You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 38 of 71 < 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 >
Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 13 Nov 18 5.04pm

This is the debate, right:

Those saying the club should accommodate the singing section:
--will improve atmosphere
--there are greater injustices in the world
--it's the club's prerogative

Those saying the club shouldn't accommodate the singing section:
--it unfairly places one group of fans over another
--the atmosphere isn't being too impacted
--it penalises some of our most loyal fans
--it will hugely disrupt the wider LH
--it rewards the HF for withholding their vocal support and threatening the club
--the HF coukd just have waited until the old stand is expanded

what points, in very simple language, did I miss?


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Nov 18 5.12pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

This is the debate, right:

Those saying the club should accommodate the singing section:
--will improve atmosphere
--there are greater injustices in the world
--it's the club's prerogative

Those saying the club shouldn't accommodate the singing section:
--it unfairly places one group of fans over another
--the atmosphere isn't being too impacted
--it penalises some of our most loyal fans
--it will hugely disrupt the wider LH
--it rewards the HF for withholding their vocal support and threatening the club
--the HF coukd just have waited until the old stand is expanded

what points, in very simple language, did I miss?


That this adversely affects older people in favour of younger people.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Nov 18 5.17pm

The main stand, more than likely, could be years and years away, not 2-3 years.

 


COYP

Laths Flag West of Selhurst. 13 Nov 18 5.54pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The main stand, more than likely, could be years and years away, not 2-3 years.

Try 10 years plus, according to a planner in Croydon Council, may never get off ground.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Nov 18 6.32pm

Originally posted by Laths

Try 10 years plus, according to a planner in Croydon Council, may never get off ground.

Which is why the HF are doing it now rather than ‘waiting 2-3 years.’

Did the club (Parish) day why don’t they wait in the club statement? That didn’t hold it they did.,

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Nov 18 7.17pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

This is the debate, right:

Those saying the club should accommodate the singing section:
--will improve atmosphere
--there are greater injustices in the world
--it's the club's prerogative

Those saying the club shouldn't accommodate the singing section:
--it unfairly places one group of fans over another
--the atmosphere isn't being too impacted
--it penalises some of our most loyal fans
--it will hugely disrupt the wider LH
--it rewards the HF for withholding their vocal support and threatening the club
--the HF coukd just have waited until the old stand is expanded

what points, in very simple language, did I miss?

You missed the fact that we already had a singing section but the "singers" decided that they didn't want that bit of real estate any more and wanted to move

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Nov 18 7.56pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You missed the fact that we already had a singing section but the "singers" decided that they didn't want that bit of real estate any more and wanted to move

No room to grow and the atmosphere was declining in the area they were in and couldn’t get more vocal people in. The club could’ve addressed this by filling in the corner until the new stand is ready in 2-3...... 10+ years time.

 


COYP

Palace in the Blood Flag 13 Nov 18 8.46pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
No room to grow and the atmosphere was declining in the area they were in and couldn’t get more vocal people in. The club could’ve addressed this by filling in the corner until the new stand is ready in 2-3...... 10+ years time.

I would change 1 word "could've" to should have.

There is no real idea of the demand for the singing section as a result of the clubs failure to fully ascertain the views of existing season ticket holders. The Club has allocated 400 seats to the section is that too many or too few? Keeping the singing section in the corner had all sorts of benefits not least it affects fewer season tickets and is far less likely to upset authorities.

I think if this dispute had never happened the new stand would be now far more advanced. The authorities will now wait to see how the club manages the regulations before allowing it to move forward

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Nov 18 9.28pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

I would change 1 word "could've" to should have.

There is no real idea of the demand for the singing section as a result of the clubs failure to fully ascertain the views of existing season ticket holders. The Club has allocated 400 seats to the section is that too many or too few? Keeping the singing section in the corner had all sorts of benefits not least it affects fewer season tickets and is far less likely to upset authorities.

I think if this dispute had never happened the new stand would be now far more advanced. The authorities will now wait to see how the club manages the regulations before allowing it to move forward

I doubt it makes the slight slightest bit of difference to date.

 


COYP

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 13 Nov 18 10.02pm

A genuine question- has anyone who is NOT effected contacted the club to let them know whether they support or oppose the proposed way of going ahead with the singing section?

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 13 Nov 18 10.12pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

A genuine question- has anyone who is NOT effected contacted the club to let them know whether they support or oppose the proposed way of going ahead with the singing section?

Yes, I have. I’ve registered my interest to try and get a ST in the new section and have congratulated them on the decision. No response though.

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 13 Nov 18 11.57pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

A genuine question- has anyone who is NOT effected contacted the club to let them know whether they support or oppose the proposed way of going ahead with the singing section?

Yes, I will be attending a forum next Tuesday with my friend "Wilf King" who is an affected Block E season ticket holder.

I am an Arthur Wait season holder but feel strongly that the club have acted appallingly, without going into all the stuff on the last 60-odd pages on this issue.

I am only speaking unofficially here but from what I am told by some Block E "evictees" they feel it is a done deal but they might as well shout loudly and try to get as good a compensation package as possible.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Nov 18 6.45am

I've edited this to include some responses.

This is the debate, right:

Those saying the club should accommodate the singing section:
--will improve atmosphere
--there are greater injustices in the world
-- the HF needed room to grow
--it's the club's prerogative

Those saying the club shouldn't accommodate the singing section:
--it unfairly places one group of fans, often younger, over another, often older
--the atmosphere isn't being too impacted
--it penalises some of our most loyal fans
--it will hugely disrupt the wider LH
--it rewards the HF for withholding their vocal support and threatening the club
--the HF had a singing section and could just have waited until the old stand is expanded to relocate


what points, in very simple language, did I miss?


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Nov 18 7.41am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

what points, in very simple language, did I miss?

Why don’t they wait for the new stand in 2-3 years vs it could years and years away. 10 years?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Nov 2018 7.47am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Nov 18 7.46am

Originally posted by Jamesey

Yes, I will be attending a forum next Tuesday with my friend "Wilf King" who is an affected Block E season ticket holder.

I am an Arthur Wait season holder but feel strongly that the club have acted appallingly, without going into all the stuff on the last 60-odd pages on this issue.

I am only speaking unofficially here but from what I am told by some Block E "evictees" they feel it is a done deal but they might as well shout loudly and try to get as good a compensation package as possible.

Yep. I wonder if Parish stumps up the £250k Scudamore payment from club funds. That’ll hurt him too. Nearly £50,000, 18% is his.

 


COYP

BuckinghamshireEagle Flag 14 Nov 18 8.18am

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

A genuine question- has anyone who is NOT effected contacted the club to let them know whether they support or oppose the proposed way of going ahead with the singing section?

Yes, I wrote to say I thought the way they are going about this is against the whole ethos of the club. I’m pretty sure my letter was not even read as in reply I only received the standard email that the E400 got saying I would be invited to an open day, though I made it clear I was not affected!

Edited by BuckinghamshireEagle (14 Nov 2018 8.19am)

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 14 Nov 18 8.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Have a care as you're walking a thin line

So clearly you agree with him, that's fine that's your prerogative. However just becuase you agree with him shouldn't mean you start taking sides.

If you go back to his original rant at me for telling it how it is you will see clearly who spat whose dummy out and started with the insults calling me a bigot for example.

I'm a big enough bloke to look after myself, and my Opinion on the matter is just as valid as yours or his, and I have already stated a number of times I don't agree with how the HF have gone about it.

Oh and by the way don't threaten me please for fighting fire with fire.

Anyway I'm done here no one knows for sure whats going to happen so until we do it's all hypothetical and the varying viewpoints all conjecture.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Nov 18 9.07am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

So clearly you agree with him, that's fine that's your prerogative. However just becuase you agree with him shouldn't mean you start taking sides.

If you think that's clear you really need to visit Specsavers.

I haven't taken sides at all in this debate and just because I warned you about your posting style doesn't imply anything to do with the subject matter

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Nov 18 9.17am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

No room to grow and the atmosphere was declining in the area they were in and couldn’t get more vocal people in. The club could’ve addressed this by filling in the corner until the new stand is ready in 2-3...... 10+ years time.

There is no evidence of a demand to grow the HF, if there was just give them all block B. This wouldn’t disrupt many people and would accommodate any growth, but that isn’t what they want. They just want a better view.

 

Terry Ven Flag 14 Nov 18 9.50am

I wrote to SP asking him how influenced he was by the HF petision coz it looked like their was a lot of false names in it. no repsonse...

 

Page 38 of 71 < 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic