This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mr Palaceman
I have not read much on the Falklands conflict to be honest. The point in the lecture that was of most interest to me was how the language and red line demands the government were making changed even as the task force was approaching and how sovereignty was an issue for negotiation. With splits in the government, it was remarkable that the campaign was successful. You can't ask more of your armed forces. I know who the lecturer is, and I think he is right when it comes to the on-off negotiations before the war. But the Argentinian loss in the war killed off any chance of them getting sovereignty during my lifetime. The services did a fantastic job.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
The boots on the ground did but the logistical and strategic planning etc. was extremely naïve and cost lives. It was a damn close run thing.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
I know who the lecturer is, and I think he is right when it comes to the on-off negotiations before the war. But the Argentinian loss in the war killed off any chance of them getting sovereignty during my lifetime. The services did a fantastic job. True.. This issue will run and run. It's a ralling cry for any new Argentine government, add oil and it becomes a real diplomatic challenge.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
I'm sorry...I have to say something on this thread. I was there....... WTF do any of you know what went on, what happened? Its all very well pontificating about this that & the other, BUT, as far as im concerned it was a Argie Pilot flying a FRENCH plane loaded with a FRENCH Exorcet Missile that SUNK my ship! I lost a lot of mates then, I saw a very good one have his HEAD blown clean off his shoulders due to the attacks. I still carry my physical injuries 34 years later......! Nuff said A sobering post.. My thoughts are with you and your family..
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
The boots on the ground did but the logistical and strategic planning etc. was extremely naïve and cost lives. It was a damn close run thing. Was it bollocks. We smashed the Argentinians. Go live in Havana, you commie traitor. Edited by matt_himself (02 Apr 2016 8.37am)
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Was it bollocks. We smashed the Argentinians. Go live in Havana, you commie traitor. Edited by matt_himself (02 Apr 2016 8.37am) Idiot. However this is of more interest and a comment on what the Tories have done to the Navy. Falklands Islands left with no Royal Navy warship protection for first time since 1982 conflict
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
Idiot. However this is of more interest and a comment on what the Tories have done to the Navy. Falklands Islands left with no Royal Navy warship protection for first time since 1982 conflict Instead of insulting people, why don't you try and back up your politically motivated posts with facts? Your a revisionism of history is incorrect and baseless.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
I'm sorry...I have to say something on this thread. I was there....... WTF do any of you know what went on, what happened? Its all very well pontificating about this that & the other, BUT, as far as im concerned it was a Argie Pilot flying a FRENCH plane loaded with a FRENCH Exorcet Missile that SUNK my ship! I lost a lot of mates then, I saw a very good one have his HEAD blown clean off his shoulders due to the attacks. I still carry my physical injuries 34 years later......! Nuff said
I think the whole point is that you should not have been out there if the islands had been protected as they should have been in the first place. They weren't because of the Tory short term cuts. Thatcher went on to gain credit for getting an island back that she lost in the first place. The press don't question why we lost the island in the first place in the same way they didn't question the Iraq dodgy dossier. Because war sells paper and gets dosh from advertising. Rich people make money; and because the press are incompetent at doing what a free press in a democratic society should do, because they are owned by very rich people and have no interest in that roll. I am not an armchair military tactician but I know that Thatcher has left us with island that is now far more symbolically important than strategically important. We could subsidize a lot of steel production for the cost of protecting sparsely populated far away island. How did we end up in this is all I'm saying.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bert the Head
I think the whole point is that you should not have been out there if the islands had been protected as they should have been in the first place. They weren't because of the Tory short term cuts. Thatcher went on to gain credit for getting an island back that she lost in the first place. The press don't question why we lost the island in the first place in the same way they didn't question the Iraq dodgy dossier. Because war sells paper and gets dosh from advertising. Rich people make money; and because the press are incompetent at doing what a free press in a democratic society should do, because they are owned by very rich people and have no interest in that roll. I am not an armchair military tactician but I know that Thatcher has left us with island that is now far more symbolically important than strategically important. We could subsidize a lot of steel production for the cost of protecting sparsely populated far away island. How did we end up in this is all I'm saying.
It is because the people of the Falklands are British, they didn't want to live under the auspices of a brutal military junta and Britain had to act to rectify the act of barbarism by the Argentine government. It's funny that when self determinationi is applied to British people, the left think it as unimportant. Also, why should unproductive steel be subsidised? If it is unprofitable, largely because during the years of nationalisation there was zero investment in the plants and piss poor management, throwing more money at it is simply ridiculous. We should be looking at ways to make it profitable or start making something else, like graphene.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
It is because the people of the Falklands are British, . Oddly enough before the war they were not considered British Subjects. As for conflating steel production??? with the issue, don't the likes of the USA apply a 164% (ish) tariff on Chinese steel......The UK is a free market dumping ground in a non free globalised oligopoly.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
Oddly enough before the war they were not considered British Subjects. As for conflating steel production??? with the issue, don't the likes of the USA apply a 164% (ish) tariff on Chinese steel......The UK is a free market dumping ground in a non free globalised oligopoly. Again, I fail to understand the point of your argument. Did the Islanders want to be part of Argentina or not before the illegal invasion? Your anti establishment rhetoric is irrelevant to the points being made.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
Oddly enough before the war they were not considered British Subjects. As for conflating steel production??? with the issue, don't the likes of the USA apply a 164% (ish) tariff on Chinese steel......The UK is a free market dumping ground in a non free globalised oligopoly. I think you will find the EU will not let us do that. Edited by elgrande (03 Apr 2016 5.03pm)
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by elgrande
I think you will find the EU will not let us do that. Edited by elgrande (03 Apr 2016 5.03pm) Off topic, but a bit like the Germans don't.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Again, I fail to understand the point of your argument. Did the Islanders want to be part of Argentina or not before the illegal invasion? Your anti establishment rhetoric is irrelevant to the points being made. Troll, Just check a history book on every point I have made on this thread. The most contentious thing I have said is that it was a damn close run thing, and if you have an issue with the history books read some of the memoires published by senior politicians and military men. If you carry on in wallowing in your ignorance and ill manners; I will, unlike your past behaviour, I intend solely to report rather than react to trolling. I am afraid that your uninformed comments or quips, on what happened demean ALL those who died in the conflict, and for that I sincerely apologise to all other posters.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
Troll, Just check a history book on every point I have made on this thread. The most contentious thing I have said is that it was a damn close run thing, and if you have an issue with the history books read some of the memoires published by senior politicians and military men. If you carry on in wallowing in your ignorance and ill manners; I will, unlike your past behaviour, I intend solely to report rather than react to trolling. I am afraid that your uninformed comments or quips, on what happened demean ALL those who died in the conflict, and for that I sincerely apologise to all other posters. The fact is that the British forces retook the islands within two months of the intention to recapture was declared by the cabinet War committee. It was an incredible logistical operation and a stunning military operation. To describe it as 'close run' is wrong. The Argentinian forces were ill prepared, ill equipped and not able to fight against the superior British forces. They were not able to repell the land invasion, with the notable exception of the Mount Longdon defence, and the strength of the Paras and Royal Marines overwhelmed them. The Argentines did not have military thinkers and doers as capable as Thompson, Fieldhouse and Woodward. If there can be criticism of commanders, then really only the loss of Galahad can really be criticised. Whilst the sinking of Belgrano is often sited as a military blunder, I don't agree with this and side with Max Hastings when he says that militarily, the sinking of the Belgrano was a necessary act of war. The lies regarding which way it was sailing was a political failing and the public at the time should have been told the reason why the military took the decision to sink the Belgrano. May I suggest that you read Max Hastings history of the conflict. It is, in my opinion, a very fair and objective view ofwhat happened.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
The fact is that the British forces retook the islands within two months of the intention to recapture was declared by the cabinet War committee. It was an incredible logistical operation and a stunning military operation. To describe it as 'close run' is wrong. The Argentinian forces were ill prepared, ill equipped and not able to fight against the superior British forces. They were not able to repell the land invasion, with the notable exception of the Mount Longdon defence, and the strength of the Paras and Royal Marines overwhelmed them. The Argentines did not have military thinkers and doers as capable as Thompson, Fieldhouse and Woodward. If there can be criticism of commanders, then really only the loss of Galahad can really be criticised. Whilst the sinking of Belgrano is often sited as a military blunder, I don't agree with this and side with Max Hastings when he says that militarily, the sinking of the Belgrano was a necessary act of war. The lies regarding which way it was sailing was a political failing and the public at the time should have been told the reason why the military took the decision to sink the Belgrano. May I suggest that you read Max Hastings history of the conflict. It is, in my opinion, a very fair and objective view ofwhat happened. The key point was the landing at San Carlos. Once successful, it was then largely going to be a land conflict between the 'best of a professional army' and an army of conscripts. What tends to get under played is the sheer size of the balls of the Navy in the landing (Coventry and Broadsword were decoys to protect the landing from air attacks, resulting in the loss of the Coventry). By drawing the Argentine air force off the landings, they essentially secured the real possibility of success. The navy took heavy losses during this period of the war. Also the Argentines managed to drop 13 dud bombs that hit British ships during the landings, due to their pilots inexperience. Had half of those gone off, the outcome could have been different, had all 13 gone off, the British would have been unable to maintain the landings, or protect the fleet. Once the landings were established, it was effectively a land war, and the UK weren't likely to lose provided they could maintain logistics. The military didn't take the decision to sink the Belgrano, it was Margret Thatcher and the Cabinet - who approved a change to the rules of engagement, at the request of the admiralty. It was probably the right military decision but the legality of that action is questionable legally, and never been tested. It could possibly be a crime, but as it was never proven to be a crime either. Certainly the Argentine navy considered it a legitimate act of war. But ultimately its a futile argument, as its more about political view points, than legal ones.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.