You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 39 of 65 < 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 >
CharlesPaterson Flag 04 Apr 19 5.50pm

Last night's surrender to Spurs was embarrassing with the squad we have.

Roy seemed content that we managed to keep it down to 2 goals when most of us could see that with a bit of ambition we could have at least come away with a draw.

This for me is his biggest fault. He is too organised for his own good and sticks rigidly to his plan.

At 1-0 we could have thrown caution to the wind and not worried about getting done by 3 or 4, we are pretty much safe after last week's win over Huddersfield, not sure why Roy can't see this!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Apr 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

2 concepts:

1 - Roy wont be around after next year I would strongly imagine. So we can tread water for another year, lose the likes of Max Meyer, and watch more joyless, negative, gutless football. Or we can act decisively. Appointing managers is a minefield, but Roy aint 45 years old, its coming.

2 - I simply dont know about the next Nuno Espirito Santo or Poch, or the Watford manager. I dont work in the game and dont spend my time researching managers. There are a lot of top leagues in Europe, let alone the world, where there are a lot of managers.

Regarding how good or bad the squad is, it was not so long ago that we had Owen Garvan starting in midfield and Wilbraham leading the line.

Good managers get the best out of their players. With the possible exception of AWB, who are we getting the best out of with our tactical setup and approach at the moment?

Who knows whether Roy will or won't...Parish will be aware of the anti Hodgson undercurrent and of course he sees the home games the same as we do. But...is that sufficient to sack him ? Or does Parish think that someone else can come in, play better football while retaining our place in the Premier League ? Neither endgame would surprise me, but I have a feeling that Roy will be around next season.

I'm with you regarding a potential replacement. I don't have the time or knowledge to recommend anybody. My point being that it's easy to say sack someone, not so easy to identify a good fit for a replacement and that is what you are asking Parish to do.

Re the squad - I'm fully aware of just how far we have come in terms of quality, but that's irrelevant to this discussion.

Take your point re AWB but say back to you - Meyer apart - who else is Hodgson not getting the best out of ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Apr 19 6.25pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Who knows whether Roy will or won't...Parish will be aware of the anti Hodgson undercurrent and of course he sees the home games the same as we do. But...is that sufficient to sack him ? Or does Parish think that someone else can come in, play better football while retaining our place in the Premier League ? Neither endgame would surprise me, but I have a feeling that Roy will be around next season.

I'm with you regarding a potential replacement. I don't have the time or knowledge to recommend anybody. My point being that it's easy to say sack someone, not so easy to identify a good fit for a replacement and that is what you are asking Parish to do.

Re the squad - I'm fully aware of just how far we have come in terms of quality, but that's irrelevant to this discussion.

Take your point re AWB but say back to you - Meyer apart - who else is Hodgson not getting the best out of ?

Where to begin:

All strikers - Benteke for example has become next to worthless on Roy's watch.
PVA - terrible form this season, should have been benched on several occasions
Zaha - patchy form at best this year, clearly not at his best currently, Roy cannot figure out a way to get him on the ball in the final third
MacArthur - overused, poor form for large parts of the year

Obviously then you have the likes of Riedewald, good enough for Ajax but not us.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

leejaneagles Flag 04 Apr 19 6.28pm

One more thing I've just thought of (though I am still in the Roy out camp) is that maybe Parish knows something we don't about Zaha and AWB.

Zaha certainly doesn't seem as passionate and he might know hes off. I think United will make AWB their main target also.

Now, if that's the case you could argue a much different outlook. Rather than progress and play expansive football, Parish might be thinking we have to scrape survival without our 2 best players.

In that situation Roy might be the right man. Without Zaha in the team a boring 0-0 suddenly seems quite ambitious.

A new Manager is definitely coming the season after next whatever happens. If they come in now and lose their best 2 players they'll already be frustrated.

Let Roy deal with the Wilfless hangover season, pray for 17th and then move on next season perhaps?

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 04 Apr 19 6.59pm

I am willing to bet Roy will be out coached by Benitez this Saturday. And am thinking to not even watch another 90 minutes of drivel due to wrong tactics, incorrect squad for the occasion because a draw would be more than sufficient for the ole geezer. And if this continues no more palace games for me till Roy is gone. Yeah I said it!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Apr 19 7.09pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

I am willing to bet Roy will be out coached by Benitez this Saturday. And am thinking to not even watch another 90 minutes of drivel due to wrong tactics, incorrect squad for the occasion because a draw would be more than sufficient for the ole geezer. And if this continues no more palace games for me till Roy is gone. Yeah I said it!

Newcastle have won their last 5 home games so it will be hard for us.Changed their formation at Arsenal,playing 3 at the back and wing backs.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 04 Apr 19 7.13pm

Hodgson OUT.

That is all.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Apr 19 7.21pm

Seem to remember there was a stat saying Benteke missed more good chances than any other player in 2017-18 ?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 04 Apr 19 7.30pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Ideally, I'd like to see Roy retire at the end of the season with a great replacement coming in whom we're already lining up. However, I have absolutely no faith in the board to manage that transition and find a good replacement properly.

Keeping Hodgson another season might sound like a safe bet, because we'd almost certainly stay up, but I think we'll lose Wilf, AWB, maybe Luka and Townsend. Our best players leaving would mean that we'd then have the terrifying prospect of starting the 2020/21 season with a new manager and new key players, and just as I have no faith in the board to replace the manager well, I have even less faith in our player recruitment.

Tricky times. At least Wilf is doing his best to deter any big bids with his performances.

You want rid of Roy, an experienced manager, who has kept us up with ease over the last 2 seasons. You want someone new, who is better, but you don't know who and have no faith in the board knowing either.

One of those, I don't like what I have got, but I want something else and I have no idea who, if I don't like it I will complain, posts.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 04 Apr 19 7.33pm

Can we sponsor A Subway store at Selhurst please.
Call it "Hodgsons Sub-way"...... maybe for a huge hint!!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Apr 19 8.19pm

I shouldn’t be that surprised if Roy walks at the end of the season anyway as we need some serious investment and there’s been nothing to suggest our recruitment will be good enough. We’ll need a miracle to stay up next season if we lose a couple of key players.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 04 Apr 19 8.21pm

Originally posted by Painter

You want rid of Roy, an experienced manager, who has kept us up with ease over the last 2 seasons. You want someone new, who is better, but you don't know who and have no faith in the board knowing either.

One of those, I don't like what I have got, but I want something else and I have no idea who, if I don't like it I will complain, posts.
[/J

An experienced manager Roy maybe but he is stuck in the past and to the detriment of developing the team and in the process attracting new players. Last night was living Proof. His after match interview was as weak as dish water and anyone who didn’t know any bettter would have thought that he was a closet Spurs fan with the praise he heaped on them.
It’s not the fans job to short list a new manager it’s the Board who have that role and i hope that they have already started but somehow i have my doubts.

 


Bring back Brolin

Bangell Flag Oxford 04 Apr 19 8.34pm

Originally posted by Painter

You want rid of Roy, an experienced manager, who has kept us up with ease over the last 2 seasons. You want someone new, who is better, but you don't know who and have no faith in the board knowing either.

One of those, I don't like what I have got, but I want something else and I have no idea who, if I don't like it I will complain, posts.

The whole point of my post was that it's very difficult to figure out what's best at the present time. Not demanding that we get rid of Roy because anyone but him could do a better job.

 

davehuggins Flag 04 Apr 19 8.47pm

It really is the old adage be very careful what you wish for! RH IMO has done a brilliant job, he has got us playing good football most of the time, all teams have poor games. What really worries me is the lack of quality signings over the last few windows. RH is not to blame for this I'm sure. I hope he stays next season and SP & Co back him and it would be a good idea to get the ground development started.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 04 Apr 19 9.19pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

It’s not the fans job to short list a new manager it’s the Board who have that role and i hope that they have already started but somehow i have my doubts.

Is it the fans job to demand the manager to be sacked, when he has achieved his objective of remaining in the Premier. This is the same objective for at least 12 other managers.
The board will thinking very carefully, who is best equipped to keep us there, as over £120m is at stake.
For those demanding attractive free flowing football will be disappointed, the money available in the game, now mean results are vital by any means possible, entertaining football isn't a priority.
Fulham played entertaining football, but let in shed loads of goals, resulting in relegation.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Apr 19 10.11pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

One more thing I've just thought of (though I am still in the Roy out camp) is that maybe Parish knows something we don't about Zaha and AWB.

Zaha certainly doesn't seem as passionate and he might know hes off. I think United will make AWB their main target also.

Now, if that's the case you could argue a much different outlook. Rather than progress and play expansive football, Parish might be thinking we have to scrape survival without our 2 best players.

In that situation Roy might be the right man. Without Zaha in the team a boring 0-0 suddenly seems quite ambitious.

A new Manager is definitely coming the season after next whatever happens. If they come in now and lose their best 2 players they'll already be frustrated.

Let Roy deal with the Wilfless hangover season, pray for 17th and then move on next season perhaps?

Or looking at it another way. If we sell our 2 best players, why give that money to roy to buy players when he will be leaving in a year. Why not give it to a new manager to buy the players he wants. .

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Apr 19 10.17pm

Originally posted by Painter

Is it the fans job to demand the manager to be sacked, when he has achieved his objective of remaining in the Premier. This is the same objective for at least 12 other managers.
The board will thinking very carefully, who is best equipped to keep us there, as over £120m is at stake.
For those demanding attractive free flowing football will be disappointed, the money available in the game, now mean results are vital by any means possible, entertaining football isn't a priority.
Fulham played entertaining football, but let in shed loads of goals, resulting in relegation.

If this was Roy's objective at the start of thd season I would be very dissapointed.

I'm not necessarily asking for free flowing football. Just something better than sitting behind the ball, trying to cath teams on the break, trying to play possession football. Even at home against the worst team to ever grace the premiership.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Apr 19 11.31pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

If this was Roy's objective at the start of thd season I would be very dissapointed.

I'm not necessarily asking for free flowing football. Just something better than sitting behind the ball, trying to cath teams on the break, trying to play possession football. Even at home against the worst team to ever grace the premiership.

I think you will find that half of the Premier League club's first objective is to stay in it. Anything else such as a cup run is a bonus.

Of course you want to finish as high up the league as you can.

We could still finish 12th this season. But that clearly isn't good enough for some on here.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 12.44am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think you will find that half of the Premier League club's first objective is to stay in it. Anything else such as a cup run is a bonus.

Of course you want to finish as high up the league as you can.

We could still finish 12th this season. But that clearly isn't good enough for some on here.

At this stage I would be amazed if Roy came back after next season.

Given that strong assumption, I say get rid at the end of this season and take control of the situation.

A year and a bit from now Parish will be doing a manager search anyway. We are not going to qualify for Europe next year with Hodgson, no way.

Same stubborn Hodgson and same negative defeatist approach will lead to the same results next season.

We have some players we need to hold on to and you cannot tell me Zaha is enjoying his football right now. We had 1 shot on target at Spurs.

Its a risk, but we need to show some balls, in the absence of Hodgson showing any, ever.

He wont be around after next year anyway, so why stumble through another disappointing and joyless season of football permeated with a few highs here and there.

Take decisive action, grow a pair, and try to kick on and actually go to the next level.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 05 Apr 19 6.50am

Originally posted by spartakev2

If this was Roy's objective at the start of thd season I would be very dissapointed.

I'm not necessarily asking for free flowing football. Just something better than sitting behind the ball, trying to cath teams on the break, trying to play possession football. Even at home against the worst team to ever grace the premiership.

Just remind yourself of what happened at the start of last season...

I find it staggering that people want rid of Roy. Whilst we aren't yet mathematically safe, we've been comfortable for a large chunk of this season. That's a massive achievement.

 

Page 39 of 65 < 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread