You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Books to Films
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Books to Films


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 02 Jun 15 4.59pm

Quote johnfirewall at 02 Jun 2015 12.00pm

Interesting that Jaws came from a book. Just need Moby Dick 3D now.

There needs to be a comprehensive list of books which you should bypass and go straight for the film.

That said, there are some stories which should be skipped in any medium. I can only be winning in having saved a week of my life in avoiding Harry Potter and Lord Of The Rings. And that's just the films.

On the other hand, I feel having watched Trainspotting first enriched the reading experience. Knowing the characters from their style of language before they've been introduced is pretty cool.

I was disappointed with the film having read the book first. Two scenes really let it down. Firstly, the scene in which they shoot the skinhead's dog is truly funny in the book whilst in the film they skip over it very quickly but they may be due to our politically correct age. The second scene which let it down badly is when Begbie throws his glass over the balcony and then goes down to sort it out. In the book this is eye watering comedy but it gets somewhat lost in the film.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 02 Jun 15 5.08pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 4.45pm

Quote EddtheEagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.02pm

Shawshank Redemption - average book made into a great film


I believe I am the only person who thought the film was absolute pants especially in comparison to earlier Hollywood prison dramas.

Your beliefs are incorrect (me & mongo give it a slating in the link). There's a few of us Kerm - I often enjoy reading the 'Hated it' reviews on IMDB (where it remains the no1 top rated film)

A fairly enjoyable but forgettable and flawed film that isn't a patch on any of the movies it attempted to plagiarise. Over-rated doesn't nearly cover it.

[Link]

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 02 Jun 15 5.14pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 5.08pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 4.45pm

Quote EddtheEagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.02pm

Shawshank Redemption - average book made into a great film


I believe I am the only person who thought the film was absolute pants especially in comparison to earlier Hollywood prison dramas.

Your beliefs are incorrect (me & mongo give it a slating in the link). There's a few of us Kerm - I often enjoy reading the 'Hated it' reviews on IMDB (where it remains the no1 top rated film)

A fairly enjoyable but forgettable and flawed film that isn't a patch on any of the movies it attempted to plagiarise. Over-rated doesn't nearly cover it.

[Link]


How can you be so obtuse?

Seriously the posters would've been f***ed in about a week!

 


Optimistic as ever

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 02 Jun 15 5.31pm

Quote fledgling at 02 Jun 2015 4.35pm

Quote Canterbury Palace at 02 Jun 2015 3.19pm

I thought Hannibal was a fantastic read and a woeful film. I suspect Shantaram might meet the same eventual fate as Johnny Depp has his hands on it.


As an aside, what did you think of the book?

I saw it through to the bitter end but got so bored with him about a third of the way through.


I loved it mate but there were definitely some parts that were gruelling to say the least. However I thought overall those were outweighed by some of the descriptive passages that were stunningly written and considering that, as I understand it, it's largely based on real events it made some of what occurred pretty amazing.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

coulsdoneagle Flag London 02 Jun 15 5.39pm

Quote npn at 02 Jun 2015 11.37am

The Beach


So true! Completely misses everything the book has and is decidedly average. Di Caprio was a terrible choice.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 02 Jun 15 6.11pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 12.44pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 12.30pm

A rarity is Ian Fleming and early Bond movies. Both as good as each other. Obviously the books are a bit deeper, well written too, but Connery's Bond and the scripts don't fail the author.

The books paint a much darker and nastier Bond, much more of a necessary evil man, hard drinking, misogynistic and borderline sociopathic than any of the Bonds until Daniel Craig (Casino Royal) managed (Noteworthy I thought that Goldeneye had more a nod to the Bond of the novels, than the movies).


I finished Diamonds are Forever this week and have From Russia With Love to start next. I'd be permanently sozzled if I drank as much as Bond does every day. Shame it's not as easy to get hold of benzedrine these days, another of his preferred tonics and quite an effective sharpener by the sound of it.

Fight Club - love the film. Binned the book after struggling with the first few chapters.

Would like to see Inherent Vice as I read the book a few years ago and loved the hippy vibe would like to know if the film lives up to it.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 02 Jun 15 6.12pm

Quote coulsdoneagle at 02 Jun 2015 5.39pm

Quote npn at 02 Jun 2015 11.37am

The Beach


So true! Completely misses everything the book has and is decidedly average. Di Caprio was a terrible choice.

Couldn't disagree more. Loved the film (watched it before reading) and love the book.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 02 Jun 15 6.25pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 5.08pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 4.45pm

Quote EddtheEagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.02pm

Shawshank Redemption - average book made into a great film


I believe I am the only person who thought the film was absolute pants especially in comparison to earlier Hollywood prison dramas.

Your beliefs are incorrect (me & mongo give it a slating in the link). There's a few of us Kerm - I often enjoy reading the 'Hated it' reviews on IMDB (where it remains the no1 top rated film)

A fairly enjoyable but forgettable and flawed film that isn't a patch on any of the movies it attempted to plagiarise. Over-rated doesn't nearly cover it.

[Link]


Shucks. At last. A comrade. Taken me twenty years to find you Super. I'm not letting go.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 02 Jun 15 6.57pm

Watership down was a fantastic book but the calibre of acting by the rabbits in the film left a lot to be desired!

 

derben Flag 02 Jun 15 8.50pm


I thought Anal Karenina was a better film than Tolstoys' scribble - meatier.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Jun 15 8.59pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 02 Jun 2015 6.57pm

Watership down was a fantastic book but the calibre of acting by the rabbits in the film left a lot to be desired!

Hahaha the film is probably as good as the book, but the book is very different, much less 'aw look at the poor bunnies' and more 'Greek drama'


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Jun 15 9.00pm

Quote derben at 02 Jun 2015 8.50pm


I thought Anal Karenina was a better film than Tolstoys' scribble - meatier.

A real greek drama.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Jun 15 9.01pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 5.08pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 4.45pm

Quote EddtheEagle at 02 Jun 2015 3.02pm

Shawshank Redemption - average book made into a great film


I believe I am the only person who thought the film was absolute pants especially in comparison to earlier Hollywood prison dramas.

Your beliefs are incorrect (me & mongo give it a slating in the link). There's a few of us Kerm - I often enjoy reading the 'Hated it' reviews on IMDB (where it remains the no1 top rated film)

A fairly enjoyable but forgettable and flawed film that isn't a patch on any of the movies it attempted to plagiarise. Over-rated doesn't nearly cover it.

[Link]

Massively overated film. Its alright, its better than the book, and its better than the remarkably sh*t Green Mile, but its not even a decent prison movie. Its boosted massively by the narration.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Jun 15 9.02pm

Quote Frickin Saweet at 02 Jun 2015 6.11pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 12.44pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 12.30pm

A rarity is Ian Fleming and early Bond movies. Both as good as each other. Obviously the books are a bit deeper, well written too, but Connery's Bond and the scripts don't fail the author.

The books paint a much darker and nastier Bond, much more of a necessary evil man, hard drinking, misogynistic and borderline sociopathic than any of the Bonds until Daniel Craig (Casino Royal) managed (Noteworthy I thought that Goldeneye had more a nod to the Bond of the novels, than the movies).


I finished Diamonds are Forever this week and have From Russia With Love to start next. I'd be permanently sozzled if I drank as much as Bond does every day. Shame it's not as easy to get hold of benzedrine these days, another of his preferred tonics and quite an effective sharpener by the sound of it.

Fight Club - love the film. Binned the book after struggling with the first few chapters.

Would like to see Inherent Vice as I read the book a few years ago and loved the hippy vibe would like to know if the film lives up to it.

Shockingly that how Flemming and friends used to drink, and then took the 'speed tablets' to stay upright and keep on drinking. World War 2 was largely fought on Benzedrine.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

coulsdoneagle Flag London 02 Jun 15 9.03pm

Quote Frickin Saweet at 02 Jun 2015 6.12pm

Quote coulsdoneagle at 02 Jun 2015 5.39pm

Quote npn at 02 Jun 2015 11.37am

The Beach


So true! Completely misses everything the book has and is decidedly average. Di Caprio was a terrible choice.

Couldn't disagree more. Loved the film (watched it before reading) and love the book.

Really I thought it was an awful film and missed the whole point of the book. The author wasn't afraid to have his incredibly flawed protagonist think like an actual human. He is a bit of a dick, pretty randy and a bit of a coward but such an accessible character. This was lost in the film in my humble opinion. Also they had to Americanise it which didn't work.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 02 Jun 15 10.02pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 2.54pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.16pm

Quote Dixie Eagle at 02 Jun 2015 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

I am stuck on Ellen Brody masturbating in a diner at the moment.



So am I now

Its not as exciting as it sounds SF....imagine female w@nking as written by Barbara Cartland...


Edited by The Sash (02 Jun 2015 1.35pm)


Would


Have

Am

 

morganistic Flag 05 Jun 15 9.15pm

I saw We Need To Talk About Kevin last night and was mightily impressed. Grim as f*ck though. Haven't read the book but I guess it's even more depressing.

Charlie and Lola was a successful transfer I thought.

 


[Link]
''careful Penny - we don't know what we're dealing with here''

lindz Flag kent 05 Jun 15 9.35pm

I quite enjoy historical fiction and Ken Follets Pillars of the earth and World without end (much better than the first IMHO) both are excellent reads and although not a movie but 8 part mini series and both were great also if that sort of thing appeals.

Another is The book thief which had great review for books but it was narrated in the voice of death and I couldn't get into it but the film was enjoyable.

I enjoyed Dan Browns Angels and Demons book but turned the film off halfway through couldn't get into it.

I suppose some make good films some don't all depends on lots of things though like storyline,director etc.

 

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 10.07pm

Quote morganistic at 05 Jun 2015 9.15pm

I saw We Need To Talk About Kevin last night and was mightily impressed. Grim as f*ck though. Haven't read the book but I guess it's even more depressing.

Charlie and Lola was a successful transfer I thought.

It's a great book. I read it before seeing the film and would say it is far better and complex than the film. They changed a few things, for example it is a cross-bow in the book rather than a long-bow.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 05 Jun 15 10.18pm

Quote morganistic at 05 Jun 2015 9.15pm

I saw We Need To Talk About Kevin last night and was mightily impressed. Grim as f*ck though. Haven't read the book but I guess it's even more depressing.

Charlie and Lola was a successful transfer I thought.


She should never have touched the white line.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Books to Films