You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why The Deterioration In Pardew's Performance?
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why The Deterioration In Pardew's Performance?


Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Den1923 Flag 30 Oct 16 4.20pm

We have big trouble ahead and relegation is a big possibility, we are weak in defence, have limited ability in midfield and have a bundle of strikers who just cannot score. Pardew's ability has to be questioned as he never seems to learn from previous errors and he has now been found out by most of the current PL coaches who seem to be able to undo our defence at will, we have holes everywhere and whilst the investment in the team has been huge in Palace terms, we have more cover in strikers who cannot score and virtually no quality cover in a bout every other department. The run of poor form since the start of 2016 continues and the current coaching team seems to be able to do nothing about it!

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 30 Oct 16 4.29pm

Originally posted by Den1923

We have big trouble ahead and relegation is a big possibility, we are weak in defence, have limited ability in midfield and have a bundle of strikers who just cannot score. Pardew's ability has to be questioned as he never seems to learn from previous errors and he has now been found out by most of the current PL coaches who seem to be able to undo our defence at will, we have holes everywhere and whilst the investment in the team has been huge in Palace terms, we have more cover in strikers who cannot score and virtually no quality cover in a bout every other department. The run of poor form since the start of 2016 continues and the current coaching team seems to be able to do nothing about it!

What do you suggest we do then?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 16 4.37pm

Originally posted by Den1923

We have big trouble ahead and relegation is a big possibility, we are weak in defence, have limited ability in midfield and have a bundle of strikers who just cannot score. Pardew's ability has to be questioned as he never seems to learn from previous errors and he has now been found out by most of the current PL coaches who seem to be able to undo our defence at will, we have holes everywhere and whilst the investment in the team has been huge in Palace terms, we have more cover in strikers who cannot score and virtually no quality cover in a bout every other department. The run of poor form since the start of 2016 continues and the current coaching team seems to be able to do nothing about it!

Let's consider the recruitment : Zaha is better on the right and likes to play on the right and we sign Townsend who also prefers to play down there and is better out there coming in and shooting with his left-foot.

There have been question marks about whether Mandanda is an improvement on Hennessey.Much was expected when Cabaye signed and he hasn't lived up to expectations.Flamini has been signed but hardly featured at all.We signed Wickham when his injury record was well known and the rest as they say is history.
Delaney is 34 and in the "Twilight" of his career and to-date the "Jury is out" on Tomkins.
The only proper left-back cover for Souare is Fryers and he has hardly established himself at our club.
You can go back to the days of the likes of Adebayor, Amoebi,Bamford !
Also what has Mutch done ? Or indeed Sako ?

Could be a long hard season for us.

 

Den1923 Flag 30 Oct 16 4.37pm

that what Pardew and the others in his team get paid to do and if they cannot deliver then the board have to take action to try and prevent further damage, to do nothing and bury your head in the sand is the worst outcome, the record since the start of 2016 is there for all to see!

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 30 Oct 16 4.44pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I have an issue with certain drills right now. Obviously defending corners isn't good and gifting free throws another. Cr&p corners and how other teams surround our player yet we cannot do 2 on 1. Very slow to loose and 2nd balls. We're not as sharp or prepared or competitive enough.

Very good post Rudi, say what you link about TP at least we were well drilled.

 


Bring back Brolin

oldstand Flag Christchurch 30 Oct 16 4.57pm

Remy could be back at the perfect time,who knows, we may have a decent partnership. He who dares Rodney.

 

Den1923 Flag 30 Oct 16 5.10pm

Also pigs might fly!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Oct 16 5.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

Let's consider the recruitment : Zaha is better on the right and likes to play on the right and we sign Townsend who also prefers to play down there and is better out there coming in and shooting with his left-foot.

There have been question marks about whether Mandanda is an improvement on Hennessey.Much was expected when Cabaye signed and he hasn't lived up to expectations.Flamini has been signed but hardly featured at all.We signed Wickham when his injury record was well known and the rest as they say is history.
Delaney is 34 and in the "Twilight" of his career and to-date the "Jury is out" on Tomkins.
The only proper left-back cover for Souare is Fryers and he has hardly established himself at our club.
You can go back to the days of the likes of Adebayor, Amoebi,Bamford !
Also what has Mutch done ? Or indeed Sako ?

Could be a long hard season for us.

I think the real issue is with recruitment and that cannot be blamed on Pardew alone.

Clubs like Southampton and Leicester have a great recruitment team led by Les Reed at Saints and Steve Walsh previously at Leicester now been poached by one of the big teams.

What have we in terms of scouting and recruitment in place? We used to have a Director of Football ( not sure what he ever did? ) but he resigned over some scandal at Cardiff, now what have we got?

That centre back for Liverpool Matip came on a free, he looked very good, obviously scouted by someone at Liverpool who saw his potential, apparently they got him in April and worked on him during the summer, now fits into their team.

Its suits some people to blame everything on Pardew, but he doesn't do everything at the club. Now whilst we have done really well to get where we are, the infrastructure at the club has faults.

Blaming Pardew after every defeat is pointless, as if we get a new manager the same will happen again, until we improve our recruitment policy.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 16 5.28pm

Originally posted by Painter

I think the real issue is with recruitment and that cannot be blamed on Pardew alone.

Clubs like Southampton and Leicester have a great recruitment team led by Les Reed at Saints and Steve Walsh previously at Leicester now been poached by one of the big teams.

What have we in terms of scouting and recruitment in place? We used to have a Director of Football ( not sure what he ever did? ) but he resigned over some scandal at Cardiff, now what have we got?

That centre back for Liverpool Matip came on a free, he looked very good, obviously scouted by someone at Liverpool who saw his potential, apparently they got him in April and worked on him during the summer, now fits into their team.

Its suits some people to blame everything on Pardew, but he doesn't do everything at the club. Now whilst we have done really well to get where we are, the infrastructure at the club has faults.

Blaming Pardew after every defeat is pointless, as if we get a new manager the same will happen again, until we improve our recruitment policy.

You make some excellent points.

My comments weren't an Anti-Pardew rant - I was just being critical of some of our recruitment. I accept that having an excellent recruitment set-up like that of Leicester/ Southampton is absolutely vital.

 

geoff Flag Midhurst 30 Oct 16 5.31pm

We didn't really expect a result yesterday and the bin dippers team is as good as they have been in years. We have a first 11 that is capable of anything from 17th to 8th and the first 11 i'm guessing is still a work in progress. The main area that has troubled us for a long time is a quality bench. Yesterdays bench looked better but only because Punch and Townsend did not start.
Center half need sorting and a new addition or two in midfield. The Jury is out for me on Mandanda instead of Henessey but lets see how the next 3 games go. As long as we stay up and continue the improvement ill be happy.
As for Pardew. We all knew he was a hot and cold manager when he arrived. Perhaps we are a season or two too early for this transitional period and we should have left that until we have quality players in all positions that can cope with transition. It all seems a bit happy and friendly!!! Someone said it before Pulis football was not great but the team were well drilled. We seem to be missing a govnor and have a team of happy mates.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Oct 16 5.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

You make some excellent points.

My comments weren't an Anti-Pardew rant - I was just being critical of some of our recruitment. I accept that having an excellent recruitment set-up like that of Leicester/ Southampton is absolutely vital.


I wasn't having a pop at you being anti Pardew. Just your post led in nicely to my points about recruitment.

 

cpj Flag Kent 30 Oct 16 5.40pm

2015 - 38 games 63 points at an average of 1.65 per game
2016 - 29 games 22 points at an average of 0.76 per game

2015 - mainly an inherited side; 2016 - mainly Pardew's choices with a lot of money spent.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Oct 16 5.56pm

Our form is more about injuries and an inability to sign players rather than the manager.

Without Soure, another quality striker,that better midfielder we should have signed and the loss of left footed Bolasie, we are light all over the field.

Not starting Townsend and dropping Delaney was a predictable mistake yesterday but Dann has to get match fit and Townsend is throwing his dummy out about playing on the left.
We need to get the chequebook out again not batter the manager.

 

Den1923 Flag 30 Oct 16 6.08pm

The recruitment points are well made, its seems we can only attract players who have been rejected elsewhere. No big names who are at the top of their game would even consider Palace as a club to progress their career. Just look at Jack Wilshire, he lived in London and yet he preferred Bournemouth to CP for a loan deal. That must point to how we handle these matters. The current game plan is not working and yet we have spent more money than ever on new players none of who have really delivered to date. may be Pardew is not entirely to blame but I guess he selects the players he wants and those he wants to sell, so he has to be a large part of the problem!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Oct 16 7.17pm

Originally posted by Den1923

The recruitment points are well made, its seems we can only attract players who have been rejected elsewhere. No big names who are at the top of their game would even consider Palace as a club to progress their career. Just look at Jack Wilshire, he lived in London and yet he preferred Bournemouth to CP for a loan deal. That must point to how we handle these matters. The current game plan is not working and yet we have spent more money than ever on new players none of who have really delivered to date. may be Pardew is not entirely to blame but I guess he selects the players he wants and those he wants to sell, so he has to be a large part of the problem!

My whole point is that Pardew is not to blame for everything, he doesn't run the club, times have changed in the modern era. Yes, he will have a say in who comes in, but we need someone to have the time and knowhow to identify the players to fit what we need.

A good example is Oriol Romeu picked up by Southampton for £5m, fantastic player who could of replaced Jedinak, was in Chelsea reserves then out on loan.

Our whole selection process needs investment, we have got to the stage, where we cannot just put youngsters in, the league is too tough.

As, I have said before, unless things change in the infrastructure getting a different manager will not solve the issue.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 16 7.41pm

Originally posted by Den1923

The recruitment points are well made, its seems we can only attract players who have been rejected elsewhere. No big names who are at the top of their game would even consider Palace as a club to progress their career. Just look at Jack Wilshire, he lived in London and yet he preferred Bournemouth to CP for a loan deal. That must point to how we handle these matters. The current game plan is not working and yet we have spent more money than ever on new players none of who have really delivered to date. may be Pardew is not entirely to blame but I guess he selects the players he wants and those he wants to sell, so he has to be a large part of the problem!

He spoke to both Pardew and Howe and was impressed by both.He felt he just needed to move away from London and now lives in an apartment in Poole with excellent views !

 

Den1923 Flag 30 Oct 16 8.04pm

Sorry that is not right, the Manager has to responsible for on field results and the quality of the players that he brings in. We have this obsession with strikers and yet the first priority has to be to stop people scoring it is only then that you have to score to win and we can do neither at the moment!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Oct 16 8.14pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Sorry that is not right, the Manager has to responsible for on field results and the quality of the players that he brings in. We have this obsession with strikers and yet the first priority has to be to stop people scoring it is only then that you have to score to win and we can do neither at the moment!

Think about it, this is a £120m business, do you really think it all hinges on the manager. That appears a very simplistic view.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 30 Oct 16 8.38pm

The Op started with a sensible question and like most threads on here it's turned into a slag off Pardew thread.
When he took over what coaches were in place? Were there key defensive and attacking coaches that have changed around the time our fortunes changed?

I do think the team were very fit when Pulis was in charge and I guess that good fitness would have only deteriorated over time if our fitness training is inadequate. Reduced fitness would affect all aspects of our play and may be a significant factor.

I think we have discussed some valid concerns about Pardew but no-one seems to think the players have to take some responsibility. For me the senior players need to get a grip of things.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 30 Oct 16 9.27pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Our form is more about injuries and an inability to sign players rather than the manager.


That's such a tired and hackneyed excuse someone should have taken it out and shot it long ago.

Edited by bexleydave (30 Oct 2016 9.28pm)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why The Deterioration In Pardew's Performance?