You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 38 of 65 < 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 >
Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 2.10pm

Originally posted by Willo

I only posed the question out of interest as the poster mentioned about some young managers and I was interested to find out if he had any in mind, thats all.

I am not sure about the relevance of the last question based on what I posted but then again I am cerebrally challenged !

Fair enough.

I just strongly disagree with people who claim someone is not allowed to say Roy is s*** without personally having his replacement lined up.

If that was my job and I worked at he club, then it would be a fair question.

Wolves and Soton spring to mind.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Apr 19 2.14pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Fair enough.

I just strongly disagree with people who claim someone is not allowed to say Roy is s*** without personally having his replacement lined up.

If that was my job and I worked at he club, then it would be a fair question.

Wolves and Soton spring to mind.

I recall then dispensing of the services of Nigel Adkins who did well for them and replacing him with some unknown called Pochettino who had left struggling Espanyol.Many thought that Cortese had taken leave of his senses - the rest as they say is history.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 2.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

I recall then dispensing of the services of Nigel Adkins who did well for them and replacing him with some unknown called Pochettino who had left struggling Espanyol.Many thought that Cortese had taken leave of his senses - the rest as they say is history.

Poch is the type of inspired managerial choice that is way out of Steve Parish’s league.

Sad but true.

The root of our inability to move on from being perennial relegation fodder is Parish and his poor decisions and limitations.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Apr 19 2.35pm

Originally posted by A89M

We lost Cabaye, RLC last season and never had a recognised striker until January 2019, whilst also spending very little in the transfer windows and Roy has kept us up for the first time without any real fear of the drop. We have created chance after chance at home, the stats suggest the most we have ever had since our time spent in the PL under Parish, beaten the champions on their own ground, gave the 2nd best team in the league a great game at Anfield, whilst playing attractive but tough to beat football and still fans want him gone.

We’re likely to lose Wilf and Wan Bissaka in the summer and I personally think Roy’s way of thinking would suit us perfectly to stabilise us during this transition. Calling for him to leave because he sticks to his organised, hard to beat formation of 442 is ridiculous. Subs could be used more often but honestly, our bench doesn’t scream games changers. We’ve played some of the best football I’ve seen in the PL under Roy even with his ‘negative’ tactics.

This strikes me of Ipswich last season, wanting rid of Mick McCarthy and look where they are now..

442? Who's our second striker then? Our main problem is that our lone striker is always so isolated he has little chance to do anything. You'd have thought at least once at some point on the last few games he would have played with 2 strikers. (And I don't mean shifting wilf inside). Would love to see benteke and bats being given a chance together - Huddersfield at home would have been the perfect chance.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 04 Apr 19 2.50pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Fair enough.

I just strongly disagree with people who claim someone is not allowed to say Roy is s*** without personally having his replacement lined up.

If that was my job and I worked at he club, then it would be a fair question.

Wolves and Soton spring to mind.

Southampton's new manager was featured recently on the BBC football site. Yes he has done a good job since he took over as in the 16 games since he did Saints have 24 points and, based on that over those 16 games Saints would be 7th in the league. However another team and manager matched that points total to be eighth in the EPL over those 16 games, his name being Roy Hodgson and, of course, the team being Crystal Palace.

Rather makes your statement that Roy is sh**e rather pathetic because, if you are right so is the Soton manager you keep eulogising about. So stick that in your pipe and smoke it.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

EddieMac Flag 04 Apr 19 3.09pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Southampton's new manager was featured recently on the BBC football site. Yes he has done a good job since he took over as in the 16 games since he did Saints have 24 points and, based on that over those 16 games Saints would be 7th in the league. However another team and manager matched that points total to be eighth in the EPL over those 16 games, his name being Roy Hodgson and, of course, the team being Crystal Palace.

Rather makes your statement that Roy is sh**e rather pathetic because, if you are right so is the Soton manager you keep eulogising about. So stick that in your pipe and smoke it.

Good man. Great post. I am sick and tired of people slating Roy and saying saints manager is great and Eddie Howe is great, Dyche is the marvelous, Wagner is top drawer. Have these fools no acccess to the league table.
We will finish where we deserve to finish at the end of the season and that wont be relegation.At this present moment the best we can ask for is between 10th to 14th.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 04 Apr 19 3.17pm

To all eagles saying if not Roy then who? Well how did other teams get progressive managers. Brighton. Watford. Wolves. Soton. If Roy is not retired it’s going to be the end of the distinct cpfc brand.
Roy did well to keep us up last season. We returned the favor by keeping him. Now it’s time to move on. In the premier league there is no such thing as mid table safety as a strategy. It will only lead to stagnation and eventual relegation. It’s an up or out competition.
“Everything has its effing time and place; It’s time now for Roy to GO”

 

EddieMac Flag 04 Apr 19 3.22pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

To all eagles saying if not Roy then who? Well how did other teams get progressive managers. Brighton. Watford. Wolves. Soton. If Roy is not retired it’s going to be the end of the distinct cpfc brand.
Roy did well to keep us up last season. We returned the favor by keeping him. Now it’s time to move on. In the premier league there is no such thing as mid table safety as a strategy. It will only lead to stagnation and eventual relegation. It’s an up or out competition.
“Everything has its effing time and place; It’s time now for Roy to GO”

A lot of folk thought FDB was a progessive manager. Chris Hughton is not a progressive manager he plays to his strenghts and his aim is to survive in the PL.

It is not Roy's fault that we have missed sitters in so many games and that our players can't pass the ball 10 yards. We should easily be at least 6 points better off this season which would put us level with West Ham in 11th.

Would that make everyone happy??

Id rather be us than Everton and West Ham who have spent an absolute fortune and are only sitting a few points ahead of us in the table.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 04 Apr 19 3.28pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

To all eagles saying if not Roy then who? Well how did other teams get progressive managers. Brighton. Watford. Wolves. Soton. If Roy is not retired it’s going to be the end of the distinct cpfc brand.
Roy did well to keep us up last season. We returned the favor by keeping him. Now it’s time to move on. In the premier league there is no such thing as mid table safety as a strategy. It will only lead to stagnation and eventual relegation. It’s an up or out competition.
“Everything has its effing time and place; It’s time now for Roy to GO”

You do know that Brighton are currently below us in the table and that Brighton fans are saying that they want Hughton out. You also do not seem to realise that Soton's record under their new Manager is no better than ours over the period since he came in and they' re still below us in the table.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 3.39pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Southampton's new manager was featured recently on the BBC football site. Yes he has done a good job since he took over as in the 16 games since he did Saints have 24 points and, based on that over those 16 games Saints would be 7th in the league. However another team and manager matched that points total to be eighth in the EPL over those 16 games, his name being Roy Hodgson and, of course, the team being Crystal Palace.

Rather makes your statement that Roy is sh**e rather pathetic because, if you are right so is the Soton manager you keep eulogising about. So stick that in your pipe and smoke it.

If you enjoy the Hodgson brand of football, good luck to you.

It is boring, gutless and turgid stuff half the time.

Our home form is a joke.

We played long ball yesterday to our worst target man/hold up player and had 1 shot on target in the entire game. We had no out ball.

This was evident early in proceedings, but he changed nothing.

After we went a goal down, he changed nothing.

Once we were 2 down, with 10 mins left, he had a go.

If you enjoy that/think its the best we can do, Penge Eagle, then I say good luck to you mate.

We can do better than this brand of football with these players. Am I willing to take a chance, get a manager in with some balls, and suffer relegation next year? At this stage, I sure am. Anything but this boring, negative, defeatist crap.

Also I was not eulogizing about the Saints manager. I was stating that no one had heard of him before he was hired, which is an entirely different discussion. He is a fine manager, point is no Saints fans had heard of him before he was hired, therefore dont tell me I cannot want Roy gone without having a name lined up.

Edited by Maine Eagle (04 Apr 2019 3.45pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Apr 19 3.42pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

To all eagles saying if not Roy then who? Well how did other teams get progressive managers. Brighton. Watford. Wolves. Soton. If Roy is not retired it’s going to be the end of the distinct cpfc brand.
Roy did well to keep us up last season. We returned the favor by keeping him. Now it’s time to move on. In the premier league there is no such thing as mid table safety as a strategy. It will only lead to stagnation and eventual relegation. It’s an up or out competition.
“Everything has its effing time and place; It’s time now for Roy to GO”

As another poster has said, Brighton do not have a progressive manager in Chris Hughton. I live deep in ' enemy territory ' and I can tell you that there are similar accusations made by their fans towards him as ours do towards Hodgson.

We didn't return any favours by keeping Roy on. He earned it based upon what he achieved last season.

'' End of the distinct CPFC brand '' - what does that even mean ?

Mid table safety is not a strategy. It's the race to what used to be 40 points but typically less now. Get to that, see where you are and go on from there. You can spend £100m and still only reach upper mid table.

I would like to read what your realistic proposals are to avoid the '' stagnation '' that you refer to. And I'll be happy to ensure that they are forwarded to Steve Parish so as to steer him in the right direction.

Over to you....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

leejaneagles Flag 04 Apr 19 3.48pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle


We can do better than this brand of football with these players. Am I willing to take a chance, get a manager in with some balls, and suffer relegation next year? At this stage, I sure am. Anything but this boring, negative, defeatist crap.

This is the key for more and I completely agree with you. I pay for a season ticket and more than just money, it takes time and effort to get to the game and it has a detrimental affect on happiness if your Team lose.

People think there's either 'enjoy football as a game' or 'kick the wife around and cry all weekend' but there is a middle ground which is what I see most weeks of fans walking down the Holmesdale, moaning to their friends or partner, angry at wasting their time, having missed something better in a lot of cases.

Palace having a good go and winning is fantastic, the best feeling. Worth every penny. Palace having a good go and losing is fine and part and parcel of not being Man City.

Watching 3 home wins all season with crap football is NOT okay under any circumstnaces.

If that's all we can offer up next season then relegate us now and I'll enjoy the Championship and the wins that come with it.

There are several people that would rather be in the Championship, do not misconstrue I am one of them. I strongly believe that replacing Roy and having a 'bloody good go' will see us rise up the table much faster than we are now, with little investment in the squad required (provided we don't lose Zaha and AWB).

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Apr 19 3.58pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

If you enjoy the Hodgson brand of football, good luck to you.

It is boring, gutless and turgid stuff half the time.

Our home form is a joke.

We played long ball yesterday to our worst target man/hold up player and had 1 shot on target in the entire game. We had no out ball.

This was evident early in proceedings, but he changed nothing.

After we went a goal down, he changed nothing.

Once we were 2 down, with 10 mins left, he had a go.

If you enjoy that/think its the best we can do, Penge Eagle, then I say good luck to you mate.

We can do better than this brand of football with these players. Am I willing to take a chance, get a manager in with some balls, and suffer relegation next year? At this stage, I sure am. Anything but this boring, negative, defeatist crap.

Also I was not eulogizing about the Saints manager. I was stating that no one had heard of him before he was hired, which is an entirely different discussion. He is a fine manager, point is no Saints fans had heard of him before he was hired, therefore dont tell me I cannot want Roy gone without having a name lined up.

Edited by Maine Eagle (04 Apr 2019 3.45pm)

In that case, we could get Alan Pardew back. I'm sure this group of players would thrive on his expansive football.

Good to hear you're willing to take the chance of getting relegated. I'm sure that Steve Parish and the other owners will be delighted that you think they should risk their investment for the sake of a few places higher up the league.

And if you're willing to accept relegation, well then clearly you will enjoy seeing the team lose on a more regular basis than they do at present.

This season has been a disappointment, no two ways about it. And last night's performance and tactical decisions were too. I think Roy made mistakes last night. But he gets it right more often than he gets it wrong, which is why I continue to support him.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 4.31pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

In that case, we could get Alan Pardew back. I'm sure this group of players would thrive on his expansive football.

Good to hear you're willing to take the chance of getting relegated. I'm sure that Steve Parish and the other owners will be delighted that you think they should risk their investment for the sake of a few places higher up the league.

And if you're willing to accept relegation, well then clearly you will enjoy seeing the team lose on a more regular basis than they do at present.

This season has been a disappointment, no two ways about it. And last night's performance and tactical decisions were too. I think Roy made mistakes last night. But he gets it right more often than he gets it wrong, which is why I continue to support him.

If the only notion that comes to mind for replacing Roy with a less timid and gutless manager is Pardew, then you might have a job as an adviser to Steve Parish on the cards.

I am not talking about getting a new manager in to finish a few places higher in the league.

I am talking about getting a new manager in to change the brand of football we are putting out.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Apr 19 4.42pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

If the only notion that comes to mind for replacing Roy with a less timid and gutless manager is Pardew, then you might have a job as an adviser to Steve Parish on the cards.

I am not talking about getting a new manager in to finish a few places higher in the league.

I am talking about getting a new manager in to change the brand of football we are putting out.

I used Pardew as a recent example of what happened the last time there was an attempt to change the brand of football. I'm sorry if you were unable to deduce that. I'll ignore the FDB debacle.

So you want a different brand of football and results are secondary, is that it ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 5.00pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I used Pardew as a recent example of what happened the last time there was an attempt to change the brand of football. I'm sorry if you were unable to deduce that. I'll ignore the FDB debacle.

So you want a different brand of football and results are secondary, is that it ?

Allow me to quote myself from earlier:

We can do better than this brand of football with these players. Am I willing to take a chance, get a manager in with some balls, and suffer relegation next year? At this stage, I sure am. Anything but this boring, negative, defeatist crap.

My answer is yes.

We are treading water in the league with some top quality players, far better than the teams around us.

Our home form is a joke.

Roy is timid, gutless, negative and defeatist. That brings results! We are staying up, I understand that. I am just sick and tired of the negative approach.

Regarding Pardew as a recent example of trying a more expansive brand, there were clues in Pardew's earlier career which might have alerted a more astute chairman to how foolish that was.

Speaking of foolish chairmen, then we have FDB.

We need to get the right manager in, which lets be honest Parish is s***e at. Even the sun shines on a dogs ass sometimes though.

Roy wont be here beyond next year anyway, then we will be forced to grow a pair, show some ballstrength, and hire a new manager anyway.

I would move him out now, and get a new manager in during the offseason who is not so negative and defeatist.

That is called being proactive, rather than reactive.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

KAOS Flag In a tree 04 Apr 19 5.07pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

In that case, we could get Alan Pardew back. I'm sure this group of players would thrive on his expansive football.

Good to hear you're willing to take the chance of getting relegated. I'm sure that Steve Parish and the other owners will be delighted that you think they should risk their investment for the sake of a few places higher up the league.

And if you're willing to accept relegation, well then clearly you will enjoy seeing the team lose on a more regular basis than they do at present.

This season has been a disappointment, no two ways about it. And last night's performance and tactical decisions were too. I think Roy made mistakes last night. But he gets it right more often than he gets it wrong, which is why I continue to support him.


Ditto! Well said ...

All this pony ... 'I'd rather see us play better football even it means us getting relegated next season ...' LMFAO ... what a load of old tosh! Are people conveniently forgetting the serious ramifications relegation from the Prem can bring?! Or are they that desperate for an extra 6-9 points a season that they'll take that chance ...

No doubt, the very same people who'll stop going in a heartbeat as soon as we're languishing near the bottom of the Championship ...

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Apr 19 5.29pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Allow me to quote myself from earlier:

We can do better than this brand of football with these players. Am I willing to take a chance, get a manager in with some balls, and suffer relegation next year? At this stage, I sure am. Anything but this boring, negative, defeatist crap.

My answer is yes.

We are treading water in the league with some top quality players, far better than the teams around us.

Our home form is a joke.

Roy is timid, gutless, negative and defeatist. That brings results! We are staying up, I understand that. I am just sick and tired of the negative approach.

Regarding Pardew as a recent example of trying a more expansive brand, there were clues in Pardew's earlier career which might have alerted a more astute chairman to how foolish that was.

Speaking of foolish chairmen, then we have FDB.

We need to get the right manager in, which lets be honest Parish is s***e at. Even the sun shines on a dogs ass sometimes though.

Roy wont be here beyond next year anyway, then we will be forced to grow a pair, show some ballstrength, and hire a new manager anyway.

I would move him out now, and get a new manager in during the offseason who is not so negative and defeatist.

That is called being proactive, rather than reactive.

I would certainly like to see some quality football on a more consistent basis. But I do think you are overestimating how good this squad is. The top players, and by that I mean those playing for the top 4-5 clubs, turn in consistently good performances which of course is why they are at those clubs and why those clubs finish where they do. Our players are probably a few points shy of the number of points they should have at this stage and arguably one or more places below where they could be. Thin dividing lines.

Appointing managers is a minefield. Moyes at United - recommended by Fergie ! More recently, Mourinho....Sarri at Chelsea not looking too bright - and these are the top clubs. Actually I think it's more of the way that Parish works with his managers that is the issue.

Back to Pardew - the early days all seemed well and results good. The only people warning us against that appointment were the Newcastle fans and I don't think we wanted to listen !

So you would move him out now ? Now that would be foolish.

I always ask the same question of the anti Roy brigade. Who would you bring in to replace him ? Not your job to answer was a reply you gave earlier. Well of course it's not. But it would be interesting to hear who you think will solve the problems that you so readily blame Roy Hodgson for.

Edited by NEILLO (04 Apr 2019 5.31pm)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 5.38pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I would certainly like to see some quality football on a more consistent basis. But I do think you are overestimating how good this squad is. The top players, and by that I mean those playing for the top 4-5 clubs, turn in consistently good performances which of course is why they are at those clubs and why those clubs finish where they do. Our players are probably a few points shy of the number of points they should have at this stage and arguably one or more places below where they could be. Thin dividing lines.

Appointing managers is a minefield. Moyes at United - recommended by Fergie ! More recently, Mourinho....Sarri at Chelsea not looking too bright - and these are the top clubs. Actually I think it's more of the way that Parish works with his managers that is the issue.

Back to Pardew - the early days all seemed well and results good. The only people warning us against that appointment were the Newcastle fans and I don't think we wanted to listen !

So you would move him out now ? Now that would be foolish.

I always ask the same question of the anti Roy brigade. Who would you bring in to replace him ? Not your job to answer was a reply you gave earlier. Well of course it's not. But it would be interesting to hear who you think will solve the problems that you so readily blame Roy Hodgson for.

Edited by NEILLO (04 Apr 2019 5.31pm)

2 concepts:

1 - Roy wont be around after next year I would strongly imagine. So we can tread water for another year, lose the likes of Max Meyer, and watch more joyless, negative, gutless football. Or we can act decisively. Appointing managers is a minefield, but Roy aint 45 years old, its coming.

2 - I simply dont know about the next Nuno Espirito Santo or Poch, or the Watford manager. I dont work in the game and dont spend my time researching managers. There are a lot of top leagues in Europe, let alone the world, where there are a lot of managers.

Regarding how good or bad the squad is, it was not so long ago that we had Owen Garvan starting in midfield and Wilbraham leading the line.

Good managers get the best out of their players. With the possible exception of AWB, who are we getting the best out of with our tactical setup and approach at the moment?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 04 Apr 19 5.39pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

This is the key for more and I completely agree with you. I pay for a season ticket and more than just money, it takes time and effort to get to the game and it has a detrimental affect on happiness if your Team lose.

People think there's either 'enjoy football as a game' or 'kick the wife around and cry all weekend' but there is a middle ground which is what I see most weeks of fans walking down the Holmesdale, moaning to their friends or partner, angry at wasting their time, having missed something better in a lot of cases.

Palace having a good go and winning is fantastic, the best feeling. Worth every penny. Palace having a good go and losing is fine and part and parcel of not being Man City.

Watching 3 home wins all season with crap football is NOT okay under any circumstnaces.

If that's all we can offer up next season then relegate us now and I'll enjoy the Championship and the wins that come with it.

There are several people that would rather be in the Championship, do not misconstrue I am one of them. I strongly believe that replacing Roy and having a 'bloody good go' will see us rise up the table much faster than we are now, with little investment in the squad required (provided we don't lose Zaha and AWB).

SP has quoted in one of the home programmes recently that the home has not been good. Ultimately the ball is in his court to sort this out as it looks highly unlikely that it will magically sort itself out as I can't see much coming from the current squad in terms of improvement. Nobody seems to be on a hot streak or working well with each other. So he could blame Roy and sack him or keep him and back him in the market, which he would have to do with a new manager in any case. What's needed in the transfer market is somebody who can pick out a few attacking gems and a manager willing to give them a go if they are brought in. The transfers have got to be right for both parties. So the focus should be our transfer dealings which have been lukewarm recently. A classic example is Meyer who looks like we have just picked him up with no idea where he would fit into the team. A dead ball specialist might of been better. Somebody who can put in a decent corner/free kick. If you have somebody with a bit of nous scouting the continent you could find this type of player. One example is Watford, who have looked safe all season, have supposedly a worse big chance conversion ratio than us, sold one of their best players last season, semi of the cup and had a go at Man Ure recently. They have club ties with the European market which is where a lot of talent can be mined. This is the kind of season we should be aiming for next season.

Edited by Booted Eagle (04 Apr 2019 5.42pm)

Edited by Booted Eagle (04 Apr 2019 5.46pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Page 38 of 65 < 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread