This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dynamicdick
All PL managers inc Mr Pardew are paid to have a plan 'B' if another manager decides to do things a little differently. They played a 3-5-2 knowing that we would only play one up front. The 5 man midfield allowed them to deny Palace space and additionally they pressed the ball meaning Palace lost possession and were forced into errors. Once they got possession they kept it very well. Even though I dislike Noble due to his constant berating of referees, he didn't stop moving and geeing up his players. I didn't see that with us. I agree with what you are saying but its not as simple as flicking a switch,we are talking about the EPL not a Sunday morning pub game.It requires a strong enough squad to be able to adapt and have multiple options and in PL terms we are still lacking a little bit.Remy will make a difference when he is fit and Cabaye proved in the second half that he gives us a balance that Ledley is not capable of.We were coming off the back of an impressive 5 game streak,we were at home so why would we look at playing anything other than how we had been?Personally I would have taken Ledley off after 15 minutes tbh he was nothing more than a passenger but AP changed things at half time and we then dominated the game,is that not a Plan 'B' given the circumstances? If he had started with a different side from the one at Everton he would have been chastised so changing it at half time as he did with the resulting second half team performance is him doing his job surely?He cannot legislate for individual errors once the game has started,you could have Plan 'L'-'X' and it wouldn't matter if players are going to ballwatch and miss penalties!
|
|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
I agree with what you are saying but its not as simple as flicking a switch,we are talking about the EPL not a Sunday morning pub game.It requires a strong enough squad to be able to adapt and have multiple options and in PL terms we are still lacking a little bit.Remy will make a difference when he is fit and Cabaye proved in the second half that he gives us a balance that Ledley is not capable of.We were coming off the back of an impressive 5 game streak,we were at home so why would we look at playing anything other than how we had been?Personally I would have taken Ledley off after 15 minutes tbh he was nothing more than a passenger but AP changed things at half time and we then dominated the game,is that not a Plan 'B' given the circumstances? If he had started with a different side from the one at Everton he would have been chastised so changing it at half time as he did with the resulting second half team performance is him doing his job surely?He cannot legislate for individual errors once the game has started,you could have Plan 'L'-'X' and it wouldn't matter if players are going to ballwatch and miss penalties! Because you get found out, Bilic is no fool and Pardew should have had something else up his sleeve to counter any change in formation that was forced upon him. This is why managers who work in the top sphere of football study coaching and obtain their badges. On the pitch it's a game of chess acted out by people.
Bring back Brolin |
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dynamicdick
Because you get found out, Bilic is no fool and Pardew should have had something else up his sleeve to counter any change in formation that was forced upon him. This is why managers who work in the top sphere of football study coaching and obtain their badges. On the pitch it's a game of chess acted out by people. Sorry mate,you picked one sentence and ignored the rest of what I wrote.No point in saying anything else,you are entitled to your opinion of course but ignoring others and using selective reading just to repeat it is pointless.And it couldn't be further from a game of chess,that comment shows how far removed you are from football and why you ignored my points. Edited by citizensmudge (17 Oct 2016 6.13pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
Sorry mate,you picked one sentence and ignored the rest of what I wrote.No point in saying anything else,you are entitled to your opinion of course but ignoring others and using selective reading just to repeat it is pointless.And it couldn't be further from a game of chess,that comment shows how far removed you are from football and why you ignored my points. Edited by citizensmudge (17 Oct 2016 6.13pm) You obviously don't play chess mate.
Bring back Brolin |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Obviously a new supporter! Nothing will be as bad a Puncheons effort against Spurs. What really pissed me off, was BTs coverage, is was a disgrace the way they all kept on how fantastic Spam were all game. Agree in the first half, but second half we deserved a draw at least. The coverage from bT really was s***. I was away watching in a pub. Did they put mic up the other end because I couldnt hear the crowd. I could see the Holmesdales mouths moving with no sound coming out. Edited by palacer (18 Oct 2016 12.48am)
People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
The tw@t on Talksport knew they were playing 3 centre backs 1 hour before kick off so presumably Pardew knew as well. And therefore he could've got thinking and planning and perhaps even implementing a counter strategy for such circumstances. He even had 3 centre backs, arguably 4 starting across our back 4 for a start. Umpteen midfielders and Zaha, Townsend, possibly Ward who could play wing back.
From what I gathered W.Ham had played this tactic before and been so awful they changed to 442 at half time, so perhaps we were a bit complacent. The problem was not our formation I believe but our inability to play through them. Our wingers should have exposed the space but didn't and long balls against three big bruisers was never going to give much joy; however, in the second half we got the ball down and probably should have got a goal. Also, if we are to push on we really need our midfielders to start weighing in with more goals as this game showed that when Bentenke isn't firing we still lack a threat (Townsend has shown that he can be that but has been inconsistent).
|
|
|
Originally posted by palacer
The coverage from bT really was s***. I was away watching in a pub. Did they put mic up the other end because I couldnt hear the crowd. I could see the Holmesdales mouths moving with no sound coming out.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
you could cite the point it didnt really work is that either kouatye or ogbonna were both on big ben all game and both are absolute beasts, a defender of that size attacking a high ball with momentum should always win those headers, but its not just against whu that long ball doesnt work, people jump on cabaye saying hes been s*** & not produced much but its very hard to the midfield to be effective when 50% of balls from the back completely bypass them, then the ball is back in midifeld 10 seconds later and your spending the game trying to break up attacks rather than starting them. it also explains a lot as to why zaha/andros didnt really get much of a lookin. its not the only problem but it is one of the problems from saturdays game. and quite a lot of deffiencies in the performance can be brought back to that point.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway |
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
The tw@t on Talksport knew they were playing 3 centre backs 1 hour before kick off so presumably Pardew knew as well. And therefore he could've got thinking and planning and perhaps even implementing a counter strategy for such circumstances. He even had 3 centre backs, arguably 4 starting across our back 4 for a start. Umpteen midfielders and Zaha, Townsend, possibly Ward who could play wing back. I'm not even blaming Pardew. You could see we needed to win v the sh1t because we'd pick up little points now, but when you get Alan Smith the citizensmudge claiming that it's all out of Pardew's hands when West Ham are pulling us apart and it's only a matter of time before they score then maybe Pardew should reflect a bit more in how he can prepare and react to things like this rather than the usual "I wasn't happy with how we started/reacted." Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Oct 2016 10.13pm) Too busy spouting s***e to take notice as usual Rudi, I said on a couple of occasions that I thought AP should have taken Ledley off after 15 minutes as he just wasn't effective in such a crowded midfield. The second half proved that it would have helped as he did indeed change the game.Secondly,are you saying that that you think AP should have panicked and changed the game plan just because the opponents named a different team? He would have had 30 minutes to try and explain a complete new set of individual and team responsibilities despite the fact that we were unbeaten in 5 and at home.This is the EPL not a sunday league game,i can imagine you if AP had done what you are suggesting and we had been 3-0 down at half time because of the changes.You would have been in your element berating the same changes you are using to dig at him now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
Too busy spouting s***e to take notice as usual Rudi, I said on a couple of occasions that I thought AP should have taken Ledley off after 15 minutes as he just wasn't effective in such a crowded midfield. The second half proved that it would have helped as he did indeed change the game.Secondly,are you saying that that you think AP should have panicked and changed the game plan just because the opponents named a different team? He would have had 30 minutes to try and explain a complete new set of individual and team responsibilities despite the fact that we were unbeaten in 5 and at home.This is the EPL not a sunday league game,i can imagine you if AP had done what you are suggesting and we had been 3-0 down at half time because of the changes.You would have been in your element berating the same changes you are using to dig at him now. He would have only had 10 minutes at half time, but he seemed to manage that OK. Hopefully he's practising different formations in training so that we have options to suit changed circumstances without the need for lengthy explanations during the match.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
Too busy spouting s***e to take notice as usual Rudi, I said on a couple of occasions that I thought AP should have taken Ledley off after 15 minutes as he just wasn't effective in such a crowded midfield. The second half proved that it would have helped as he did indeed change the game.Secondly,are you saying that that you think AP should have panicked and changed the game plan just because the opponents named a different team? He would have had 30 minutes to try and explain a complete new set of individual and team responsibilities despite the fact that we were unbeaten in 5 and at home.This is the EPL not a sunday league game,i can imagine you if AP had done what you are suggesting and we had been 3-0 down at half time because of the changes.You would have been in your element berating the same changes you are using to dig at him now. But surely there's a piece of paper somewhere in his folder that says "This is what we do if the other lot play five at the back", and another one that says "This is what we do if the other lot play three at the back", and so on?
============ |
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
He would have only had 10 minutes at half time, but he seemed to manage that OK. Hopefully he's practising different formations in training so that we have options to suit changed circumstances without the need for lengthy explanations during the match. He would have has 45 minutes to see how it panned out,how did anyone Bilic included know it was going to work?We might have gone out and ripped them apart,always so many experts on here using hindsight to justify their opinions and question the manager. The players could see the problems after the first 45 and it becomes a much easier process to deal individually and as a team even in ten minutes.I started a thread weeks ago suggesting that we might try a 3-5-2 after we had signed Remy and I still think we will at some point.Those saying we should have changed formation and tactics before the game need to understand that we are still limited squad wise and this makes it a lot harder to change things around. Like I said,the same people that are on here digging at AP for not panic reacting would be the same ones ripping him apart if he had done just that and we had lost 4-0.Its reactive and uses hindsight to try and make AP look like hes not good at his job while also ignoring the many positives.
|
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
But surely there's a piece of paper somewhere in his folder that says "This is what we do if the other lot play five at the back", and another one that says "This is what we do if the other lot play three at the back", and so on? Over a season,with a limited squad you are far better using the piece of paper marked "Play to Your Strengths".Im sure Chelsea,Liverpool and City use their squads and everything inside their folders but even they get turned over by us and many other smaller teams.
|
|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
Too busy spouting s***e to take notice as usual Rudi, I said on a couple of occasions that I thought AP should have taken Ledley off after 15 minutes as he just wasn't effective in such a crowded midfield. The second half proved that it would have helped as he did indeed change the game.Secondly,are you saying that that you think AP should have panicked and changed the game plan just because the opponents named a different team? He would have had 30 minutes to try and explain a complete new set of individual and team responsibilities despite the fact that we were unbeaten in 5 and at home.This is the EPL not a sunday league game,i can imagine you if AP had done what you are suggesting and we had been 3-0 down at half time because of the changes.You would have been in your element berating the same changes you are using to dig at him now. One man's panicking is another man's preparation and planning. As others have said, it's quite normal for a manager to plan and counter act. I'm not even blaming Pardew for losing. Weeks ago I just knew we'd lose this one. They needed to win and we're still patting each other on the back after beating the sh1t at the bottom. But seeing as you're excusing Pardew from any sort of responsibility in being able to adapt to a formation which is blindingly obvious to the radio reporter then I am questioning his prep work. What happens when another back 3/5 is named an hour before kick off? Nothing again? How many times isn't the manager questioned? Maybe another reason why he goes through bad patches. What works for a while gets worked out by opposition and then in turn it takes him a while to work out to either counter their tactics and/or develop his own again. I'm not even blaming him but it should be raised. But he will be blamed if diabolical runs happen again.
COYP |
|
| glaziermart |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
The reason we lostrich is that this was a must win game for them. They obviously spent two weeks on a game plan and we're really up for it. If they had lost they would have been in serious trouble. We went into it on a good run of form and with their position in the league probably didn't give it 100% from the start. Human nature. ..even then if the penalty goes in we probably could have won it. Excellent comments. It happens in football. They knew they had to stop the rot. Local derbies wherever they are played tend to upset the form book. I bet come Christmas we will still be above the Spammers
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.