This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
The Stanly Milgram investigation proved that people will do anything they are told.
We'll never die |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote corkery at 15 Jul 2015 8.59pm
The Stanly Milgram investigation proved that people will do anything they are told. Gibsons investigation of Milgram's experiment presents a very good critical analysis of Milgram's Obedience study that presents a very valid argument against the simplistic parameters Milgram established (he shows that negotiation is the core of obedience and power, not a inherent construct). Milgram's work suffers from very strong experimenter bias and its assumptions are faulty, when you look at the results in term of discourse analysis (the rate of obedience drops dramatically when you listen to the faux authority figure and the subjects discourse. Sorry I wrote my last essay on Gibson and Milgram, and I'm a huge Zimbardo and Milgram fan.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Frickin Saweet at 15 Jul 2015 5.43pm
Quote Catfish at 15 Jul 2015 5.17pm
He worked at Auchwitz doing the admin and knew what was going on. He didn't play a part in killing people but has been convicted as an accessory. Yes, he is guilty and has much to feel guilty about but has any good been done? Having got him to confess, perhaps more good would have been done by pursuading him to give a full account that further undermines holocaust denials in the future. The policy after the war was to go after the leaders and those who had committed high profile atrocities. It was simply not possible to convict every person who worked for the Nazis or breached a convention. everybody wanted to move on and I think they were right to do so.
He already has, see extract taken from Vice referencing a 2005 BBC documentary: Groening appeared in a 2005 BBC documentary titled Auschwitz: The Nazis and the Final Solution. Responding to Holocaust deniers, he stated clearly: "I saw the gas chambers. I saw the crematoria. I saw the open fires. I was on the ramp when the selections [for the gas chambers] took place. I would like you to believe these atrocities happened — because I was there." I find Groening's and a Holocaust survivor's comment really interesting. She asks why he and those like him, cultured and educated, did not challenge that atrocities that were happening. He effectively says he was following orders, being obedient: "There was a self-denial in me that today I find impossible to explain," Groening said during the trial. "Perhaps it was also the convenience of obedience with which we were brought up, which allowed no contradiction. This indoctrinated obedience prevented registering the daily atrocities as such and rebelling against them." But on that - what happens if you challenge orders of the Nazi hierarchy? Probably get shot. So to not follow orders is suicide. And what does that say about soldiers carrying out orders that are later deemed illegal. Are they all put on trial - where do you draw the line? Will hundreds of Serbian soldiers be facing trial too for the mass murder of civilians? I'm not defending it - my gut reaction is that they should all hang for the atrocities, but it's a bloody complex thing. Its important to remember that the Death Camps etc. were not staffed by the German Army but by the SS, who were volunteers, specifically. Waffen SS drafted after 1943 were given different legal rights to Waffen SS volunteers. Punishment for those who were compassionate or questioned the gassing, wasn't execution, but transfer to the Waffen SS unit (which was fairly common). So until 1943 the camp SS were all there voluntarily. As for the Serbian soldiers, less so, but most of the autrocities committed in the Bosnia and Croat conflicts weren't the army, but the volunteer nationalist militias.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 16 Jul 2015 12.29pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2015 11.16am
Quote corkery at 15 Jul 2015 8.59pm
The Stanly Milgram investigation proved that people will do anything they are told. Gibsons investigation of Milgram's experiment presents a very good critical analysis of Milgram's Obedience study that presents a very valid argument against the simplistic parameters Milgram established (he shows that negotiation is the core of obedience and power, not a inherent construct). Milgram's work suffers from very strong experimenter bias and its assumptions are faulty, when you look at the results in term of discourse analysis (the rate of obedience drops dramatically when you listen to the faux authority figure and the subjects discourse. Sorry I wrote my last essay on Gibson and Milgram, and I'm a huge Zimbardo and Milgram fan. You should be sorry - in fact you should be put on trial for crimes against plain English. Probably; its the product of a Conservative State Education, so I blame Thatcher, at least from the age of 9 onwards. Its always someone else's fault, right
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote topcat at 16 Jul 2015 2.22pm
Quote johnfirewall at 16 Jul 2015 11.16am
What if he'd done the accounts as a job for an external firm, or worked for Allianz to insure the camps? I won't go so far as to mention the story that Cola Cola invented Fanta for the Nazis as they didn't have the ingredients to make the actual cola in Germany, or whichever oil company it was who had to develop a new fuel for the Luftwaffe's planes or Boss designing the uniforms, but there was a lot more direct involvement that could equally be punishable. I can't boycott the whole country (who signed up for it) as I'm off there to see Palace this weekend. I'm with the survivor who says he should be given community service lecturing on what he saw. This Having a German speak about why he opted for a desk job overseeing the death of 1000s as opposed to almost certain death fighting for his country would be more useful than 4 years in gaol. The important thing to remember here is that he wasn't fighting for his country. The SS were an armed political force, not a national army. I don't think there is any reasonable excuse that permits avoiding responsibility for direct participation in genocide of civilians. That said its worth noting that the individual in question twice applied to transfer from Auschwitz, and eventually ended up in the Waffen SS fighting in the Ardnes. He also served as a witness against another War Criminal and spoke out against Holocaust denial. It seems something like a suspended or community sentence would be more appropriate, and that maybe his conviction has more to do with political capital than anything else. But he was a direct and willing conspirator in the holocaust. Four years maybe lecturing at the assorted memorial camps would probably serve better than prison.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote topcat at 16 Jul 2015 2.22pm
Quote johnfirewall at 16 Jul 2015 11.16am
What if he'd done the accounts as a job for an external firm, or worked for Allianz to insure the camps? I won't go so far as to mention the story that Cola Cola invented Fanta for the Nazis as they didn't have the ingredients to make the actual cola in Germany, or whichever oil company it was who had to develop a new fuel for the Luftwaffe's planes or Boss designing the uniforms, but there was a lot more direct involvement that could equally be punishable. I can't boycott the whole country (who signed up for it) as I'm off there to see Palace this weekend. I'm with the survivor who says he should be given community service lecturing on what he saw. /quote] This Having a German speak about why he opted for a desk job overseeing the death of 1000s as opposed to almost certain death fighting for his country would be more useful than 4 years in gaol. Actually he transferred out from the role at a Death Camp, and fought with the Waffen SS in Battle of the Bulge.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Cucking Funt at 16 Jul 2015 3.39pm
Seeing the thread title, I thought we'd signed an up and coming youngster for the (Hitler) youth squad. I thought it was an advert for a far right version of the popular dice game.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Jul 2015 10.25am
I find it odd that many people are prepared to forgive and forget the part this guy played in exterminating hundreds of thousands of innocent human beings yet these same people have such a bitter hatred of Maggie Thatcher, the Bankers and old people who they believe are bleeding the country dry with their pensions.
Probably because they have first hand experience of Conservative policy of the 80s, which Thatcher personally was responsible for. Where as this bloke was an administrator for a few years at the death camps, until he could transfer out to a Waffen SS battalion.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.