You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dwight Gayle
November 16 2026 12.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dwight Gayle


Page 4 of 13 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Apr 14 2.48pm

Quote fozzaisere at 28 Apr 2014 2.19pm

This thread is rather pointless.

Since, to the best of my knowledge, Tony Pulis doesn't post on HOL couldn't you say exactly the same thing about every, single thread here? The board exists so we can post opinions about things over which we have no control. If you think that's a pointless exercise it rather begs the question of why on earth you are involved?

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Apr 14 6.02am

I like the guy and think hes gona be a star in time, another ian wright, cant judge him to harshly v city, nobody else scored if i remember correctly, and his 3 points v villa with the goal of the season took bottle, if he had missed the target i can only imagine the abuse he would get, football is all about confidence and im sure if we all got behind him like we do glen we would see the benefit!

 

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 29 Apr 14 6.23am

Got a feeling from the odd comments Pulis has made regarding Gayle, that he likes the fella. Just too inexperienced to start games in a cut throat relegation battle.

Can see him trying to mould Gayle into Jerome's role, with the added bonus of goals.

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 29 Apr 14 2.12pm

If you listen to the Parish interview, which can be accessed elsewhere on this site, it would seem that Gayle is considered to be an ongoing project and part of next season's plans.

SP goes out of his way to say that the pressure put on Gayle at the beginning of the season was very unfair - i.e. giving the lead strike role to a young inexperienced player and expecting him to immediately deliver in the Premiership.

I know somebody will come back and say having spent £3 million on him then we were entitled to that expectation, but, let's remember, the player himself has no say in the money that is paid for him.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 29 Apr 14 2.23pm

Quote Pete53 at 29 Apr 2014 2.12pm

If you listen to the Parish interview, which can be accessed elsewhere on this site, it would seem that Gayle is considered to be an ongoing project and part of next season's plans.

SP goes out of his way to say that the pressure put on Gayle at the beginning of the season was very unfair - i.e. giving the lead strike role to a young inexperienced player and expecting him to immediately deliver in the Premiership.

I know somebody will come back and say having spent £3 million on him then we were entitled to that expectation, but, let's remember, the player himself has no say in the money that is paid for him.

Out of fairness I feel obliged to correct you on his price, as I have for the ones who overestimate it It is £4.25m

 

fozzaisere Flag 29 Apr 14 2.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Apr 2014 2.48pm

Quote fozzaisere at 28 Apr 2014 2.19pm

This thread is rather pointless.

Since, to the best of my knowledge, Tony Pulis doesn't post on HOL couldn't you say exactly the same thing about every, single thread here? The board exists so we can post opinions about things over which we have no control. If you think that's a pointless exercise it rather begs the question of why on earth you are involved?

Indeed, but discussing Gayles poor performance after not playing for 4 months and only playing for 15 minutes against the best side in the league does seem pointless.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 29 Apr 14 2.49pm

Quote Bubbs at 29 Apr 2014 6.23am

Got a feeling from the odd comments Pulis has made regarding Gayle, that he likes the fella. Just too inexperienced to start games in a cut throat relegation battle.

Can see him trying to mould Gayle into Jerome's role, with the added bonus of goals.

Gayle definitely has an eye for goal which is something the very best strikers have and not something you can easily teach. Physically I don't think he is quite up to speed with the Premiership yet but after a decent pre-season with a strength coach there is nothing to say he won't bulk up ready for next season.

Wilf was very lightweight in his first season (No wonder due to him being so young) but he was obviously put on a weight and strength plan for the pre-season and came back twice the player as he could hold his own.

I have every faith in Gayle stepping up and scoring lots of goals for us but he does need to play in the right system and he does need to bulk up too. If both of those things happen then we could well end up laughing at how much we actually paid for him. Whatever the outcome, he is a decent footballer and those that don't rate him at all, well.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 29 Apr 14 2.55pm

Quote boilerboy at 27 Apr 2014 11.40pm

Without a doubt he's Class. Mark my words. Pulis has had to do the best with what he has got, and has played a team hard to beat. It will be a busy summer with several ins and outs. Hopefully and I'm pretty confident Gayle will be part of next seasons squad.

Said it when we bought him and I will say it again Barry Fry must have been pissing his pants when we splashed so much cash on Gayle. Fry publicly stated he was the best ever natural striker he had ever seen. As son as the cheque cleared he never mentioned him again. Funny that. Only reason we bought Gayle was because Harry Redknapp was looking at him. So S Parish panicked bought him as quick as he could and got mugged by Peterborough. Gayle does not have the natural instinct and ability to be a Premier League striker. We have all scrored great goals in our time over the fields or in Sunday league games but it doesn't make us Premier League strikers.

Edited by bubble wrap (29 Apr 2014 2.56pm)

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 29 Apr 14 3.01pm

Quote bubble wrap at 29 Apr 2014 2.55pm

Quote boilerboy at 27 Apr 2014 11.40pm

Without a doubt he's Class. Mark my words. Pulis has had to do the best with what he has got, and has played a team hard to beat. It will be a busy summer with several ins and outs. Hopefully and I'm pretty confident Gayle will be part of next seasons squad.

Said it when we bought him and I will say it again Barry Fry must have been pissing his pants when we splashed so much cash on Gayle. Fry publicly stated he was the best ever natural striker he had ever seen. As son as the cheque cleared he never mentioned him again. Funny that. Only reason we bought Gayle was because Harry Redknapp was looking at him. So S Parish panicked bought him as quick as he could and got mugged by Peterborough. Gayle does not have the natural instinct and ability to be a Premier League striker. We have all scrored great goals in our time over the fields or in Sunday league games but it doesn't make us Premier League strikers.

Edited by bubble wrap (29 Apr 2014 2.56pm)


No, but Gayle has in every league he has played in so far which is why he currently is. We shall see next season.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 29 Apr 14 3.10pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 29 Apr 2014 3.01pm

Quote bubble wrap at 29 Apr 2014 2.55pm

Quote boilerboy at 27 Apr 2014 11.40pm

Without a doubt he's Class. Mark my words. Pulis has had to do the best with what he has got, and has played a team hard to beat. It will be a busy summer with several ins and outs. Hopefully and I'm pretty confident Gayle will be part of next seasons squad.

Said it when we bought him and I will say it again Barry Fry must have been pissing his pants when we splashed so much cash on Gayle. Fry publicly stated he was the best ever natural striker he had ever seen. As son as the cheque cleared he never mentioned him again. Funny that. Only reason we bought Gayle was because Harry Redknapp was looking at him. So S Parish panicked bought him as quick as he could and got mugged by Peterborough. Gayle does not have the natural instinct and ability to be a Premier League striker. We have all scrored great goals in our time over the fields or in Sunday league games but it doesn't make us Premier League strikers.

Edited by bubble wrap (29 Apr 2014 2.56pm)


No, but Gayle has in every league he has played in so far which is why he currently is. We shall see next season.

Really hope you are right but just cannot see it myself and don't think Tony Pulis does either.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Apr 14 3.55pm

In the end, the speculation is pointless because there are so many variables none of us can predict. Gayle may be here next season or he may not. I suspect that we have three or four players who are flat out "not for sale at any price" (and Gayle is assuredly not one of them) and the rest could be had for the right fee. Bottom line is that if Pulis wants to expand the size of whatever transfer kitty Parrish gives him and he gets an offer for Gayle that he thinks is reasonable, he will sell. But in the meantime, it makes sense to talk up all our players a). to make them feel valued, and b). to ensure we get the best possible price if there are interested buyers out there.

My guess is that there a fair number of Championship clubs who've seen the damage Gayle did at that level in the past and who are thinking "given how it's worked out in the Premiership, we might be able to get him out of Palace for a price and he could do a job for us in a promotion run." To, say, a Leeds or a Nottingham Forest (random examples), he would represent a far more attractive asset than he would to us, particularly now that we are genuinely aspiring to be a mid-table Premiership team. And if we want someone like Wickham (another random example) and we can raise a few million of his fee by selling Gayle, therefore leaving a chunk of our budget over for a left back (or whatever) then keeping Gayle would make no sense.

I think we're saying the right things. I have read nothing to change my initial view which is that I'd be shocked if Gayle was still with us when the August transfer window closes.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 29 Apr 14 4.07pm

Thinking back to the Sunderland home game at the beginning of the season, I thought he looked a threat.

He just hasn't fit into Pulis game plan. Once we have made more signings he might. He's here now and doubt anybody will be bidding for him, so let's see if we can get the best out of him.

We might all be eating our words come next season.

 

seeweedhater Flag London 29 Apr 14 4.14pm

And it's Gayle grabbing a brace against pool!

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Apr 14 4.23pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm

doubt anybody will be bidding for him


Don't understand why you would think this at all. On the contrary, I think there'll be a queue of interested parties once the season is over. He has not done well this year so is likely to be available at a discount (or clubs will think that), his present club (Palace) can be expected to at least be interested in listening to offers, he's a proven scorer at sub-Premiership level and he would be a good fit for a competitive Championship team with some ambition, who wanted an immediate impact striker. I would be very, very surprised if we don't have a number of approaches by top Championship sides interested in signing Gayle this summer.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 29 Apr 14 8.26pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm

We might all be eating our words come next season.

I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.

Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.

Wd snap hands off for 2M.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 29 Apr 14 10.07pm

Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm

We might all be eating our words come next season.

I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.

Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.

Wd snap hands off for 2M.


And I make you right too Stan. The improvement needed is just too vast and he isn't going to do it.

The pill is just too bitter at the moment for others to take.

Fvcking good goal at Villa though.

Edited by Kermit8 (29 Apr 2014 10.08pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Esteban Flag Addiscombe 29 Apr 14 11.48pm

Jesus, you lot are a miserable bunch of bumsniffers! This has got to be our best season in the Loadsadosh league and all you can do is pick on a player who you possibly watched for an hour all season and then you decide he's no good based on what? Nothing intelligent!

 


Old Father Time

Aut insanit homo, aut versus facit

Gyro1780 Flag Leatherhead, Surrey 30 Apr 14 12.20am

Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm

We might all be eating our words come next season.

I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.

Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.

Wd snap hands off for 2M.

I'm going on record now to say that Gayle will have a big part to play next season & you'll all be glad we kept him.

 

priestinator Flag Croydon 30 Apr 14 12.36am

I agree with an earlier comment saying that he certainly appears to have beefed up a bit lately, with a bit more strength I can see him becoming a Jermain Defoe type player who isn't too involved in linking up play but valuable purely for a bit of finesse in front of goal.

Speaking of his tactical awareness, he does seem a bit off but that is something that can be remedied quickly, and I'd argue that he is better than Murray, who seems to have gone back to his old ways of being caught offside too much.

But in all honesty he needs to be playing with a strike partner, or a playmaker in central mifield to play him through.(as IH clearly planned with Campana and Bannan)

He's worth another season, a full pre-season could be just what he needs and if anything he'll probably increase his market value.

 

I'm not french Flag 30 Apr 14 12.38am

2 seasons ago Bristol city were talking this way about yala bolasie and look where he is now.

Gayle would be half decent IF he bulked up a bit and was able to have more of a presence. He's already shown us he can finish.

not expecting fireworks but he's definitely not peaked yet

Edited by I'm not french (30 Apr 2014 12.39am)

 

Page 4 of 13 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dwight Gayle