You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are there plans to build a new stadium?
November 16 2026 12.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are there plans to build a new stadium?


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 22 Apr 14 2.25pm


I heard the ground is being 'lowered' to build up the stands, a new semi-circular' main stand replacing the original rust bucket and a capacity higher than 30,000. Either a change or oblivion.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 22 Apr 14 2.39pm

Quote adrian b at 22 Apr 2014 2.25pm


I heard the ground is being 'lowered' to build up the stands, a new semi-circular' main stand replacing the original rust bucket and a capacity higher than 30,000. Either a change or oblivion.


I can understand lowering the pitch, but a "semi-circular" stand? How the hell would that work?

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

PalaceSi Flag Brockley 22 Apr 14 2.41pm

to quote one poster who stated'
"Nope, for me we've got to where we are...Palace is Selhurst and Thornton Heath not Penge and Gypsy Hill."

I don't understand this at all and it drives me nuts. Crystal Palace is Crystal Palace which is why we are called Crystal Palace FC not Selhurst and Thorton heath FC or Croydon FC or anywhere else FC it really is not rocket science. If you want to buy baked beans you buy a tin which says baked beans on not spagetti hoops or carrots!

Edited by PalaceSi (22 Apr 2014 2.44pm)

 

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 22 Apr 14 7.35pm

Quote PalaceSi at 22 Apr 2014 2.41pm

to quote one poster who stated'
"Nope, for me we've got to where we are...Palace is Selhurst and Thornton Heath not Penge and Gypsy Hill."

I don't understand this at all and it drives me nuts. Crystal Palace is Crystal Palace which is why we are called Crystal Palace FC not Selhurst and Thorton heath FC or Croydon FC or anywhere else FC it really is not rocket science. If you want to buy baked beans you buy a tin which says baked beans on not spagetti hoops or carrots!

Edited by PalaceSi (22 Apr 2014 2.44pm)

So in that case Arsenal have the wrong name and should move back to Woolwich, Chelsea should move to Chelsea or rename to Fulham II, etc.
The point is we've been at Selhurst Park nearly 90 years so more or less 9 times longer than Crystal Palace Park or anywhere else so I think by now you can safely say it's our home.

 

Halfwayline Flag Waddon 22 Apr 14 7.38pm

small]

Wisbech!
That is a journey and a half. It raises a key question concerning the location of the stadium - where do Palace supporters live? I suspect that if you had a heat map from 1972 and now you would see that the first one was tightly packed around Norwood and Croydon. A present one is likely to show tat support has spread very widely. Palace must have this data from their membership and season ticket sales. It would be interesting to know what proportion of support now travels from outside Croydon.

I did a poll on the BBS 823 fan's responded to where they live. Just 16% live in Croydon.

Edited by Halfwayline (22 Apr 2014 7.38pm)

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 22 Apr 14 7.54pm

Quote Halfwayline at 22 Apr 2014 7.38pm

small]

Wisbech!
That is a journey and a half. It raises a key question concerning the location of the stadium - where do Palace supporters live? I suspect that if you had a heat map from 1972 and now you would see that the first one was tightly packed around Norwood and Croydon. A present one is likely to show tat support has spread very widely. Palace must have this data from their membership and season ticket sales. It would be interesting to know what proportion of support now travels from outside Croydon.

I did a poll on the BBS 823 fan's responded to where they live. Just 16% live in Croydon.

Edited by Halfwayline (22 Apr 2014 7.38pm)

That is an astonishingly small %. It begs the question of whether the club is drawing in support from the local community or is simply relying on next generation of exist g supporters. If we rely on people travelling a long way then any stadium must be close to a mainline station or major road junction.
But that % of local support has to grow or the clubs long term future is very bleak.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 22 Apr 14 8.15pm

Quote Catfish at 22 Apr 2014 7.54pm

Quote Halfwayline at 22 Apr 2014 7.38pm

small]

Wisbech!
That is a journey and a half. It raises a key question concerning the location of the stadium - where do Palace supporters live? I suspect that if you had a heat map from 1972 and now you would see that the first one was tightly packed around Norwood and Croydon. A present one is likely to show tat support has spread very widely. Palace must have this data from their membership and season ticket sales. It would be interesting to know what proportion of support now travels from outside Croydon.

I did a poll on the BBS 823 fan's responded to where they live. Just 16% live in Croydon.

Edited by Halfwayline (22 Apr 2014 7.38pm)

That is an astonishingly small %. It begs the question of whether the club is drawing in support from the local community or is simply relying on next generation of exist g supporters. If we rely on people travelling a long way then any stadium must be close to a mainline station or major road junction.
But that % of local support has to grow or the clubs long term future is very bleak.

______________________________________


If we remain in the Prem for a few more years, rest assured that the number of local supporters will increase.

On topic,

Although I personally would like us to return to our ancestral home, I cannot see that happening. Unless it does, I want us to stay at Selhurst Park and redevelop.


Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (22 Apr 2014 8.17pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Firegut Flag Croydon 22 Apr 14 8.27pm

Quote Selhurstboys at 22 Apr 2014 7.35pm

Quote PalaceSi at 22 Apr 2014 2.41pm

to quote one poster who stated'
"Nope, for me we've got to where we are...Palace is Selhurst and Thornton Heath not Penge and Gypsy Hill."

I don't understand this at all and it drives me nuts. Crystal Palace is Crystal Palace which is why we are called Crystal Palace FC not Selhurst and Thorton heath FC or Croydon FC or anywhere else FC it really is not rocket science. If you want to buy baked beans you buy a tin which says baked beans on not spagetti hoops or carrots!

Edited by PalaceSi (22 Apr 2014 2.44pm)

So in that case Arsenal have the wrong name and should move back to Woolwich, Chelsea should move to Chelsea or rename to Fulham II, etc.
The point is we've been at Selhurst Park nearly 90 years so more or less 9 times longer than Crystal Palace Park or anywhere else so I think by now you can safely say it's our home.

That's the defining argument from my perspective. We've been at Selhurst for nearly a century. That's much more like "home" to me than the park.

I mean it's not a massive problem for me either way, because at the end of the day, the club's area is not restricted to Thornton Heath/South Norwood/Croydon.

Streatham, Norbury, Upper and West Norwood, Penge, etc - it's still all local to our club IMO.

But our stadium has been "home" since the 1920s. It's a historic ground in the middle of a built up area - the classic English football ground. And it's ours. I wouldn't want to trade it in for something like the Amex, in the middle of a huge park.

On a selfish level I love living very close to the ground but tbf when living in Streatham and Tulse Hill I still loved making the short journey to Selhurst, the pubs near the ground, just the whole ritual really.

People talking about Selhurst being difficult to get to, as an argument for moving to the park, I don't really get. I don't see how the park is more easily accessible to people. Especially those living south of the area. But also those coming from north of the river and beyond. Ten minutes to Norwood Junction from London Bridge. About twenty minutes from Victoria to Thornton Heath.

 

PalaceSi Flag Brockley 22 Apr 14 8.59pm

Selhurst Park is literally down the road from Crystal Palace and i don't mind staying there, what i don't like is this constant inference that we have no links with Crystal Palace anymore. That somehow we are Croydon's club or as the poster suggested representing Selhurst and thornton heath.
Crystal Palace FC being Crystal Palace FC is why i started supporting the club. I grew up in the borough of Lewisham not that far from Crystal Palace where the great building was, i get the feeling a lot of fans reckon people from the borough of Lewisham should support Millwall even if they live adjacent to the park whilst Crystal Palace FC represents places in the countyside in the borough of Croydon a long long way from Crystal Palace.
I grant you Arsenal was a wierd one but Chelsea play near Chelsea and we play near Crystal Palace.
Its a question of identity and i think it matters because kids from all the inner city boroughs will be put off any links with Croydon. I want us to be a South London Club from Crystal Palace and make some serious inroads north especially while all the other South London clubs are at a low ebb.


.

Quote Firegut at 22 Apr 2014 8.27pm

Quote Selhurstboys at 22 Apr 2014 7.35pm

Quote PalaceSi at 22 Apr 2014 2.41pm

to quote one poster who stated'
"Nope, for me we've got to where we are...Palace is Selhurst and Thornton Heath not Penge and Gypsy Hill."

I don't understand this at all and it drives me nuts. Crystal Palace is Crystal Palace which is why we are called Crystal Palace FC not Selhurst and Thorton heath FC or Croydon FC or anywhere else FC it really is not rocket science. If you want to buy baked beans you buy a tin which says baked beans on not spagetti hoops or carrots!

Edited by PalaceSi (22 Apr 2014 2.44pm)

So in that case Arsenal have the wrong name and should move back to Woolwich, Chelsea should move to Chelsea or rename to Fulham II, etc.
The point is we've been at Selhurst Park nearly 90 years so more or less 9 times longer than Crystal Palace Park or anywhere else so I think by now you can safely say it's our home.

That's the defining argument from my perspective. We've been at Selhurst for nearly a century. That's much more like "home" to me than the park.

I mean it's not a massive problem for me either way, because at the end of the day, the club's area is not restricted to Thornton Heath/South Norwood/Croydon.

Streatham, Norbury, Upper and West Norwood, Penge, etc - it's still all local to our club IMO.

But our stadium has been "home" since the 1920s. It's a historic ground in the middle of a built up area - the classic English football ground. And it's ours. I wouldn't want to trade it in for something like the Amex, in the middle of a huge park.

On a selfish level I love living very close to the ground but tbf when living in Streatham and Tulse Hill I still loved making the short journey to Selhurst, the pubs near the ground, just the whole ritual really.

People talking about Selhurst being difficult to get to, as an argument for moving to the park, I don't really get. I don't see how the park is more easily accessible to people. Especially those living south of the area. But also those coming from north of the river and beyond. Ten minutes to Norwood Junction from London Bridge. About twenty minutes from Victoria to Thornton Heath.


 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 22 Apr 14 9.13pm

Did read a while back that cp park idea is dead and buried and we were looking at redeveloping sp with a school behind main stand and sainsburys involved to, i for one would like to stay at selhurst as im one of the 16 per cent and with lots coming from south of coulsdon and sutton way i would say about a good third to half of all support comes from croydon and surrounding areas, i would like a villa park type stadia like eastender, four different style stands2,3 and 4 tiers, but as i said, think we are staying so should get used to it!

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 22 Apr 14 9.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 21 Apr 2014 10.08am

We also lose our South London/Croydon identity and become a club from Kent f*** That.


You do realise that CPP is SE19. Or is that Kent to you. On my map, it is a bit closer to central London, but still south. When I was very young Croydon wasn't a London borough, although Selhurst was.The giveaway is the post code. DOH

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 22 Apr 14 9.29pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 22 Apr 2014 9.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 21 Apr 2014 10.08am

We also lose our South London/Croydon identity and become a club from Kent f*** That.


You do realise that CPP is SE19. Or is that Kent to you. On my map, it is a bit closer to central London, but still south. When I was very young Croydon wasn't a London borough, although Selhurst was.The giveaway is the post code. DOH


CPP is now within the London Borough of Bromley so it has a BR postcode, not an SE one. I don't think it matters a jot mind you, and it still has a London telephone number (020.

Edited by SloveniaDave (22 Apr 2014 9.29pm)

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

AussieJedinak Flag Folkestone 22 Apr 14 10.56pm

At the end of the day who would want to play out of a generic and stale stadium?

Two words I hear too much in sport these days are franchise and business.

 

bailj018 Flag Crawley 23 Apr 14 1.46pm

Quote Catfish at 20 Apr 2014 9.47pm

All this "spiritual home" stuff about CP park evades the issue of how fans lving South of the park will get there. Getting to Gipsy Hill or Crystal Palace station is a pain in the butt. Selhurst may have its faults but having three stations nearby is a big plus. This is especially important given that so many fans are ex-Croydon or South Norwood.
If we locate somewhere away from a mainline station then it has to be in an area that allows for dispersal of traffic, ie: major road links. That would suggest places such as A23 or A22. If that is the case then maybe we should be looking for locations at places like Godstone or some brownfield site on the southern M25?

Was wondering when someone would mention the practicalities of getting to games for fans who are no longer super close to the stadium. I currently live in Crawley, get the train from Three Bridge's to Norwood Junction in 30/40 mins. Selhurst Park is in a perfect location (for me) but the need for a stadium revamp is undeniable. There will always be ups and downs of renovating/moving etc. In the long term however, I think the best solution would be to move, too much hassle trying to expand/improve our current stadium with Sainsbury's and the council etc.

 

cyclecpfc Flag Bromley 23 Apr 14 2.14pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 22 Apr 2014 9.29pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 22 Apr 2014 9.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 21 Apr 2014 10.08am

We also lose our South London/Croydon identity and become a club from Kent f*** That.


You do realise that CPP is SE19. Or is that Kent to you. On my map, it is a bit closer to central London, but still south. When I was very young Croydon wasn't a London borough, although Selhurst was.The giveaway is the post code. DOH

CPP is now within the London Borough of Bromley so it has a BR postcode, not an SE one. I don't think it matters a jot mind you, and it still has a London telephone number (020.

Edited by SloveniaDave (22 Apr 2014 9.29pm)

which is why penge has a SE20 postcode crystal palace park road has an se26 postcode and anerley has an se19 post code all surrounding the bromley side?


Edited by cyclecpfc (23 Apr 2014 2.14pm)

 

RedandBlueArmy! Flag Croydon 23 Apr 14 2.50pm

I really don't see a problem..
We can have the whole stadium revamped durin this summers break ready for next season...
Throw enough builders at it and it will be completed before next season...
What's is the problem?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Apr 14 3.09pm

Quote croydon proud at 22 Apr 2014 9.13pm

Did read a while back that cp park idea is dead and buried and we were looking at redeveloping sp with a school behind main stand and sainsburys involved to, i for one would like to stay at selhurst as im one of the 16 per cent and with lots coming from south of coulsdon and sutton way i would say about a good third to half of all support comes from croydon and surrounding areas, i would like a villa park type stadia like eastender, four different style stands2,3 and 4 tiers, but as i said, think we are staying so should get used to it!


Blo*dy hell, they are going to rebuild Lady Edridge? That damned place ruined me sister.

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 23 Apr 14 3.31pm

Quote cyclecpfc at 23 Apr 2014 2.14pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 22 Apr 2014 9.29pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 22 Apr 2014 9.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 21 Apr 2014 10.08am

We also lose our South London/Croydon identity and become a club from Kent f*** That.


You do realise that CPP is SE19. Or is that Kent to you. On my map, it is a bit closer to central London, but still south. When I was very young Croydon wasn't a London borough, although Selhurst was.The giveaway is the post code. DOH

CPP is now within the London Borough of Bromley so it has a BR postcode, not an SE one. I don't think it matters a jot mind you, and it still has a London telephone number (020.

Edited by SloveniaDave (22 Apr 2014 9.29pm)

which is why penge has a SE20 postcode crystal palace park road has an se26 postcode and anerley has an se19 post code all surrounding the bromley side?


Edited by cyclecpfc (23 Apr 2014 2.14pm)


Possibly, but Crystal Palace Park is within the LB Bromley. It was swapped, some years ago, with Norwood country park.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 23 Apr 14 3.36pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 23 Apr 2014 3.31pm

Quote cyclecpfc at 23 Apr 2014 2.14pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 22 Apr 2014 9.29pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 22 Apr 2014 9.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 21 Apr 2014 10.08am

We also lose our South London/Croydon identity and become a club from Kent f*** That.


You do realise that CPP is SE19. Or is that Kent to you. On my map, it is a bit closer to central London, but still south. When I was very young Croydon wasn't a London borough, although Selhurst was.The giveaway is the post code. DOH

CPP is now within the London Borough of Bromley so it has a BR postcode, not an SE one. I don't think it matters a jot mind you, and it still has a London telephone number (020.

Edited by SloveniaDave (22 Apr 2014 9.29pm)

which is why penge has a SE20 postcode crystal palace park road has an se26 postcode and anerley has an se19 post code all surrounding the bromley side?


Edited by cyclecpfc (23 Apr 2014 2.14pm)


Possibly, but Crystal Palace Park is within the LB Bromley. It was swapped, some years ago, with Norwood country park.

Yes. However, most of the park (including the stadium) is SE19, with most of the rest SE20 or SE26. Why it is divided, I have no idea. None of it has a BR postcode. And I don't see what difference it makes. It's South London which ever way you spin it.

 

anerley_eagle Flag Mid Wales 23 Apr 14 3.50pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 23 Apr 2014 3.36pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 23 Apr 2014 3.31pm

Quote cyclecpfc at 23 Apr 2014 2.14pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 22 Apr 2014 9.29pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 22 Apr 2014 9.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 21 Apr 2014 10.08am

We also lose our South London/Croydon identity and become a club from Kent f*** That.


You do realise that CPP is SE19. Or is that Kent to you. On my map, it is a bit closer to central London, but still south. When I was very young Croydon wasn't a London borough, although Selhurst was.The giveaway is the post code. DOH

CPP is now within the London Borough of Bromley so it has a BR postcode, not an SE one. I don't think it matters a jot mind you, and it still has a London telephone number (020.

Edited by SloveniaDave (22 Apr 2014 9.29pm)

which is why penge has a SE20 postcode crystal palace park road has an se26 postcode and anerley has an se19 post code all surrounding the bromley side?


Edited by cyclecpfc (23 Apr 2014 2.14pm)


Possibly, but Crystal Palace Park is within the LB Bromley. It was swapped, some years ago, with Norwood country park.

Yes. However, most of the park (including the stadium) is SE19, with most of the rest SE20 or SE26. Why it is divided, I have no idea. None of it has a BR postcode. And I don't see what difference it makes. It's South London which ever way you spin it.

Correct. All of Bromley is technically 'South London' even out to Orpington.

BORING FACT ALERT

Postal addresses/post codes around London date back to the 1930s. At that time, Orpington was truly in Kent. The nearby Borough of Beckenham straddled the border, with Beckenham being in Kent and Penge being in London.

In 1965, the Greater London Area was defined by law, and a number of Outer London Boroughs were formed in areas that had previously been parts of Kent, Surrey and Essex - and the whole of Middlesex got swallowed up. The London Borough of Bromley was one of the new boroughs. Politically it is part of London, but it's postal addresses are still in Kent - except for Penge/Crystal Palace.

Check it out:

[Link]

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are there plans to build a new stadium?