it was not untrue at all, and my point stands.


The key word in your post is "benefit". I would suggest that it is untrue to say that we had the "benefit" of north sea oil and gas.

There were in the 60's and 70's no actual material benefits of north sea oil and gas for the UK. Oil wasn't produced in any quantities as the technology for doing so at the depth of the north sea was in it's infancy, and many many lives were lost in securing what little production there was on line at that time.

Gas was being produced in greater quantity, but as almost all gas appliances had to be converted to be able to use natural gas at great cost, and relatively few people had gas central heating at that time, the benefits to consumers and the exchequer were, at best,at the margin.


I didn't say material benefit, I said benefit.


So it was an immaterial benefit? Doesn't sound very useful, does it?


Why are you spinning what I said? West Sole gas came onstream in 1967.


What year did R Sole gas come online anyone know ??

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 10 Apr 13 5.08pm

Glenda Jackson's ranting in the Commons - what a truly awful person!

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

teejay61 Flag The Cup of Sid 10 Apr 13 5.08pm

Wow

60 pages of HOL "banter" on Mrs T

The Iron Lady must be laughing her wotsits off

 


Supporting the mighty CPFC since September 1971

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 Apr 13 5.19pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 5.00pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.53pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 4.49pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 4.13pm

Quote crystal balls at 10 Apr 2013 11.55am

Quote chris123 at 10 Apr 2013 7.54am

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 11.38pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 10.56pm

Quote crystal balls at 09 Apr 2013 10.11pm

Quote chris123 at 09 Apr 2013 8.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2013 6.26pm

Quote Willo at 09 Apr 2013 6.23pm

Quote

If you didnt know who she was but saw the list of 'anti's' getting their two penneth in over her corpse then you would have a natural instinct to be on her side purely because of the odious collection lining up

I ask - Where does it come from, this vitriloic loathing? Anti-Thatcherites tell you that it’s because she closed down the old industries. (She didn’t, of course, she simply stopped obliging everyone else to support them.)

Yet it must surely be patently obvious by now that nothing would have kept the dockyards and coalmines and steel mills open. A similar process of de-industrialisation has unfolded in every other Western European country, and the only parties that still talk of “reviving our manufacturing base” are Respect, the Scottish Socialists and the BNP !!!!

RIP

Willo


Its not so much the closing down, its the manner in which they were closed down, and the population, few of whom voted conservative, were just left to deal with the fact that employment was ripped out almost overnight, leaving hundreds chasing single jobs.



Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit ofNorth Sea oil and gas?


Simply untrue! Although some exploration of oil and gas fields went on from 60s, the Brent field in UK waters wasn't even discovered until 1971, and the first oil wasn't pumped (at a relatively modest level initially) from the Argyl field until 1975. Revenue from the taxation of oil commenced in a significant way from 1980 onwards.

The revenue from oil and the proceeds of privatisations could have been used b Hesletine to regenerate the country, but were instead used to fund income tax cuts for the higher paid instead.

Edited by Moose (09 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


West Sole came onstream in 1967.


The income to the exchequer from West Sole was insignificant, as was the amount of gas it produced. Oil and gas revenues from licensing and taxation only made any difference from 1980 onward.


The comment was that what I'd said was simply untrue, it was not untrue at all, and my point stands.


The key word in your post is "benefit". I would suggest that it is untrue to say that we had the "benefit" of north sea oil and gas.

There were in the 60's and 70's no actual material benefits of north sea oil and gas for the UK. Oil wasn't produced in any quantities as the technology for doing so at the depth of the north sea was in it's infancy, and many many lives were lost in securing what little production there was on line at that time.

Gas was being produced in greater quantity, but as almost all gas appliances had to be converted to be able to use natural gas at great cost, and relatively few people had gas central heating at that time, the benefits to consumers and the exchequer were, at best,at the margin.


I didn't say material benefit, I said benefit.


So it was an immaterial benefit? Doesn't sound very useful, does it?


Why are you spinning what I said? West Sole gas came onstream in 1967.


And Dover Sole are available in my local fishmongers, so what?

I'm saying that north sea oil and gas provided little or no benefit to the UK until 1980. To say we had a "benefit" suggests that the exchequer received a positive inflow of revenue or that the people of the UK had a readily available source of cheap energy, neither of which are remotely true. That isn't spin, it's fact.

This is what I said

"Uneconomic pits have routinely closed since the war, why should uneconomic mining be subsidised when no other industry was, and when from the 1960's we had the benefit of North Sea oil and gas?"

Is there anything factually inaccurate in that?

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 10 Apr 13 5.19pm

Public money to cover approx Ł10M of security for her funeral.
In these times of austerity, the tories can spunk money away with the best of them.

and her son is "SIR Mark Thatcher". How the fck did that knighthood happen. ?
A man involved in arms deals and alleged organising of military coups,...now thought to be developing property in Spain. Dodgy fcker

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Page 36 of 76 < 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher