Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Jul 2015 12.27pm
Quote serial thriller at 26 Jul 2015 11.45am
So would you be able to sleep at night knowing that you would have effectively sent thousands to their deaths rather than trying to provide basic support for them?
Children born to a state are that state's and that family's responsibility.
This country is already massively over generous to outside aid....An unpopular policy, which is direct from the British taxpayer....We pay out more compared to the vast majority of the world.
There is nothing, of course, stopping you from giving all you own to outside aid. Maybe it is you who should find it difficult to sleep at night....Because it is you who hold these convictions.
Maybe you should be out there doing aid....I'd respect that.
Wealthy nations should look to help and advise poorer ones.....What they shouldn't and frankly can't do is take their people.
A state's responsibility should be towards their own poor.....Everytime you increase dependency you worsen what's here for our own working poor, ill people or unemployed.
Also why only help the ones who get here?.....Why aren't you sending large cheques overseas to all those poorer, older or iller individuals you couldn't afford the ticket onto the boat? There's a hypocrisy overwise......The logical argument is endless.
British taxpayers have a right to expect their money to go towards British problems.
If you think that is selfish....Then be assured that this is the world you were born into. You can be different but don't expect or moan about others not following you.
Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Jul 2015 12.28pm)
That is an astounding claim Stirling, and suggests a devotion to the concept of the nation state which is almost religious.
If you live in Northern Iraq, or Eastern Syria, your state - as in who claims authority over you - will almost definitely have changed at least twice in your lifetime. You will also most probably have lost a family member to one of the civil wars that have ensued in your state.
What you are saying would have truly revolutionary consequences on people's lives. If you were Jewish but you were born in Nazi Germany, are you to accept the responsibility of that state in handling you and hope for no external intevention? If you were a freedman in Haiti after the Haitian revolution, do you still remain the French state's responsibility because you were born in chains in one of its colonies? Likewise, if you are a child now born in the region controlled by IS, are you saying you have absolutely no right to expect help from the outside world, even if it condemnds you to a life of rape, forced marriage, violence and seclusion?
Your point on why I'm not out there helping is particularly bonkers. I don't have the money to get a flight to Syria, let alone finance an aid mission, and that's why I do what I can within the environment around me: discuss it with people, support people who I see are trying to help, and of course waste hours of my life on a football forum debating in detail what UK foreign policy should be. I think that was actually Nelson Mandela's background before going in to politics too!
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|