You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 37 of 44 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >
ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 03 Jan 19 10.28am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I don't hate Roy Hodgson, I actually back him as Palace's manager and think he's the right man for the job given the circumstances. I've commented previously on how the club is run, and how RH can be one dimensional. He hits his targets and has found his level.

I challenged the believe that he was a successful England manager. He wasn't. He was a disaster for the (as yet) unchallenged facts:

Harry Kane on corners
3 tournament game wins in 11 attempts
Iceland
World Cup 2014


He was unbeaten in all his qualifying games, why don't you loo0k at the records be spouting your nonsense "facts"

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 03 Jan 19 10.52am

Well one thing I do blame RH for is for the number of teams that have had their worst game of the season when playing us . Funny that .

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Jan 19 12.03pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Well one thing I do blame RH for is for the number of teams that have had their worst game of the season when playing us . Funny that .

Some have though haven’t they? Last season we were playing teams at the worst time, whereas Brighton were playing teams at the best time. Let’s be honest, Burnley, Leicester and Cardiff whonwe failed to score against were all pretty bad. Chelsea weren’t very good either where our last 10 minute effort wasn’t enough compared to vs Wolves and I wasn’t impressed with Wolves last night either. Sure against Man City we can heap praise on Roy’s tactics and use of the team but in all those others the opposition were poor, of that there’s no doubt. I’d take that all day long apart from that unless we start taking teams on more or looking for a win before 80 minutes we’ll be relying on the opposition being poor or poorer to people win the points, although I suppose that’s the thing. It worked v Wolves and not v Chelsea so that’s 3 points from those 2 and 1.5 points per game, which is how we were sometimes on the right side of these fine margins Roy plays. It worked wonders last season but this season it’s been frustrating, and you cannot deny that last night could easily have been 0-0 or 1-0 to them so he’s setting up to ride the fine margins and hopefully stay up. Music to Parish’ ears if he doesn’t quit if Parish doesn’t provide transfer funds, but very disappointing for fans who go to certain matches or see that the Chelsea match was there for a point plus a push for maybe 3 rather than very little endeavour and maybe a half chance.

It’s not pretty and it can work, but playing for that maybe chance carries risks and frustrates supporters no end to the point they start thinking is it worth being there if you can watch this kind of football and every game in your armchair.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Jan 19 12.09pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


He was unbeaten in all his qualifying games, why don't you loo0k at the records be spouting your nonsense "facts"

We are a 2nd tier nation now (we were a 1st) so we’ll often be the 2nd best team out of 4 in the group in tournaments. Therefore 3 tournament wins out of 11 is terrible and given we’re the best or 2nd best in bigger qualifying groups I expect us to have a good qualifying record. It’s not something to wear as a badge of honour. We can beat the lines of Leichtenstein and Andorra twice.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Jan 19 12.25pm

I wouldn’t be surprised if Parish has offended Roy an extension. Whether Roy wants it is another matter. Parish probably has no idea who our next manager shouldvor could be and probably neither do the ex players by his side.

 


COYP

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Jan 19 2.09pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I wouldn’t be surprised if Parish has offended Roy an extension. Whether Roy wants it is another matter. Parish probably has no idea who our next manager shouldvor could be and probably neither do the ex players by his side.

Probably several other people as well

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Jan 19 8.35pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Probably several other people as well

Gotta love predictive text sometimes.

 


COYP

pssguy Flag 03 Jan 19 9.14pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

The corner taking thing was a bit silly, but there's a lot to say about camaraderie and this helped Iceland hugely as it did with Southgate's campaign.

What helped Southgate's campaign was meagre opposition and a ridiculous media campaign.

Just a reminder that England lost twice to Belgium, once to Croatia, overcame Colombia on penalties and scored an extra time victory over Tunisia. It really was pretty unimpressive

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Jan 19 10.00pm

Originally posted by pssguy

What helped Southgate's campaign was meagre opposition and a ridiculous media campaign.

Just a reminder that England lost twice to Belgium, once to Croatia, overcame Colombia on penalties and scored an extra time victory over Tunisia. It really was pretty unimpressive

Yes I agree, but we certainly would not of been one game away from a final with any of our previous setups.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 03 Jan 19 10.33pm

Neither if they manage to bring in a quality striker this window. And a good no.10 would be nice, or even Moses.

 

rattus2002 Flag 04 Jan 19 1.52am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Some have though haven’t they? Last season we were playing teams at the worst time, whereas Brighton were playing teams at the best time. Let’s be honest, Burnley, Leicester and Cardiff whonwe failed to score against were all pretty bad. Chelsea weren’t very good either where our last 10 minute effort wasn’t enough compared to vs Wolves and I wasn’t impressed with Wolves last night either. Sure against Man City we can heap praise on Roy’s tactics and use of the team but in all those others the opposition were poor, of that there’s no doubt. I’d take that all day long apart from that unless we start taking teams on more or looking for a win before 80 minutes we’ll be relying on the opposition being poor or poorer to people win the points, although I suppose that’s the thing. It worked v Wolves and not v Chelsea so that’s 3 points from those 2 and 1.5 points per game, which is how we were sometimes on the right side of these fine margins Roy plays. It worked wonders last season but this season it’s been frustrating, and you cannot deny that last night could easily have been 0-0 or 1-0 to them so he’s setting up to ride the fine margins and hopefully stay up. Music to Parish’ ears if he doesn’t quit if Parish doesn’t provide transfer funds, but very disappointing for fans who go to certain matches or see that the Chelsea match was there for a point plus a push for maybe 3 rather than very little endeavour and maybe a half chance.

It’s not pretty and it can work, but playing for that maybe chance carries risks and frustrates supporters no end to the point they start thinking is it worth being there if you can watch this kind of football and every game in your armchair.

We’ve also played some good attacking stuff in some games and not been fully rewarded. Arsenal and spurs at home and Utd away could have easily yielded more points had we had a bit of luck or indeed a goal scorer. We certainly Didn’t setup just to stifle the opposition in those games and I wouldn’t say it was dull or boring. It’s impossible to play well every week, against Chelsea we had an off day and probably suffered from having played against a physical Cardiff side and chasing the ball continuously against a City team that move the ball so quickly.

The criticism from some quarters that the football is dull and boring seems a bit harsh to me. Under Roy we’ve played some of the best football I have ever seen at Selhurst. The end of last season in particular where some of the stuff we played was a delight.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 04 Jan 19 4.45am

Roy is the perfect yes man for Parish. At least for the next year or so we will have limited funds - what new manager would walk into that, having to utilize an inherited squad which hasn't really found its stride.

I see Roy staying with us until a big player will be sold, to create some cash flow and then a new bloke will be tempted to come in with 70-90 mil to spend.

 


This was once a quality forum....

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Jan 19 8.46am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Some have though haven’t they? Last season we were playing teams at the worst time, whereas Brighton were playing teams at the best time. Let’s be honest, Burnley, Leicester and Cardiff whonwe failed to score against were all pretty bad. Chelsea weren’t very good either where our last 10 minute effort wasn’t enough compared to vs Wolves and I wasn’t impressed with Wolves last night either. Sure against Man City we can heap praise on Roy’s tactics and use of the team but in all those others the opposition were poor, of that there’s no doubt. I’d take that all day long apart from that unless we start taking teams on more or looking for a win before 80 minutes we’ll be relying on the opposition being poor or poorer to people win the points, although I suppose that’s the thing. It worked v Wolves and not v Chelsea so that’s 3 points from those 2 and 1.5 points per game, which is how we were sometimes on the right side of these fine margins Roy plays. It worked wonders last season but this season it’s been frustrating, and you cannot deny that last night could easily have been 0-0 or 1-0 to them so he’s setting up to ride the fine margins and hopefully stay up. Music to Parish’ ears if he doesn’t quit if Parish doesn’t provide transfer funds, but very disappointing for fans who go to certain matches or see that the Chelsea match was there for a point plus a push for maybe 3 rather than very little endeavour and maybe a half chance.

It’s not pretty and it can work, but playing for that maybe chance carries risks and frustrates supporters no end to the point they start thinking is it worth being there if you can watch this kind of football and every game in your armchair.

Every team has bad days, such as when we played Chelsea we had an off day. However, it is possible our lacklustre display against Chelsea meant we had the energy to beat Wolves, whereas they spent all theirs beating Spurs.

What Roy does is make us competitive in most games we play. We have the fourth highest number of clean sheets in the league and were it not for misfiring strikers we would be comfortably higher. You can't blame him for the players failure to convert one of 31 chances against Cardiff, can you? When we play teams we're expected to beat we are on the front foot, when it's the other way round we look to counter. Would you do it differently? Chelsea aside we have created chances even against the top four and have achieved draws against Arsenal and Man Utd as well as running Spurs and Liverpool close.


Before we played them how many people thought we'd get 3 wins and a draw out of our last 5 games? Not many I imagine. If Roy's tactic is to somehow make other teams play badly I'll take that!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 04 Jan 19 10.31am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Every team has bad days, such as when we played Chelsea we had an off day. However, it is possible our lacklustre display against Chelsea meant we had the energy to beat Wolves, whereas they spent all theirs beating Spurs.

What Roy does is make us competitive in most games we play. We have the fourth highest number of clean sheets in the league and were it not for misfiring strikers we would be comfortably higher. You can't blame him for the players failure to convert one of 31 chances against Cardiff, can you? When we play teams we're expected to beat we are on the front foot, when it's the other way round we look to counter. Would you do it differently? Chelsea aside we have created chances even against the top four and have achieved draws against Arsenal and Man Utd as well as running Spurs and Liverpool close.


Before we played them how many people thought we'd get 3 wins and a draw out of our last 5 games? Not many I imagine. If Roy's tactic is to somehow make other teams play badly I'll take that!

People often say that we did well because the other side were terrible and do not understand that they were terrible purely because we disrupted their play, Chelsea disrupted our play! people need to get over it! ..we disrupted Wolves, we gave them no encouragement with the ball whatsoever.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 04 Jan 19 10.33am

..and that was down to our manager.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 04 Jan 19 10.36am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Every team has bad days, such as when we played Chelsea we had an off day. However, it is possible our lacklustre display against Chelsea meant we had the energy to beat Wolves, whereas they spent all theirs beating Spurs.

What Roy does is make us competitive in most games we play. We have the fourth highest number of clean sheets in the league and were it not for misfiring strikers we would be comfortably higher. You can't blame him for the players failure to convert one of 31 chances against Cardiff, can you? When we play teams we're expected to beat we are on the front foot, when it's the other way round we look to counter. Would you do it differently? Chelsea aside we have created chances even against the top four and have achieved draws against Arsenal and Man Utd as well as running Spurs and Liverpool close.

Before we played them how many people thought we'd get 3 wins and a draw out of our last 5 games? Not many I imagine. If Roy's tactic is to somehow make other teams play badly I'll take that!

Spot on. It drives me potty how we seem to crystallise every bad performance into signs of relegation and every good performance into signs of bad luck for the opposition.

What keeps us up, year on year, are these runs of 10 points in 5 games. Every year we have these runs of 10 games where we pick up next to nothing, but if we can get two or three runs of 5 games Wewhere we pick up 10 points then by the end of the season we have enough. Whether those runs come in the first half of the season (as in the Pardew season) or the last half (as in every other season) doesn’t really matter.

If you look at the last five games, the point against Cardiff was the other side of the coin to the win against Man City, and the win against Wolves was the other side of the coin to the defeat to Chelsea. In the round, we have enough points for this stage in the season.

You just need to look at the top of the Premier to see how things are moving forward. Compare the top 2 (Manchester City and Liverpool) in our first season back with the top 2 now (Manchester City and Liverpool) and see how they have moved forward. We are moving forward just by standing still.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 05 Jan 19 12.35pm

what are we blaming roy or steve for now? sitting nicely in 14th being above the point a game average?

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Jan 19 1.04pm

Positivity. I think that is what we want to see.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 06 Jan 19 12.34am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Every team has bad days, such as when we played Chelsea we had an off day. However, it is possible our lacklustre display against Chelsea meant we had the energy to beat Wolves, whereas they spent all theirs beating Spurs.

What Roy does is make us competitive in most games we play. We have the fourth highest number of clean sheets in the league and were it not for misfiring strikers we would be comfortably higher. You can't blame him for the players failure to convert one of 31 chances against Cardiff, can you? When we play teams we're expected to beat we are on the front foot, when it's the other way round we look to counter. Would you do it differently? Chelsea aside we have created chances even against the top four and have achieved draws against Arsenal and Man Utd as well as running Spurs and Liverpool close.


Before we played them how many people thought we'd get 3 wins and a draw out of our last 5 games? Not many I imagine. If Roy's tactic is to somehow make other teams play badly I'll take that!

I wouldn't disagree with the post but how much of that is down to hodgsons management or the fact his inherited a pretty decent team who can turn it on against anyone every now and then. The frustrating thing for me is we look just one click away from being a pretty decent team and that's down to Roy to make happen but he would rather play it safe knowing the quality we have will just be enough to see us alright. We've got the best defence outside the top 6 and we quite clearly have problems converting chances so how are we looking to improve this ?

We don't seem to be, there's no evolution in our game at all. When benteke was fit, he was played deeper with wilf playing off him and has never looked great as a striker and has always been so much more ineffective and isolated up top on his own. We just play so narrow. Townsend and zaha are just as bad as each other, one wants to take on the whole team and the other just wants to cut in and shoot between 4 defenders and a goalie 9 times out of 10 his shot being blocked. Zaha just seems to take on everyone out of frustration that there's no one good enough to pass to. How many times does wan bissaka overlap only to get ignored because Townsend decides to cut in again. Van aanholt doesn't even bother and just runs to the edge of the box hoping zaha might pass, the rare occasion he does it's always a short pass back to wilf, tho neither are the best at crossing but we don't even attempt to try and change or do anything different.

We can't score and the attitude seems to be oh well we will have just enough quality to stay up anyway. Great 2nd half of the season to watch.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Jan 19 8.32am

Originally posted by rikz

I wouldn't disagree with the post but how much of that is down to hodgsons management or the fact his inherited a pretty decent team who can turn it on against anyone every now and then. The frustrating thing for me is we look just one click away from being a pretty decent team and that's down to Roy to make happen but he would rather play it safe knowing the quality we have will just be enough to see us alright. We've got the best defence outside the top 6 and we quite clearly have problems converting chances so how are we looking to improve this ?

We don't seem to be, there's no evolution in our game at all. When benteke was fit, he was played deeper with wilf playing off him and has never looked great as a striker and has always been so much more ineffective and isolated up top on his own. We just play so narrow. Townsend and zaha are just as bad as each other, one wants to take on the whole team and the other just wants to cut in and shoot between 4 defenders and a goalie 9 times out of 10 his shot being blocked. Zaha just seems to take on everyone out of frustration that there's no one good enough to pass to. How many times does wan bissaka overlap only to get ignored because Townsend decides to cut in again. Van aanholt doesn't even bother and just runs to the edge of the box hoping zaha might pass, the rare occasion he does it's always a short pass back to wilf, tho neither are the best at crossing but we don't even attempt to try and change or do anything different.

We can't score and the attitude seems to be oh well we will have just enough quality to stay up anyway. Great 2nd half of the season to watch.


Blimey, you really really look for the negatives,are you saying that every single thing bad, or loss, mistake, it is all down to RH, but every win or good play is to the good players at his disposal. Poor Roy. he is really in a cant win situation, he is dammed if he does and dammed if he doesn't.

 

Page 37 of 44 < 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?