You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 37 of 71 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 11 Nov 18 6.58am

If we stay up and if the ULTRAS return next season behind the goal then we will have amongst the loudest ground in London.
As I understand it, the Ultras will be at the back of the Lower so what about the banners etc? How is that going to work? We need them down the front.

 

bicycle repair man 11 Nov 18 9.07am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I thought you said you are not into the singing.!!



Oh dear,more fake news, I've never said any such thing.
But I am against Palace fans who've been going to Selhurst Park all their life,being treated like rubbish.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 11 Nov 18 3.34pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I was ill so couldn’t go so I watched it on telly. Our fans were brilliant made so much noise and the commentators kept commenting on us too. To be fair Spurs fans were loud too.

From block C in the Holmesdale it is was poor sadly, apart from the 10 mins before half time. As for the Spurs fans, it certainly didn’t carry to the Holmesdale until after they scored. At least there are quieter fans than ours which is a positive! If our other fans could step up, the HF wouldn’t be missed.

As for the step in drummer, fair play for giving it a go, however needs to get some variety and be more persistent.

Decent performance yesterday considering no Wilf. Didn’t deserve to lose.

 

timbob Flag 11 Nov 18 6.49pm

How is this still a thread ??

Why are we at the beck n call for less than 100 chavs?

We all need to get behind the team n get on our feet n shout loud for palace

As real supporters let’s not rely on a few let’s get up n at em !

Theres a lot of real good ‘family’ proper supporters at this club I’m sure we can pull the atmosphere around without the need of a few immature divas

Please don’t refer to them as ‘ultras’

‘Ultras ‘ are committed and passionate fans who stick with their team through thick or thin

Take up my challenge n show yourselves again next game if you think you can sing loud enough

R.I.P dear Staffie thoughts with you this day of remembrance

Coyp

Edited by timbob (11 Nov 2018 8.27pm)

 

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 11 Nov 18 8.34pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

No. The club is creating a singing section.
Just like they moved people to move the away fans.
Just like they moved people out of the executive seats
Just like they moved people for the gantry
Just like they made the whitehorse a family stand.

The club are making a change to quadruple (???) the amount of singers, hoping it will have a knock on effect to the rest of the stand.

Its a progressive change, it's a new initiative. People are having to move and lets all hope they get looked after, I know I wouldn't be happy of course, but in big changes people will be affected.
Let's just hope it is successful and makes Selhurst a positive place next season.

Edited by Dean_CPFC (10 Nov 2018 12.36pm)

And none of those were fair and all of them sadly ended up with some long term supporters/Season Ticket holders not coming to games anymore.

It's not being moved out of my seat to create a singing section that makes me angry. That'd be a bit annoying but I'd get it.

It's being moved from one of the best views in the Lower Holmesdale (because, you know, I go to watch the football) to what is undoubtedly going to be a worse view because all the other decent seats are already taken.

And for some around me, those who have sat in the same seats for 20 years and have a community around them, they are now older, more vulnerable, less good and coping with change, and have said that they will probably now just stop coming. So sad.

And no, they are NOT being looked after by the club.

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

bicycle repair man 11 Nov 18 10.15pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

And none of those were fair and all of them sadly ended up with some long term supporters/Season Ticket holders not coming to games anymore.

It's not being moved out of my seat to create a singing section that makes me angry. That'd be a bit annoying but I'd get it.

It's being moved from one of the best views in the Lower Holmesdale (because, you know, I go to watch the football) to what is undoubtedly going to be a worse view because all the other decent seats are already taken.

And for some around me, those who have sat in the same seats for 20 years and have a community around them, they are now older, more vulnerable, less good and coping with change, and have said that they will probably now just stop coming. So sad.

And no, they are NOT being looked after by the club.


What sad ,totally unnecessary mess.
It's crazy,a singing section ?
Surely the whole ground is a singing section.
Who qualifies for a ticket in the "singing section" ?
Are they holding auditions ?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Nov 18 10.16pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

And none of those were fair and all of them sadly ended up with some long term supporters/Season Ticket holders not coming to games anymore.

It's not being moved out of my seat to create a singing section that makes me angry. That'd be a bit annoying but I'd get it.

It's being moved from one of the best views in the Lower Holmesdale (because, you know, I go to watch the football) to what is undoubtedly going to be a worse view because all the other decent seats are already taken.

And for some around me, those who have sat in the same seats for 20 years and have a community around them, they are now older, more vulnerable, less good and coping with change, and have said that they will probably now just stop coming. So sad.

And no, they are NOT being looked after by the club.

I was handed a piece of paper at the match yesterday recommending that I contact someone that is integrating the resistance. If anyone wants it please pm me.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Nov 18 10.17pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


What sad ,totally unnecessary mess.
It's crazy,a singing section ?
Surely the whole ground is a singing section.
Who qualifies for a ticket in the "singing section" ?
Are they holding auditions ?

Hopefully we shall know on the 20th.

 

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 12 Nov 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Mapletree

I was handed a piece of paper at the match yesterday recommending that I contact someone that is integrating the resistance. If anyone wants it please pm me.

Yep, that's us, trying to look after each other, because the club won't or can't.

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

RyWa Flag Beckenham 12 Nov 18 11.17am

I sit Block X of the Arthur and I will agree the atmosphere first half was a big improvement, I think the "Roy Hodgsons Reg & Blue Army" chant lasted a good 20mins getting louder each loop. Though the singing died off second half, even more so after the goal.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 12 Nov 18 11.35am

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

Yep, that's us, trying to look after each other, because the club won't or can't.

Thanks. I appreciated that and have completed the survey.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 12 Nov 18 4.00pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

This is a football forum dedicated to all things Crystal Palace and not many people (including myself) wish to debate news and politics here

Why don't you take some of your suggested medicine and debate properly yourself as stupid childish insults are the sign of someone losing an argument


You weren't so quick to judge when Mr repair man was calling me a bigot and an idiot, from pretty much my first reply to his little Englander rant. Ig your going to try and chastise me (lol) then I suggest you read back and see who is the real child in the piece.

And I have lost no argument, the ONLY thing I keep reading is "it's not fair" from apparently grown men about having to move seats FFS get a grip. It reads like an episode of Kevin and Perry on Harry Enfield and chums.

Furthermore any one who insinuates the atmosphere hasn't changed since the HF flounced is in utter denial, and for the record It pains me to have say this AGAIN (as I have clearly stated I don't agree with the petulant manner in which they flounced.) I do not agree with the HF's actions, but to say the atmosphere has not been affected is total and utter bulls***.

This is a football forum dedicated to all things Crystal Palace and not many people (including myself) wish to debate news and politics here

Wrong again I'm afraid, have a look across the top of the website when you log in, you will see a number of tabs including ones on news and politics, general talk and Gold talk. I merely pointed out that a thread on child abuse got less interest than this one (and continues to do so) which to me speaks volumes about peoples priorities, and how self indulgent those priorities have become, when a thread on having to move seats in a football ground, gets more hit/replies/interest (however you wish to express it) than a thread on the alarming figures in relation to the rise in child abuse and the organised gangs we now have perpetrating it.

It was a comparison to hopefully show that I think the whole thing (the singing section) is being taken way way way to seriously by some when there are much much more serious issues at hand.

But fine with me if you want to ignore it, as I said speaks volumes. The amount of indignation being flung about is utterly laughable, and I'm the one being called pathetic ??? youliterally couldn't make it up.


Edited by Dannyh.V2 (12 Nov 2018 4.01pm)

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 12 Nov 18 4.18pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

And none of those were fair and all of them sadly ended up with some long term supporters/Season Ticket holders not coming to games anymore.

I would argue that if something as trivial as moving seat makes you stop coming then are you really a fan of the club ?

It's not being moved out of my seat to create a singing section that makes me angry. That'd be a bit annoying but I'd get it.

Thank the Lord someone at last who gets it.


It's being moved from one of the best views in the Lower Holmesdale (because, you know, I go to watch the football) to what is undoubtedly going to be a worse view because all the other decent seats are already taken.

I spoke to soon LOL (only joking), however that is a bit presumptuous on your part as nothing has been set in stone to my Knowledge.


And for some around me, those who have sat in the same seats for 20 years and have a community around them, they are now older, more vulnerable, less good and coping with change, and have said that they will probably now just stop coming. So sad.

So far the only relevant argument I have read on here amongst all the teddy's being thrown and dummies being spat. The elderly and more vulnerable people who rely on the immediate fans around them for support will suffer and that is a crying shame, and yes I concede the club should be doing more for these people if they are to move them from their match day support network.

And no, they are NOT being looked after by the club.

I think where we have been a small family club for so long people have got used to having a close relationship with the club and it's management, but as clubs get bigger invariably that relationship changes sometimes for the good of the club, and not particularly the fans. SP is in a catch 22, the HF are clearly holding him to ransom ( that I do not agree with ) but without them the atmosphere is as shyte as the Emirates, Souless. So what does he do ? lose the Atmosphere that made us the pride of South London if not entire Premiership ? or put a few peoples noses out of joint in moving them ?

To me it's a no brainer, I'm not saying it's a nice thing to do, just that it has to happen if the atmosphere is to return to Selhurst.

The only other answer is for those people in the ground to create the Atmosphere themselves ?? But to date I have not seen any stand or block (including Block E) take up the challenge.

And may I thank you for coming up an actual reason for not wanting to move, other than the normal "it's not fair " whine.

 

bicycle repair man 12 Nov 18 5.48pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

Why don't you take some of your suggested medicine and debate properly yourself as stupid childish insults are the sign of someone losing an argument


You weren't so quick to judge when Mr repair man was calling me a bigot and an idiot, from pretty much my first reply to his little Englander rant. Ig your going to try and chastise me (lol) then I suggest you read back and see who is the real child in the piece.

And I have lost no argument, the ONLY thing I keep reading is "it's not fair" from apparently grown men about having to move seats FFS get a grip. It reads like an episode of Kevin and Perry on Harry Enfield and chums.

Furthermore any one who insinuates the atmosphere hasn't changed since the HF flounced is in utter denial, and for the record It pains me to have say this AGAIN (as I have clearly stated I don't agree with the petulant manner in which they flounced.) I do not agree with the HF's actions, but to say the atmosphere has not been affected is total and utter bulls***.

This is a football forum dedicated to all things Crystal Palace and not many people (including myself) wish to debate news and politics here

Wrong again I'm afraid, have a look across the top of the website when you log in, you will see a number of tabs including ones on news and politics, general talk and Gold talk. I merely pointed out that a thread on child abuse got less interest than this one (and continues to do so) which to me speaks volumes about peoples priorities, and how self indulgent those priorities have become, when a thread on having to move seats in a football ground, gets more hit/replies/interest (however you wish to express it) than a thread on the alarming figures in relation to the rise in child abuse and the organised gangs we now have perpetrating it.

It was a comparison to hopefully show that I think the whole thing (the singing section) is being taken way way way to seriously by some when there are much much more serious issues at hand.

But fine with me if you want to ignore it, as I said speaks volumes. The amount of indignation being flung about is utterly laughable, and I'm the one being called pathetic ??? youliterally couldn't make it up.


Edited by Dannyh.V2 (12 Nov 2018 4.01pm)


Hold on,more fake news.
It's true you are bigoted with your views, that's not name calling.
I certainly didn't have a "little Englander" rant, that's simply not true.
And I've never called anyone an idiot on this message board,not even you.
You need to be doing a little fact checking.
And why on Earth are you still going on about child abuse,on a thread devoted to matters Palace ?

Edited by bicycle repair man (12 Nov 2018 6.33pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Nov 18 9.05pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


C Hold on,more fake news.
O It's true you are bigoted with your views, that's not name
B calling.
L I certainly didn't have a "little Englander" rant, that's simply
E not true.
R And I've never called anyone an idiot on this message
S board,not even you.
You need to be doing a little fact checking.
And why on Earth are you still going on about child abuse,on a thread devoted to matters Palace ?

Edited by bicycle repair man (12 Nov 2018 6.33pm)

 


COYP

timbob Flag 12 Nov 18 9.58pm

This is getting v v childish now

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 13 Nov 18 8.56am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


Hold on,more fake news.

Where have mentioned any thing Fake or untrue ?

It's true you are bigoted with your views, that's not name calling.

Simply Don't know where to begin with slice of Fried gold.

I certainly didn't have a "little Englander" rant, that's simply not true.

Yes It is.

And I've never called anyone an idiot on this message board,not even you.

Apologies, you insinuated I was less than intelligent

You need to be doing a little fact checking.

Nope, no I don't, there a very little facts available with regards to the PROPOSED moving of fans to accommodate the HF

And why on Earth are you still going on about child abuse,on a thread devoted to matters Palace ?

I was drawing a comparison, would you like me to explain the big word for you ?


Still no valid or constructive argument I see. But apparently I'm the one losing the argument.

Edited by bicycle repair man (12 Nov 2018 6.33pm)

 

bicycle repair man 13 Nov 18 10.07am

Any future debate with you is pointless.
if anyone holds an opposing view,you react in a childishly aggressive, condescending manner.And often go completely off topic
all together.
To reinforce your argument you just make things up.
I'd love to see evidence of my mythical "little Englander rant".

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Nov 18 10.08am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I was drawing a comparison, would you like me to explain the big word for you ?

Have a care as you're walking a thin line

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Nov 18 10.18am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Any future debate with you is pointless.
if anyone holds an opposing view,you react in a childishly aggressive, condescending manner.And often go completely off topic
all together.
To reinforce your argument you just make things up.
I'd love to see evidence of my mythical "little Englander rant".

Look, instead of saying the same thing everyday, 10 times a day, why don’t you discuss the changes, say for instance, a full lower tier reset or no reset. Or how the fans are being treated before and after the changes, because those are what’s at stake. You may find you’re able to have an intelligent conversation about it with people on either side agreeing with you, including me, because I think the usual p1ss poor handling is derisory and insulting. Try it.

 


COYP

Page 37 of 71 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic