Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Feb 2014 10.51am
Quote Plane at 16 Feb 2014 2.00pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 16 Feb 2014 11.20am
Quote Plane at 16 Feb 2014 11.18am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 16 Feb 2014 11.07am
Quote Plane at 16 Feb 2014 10.54am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 15 Feb 2014 4.15pm
My post did make the point that it was not illegal (highlighted in red).
Whilst his actions broke no laws, he was hardly being a benefactor to CPFC as he had bought the club for a song and could have led Palace to even greater success but he chose to be greedy and cash in.
That behaviour does not warrant him being "honoured" by the club, in my opinion.
Yes, I can read.
So chairmen need to be benefactors to the club to fulfil your ideal of a chairman, perhaps you ought to mention that to CPFC2010, should they just plough all of their wealth in to satisfy your ambition? He bought the club for a song as it had been run down by the previous incumbent and no-one else wanted it, or put another way, he saw an opportunity and had the money to achieve it.
You've side stepped the question I want you and others to answer, why shouldn't he spend money made from his business?
I can read too.
If you can read why did you feel the need to point out something I had already acknowledged?
Why are you being so aggressive? You have an opinion and so do I. No need for it.
I have not "sidestepped" anything but made it plain that I do not regard him as a benefactor and therefore totally unacceptable as a potential candidate to be honoured.
Earlier you suggested that Noades was similar to myself (based on my right leaning politics and capitalist views I guess), but as far as Palace is concerned he is nothing like me - if I had a windfall I would donate it to Palace without question. I would not be looking for a return on my money.
Lets hope I've cleared that up without the need for you to be in my face about it.... LOL
Edited by Hoof Hearted (16 Feb 2014 11.09am)
I'm not being aggressive Hoof, there's not any point in pursuing this as you have again failed to answer anything I've asked you. 
I haven't though?
OK, highlight for me where you have answered this much asked question, the one I've highlighted in red.
From your comments on this topic after this post, you seem unable to acknowledge that Noades did anything correctly, as I've said before, try taking your emotion out of the equation and look at the facts.
You're still being quite aggressive whereas I am stating quite calmly what I think of Noades - which incidentally mirror the thoughts of most Brentford fans that feel equally ripped off from "Uncle Ron".
To try and answer your question... yes I do believe that football club chairmen should be benefactors. What is wrong with that?
There are precious few margins to make money if you run the club to a success on field and maintain the dignity/history of the club. We have all seen the fcuk ups at Portsmouth and the recent shenanigans at Hull and Cardiff.
As I have already stated Noades bought our club for a song and when things started to improve he used it as a cash cow to fund his desire to set up a few golf clubs. We have already determined that his actions were not illegal, but he can hardly be regarded as someone to be honoured because he clearly had no love for Palace otherwise he would have tried to make us as successful as we possibly could be.
So in summary I believe that Noades had no right to redistribute CPFC assets to his other businesses because he was acting as a temporary "steward" of the club and as such had a duty of care to protect the ongoing stability of it for past present and future fans.
Personally I agree with your sentiment 100%. Others may love Uncle Ron but I feel he's responsible for one of the worst moments in our history and I wasn't here for one of the best.
Just one thing...Hull and Cardiff's owners are both benefactors...something that perhaps should be remembered.
He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........