This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 23 Feb 2013 1.13pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Feb 2013 12.13pm
I have addressed your arguments and show their flaws.
My opinion on the matter is that the charges are a foil. A fact of the matter is that Assange will not go to Sweden while onward extradition is a possibility. He should be questioned on the case, it's a serious allegation, but he should not face onward extradition. A right that Sweden has the power to exert, but have remained wooly on. No country should have the right to extradite someone and then extradite them from there for trial elsewhere. Extradition should only apply to prosecution for offences in the extraditing country.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 23 Feb 2013 1.19pm
Although over 50 years ago I would urge you to read up about US actions in the Korean War Stirling if you haven't already just so to know exactly what the US are capable of. It is truly shocking.
An estimated one million civilians were murdered by the US via official policy. Not just the US, the members of the Security council and those in possession of veto essentially make the UN a two tiered interest group. The UN is largely dependent on a few nations to operate, and consequently those countries, including the security council, will veto in national interests, irrespective of the international situation involved. The US will never abandon Israel to the UN, because its a client state, exactly the same reason why the Russians and French were intransent over the second gulf war resolutions. Essentially, the UN is a very high minded, well meant institution thats largely a strong arm means of a few western nations to get their own way.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 7.17pm
If he is extradited to Sweden and he is found guilty after trial and jailed. What international law would stop the US from requesting his extradition on to them?
I read a summary of the extradition treaty between Sweden and the United States and the key points are: 1. Political and military extraditions are prohibited. As I have previously mentioned, Sweden are remaining entirely on the fence about it. In fact, they actually have previous for ignoring the treaty entirely. "In 2001 the Swedish government delivered two Egyptians seeking asylum to the CIA, which rendered them immediately to the Mubarak regime, which tortured them". [Link] So the United States would have to request extradition on charges that are not deemed political or military first of all, which would be difficult... if Sweden actually followed it's own treaty. Which it clearly doesn't. Stirling likes to think that the law is black and white on these issues. Not only is it grey, it's also fvcking mess. Each of the states involved here has previous for picking and choosing which laws and treaties to follow when it suits them diplomatically.
WORRIED that your teeth will be stained after a heavy night drinking red wine? Fear not; drink a bottle of white wine before going to bed, to remove the stains. |
|
|
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 7.39pm
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 7.17pm
If he is extradited to Sweden and he is found guilty after trial and jailed. What international law would stop the US from requesting his extradition on to them?
I read a summary of the extradition treaty between Sweden and the United States and the key points are: 1. Political and military extraditions are prohibited. As I have previously mentioned, Sweden are remaining entirely on the fence about it. In fact, they actually have previous for ignoring the treaty entirely. "In 2001 the Swedish government delivered two Egyptians seeking asylum to the CIA, which rendered them immediately to the Mubarak regime, which tortured them". [Link] So the United States would have to request extradition on charges that are not deemed political or military first of all, which would be difficult... if Sweden actually followed it's own treaty. Which it clearly doesn't. Stirling likes to think that the law is black and white on these issues. Not only is it grey, it's also fvcking mess. Each of the states involved here has previous for picking and choosing which laws and treaties to follow when it suits them diplomatically.
Just because Sweden did something over ten years ago doesn't mean that it will do the same thing again. It's a moot point: we don't know. Stirling doesn't think the law is black and white, interpretation is everything and how a state decides to do that is their own concern. Indeed interpretation is exactly why lawyers live in large houses. You have said that a previous Swedish government have broken a treaty, maybe, maybe not. I'm sure there are plenty in Sweden who wouldn't agree with you. It's grey, maybe it's you who actually thinks in black and white.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 7.39pm
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 7.17pm
If he is extradited to Sweden and he is found guilty after trial and jailed. What international law would stop the US from requesting his extradition on to them?
I read a summary of the extradition treaty between Sweden and the United States and the key points are: 1. Political and military extraditions are prohibited. As I have previously mentioned, Sweden are remaining entirely on the fence about it. In fact, they actually have previous for ignoring the treaty entirely. "In 2001 the Swedish government delivered two Egyptians seeking asylum to the CIA, which rendered them immediately to the Mubarak regime, which tortured them". [Link] So the United States would have to request extradition on charges that are not deemed political or military first of all, which would be difficult... if Sweden actually followed it's own treaty. Which it clearly doesn't. Stirling likes to think that the law is black and white on these issues. Not only is it grey, it's also fvcking mess. Each of the states involved here has previous for picking and choosing which laws and treaties to follow when it suits them diplomatically. Any extradition is a f***ing mess as far as I can tell! Thing is he has certainly broken laws, both US and international, that he could be extradited on without it being deemed for military or political reasons. He's admitted what he's done, or been a part of at the very least, and revelled in the notoriety. I don't blame Sweden for not showing their hand, nor their declining any of his requests prior to or since winning the judgement. He's tried to dictate matters to them, and us for that matter by skipping bail and with his subsequent balcony speeches, when due process has been followed.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Feb 2013 7.57pm
Stirling doesn't think the law is black and white, interpretation is everything and how a state decides to do that is their own concern. Indeed interpretation is exactly why lawyers live in large houses. You have said that a previous Swedish government have broken a treaty, maybe, maybe not. I'm sure there are plenty in Sweden who wouldn't agree with you.
There is no maybe, maybe not on whether Sweden broke its own treaty on extradition. [Link] Guardian bias aside, it's a very well documented case of Extraordinary Rendition and the dismissal of international law as the basis for extradition.
WORRIED that your teeth will be stained after a heavy night drinking red wine? Fear not; drink a bottle of white wine before going to bed, to remove the stains. |
|
|
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 8.31pm
You're tying yourself in knots here. You previously accused Assange of taking a pick and choose mentality to international law. So a state can bend international law whenever they choose to, but an individual subject to the same, loose, subjective law or treaty is not allowed an interpretation? There is no maybe, maybe not on whether Sweden broke its own treaty on extradition. [Link] Guardian bias aside, it's a very well documented case of Extraordinary Rendition and the dismissal of international law as the basis for extradition. An individual does not get to officially decide upon which laws they do or do not follow....Well, legally. A democratic state however votes on and creates laws. It frames those laws and creates its extradition laws within its own parliament. If a state breaks its own laws, then as the state does to the citizen, it can be taken to court by any citizen or organization who believes it has....If they have the wonga. You say Sweden broke its own extradition laws. So has it lost any judgement upon its decision in a court of law? If it had I'd concede you have a point. Anyway this is besides the point. As I say, what a previous Swedish government did ten years ago has little relevance to today.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 9.09pm
They could after all have beaten Sweden to the chase and applied to extradite him from us. Once they have him, I presume they could try him on all sorts of petty matters the like of which i've mentioned.
WORRIED that your teeth will be stained after a heavy night drinking red wine? Fear not; drink a bottle of white wine before going to bed, to remove the stains. |
|
|
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 9.16pm
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 9.09pm
They could after all have beaten Sweden to the chase and applied to extradite him from us. Once they have him, I presume they could try him on all sorts of petty matters the like of which i've mentioned.
As it stands there is no case, he should stop using that as his defence against A) going to Sweden and B) breaking our laws.
Optimistic as ever |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.