You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Weatherspoons fined for banning p*****
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Weatherspoons fined for banning p*****


Page 4 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
npn Flag Crowborough 20 May 15 2.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 May 2015 12.58pm

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am

They accepted the order, then turned it down later - are you saying that it would be fine if they'd rejected the order up front (which makes a mockery of the whole case, in my opinion)?

Yes, if they have a corporate policy then it should be communicated to the staff and practiced - You don't have to accept someone's custom, I suppose (although you can't refuse them on the basis of being gay) but once you have taken an order you have entered into a contract with that party.

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am

As for refusing to promote political causes, that would be fine, but you "have to be upfront" about it? Does that mean you have to list all the things you are NOT willing to put on a cake before you've been asked to do so?

I would imagine that you should communicate that policy to your staff and the people taking orders.

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am

I am totally for non-discrimitation on the grounds of pretty much anything, but I'm also totally for the rights of anyone (business or personal) to refuse to promote something they feel strongly against.

I disagree with the part in regards to a business, as a business, except maybe as applies to a sole trader, as a business is not a person, but a collection of people. Furthermore, businesses have to operate in line with commercial law and regulation.

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am
Would a vegan baker have to produce a "bring back fox hunting" cake?
As in the example above, would a muslim have to produce one with Mo on it?

Its not about an individual, this is about a company violating contract law and commercial law on the basis of the views of some of its owners.

In either case both could turn down the order but they cannot accept it, and then change their minds.

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am

In fact, forget the cakes - what about printers? Should a printer be obliged by law to print whatever they are asked? BNP leaflets, for instance?

They aren't required to, as a service they do not have to enter into a contract, but if they do accept a contract then they are bound by it.

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am
Or is it simply the fact that someone accepted the order and later cancelled it which is the problem (which, again, makes a mockery of the law if you're allowed to reject outright, just not accept and reject later).

By rejecting it later, you're breaking the contract with the ordering party, which opens you to redress. Same as any contract, once you accept it, you can't just break it without redress or recourse for the aggrieved party.

I work

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 11.37am
Shoe on the other foot: would a gay baker be obliged to make a "ban gay marriage" cake?

If they accepted the contract in the first place, then yes.

In addition to that you cannot discriminate against a client based on race, gender, sexual orientation or religion (ie you have to find another reason to turn down their business).


To reiterate, as I understand it they didn't discriminate because they were gay, they simply objected to the wording.

I'm sure they would have objected if a straight person had ordered a cake with the same wording which by definition means they haven't been discriminated againbst, surely?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 20 May 15 3.57pm

Which wasn't the finding of the case, or the appeals, where the judges specifically stated they have violated commercial law in regards to discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation, and awarded costs to the plaintiff.

I don't know the full ins and outs, of the case, but it seems that they have failed at least twice now to show their actions were reasonable, and non discriminatory.

What they might do in different hyperthetical circumstances, is irrelevant, the case in question is what counts.

They broke a contractual obligation unreasonably, and protested a false ground, on which sufficient grounds were presented for them to have violated commercial law regarding discrimination.

As the judge points out, repeatedly, their business is not a Christian business, and as such their beliefs remain irrelevant. Once they accepted payment they were contractually obligated to produce their end of the deal.

I'm sure their god will reward them in the next life for the martyrdom or whatever.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 20 May 15 4.30pm

I quite liked the comparison of asking a muslim printers, to print pictures of Mo.

 


Optimistic as ever

derben Flag 20 May 15 5.15pm

I don't really like these big over-rich, fruity cakes anyway. I prefer smaller ones, like fairy cakes, or a nice mincepie.

Edited by derben (20 May 2015 5.34pm)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 20 May 15 5.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 May 2015 3.57pm

Which wasn't the finding of the case, or the appeals, where the judges specifically stated they have violated commercial law in regards to discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation, and awarded costs to the plaintiff.

I don't know the full ins and outs, of the case, but it seems that they have failed at least twice now to show their actions were reasonable, and non discriminatory.

What they might do in different hyperthetical circumstances, is irrelevant, the case in question is what counts.

They broke a contractual obligation unreasonably, and protested a false ground, on which sufficient grounds were presented for them to have violated commercial law regarding discrimination.

As the judge points out, repeatedly, their business is not a Christian business, and as such their beliefs remain irrelevant. Once they accepted payment they were contractually obligated to produce their end of the deal.

I'm sure their god will reward them in the next life for the martyrdom or whatever.


But the fact remains that if I (a straight bloke) had made an identical request for an identical cake, they'd have told me to get stuffed too, therefore they cannot possibly be discriminating against the plaintiff on the grounds of his sexual orientation (in fact, the guy was long gone and the owners never even saw him, when the decision was made to cancel the order).

So I agree with you - if they were being prosecuted for failing to fulfil a contract, fair play, but for discrimination on the grounds of sexuality? Do me a favour.

The law, as they say, is an ass.

 

eagles2011 Flag 20 May 15 7.42pm

I thought this was about a pub refusing admission to a bunch of pikeys - seems to have changed to gay cakes

 

ilovejo Flag Croydon 20 May 15 8.13pm

I've worked at a Gypsy wedding once (didn't know they were travellers until they turned up), absolute fcking nightmare.

It was running ok until they decided to have a fight in the middle of the dance floor... blood everywhere, and we found part of someone's ear!!!
I had to pull 2 members of staff into the kitchen area and lock the doors or god knows what would've happened if we got caught in it.

 


"Dream as if you will live forever, live as if you will die today."

James Dean, Legend. RIP.

PSN username: olzzy999

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 May 15 8.30pm

Quote ilovejo at 20 May 2015 8.13pm

I've worked at a Gypsy wedding once (didn't know they were travellers until they turned up), absolute fcking nightmare.

It was running ok until they decided to have a fight in the middle of the dance floor... blood everywhere, and we found part of someone's ear!!!
I had to pull 2 members of staff into the kitchen area and lock the doors or god knows what would've happened if we got caught in it.


Probably shouldn't confuse Gypsy and Traveller. Travellers are trained to fight from being very small, forced into hitting each other as children. They think fighting is good sport and natural.

They also think dropping potentially dangerous rubbish anywhere they feel like is absolutely fine. Can't see there is much to celebrate in a culture like that and I really don't know how they get away with as much as they do. When they turn up they are a mobile crimewave. Why on earth would anyone want them around, especially as you will get a fistful if you complain.

 

derben Flag 20 May 15 8.49pm

Quote Mapletree at 20 May 2015 8.30pm

Quote ilovejo at 20 May 2015 8.13pm

I've worked at a Gypsy wedding once (didn't know they were travellers until they turned up), absolute fcking nightmare.

It was running ok until they decided to have a fight in the middle of the dance floor... blood everywhere, and we found part of someone's ear!!!
I had to pull 2 members of staff into the kitchen area and lock the doors or god knows what would've happened if we got caught in it.


Probably shouldn't confuse Gypsy and Traveller. Travellers are trained to fight from being very small, forced into hitting each other as children. They think fighting is good sport and natural.

They also think dropping potentially dangerous rubbish anywhere they feel like is absolutely fine. Can't see there is much to celebrate in a culture like that and I really don't know how they get away with as much as they do. When they turn up they are a mobile crimewave. Why on earth would anyone want them around, especially as you will get a fistful if you complain.

Surely we are supposed to 'celebrate' them for 'enriching' our culture with 'diversity'?

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 20 May 15 8.57pm

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 5.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 May 2015 3.57pm

Which wasn't the finding of the case, or the appeals, where the judges specifically stated they have violated commercial law in regards to discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation, and awarded costs to the plaintiff.

I don't know the full ins and outs, of the case, but it seems that they have failed at least twice now to show their actions were reasonable, and non discriminatory.

What they might do in different hyperthetical circumstances, is irrelevant, the case in question is what counts.

They broke a contractual obligation unreasonably, and protested a false ground, on which sufficient grounds were presented for them to have violated commercial law regarding discrimination.

As the judge points out, repeatedly, their business is not a Christian business, and as such their beliefs remain irrelevant. Once they accepted payment they were contractually obligated to produce their end of the deal.

I'm sure their god will reward them in the next life for the martyrdom or whatever.


But the fact remains that if I (a straight bloke) had made an identical request for an identical cake, they'd have told me to get stuffed too, therefore they cannot possibly be discriminating against the plaintiff on the grounds of his sexual orientation (in fact, the guy was long gone and the owners never even saw him, when the decision was made to cancel the order).

So I agree with you - if they were being prosecuted for failing to fulfil a contract, fair play, but for discrimination on the grounds of sexuality? Do me a favour.

The law, as they say, is an ass.


Maybe that explains why he sued then..

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Old Chap Flag Orpington 21 May 15 11.10am

Quote ilovejo at 20 May 2015 8.13pm

I've worked at a Gypsy wedding once (didn't know they were travellers until they turned up), absolute fcking nightmare.

It was running ok until they decided to have a fight in the middle of the dance floor... blood everywhere, and we found part of someone's ear!!!
I had to pull 2 members of staff into the kitchen area and lock the doors or god knows what would've happened if we got caught in it.

Pub near me was a nice family run place, had a restaurant you could take your gran for a meal. Change of landlord, new one was warned not to let the pikeys in - he ignored the advice.

Loads of them started coming, but they would fight amongst themselves almost every night, place was wrecked, all the other customers went somewhere else, drug dealing going on.

Pub were told to employ security, that didn't stop them, police got fed up & opposed the licence, pub closed down

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 May 15 11.34am

Quote npn at 20 May 2015 5.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 May 2015 3.57pm

Which wasn't the finding of the case, or the appeals, where the judges specifically stated they have violated commercial law in regards to discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation, and awarded costs to the plaintiff.

I don't know the full ins and outs, of the case, but it seems that they have failed at least twice now to show their actions were reasonable, and non discriminatory.

What they might do in different hyperthetical circumstances, is irrelevant, the case in question is what counts.

They broke a contractual obligation unreasonably, and protested a false ground, on which sufficient grounds were presented for them to have violated commercial law regarding discrimination.

As the judge points out, repeatedly, their business is not a Christian business, and as such their beliefs remain irrelevant. Once they accepted payment they were contractually obligated to produce their end of the deal.

I'm sure their god will reward them in the next life for the martyrdom or whatever.


But the fact remains that if I (a straight bloke) had made an identical request for an identical cake, they'd have told me to get stuffed too, therefore they cannot possibly be discriminating against the plaintiff on the grounds of his sexual orientation (in fact, the guy was long gone and the owners never even saw him, when the decision was made to cancel the order).

So I agree with you - if they were being prosecuted for failing to fulfil a contract, fair play, but for discrimination on the grounds of sexuality? Do me a favour.

The law, as they say, is an ass.

Its irrelivent, because that didn't happen, and a case is based on what happened, not what may happen in a hypothetical case. Of course it it could be shown to have occured prior to the event, then it would be fine.

It doesn't help your defence when you specifically state you don't agree with gay marriage because you're a christian, when of course any number of christians do support gay marriage (even among evangelicals and born again movements there are those that are christian and pro-gay marriage). Especially given a historical context that those same groups also opposed every step of equal rights legilsation revolving around homosexuality, but thats not accorded as evidence either.

Making such statements about a case, prior to hearings is just asking for it to be included in the plantiffs case against you.

I think, had they actually pursued a case sensibly, and controlled their own mouths in the press, they'd have avoided that aspect. Remember this is balance of evidence, not reasonable doubt (which would likely be in their favour).

So in truth, its fairly easy to make a reasonable case that 'they had an issue with the message and homosexuality' rather than just an objection to the political message.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 May 15 11.39am

A lot of the stories on here, remind me of the 'Battle Inn' on the Oxford road. The only pub I've ever seen with window protection grilles on the inside and outside of the windows.

Lovely place, Irish Traveller Pro-IRA pub. The police would regular just pull up in the carpark with a van of coppers, from about 6pm most nights - Cost effective policing, as almost all the nutbar pub psychos in the area drank there.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 21 May 15 11.40am

Im sorry, how did we get from arsehole pikeys to Gay cakes, and all with the famous twister of words Mr Cheval Blanc no where to be seen.

Bur for the record, why should someone be forced to make a gay cake if their religion opposes battyness. Would a muslim be forced to eat a bacon sandwhich ? No they wouldnt! So whats the difference ?

Back on point.....

Pikeys in general are utter shysters of the highest order , My old man (god rest his sole) ran and managed pubs most of his adult life. I've seen what these piss taking c***s can do to a good boozer.

The law is an ass.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

derben Flag 21 May 15 11.46am

Despite Jamie's convoluted explanations of this injustice; Ashers Bakery, gay rights activist Gareth Lee,the Equality Commisssion, Judge Isobel Brownlie, and everyone on HOL - including Jamie, know that the 'judgement' is merely a politically correct pandering to supposed rights of fashionable minorities to override the rights of unfashionable minorities.

Judge Brownlie has form on this - she awarded £5,000 damages to four members of the 'travelling community' when a pub landlord in Newry refused to serve them.

She also threw out the case of a former British army secret agent inside the IRA, who claimed the publication of a photograph of him had endangered his life.

Edited by derben (21 May 2015 11.48am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 May 15 1.18pm

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 11.40am

Im sorry, how did we get from arsehole pikeys to Gay cakes, and all with the famous twister of words Mr Cheval Blanc no where to be seen.

Bur for the record, why should someone be forced to make a gay cake if their religion opposes battyness. Would a muslim be forced to eat a bacon sandwhich ? No they wouldnt! So whats the difference ?

Back on point.....

Pikeys in general are utter shysters of the highest order , My old man (god rest his sole) ran and managed pubs most of his adult life. I've seen what these piss taking c***s can do to a good boozer.

The law is an ass.

Businesses aren't individuals, and as such do not enjoy rights as people. This isn't America.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 21 May 15 3.51pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 May 2015 1.18pm

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 11.40am

Im sorry, how did we get from arsehole pikeys to Gay cakes, and all with the famous twister of words Mr Cheval Blanc no where to be seen.

Bur for the record, why should someone be forced to make a gay cake if their religion opposes battyness. Would a muslim be forced to eat a bacon sandwhich ? No they wouldnt! So whats the difference ?

Back on point.....

Pikeys in general are utter shysters of the highest order , My old man (god rest his sole) ran and managed pubs most of his adult life. I've seen what these piss taking c***s can do to a good boozer.

The law is an ass.

Businesses aren't individuals, and as such do not enjoy rights as people. This isn't America.


Bullsh1t and you know it. Do we not live in a free society where hundreds of thousands of people died for freedom of speach ? all this PC crap and people being forced to change their views, even religious beliefs by law, is utterly utterly wrong.

What next straight blokes have to get bummed just so they can see it from a gay perspective and understand the struggle of gay men ? If I had a cake shop and someone asked me to make an Sein Fein (IRA) cake, I'd tell them to f*** right off out of it same goes for the proddy nutters the UVF, and anyone else I didn’t like its called freedom of choice which is being eroded by the PC Nazis in local government.

I am literally sick of people being made to cow tow to anyone who feels part of a minority; the tail is wagging the dog and no mistake.

Point proven today in parliament, the current lying bastad in the hot seat, says he will pass a bill that foreign workers who have no right to be here will have their money/wages taken from them. You should have heard the supercilious w***ers on the radio phone in, all clamouring to be more right on and PC than the next man.

Someone needs to get a grip of this “cant say boo! to a goose” attitude it is a breeding ground for the weak minded, the soft, and the mentally challenged.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

derben Flag 21 May 15 4.24pm


Surely the time has come for designated gay towns where gay people can 'marry', 'have' children, put silly slogans on cakes etc - and they could like refuse to give hetrosexuals a room, or censor their cake inscriptions and generally poke fun at them.

Just picking a town at random to try this out - how about Brighton?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 May 15 4.25pm

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 3.51pm

Bullsh1t and you know it. Do we not live in a free society where hundreds of thousands of people died for freedom of speach ? all this PC crap and people being forced to change their views, even religious beliefs by law, is utterly utterly wrong.

You not forced to change your views, you are however required to adhere to laws governing the provision of paid services and goods, which stipulate you cannot discriminate or refuse people on the basis of their sexual orientation.

Just like you can't refuse to sell or provided services to people because their black, female or Christian.

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 3.51pm

What next straight blokes have to get bummed just so they can see it from a gay perspective and understand the struggle of gay men ? If I had a cake shop and someone asked me to make an Sein Fein (IRA) cake, I'd tell them to f*** right off out of it same goes for the proddy nutters the UVF, and anyone else I didn’t like its called freedom of choice which is being eroded by the PC Nazis in local government.

And you'd be fine. You don't have to accept someone's business, what you can't do is break a contract with someone because you change your mind later. Its perfectly legal and ok to say 'I'm sorry, we don't do political messages'.

Once you enter a contract, you can only terminate it through fulfillment of agreed clauses. Your political beliefs or personal belief or religious beliefs are not grounds for breaking a contract.

If you're then stupid enough to say its 'because you don't support gay marriage' in the press and ally yourself with causes that have notorious been against any gay rights, you shouldn't be surprised that goes against you in court.

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 3.51pm

I am literally sick of people being made to cow tow to anyone who feels part of a minority; the tail is wagging the dog and no mistake.

They're not though are they, they're being made to comply with the law, that essentially states you cannot discriminate against UK citizens in business and forced to abide by Contract law.

Doesn't seem unreasonable to me. Since when did having religion translate as the right to discriminate against people buying or ordering cakes? Is that in the bible?

No, its another bunch in society who get their knickers in a twist and hysterical when something doesn't go their way, and cry about how oppressed they are by having to abide by the same rules and laws as everyone else.

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 3.51pm

Point proven today in parliament, the current lying bastad in the hot seat, says he will pass a bill that foreign workers who have no right to be here will have their money/wages taken from them. You should have heard the supercilious w***ers on the radio phone in, all clamouring to be more right on and PC than the next man.

I'm radical, I'd deport them and then fine the people who employed them five times the annual salary of the employee for each year they'd worked there. I can't answer for the kind of people who phone in on radio shows.

Then again, I'd also implement work programs and mandatory language courses for successful asylum applicants, before they transitioned to being citizens.

In my experience they tend to be pricks, wind up merchants and people who watch daytime tv.

Quote dannyh at 21 May 2015 3.51pm
Someone needs to get a grip of this “cant say boo! to a goose” attitude it is a breeding ground for the weak minded, the soft, and the mentally challenged.

I think its generally called expecting people to be somewhat considerate of other people. Not sure that breaking contract law and discriminating against someone on the grounds of their sexual orientation is actually the same as saying 'boo to a goose'.

I mean what's the world coming to when businesses are required not to discriminate against their customers and treat UK citizens as UK citizens.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 May 15 4.28pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 4.24pm


Surely the time has come for designated gay towns where gay people can 'marry', 'have' children, put silly slogans on cakes etc - and they could like refuse to give hetrosexuals a room, or censor their cake inscriptions and generally poke fun at them.

Just picking a town at random to try this out - how about Brighton?

Or we could just be reasonable human beings and get along, follow the law, and maybe take more interest in what we do, rather than object to what other people choose to do.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 4 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Weatherspoons fined for banning p*****