You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Times Tables failure = forced academy.
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Times Tables failure = forced academy.


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
chris123 Flag hove actually 10 Mar 15 9.23pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 9.09pm

Quote NickinOX at 10 Mar 2015 1.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 12.49pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Mar 2015 12.39pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 12.35pm

[Link]

This details transference of property and the money academy chains are making through selling off 'excess' land for profit.


I said "credible" and "unbiased". Try again.

But even the link says August 2012, so it's steam rolling ahead clearly....

Which of the facts in the article are wrong?

Are any articles unbiased?

Using that logic this must be just as valid. It even uses evidence rather than mostly citing other blog posts written by the same person.

[Link]

I would like to see how free schools do in comparison to non-free schools when the next set of results come out (later this year I think); whether they have a demographic advantage (currently the evidence seems to says no, but there is only a limited sample size); and whether they have been set up in areas of need (again the evidence is too limited to draw full conclusions, but suggests they have been). Once more data is available I think it will be reasonable to judge.

On the other side, I would like to see actual evidence that having a teacher training certificate makes someone a better teacher, and whether comprehensive schools actually did better for their pupils' education than the old system of grammar and technical schooling. Which at least let students excel in an area of aptitude rather than trying to pretend they were all essentially the same. Something that is patently silly.

According to this [Link] the policy exchange (Tory funded, founded by Gove) research on free schools is seriously flawed.

Edited by nickgusset (10 Mar 2015 9.14pm)


Policy Exchange is an independent, non-partisan educational charity seeking free market and localist solutions to public policy questions.

Charity Registration Number: 1096300

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 15 9.29pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Mar 2015 9.23pm


Policy Exchange is an independent, non-partisan educational charity seeking free market and localist solutions to public policy questions.

Charity Registration Number: 1096300


Policy Exchange: an organisation established by Michael Gove and other leading Conservative Party members, and which describes itself as seeking “free market” solutions to public policy problems (i.e. privatisation).

Although a registered charity, it does not release the names of its funders. Moreover, although its financial statement describes most of its spending as ‘research’, much of this appears to be devising and advocating Conservative Party policy. Indeed, its 2012-13 accounts boast of its influence on government policy including increasing chain-sponsored academies, the mandatory work scheme for unemployed people, and Prevent. (This report on free schools was funded particularly by Krishna Rao and Jeremy Isaacs of Goldmann Sachs, who also funded an earlier report on teachers’ performance pay.)

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 10 Mar 15 9.38pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 9.09pm

Quote NickinOX at 10 Mar 2015 1.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 12.49pm

Quote Stuk at 10 Mar 2015 12.39pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 12.35pm

[Link]

This details transference of property and the money academy chains are making through selling off 'excess' land for profit.


I said "credible" and "unbiased". Try again.

But even the link says August 2012, so it's steam rolling ahead clearly....

Which of the facts in the article are wrong?

Are any articles unbiased?

Using that logic this must be just as valid. It even uses evidence rather than mostly citing other blog posts written by the same person.

[Link]

I would like to see how free schools do in comparison to non-free schools when the next set of results come out (later this year I think); whether they have a demographic advantage (currently the evidence seems to says no, but there is only a limited sample size); and whether they have been set up in areas of need (again the evidence is too limited to draw full conclusions, but suggests they have been). Once more data is available I think it will be reasonable to judge.

On the other side, I would like to see actual evidence that having a teacher training certificate makes someone a better teacher, and whether comprehensive schools actually did better for their pupils' education than the old system of grammar and technical schooling. Which at least let students excel in an area of aptitude rather than trying to pretend they were all essentially the same. Something that is patently silly.

According to this [Link] the policy exchange (Tory funded, founded by Gove) research on free schools is seriously flawed.

Edited by nickgusset (10 Mar 2015 9.14pm)

This criticism is coming from someone who cited a blogger citing his own blogs as evidence. You've now linked another blog site. Come on Nick, that is fallacious on multiple levels.

So what that the website I posted is run by a right of center policy think tank. That does not automatically make what they say wrong, or right. Their research is published and can be properly fact checked. Whether they are correct or not, I have no idea. However, and whether I agree with their argument or not, that they conducted research which is available for review tells me they at least make a legitimate case.

If you are going to claim something is wrong, explain why your argument holds water and provide some evidence to support it. If all you are going to offer are ad hominem attacks from blog sites, you clearly have no real argument.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 10 Mar 15 9.40pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 9.29pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Mar 2015 9.23pm


Policy Exchange is an independent, non-partisan educational charity seeking free market and localist solutions to public policy questions.

Charity Registration Number: 1096300


Policy Exchange: an organisation established by Michael Gove and other leading Conservative Party members, and which describes itself as seeking “free market” solutions to public policy problems (i.e. privatisation).

Although a registered charity, it does not release the names of its funders. Moreover, although its financial statement describes most of its spending as ‘research’, much of this appears to be devising and advocating Conservative Party policy. Indeed, its 2012-13 accounts boast of its influence on government policy including increasing chain-sponsored academies, the mandatory work scheme for unemployed people, and Prevent. (This report on free schools was funded particularly by Krishna Rao and Jeremy Isaacs of Goldmann Sachs, who also funded an earlier report on teachers’ performance pay.)

This is all ad hominem.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

legaleagle Flag 10 Mar 15 9.41pm

Policy Exchange:

[Link]

A "non partisan" charity it may be,but in general terms it appears on the face of it hardly the most open minded people with no particular political sympathies around

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 10 Mar 15 9.42pm

Quote legaleagle at 10 Mar 2015 9.41pm

Policy Exchange:

[Link]

A "non partisan" charity it may be,but in general terms it appears on the face of it hardly the most open minded people with no particular political sympathies around

Again, so what? What is wrong with their actual argument. Where is their research flawed?


 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

TUX Flag redhill 10 Mar 15 9.45pm

We are now 'a dumb' country producing 'dumb kids' but telling them they are bright!
How did that happen?

 

legaleagle Flag 10 Mar 15 9.46pm

.

Edited by legaleagle (10 Mar 2015 9.46pm)

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 10 Mar 15 9.48pm

Quote legaleagle at 10 Mar 2015 9.41pm

Policy Exchange:

[Link]

A "non partisan" charity it may be,but in general terms it appears on the face of it hardly the most open minded people with no particular political sympathies around

Don't get me wrong, It is reasonable to ask the question, but surely it is relevant only if the evidence appears to be biased or the research is flawed.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

legaleagle Flag 10 Mar 15 9.49pm

Quote NickinOX at 10 Mar 2015 9.42pm

Quote legaleagle at 10 Mar 2015 9.41pm

Policy Exchange:

[Link]

A "non partisan" charity it may be,but in general terms it appears on the face of it hardly the most open minded people with no particular political sympathies around

Again, so what? What is wrong with their actual argument. Where is their research flawed?



I wasn't commenting on their research.I am not familiar with the minutiae of it.Rather,I was commenting on the "non partisan" nature of the charity in question, which is not entirely irrelevant when taking into account material published by such a charity. You are quite right that political inclination does not automatically make research invalid,but it is always appropriate to be aware of the potential biases of those commissioning/publishing it,from whatever side of the ideological spectrum,as much from the point of view of what aspects might not be included in the focus of the research as what is included.

Edited by legaleagle (10 Mar 2015 9.52pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 Mar 15 9.55pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 9.29pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Mar 2015 9.23pm


Policy Exchange is an independent, non-partisan educational charity seeking free market and localist solutions to public policy questions.

Charity Registration Number: 1096300


Policy Exchange: an organisation established by Michael Gove and other leading Conservative Party members, and which describes itself as seeking “free market” solutions to public policy problems (i.e. privatisation).

Although a registered charity, it does not release the names of its funders. Moreover, although its financial statement describes most of its spending as ‘research’, much of this appears to be devising and advocating Conservative Party policy. Indeed, its 2012-13 accounts boast of its influence on government policy including increasing chain-sponsored academies, the mandatory work scheme for unemployed people, and Prevent. (This report on free schools was funded particularly by Krishna Rao and Jeremy Isaacs of Goldmann Sachs, who also funded an earlier report on teachers’ performance pay.)


Policy Exchange was first registered with the Charity Commission March 2003. Michael Gove is a former Chairman, but I think resigned when he became an MP

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Mar 15 10.35pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 9.45pm

We are now 'a dumb' country producing 'dumb kids' but telling them they are bright!
How did that happen?

Probably because previous generations have a very misguided sense of their own generations intelligence.

Plenty of thick c**ts around in every generation.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 15 10.36pm

Quote NickinOX at 10 Mar 2015 9.40pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Mar 2015 9.29pm

Quote chris123 at 10 Mar 2015 9.23pm


Policy Exchange is an independent, non-partisan educational charity seeking free market and localist solutions to public policy questions.

Charity Registration Number: 1096300


Policy Exchange: an organisation established by Michael Gove and other leading Conservative Party members, and which describes itself as seeking “free market” solutions to public policy problems (i.e. privatisation).

Although a registered charity, it does not release the names of its funders. Moreover, although its financial statement describes most of its spending as ‘research’, much of this appears to be devising and advocating Conservative Party policy. Indeed, its 2012-13 accounts boast of its influence on government policy including increasing chain-sponsored academies, the mandatory work scheme for unemployed people, and Prevent. (This report on free schools was funded particularly by Krishna Rao and Jeremy Isaacs of Goldmann Sachs, who also funded an earlier report on teachers’ performance pay.)

This is all ad hominem.


Mea culpa. I could have paraphrased, but am on me phone. It's from the NUT. The info would have been the same regardless.

 

TUX Flag redhill 10 Mar 15 10.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 10 Mar 2015 9.46pm

.

Edited by legaleagle (10 Mar 2015 9.46pm)

I guess the question was too hard to answer.


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 15 10.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Mar 2015 10.35pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 9.45pm

We are now 'a dumb' country producing 'dumb kids' but telling them they are bright!
How did that happen?

Probably because previous generations have a very misguided sense of their own generations intelligence.

Plenty of thick c**ts around in every generation.



It's cunds.

Going by classes I've taught over the last 15 years, you'll always get a range of abilities and (academic) intelligence.
Bell curve and all that.

 

TUX Flag redhill 10 Mar 15 11.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Mar 2015 10.35pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 9.45pm

We are now 'a dumb' country producing 'dumb kids' but telling them they are bright!
How did that happen?

Probably because previous generations have a very misguided sense of their own generations intelligence.

Plenty of thick c**ts around in every generation.


I was referring to the global education figures and how we've dropped down the list over recent years. Kinda worrying imo.
And I agree, there are thick c**ts in every generation.


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 15 11.15pm

[Link]

This makes an interesting read, as does
[Link]


The first link (a peer reviewed academic piece) concludes that there isn't enough evidence either way that free schools are a success or failure, so Cameron and Morgan are wrong to make the claims that they do.

The second is a parliamentary report that shows the education minister is exaggerating how good free schools and academies are.


My opposition to academies comes partly (other than the transference of over £1billion of PUBLIC assets to academies to sell and pocket the profit among other things) after working with Alisdair Smith of the Anti Academies Alliance. He's seen evidence that free schools and academies (at secondary level) massage their exam results by pulling kids out of exams if they think they are going to fail because they don't want the overall results dragged down!

It's also worth looking at news reports about schools that have been or are about to be changed to academy status. In a lot of cases, if a governing body are against the change, they are removed and replaced by IEB's - interim executive boards, which help steamroller the change. Schools are forced into academisation despite overwhelming opposition from parents. see [Link] for an example.


Also worth looking at [Link] (yes it's biased because it is from an anti academies group) that highlights many failures of the academy and free school experiment.

 

legaleagle Flag 10 Mar 15 11.19pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 10.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 10 Mar 2015 9.46pm

.

Edited by legaleagle (10 Mar 2015 9.46pm)

I guess the question was too hard to answer.


far too hard

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 15 11.19pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 11.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Mar 2015 10.35pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 9.45pm

We are now 'a dumb' country producing 'dumb kids' but telling them they are bright!
How did that happen?

Probably because previous generations have a very misguided sense of their own generations intelligence.

Plenty of thick c**ts around in every generation.


I was referring to the global education figures and how we've dropped down the list over recent years. Kinda worrying imo.
And I agree, there are thick c**ts in every generation.


Depends what list you look at. There are a few different ones. We do well in some, not so well in others- I'm off to bed so won't search for them tonight. However this [Link] shows we are second best in Europe and 6th in the world using rankings that are based upon an amalgamation of international tests and education data - including the OECD's Pisa tests, and two major US-based studies, Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (Timss) and Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (Pirls).


Edited by nickgusset (10 Mar 2015 11.20pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 10 Mar 15 11.28pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 11.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Mar 2015 10.35pm

Quote TUX at 10 Mar 2015 9.45pm

We are now 'a dumb' country producing 'dumb kids' but telling them they are bright!
How did that happen?

Probably because previous generations have a very misguided sense of their own generations intelligence.

Plenty of thick c**ts around in every generation.


I was referring to the global education figures and how we've dropped down the list over recent years. Kinda worrying imo.
And I agree, there are thick c**ts in every generation.



A very interesting question,and one too important for knee jerk quick fix political responses.This is what the OECD had to say about educational attainment here in 2014

[Link]

And some 2013 OECD international comparisons here

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (10 Mar 2015 11.29pm)

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Times Tables failure = forced academy.